New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

None of that is part of my argument here. My argument is anti-government pro-capitalism. The fact that she shares those economic policy views is inconsequential to the argument in which we are currently engaged. ETR may well be kind to animals, but that has no bearing on the argument at hand (either). I like ETR. He is at least unabashed about his disdain for capitalism. You, on the other hand, couch yours in terms of "I love capitalism, but…" What comes after the but is always a betrayal of your "middle view."

Why dodge her motives? She is pro-Hitler and would love to support any accusation leveled at FDR that makes him responsible for the war...and that is exactly what you are doing, if only because of your bizarre definition of when WWII began.
 
The comment about green cheese was related to your linking someone else's opinions to mine. Funny that you blow off the fact that Queenie likes your anti-FDR rant. She just wants Hitler to be off the hook for starting WWII...just like you do.

So your attempting to claim WWII started on December 7th, 1941? It didn't. The US was the very last major power to join the war. You seem to be saying the US would have been better off letting Britain fall. That, all by itself, is one of the more amazing things you have posted. It is certain that would have happened if the US had stayed out.
All of Europe was at war by 1940 or had been conquered. Asia was likewise at war long before the US entered the war.

Your idea that all recessions/depressions are the same is idiotic at best. Saying that they are all related to "market dislocations" is the same as saying they were caused by something going wrong. DUH. The depression of 1920/1921 was caused by a halt in military spending, the sudden jump in unemployment when active duty soldiers came home and were mustered out and the surge in European production competing with US products. GDP dropped 7%. In 1929/1930 the GDP dropped 9% and in 1930/1931 another 6.5% and in 1931/1932 a whopping 13%. You praise Harding for his policies during the 1920 depression, but did you also approve of the Emergency Tarriff of 1921 and the Fordney-McCumber Tariff act? Did you know that Harding was sworn in on March 5th, 1921....and you claim his policies made the recovery happen quickly....His tax cuts didn't take effect until 1922 and Harding died in august 1923.

Did FDR get the US involved in WWII to help fix the economy? That is what you have not proven and is simply an unfounded and unsupported attempt to discount the contribution FDR made to improve the economy, prepare the country for the certain involvement in the war and keep the US from becoming a right wing fascist state like others had.

1. Did Hitler come to power due to anything FDR had done? No.
2. Did Hitler solidify his control of the country due to anything FDR did or didn't do? No.
3. Did FDR do anything to make the depression worse? Not if you were unemployed in 1933 and were then to find a job due to FDR's programs or the improving economy. Your opinion not withstanding, every industrial economy...Germany, Canada, the UK, the US..all began to see improvement starting in 1935. Japan suffered the least of the major nations in the depression. Is that because they were such great capitalists?

I'm not trying to rehabilitate Hitler's image, I'm trying to put the facts in context with respect to FDR's. The fact is much of what Hitler accomplished in the late 30s (which, yes, led to war) would not have been possible if the world economy would have been in robust recovery since 1933, when FDR had the opportunity to REALLY "fix the depression," by following President Harding's lead in how to deal with an economic downturn. You keep restating that argument as something else so you can pretend you don't have to address the case I keep making, which is this:

1. The depression led to the unrest that manifested in war.

2. FDR's failed policy agenda prolonged the depression.

3. After 10 years of that failure, he engineered the US entrance into the war (the depression caused) so he could go down in history as a "war president" and not the "failed president" he actually was.

That's my argument. Stop making it into something it isn't and address those three points, or admit you can't. I never said FDR caused Hitler's rise to power, so stop pretending I did.

As for our discussion regarding economic downturns, you are describing the symptoms and I am focusing on the disease. Yes, different situations (like wars ending, surges in foreign competition, oil shacks, etc.) but always and everywhere the result is market dislocations (which are best treated by allowing them to clear). You facilitate those markets in clearing, no depression; you try to keep them from clearing (like FDR and Obama) and you get depression. It really is that simple.
 
NBER says the great depression lasted from Aug 1929 to March of 1933.

What, no link? You are conflating the recession and the depression. The Great Depression is widely acknowledged to have lasted at least (erroneously) until the US entered the war in 1941, and more correctly, until the war ended in 1946:

http://www.investopedia.com/terms/g/great_depression.asp

The economy, as you lefties love to point out, started growing (by NBR's flawed GDP centric determination) in 1933. But the "growth" was just the mirage of government spending (and hiring), and fooled no one, which is why the more enduring definition of the "Great Depression" is at direct odds with that (unsupported) assertion of yours.
 
A recession is two consecutive quarters of GDP decline. A depression is a decline of more than 10%...

Again, no link.

A depression is an unusual and extreme form of recession. Depressions are characterized by their length, by abnormally large increases in unemployment, falls in the availability of credit (often due to some form of banking or financial crisis), shrinking output as buyers dry up and suppliers cut back on production and investment, large number of bankruptcies including sovereign debt defaults, significantly reduced amounts of trade and commerce (especially international trade), as well as highly volatile relative currency value fluctuations (often due to currencydevaluations). Price deflation, financial crises and bank failures are also common elements of a depression that do not normally occur during a recession.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depression_(economics)
 
Why dodge her motives? She is pro-Hitler and would love to support any accusation leveled at FDR that makes him responsible for the war...and that is exactly what you are doing, if only because of your bizarre definition of when WWII began.

She is a capitalist. I am capitalist. Thank you for pointing that out. Now your turn - ETR is a communist. You are a...
 
Again, no link.

