New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

Why is it that you find it so difficult to accurately quote any post you read? Where did I say that stock market crashes cause depressions?

You claimed the fact that there wasn't one associated with the 1920/21 depression held some significance. I just showed that it didn't, is all. The initial downturn in 1920 was worse than the initial downturn in 1929 (and 2008), but without the decade long non-recovery. The only difference that matters is how the government reacted. I keep telling you that all recessions are basically the same - markets experiencing dislocations. The government stays out of the way and lets them clear, you don't get a depression. You put anti-capitalists like you in charge who want to "control" the markets to make sure no one "suffers" any economic pain, and they only end up making it so most everyone does, for as long as it takes to finally clear the markets. In the 1930s it took a war (or more precisely, the end of a war) to finally get them cleared. Today we're still waiting. There's been some slight increase in economic momentum from Trump's deregulatory efforts, but we still have Obamacare and Dodd Frank gumming up over one-third of the economy, so there's still no real recovery in sight - despite, contrary to the real economic conditions, record stock market gains. Just more evidence that the stock market has no direct correlation with the underlying economic conditions. Unless, of course, an anti-capitalist politician uses a "crash" to take control of the economy and implement an anti-capitalist agenda.

2 + 2 = 4
 
You claimed the fact that there wasn't one associated with the 1920/21 depression held some significance. I just showed that it didn't, is all. The initial downturn in 1920 was worse than the initial downturn in 1929 (and 2008), but without the decade long non-recovery. The only difference that matters is how the government reacted. I keep telling you that all recessions are basically the same - markets experiencing dislocations. The government stays out of the way and lets them clear, you don't get a depression. You put anti-capitalists like you in charge who want to "control" the markets to make sure no one "suffers" any economic pain, and they only end up making it so most everyone does, for as long as it takes to finally clear the markets. In the 1930s it took a war (or more precisely, the end of a war) to finally get them cleared. Today we're still waiting. There's been some slight increase in economic momentum from Trump's deregulatory efforts, but we still have Obamacare and Dodd Frank gumming up over one-third of the economy, so there's still no real recovery in sight - despite, contrary to the real economic conditions, record stock market gains. Just more evidence that the stock market has no direct correlation with the underlying economic conditions. Unless, of course, an anti-capitalist politician uses a "crash" to take control of the economy and implement an anti-capitalist agenda.

2 + 2 = 4

The cause of the recession of 1920 had to do with a massive change in unemployment when a couple million soldiers were mustered out...a number of factories shut down to re-tool for civilian products and the Fed raised interest rates...a lot.

Those were not factors in 1929. In addition margin trading on wall street had boomed...and you only needed 10%. That was not an issue in 1920.

You claim Harding slashed government in 1921...no, he didn't. Wilson did in 1919. You also claim Harding cut taxes...yes he did, but he also included far more people in tax collections by expanding the taxable income base. You argue that it was a tariff that made 1929 worse and ignore the tariffs passed and signed by Harding.
 
The cause of the recession of 1920 had to do with a massive change in unemployment when a couple million soldiers were mustered out...a number of factories shut down to re-tool for civilian products and the Fed raised interest rates...a lot.

Those were not factors in 1929. In addition margin trading on wall street had boomed...and you only needed 10%. That was not an issue in 1920.

You claim Harding slashed government in 1921...no, he didn't. Wilson did in 1919. You also claim Harding cut taxes...yes he did, but he also included far more people in tax collections by expanding the taxable income base. You argue that it was a tariff that made 1929 worse and ignore the tariffs passed and signed by Harding.

Yada yada yada. You keep describing various symptoms of the same disease and claim they indicate there's different diseases. That's bullshit! It's one disease! Markets out of balance. And there's one cure - let them clear.

Harding did not do the massive interventions to try and keep the markets from clearing like Hoover/FDR and Bushbama did. He simply did not get in the way and attempt to use government to prevent or fix the downturn, like your anti-market progressive heroes did (and which led to decade long non-recoveries). THAT is why the 1920 depression is different - because it was over sooner!
 
Yada yada yada. You keep describing various symptoms of the same disease and claim they indicate there's different diseases. That's bullshit! It's one disease! Markets out of balance. And there's one cure - let them clear.