A depression is an unusual and extreme form of recession. Depressions are characterized by their length, by abnormally large increases in unemployment, falls in the availability of credit (often due to some form of banking or financial crisis), shrinking output as buyers dry up and suppliers cut back on production and investment, large number of bankruptcies including sovereign debt defaults, significantly reduced amounts of trade and commerce (especially international trade), as well as highly volatile relative currency value fluctuations (often due to currencydevaluations). Price deflation, financial crises and bank failures are also common elements of a depression that do not normally occur during a recession.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depression_(economics)

The closest there is to a rule of thumb in determining what qualifies as a depression is that a 10% decline in GDP (or a comparable economic metric) can be considered to be a depression.

http://www.investorguide.com/article/15779/depression-vs-recession-d1412/

http://www.diffen.com/difference/Depression_vs_Recession
 
she's a fascist, you are a....

Fascism has exactly nothing to do with the matters we are discussing. Unless you are suggesting that I am sporting a fascist viewpoint here (which is [Unwelcome language removed] absurd) then what you have here is exactly nothing.
 
The closest there is to a rule of thumb in determining what qualifies as a depression is that a 10% decline in GDP (or a comparable economic metric) can be considered to be a depression.

http://www.investorguide.com/article/15779/depression-vs-recession-d1412/

http://www.diffen.com/difference/Depression_vs_Recession

From your link:

For both terms it's also somewhat debatable as to when a recession or a depression ends. Some consider them to end when an economy returns to a growth position, others consider it to end when a company (sic) has achieved its pre-downturn levels.

Now go find me a credible source that says (as you did here) that the Great Depression was over in 1933.
 
Fascism has exactly nothing to do with the matters we are discussing. Unless you are suggesting that I am sporting a fascist viewpoint here (which is [Unwelcome language removed] absurd) then what you have here is exactly nothing.

You are the one who wandered into the area of guilt by association. You are associated, on this thread, with a holocaust denying, Hitler apologist.
 
From your link:

For both terms it's also somewhat debatable as to when a recession or a depression ends. Some consider them to end when an economy returns to a growth position, others consider it to end when a company (sic) has achieved its pre-downturn levels.

Now go find me a credible source that says (as you did here) that the Great Depression was over in 1933.

NBER....
 
The closest there is to a rule of thumb in determining what qualifies as a depression is that a 10% decline in GDP (or a comparable economic metric) can be considered to be a depression.

http://www.investorguide.com/article/15779/depression-vs-recession-d1412/

http://www.diffen.com/difference/Depression_vs_Recession

Nice source…

Audience is worthless, almost entirely residents of poor, third world nations. Advertisers get almost no value whatsoever.

As others have mentioned, the CEO is an absolutely terrible leader. Has no vision and is only concerned with increasing pageviews, most of which are from third-world countries. He's one of those jerkoffs who corrects the grammar of waiters/waitresses, if that provides any insight into his personality. Outdated business model relying upon spamming people with promotional emails that signed up for dictionary …

The atmosphere is oppressive. The CEO finds fault with everyone and everything, even what's working. The product is awful and attracts an audience that is almost entirely 3rd world. Management refuses to recognize the lack of value in the audience, so they just keep adding more eyeballs, even though they provide virtually no value.


https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/WebFinance-Reviews-E226512.htm
 
You are the one who wandered into the area of guilt by association. You are associated, on this thread, with a holocaust denying, Hitler apologist.

Your views with respect to the political and economic aspects of the 1930s don't diverge a whit (as far as I can tell) with the admitted commie. I don't deny the holocaust nor do I think Hitler was "misunderstood."
 
Your views with respect to the political and economic aspects of the 1930s don't diverge a whit (as far as I can tell) with the admitted commie. I don't deny the holocaust nor do I think Hitler was "misunderstood."
still having a problem staying on topic, eh?
 
Your views with respect to the political and economic aspects of the 1930s don't diverge a whit (as far as I can tell) with the admitted commie. I don't deny the holocaust nor do I think Hitler was "misunderstood."

My views don't diverge from the facts. Your opinion that if the US economy had been left alone to recover that it would have prevented WWII. It is your opinion and lacks any supporting facts at all.
 
I'm not trying to rehabilitate Hitler's image, I'm trying to put the facts in context with respect to FDR's. The fact is much of what Hitler accomplished in the late 30s (which, yes, led to war) would not have been possible if the world economy would have been in robust recovery since 1933, when FDR had the opportunity to REALLY "fix the depression," by following President Harding's lead in how to deal with an economic downturn. You keep restating that argument as something else so you can pretend you don't have to address the case I keep making, which is this:

1. The depression led to the unrest that manifested in war.

2. FDR's failed policy agenda prolonged the depression.

3. After 10 years of that failure, he engineered the US entrance into the war (the depression caused) so he could go down in history as a "war president" and not the "failed president" he actually was.

That's my argument. Stop making it into something it isn't and address those three points, or admit you can't. I never said FDR caused Hitler's rise to power, so stop pretending I did.

As for our discussion regarding economic downturns, you are describing the symptoms and I am focusing on the disease. Yes, different situations (like wars ending, surges in foreign competition, oil shacks, etc.) but always and everywhere the result is market dislocations (which are best treated by allowing them to clear). You facilitate those markets in clearing, no depression; you try to keep them from clearing (like FDR and Obama) and you get depression. It really is that simple.

1. I have stated as much in a half dozen posts.
2. You are wrong.
3. Any facts to support that opinion?

What the hell would "market clearing" look like in 1933?
 
Back
Top