Harding did not do the massive interventions to try and keep the markets from clearing like Hoover/FDR and Bushbama did. He simply did not get in the way and attempt to use government to prevent or fix the downturn, like your anti-market progressive heroes did (and which led to decade long non-recoveries). THAT is why the 1920 depression is different - because it was over sooner!

You keep claiming that all recessions/depressions have the same causes....by saying "market dislocation". 1920 was helped by the Fed cutting interest rates back and when factories returned to production of civilian goods. Pretty simple solutions.

1929 was far different. It was global. It was far deeper in the first two years than was 1920
and regardless of your claim that it was Hoover who made it worse...the fact is that globally it was getting worse by the month. Margin accounts on wall street at 10% equity resulted in a massive hit to millions of people and eventually in bank failures that took all of their deposits with them when they failed.

Harding was president for 17 months. The 1920 depression ended in July 1921...just 4 months after Harding was sworn in. In short, he came along just in time for you to claim his policies are the solution to depressions, no matter the cause.
 
You keep claiming that all recessions/depressions have the same causes....by saying "market dislocation". 1920 was helped by the Fed cutting interest rates back and when factories returned to production of civilian goods. Pretty simple solutions.

1929 was far different. It was global. It was far deeper in the first two years than was 1920
and regardless of your claim that it was Hoover who made it worse...the fact is that globally it was getting worse by the month. Margin accounts on wall street at 10% equity resulted in a massive hit to millions of people and eventually in bank failures that took all of their deposits with them when they failed.

Harding was president for 17 months. The 1920 depression ended in July 1921...just 4 months after Harding was sworn in. In short, he came along just in time for you to claim his policies are the solution to depressions, no matter the cause.

Not the same precise causes, just as cancer doesn't always have the same precise causes. But the disease IS the same - market dislocation(s). It's really quite simple - Say's Law is immutable. Production "creates" demand (in that it brings about the ability pay for it). Consumption, however, cannot ever "create" production. It just doesn't work. It never has, and two uber-Keynesian policy failures (the Great Depression and Obama's "end of growth") give us all the proof we need that this is, in fact, a fact. Let the markets clear, and creative destruction takes over to create new production that funds expanded demand (and growth resumes).

So when lefties like FDR and Obama try to "fix" the market dislocations by putting consumption in the driver's seat, it is always and everywhere doomed to failure. It is just borrowing, after all, and it simply pulls future demand, and the future tax on production to pay for it, into the present. It's so [Unwelcome language removed] obvious that this is just simple logic that it must take two foot thick ideological blinders (such as those you wear when posting here) to deny it.
 
Not the same precise causes, just as cancer doesn't always have the same precise causes. But the disease IS the same - market dislocation(s). It's really quite simple - Say's Law is immutable. Production "creates" demand (in that it brings about the ability pay for it). Consumption, however, cannot ever "create" production. It just doesn't work. It never has, and two uber-Keynesian policy failures (the Great Depression and Obama's "end of growth") give us all the proof we need that this is, in fact, a fact. Let the markets clear, and creative destruction takes over to create new production that funds expanded demand (and growth resumes).

So when lefties like FDR and Obama try to "fix" the market dislocations by putting consumption in the driver's seat, it is always and everywhere doomed to failure. It is just borrowing, after all, and it simply pulls future demand, and the future tax on production to pay for it, into the present. It's so [Unwelcome language removed] obvious that this is just simple logic that it must take two foot thick ideological blinders (such as those you wear when posting here) to deny it.

"Production creates demand"? Sure thing. You make it and someone will buy it...no matter how useless the product is. No....demand creates production.

In your view we shouldn't have had a bank holiday in 1933...letting the banks fail was economically sound. Of course that would have meant that many hundreds of thousands of people would have lost everything they'd saved, reducing resources available to consumers and throttling consumption, further impacting production.

Letting the market clear, in the case of 2006 to 2009 would have meant many hundreds of thousands of more workers unemployed. You seem to be arguing against any unemployment insurance extension, meaning a hit on demand and consumption and even more people out of work....and more people's homes in foreclosure and in the absence of federal aid, even more people looking for a place to stay. You'd be against the bailouts of AIG and a number of brokerages and banks. As those businesses failed there would have been even more people unemployed....and an even greater number of failed retailers and their suppliers.

Why do you suppose Harding called all of those business CEO's in to the White House to talk about unemployment? Why did he sign legislation implementing tariffs? You have yet to acknowledge that it was Wilson who dramatically cut the federal budget in 1919. You have also not addressed the fact that NBER said the depression ended just four months after Harding was sworn in.

Two things happened...the Fed cut interest rates back and the factory retooling ended and cranked up production. By the time FDR became president we had 25% official unemployment....and I'm sure you'd agree that in an agricultural economy with no real way of counting the number of people out of work, that number is probably optimistic.

Notice that the number of people employed at the beginning of the 1920 depression was about 27.5 million and dropped to about 24.5 million. At the beginning of the 1929 depression to 1932 the number of workers dropped from 31 million to less than 24 million. Still think 1920 was worse? While you argue that FDR's policies kept us from having a recovery...the fact is that within 4 years of his becoming president we were back at about 31 million employed.

755px-US_Employment_Graph_-_1920_to_1940.svg.png
 
"Production creates demand"? Sure thing. You make it and someone will buy it...no matter how useless the product is. No....demand creates production.

In your view we shouldn't have had a bank holiday in 1933...letting the banks fail was economically sound. Of course that would have meant that many hundreds of thousands of people would have lost everything they'd saved, reducing resources available to consumers and throttling consumption, further impacting production.

Letting the market clear, in the case of 2006 to 2009 would have meant many hundreds of thousands of more workers unemployed. You seem to be arguing against any unemployment insurance extension, meaning a hit on demand and consumption and even more people out of work....and more people's homes in foreclosure and in the absence of federal aid, even more people looking for a place to stay. You'd be against the bailouts of AIG and a number of brokerages and banks. As those businesses failed there would have been even more people unemployed....and an even greater number of failed retailers and their suppliers.

Why do you suppose Harding called all of those business CEO's in to the White House to talk about unemployment? Why did he sign legislation implementing tariffs? You have yet to acknowledge that it was Wilson who dramatically cut the federal budget in 1919. You have also not addressed the fact that NBER said the depression ended just four months after Harding was sworn in.

Two things happened...the Fed cut interest rates back and the factory retooling ended and cranked up production. By the time FDR became president we had 25% official unemployment....and I'm sure you'd agree that in an agricultural economy with no real way of counting the number of people out of work, that number is probably optimistic.

Notice that the number of people employed at the beginning of the 1920 depression was about 27.5 million and dropped to about 24.5 million. At the beginning of the 1929 depression to 1932 the number of workers dropped from 31 million to less than 24 million. Still think 1920 was worse? While you argue that FDR's policies kept us from having a recovery...the fact is that within 4 years of his becoming president we were back at about 31 million employed.

755px-US_Employment_Graph_-_1920_to_1940.svg.png

That is a common (mis) re-statement of Say's Law, and, in fact, not at all what it, well, says. You cannot consume unless you produce, first. The production funds the ability to consume. Consumption in lieu of production is either borrowing or communism. In the case of one you are taking future production and pulling it into the present. Under communism you take someone's production and give it to someone else. I understand your reluctance to acknowledge that, because those are two of the left's favorite things. But that's just how it works, always and everywhere. And that's precisely why this government interference in economic downturns, which you are attempting to defend, ends up doing more harm than good. You simply cannot borrow or wealth redistribute your way to prosperity. Only by getting organic production going again, through the process of creative destruction, can the economy fully recover.

LOL! Only "four years?" Well, why didn't you say so! And how many of those were make-work jobs funded by the government? And how many of the additional jobs added in 1940 were simply military Keynesianism as he shoved Americans into WWII? No matter what you say about the Great Depression, or how many times you say it, the fact is that the official historical account dates the "end of the Great Depression" as 1941 - which of course only refers to the time where he gained the ability to (finally) borrow and spend enough to totally mask it - not 1937. The real recovery only began after the war, when the FDR anti-market economic policy agenda, was removed.

What your chart actually shows is how the down trend in employment in 1929 initially was less sharp than the one in 1921, and then it suddenly gets worse in 1930. What that looks like to me is that somebody did something to make it worse (and not that something that should have been done, wasn't). That "somebody" isn't Mr. Market, it's Uncle Sam! There is no reason a down turn will last "just four years" (sic) unless there is something preventing the economy's (and by that I mean the people's) natural pursuit of self interest through production, let alone for a decade (or more) as it did during the Great Depression and is currently. The fact that it has only done so in these two instances, both cases when the Presidents displayed open antipathy towards free markets and actively seized powers over the markets that no other Presidents ever did, if you are smart, has you going "hmmmmm." But doing so leads one to a conclusion the progressive Keynesians won't consider - that everything they believe about economics is wrong!
 
Last edited:
That is a common (mis) re-statement of Say's Law, and, in fact, not at all what it, well, says. You cannot consume unless you produce, first. The production funds the ability to consume. Consumption in lieu of production is either borrowing or communism. In the case of one you are taking future production and pulling it into the present. Under communism you take someone's production and give it to someone else. I understand your reluctance to acknowledge that, because those are two of the left's favorite things. But that's just how it works, always and everywhere. And that's precisely why this government interference in economic downturns, which you are attempting to defend, ends up doing more harm than good. You simply cannot borrow or wealth redistribute your way to prosperity. Only by getting organic production going again, through the process of creative destruction, can the economy fully recover.

LOL! Only "four years?" Well, why didn't you say so! And how many of those were make-work jobs funded by the government? And how many of the additional jobs added in 1940 were simply military Keynesianism as he shoved Americans into WWII? No matter what you say about the Great Depression, or how many times you say it, the fact is that the official historical account dates the "end of the Great Depression" as 1941 - which of course only refers to the time where he gained the ability to (finally) borrow and spend enough to totally mask it - not 1937. The real recovery only began after the war, when the FDR anti-market economic policy agenda, was removed.

What your chart actually shows is how the down trend in employment in 1929 initially was less sharp than the one in 1921, and then it suddenly gets worse in 1930. What that looks like to me is that somebody did something to make it worse (and not that something that should have been done, wasn't). That "somebody" isn't Mr. Market, it's Uncle Sam! There is no reason a down turn will last "just four years" (sic) unless there is something preventing the economy's (and by that I mean the people's) natural pursuit of self interest through production, let alone for a decade (or more) as it did during the Great Depression and is currently. The fact that it has only done so in these two instances, both cases when the Presidents displayed open antipathy towards free markets and actively seized powers over the markets that no other Presidents ever did, if you are smart, has you going "hmmmmm." But doing so leads one to a conclusion the progressive Keynesians won't consider - that everything they believe about economics is wrong!

Say's law is his opinion. If Shay were right then all we need to do is keep producing...keep building cars and even though there are no buyers, eventually purchasing power will recover and people will buy all those cars....right? o_O

To put it succinctly...if there is no demand, there will be no production.

Demand creates production. As unemployment increases, demand will decrease. People have no means with which to purchase production. That causes an adjustment in production and an additional increase in unemployment. That is a cycle that was resolved in 1920 when factories completed the shift to non-military products and brought their workforce back...and was additionally helped when the Fed cut interest rates.

The situation, as I keep repeating, was entirely different in 1929. Paper wealth had allowed demand to increase without regard to the actual ability to pay for the goods (and stocks on margin). The chart on the number of people employed demonstrates this very well in the period from 1923 to 1929. Debt increased substantially as people discovered credit. The drought and dust bowl didn't help as agriculture hit the skids.

You seem to think 1920 was worse. It wasn't. About the same number of people lost their jobs in the first year of the downturns in both cases. Since there were not factories reopening in 1930 as there were in 1921...there was no automatic recovery. The stock market was not a factor in 1920, it was in 1929. The Global Economy was hardly impacted by the US depression in 1920. That was not the case in 1929.

You dismiss unemployment as an indicator of just what the state of the economy was. I think that is the singularly most important indicator.
 
Say's law is his opinion. If Shay were right then all we need to do is keep producing...keep building cars and even though there are no buyers, eventually purchasing power will recover and people will buy all those cars....right? o_O

To put it succinctly...if there is no demand, there will be no production.

Demand creates production. As unemployment increases, demand will decrease. People have no means with which to purchase production. That causes an adjustment in production and an additional increase in unemployment. That is a cycle that was resolved in 1920 when factories completed the shift to non-military products and brought their workforce back...and was additionally helped when the Fed cut interest rates.

The situation, as I keep repeating, was entirely different in 1929. Paper wealth had allowed demand to increase without regard to the actual ability to pay for the goods (and stocks on margin). The chart on the number of people employed demonstrates this very well in the period from 1923 to 1929. Debt increased substantially as people discovered credit. The drought and dust bowl didn't help as agriculture hit the skids.

You seem to think 1920 was worse. It wasn't. About the same number of people lost their jobs in the first year of the downturns in both cases. Since there were not factories reopening in 1930 as there were in 1921...there was no automatic recovery. The stock market was not a factor in 1920, it was in 1929. The Global Economy was hardly impacted by the US depression in 1920. That was not the case in 1929.

You dismiss unemployment as an indicator of just what the state of the economy was. I think that is the singularly most important indicator.

Again, you completely misread the facts (and suggest that they are opinions). In a simple economy, say, two guys on a desert island, where each only produces what he and he only needs, there will be no commerce, no "market" at all. If one spends all his time fishing so he has extra fish, and the other spends all his time collecting fire wood, so that he has a surplus of wood, then and only then can they "trade" one surplus for the other. That's about as far as I can dumb it down for you.

Just because we have a modern economy, that simple law of markets (Say's Law) still exists. No one can consume anything, unless and until someone produces something. I get it - you progressives want to believe in the economic concept of "consumption stimulus" as the equivalent of the economic "free lunch," which frankly is the basis for the Keynesian "fiscal multiplier." But I just have to keep pointing out that in both instances where we had these ardent anti-market Presidents trying to use government spending and regulation to "fix" the economy, it simply didn't/hasn't worked. You keep saying that FDR's agenda "ended the Great Depression," when by all respected accounts it didn't end at least until the US entrance to WWII. And you keep saying that Obama's agenda "kept things from getting worse," but the fact is a) it was never going to "keep" getting worse and b) it really hasn't gotten any better:

Screen Shot 2017-09-02 at 5.31.23 PM.png

People like you keep claiming "success" where there is, indeed, none. Which is why you must cling at all cost to the fiction that recessions aren't all (essentially) the same. In fact, recessions ARE all the same, in that they are market dislocations that must be worked off before growth can resume. What makes them "different" are the policy choices made by governments when they occur. That is what determines if and when the recovery arrives. When the government stays out of the way, as it did in 1920/21 and 1987, the recovery soon arrives, and growth resumes its pre-downturn trajectory. When the government intervenes, using massive amounts of "stimulus" (read: fake economic activity) and (especially) regulatory "reform" designed to "cure" the "failures" of the markets, the recovery is delayed. In such instance, the government is saying (to the markets, and those who participate in them) "the beatings will continue until morale improves." Is it any wonder that in such instances, (economic) morale never improves? This isn't rocket science...
 
Again, you completely misread the facts (and suggest that they are opinions). In a simple economy, say, two guys on a desert island, where each only produces what he and he only needs, there will be no commerce, no "market" at all. If one spends all his time fishing so he has extra fish, and the other spends all his time collecting fire wood, so that he has a surplus of wood, then and only then can they "trade" one surplus for the other. That's about as far as I can dumb it down for you.

Just because we have a modern economy, that simple law of markets (Say's Law) still exists. No one can consume anything, unless and until someone produces something. I get it - you progressives want to believe in the economic concept of "consumption stimulus" as the equivalent of the economic "free lunch," which frankly is the basis for the Keynesian "fiscal multiplier." But I just have to keep pointing out that in both instances where we had these ardent anti-market Presidents trying to use government spending and regulation to "fix" the economy, it simply didn't/hasn't worked. You keep saying that FDR's agenda "ended the Great Depression," when by all respected accounts it didn't end at least until the US entrance to WWII. And you keep saying that Obama's agenda "kept things from getting worse," but the fact is a) it was never going to "keep" getting worse and b) it really hasn't gotten any better:

View attachment 37597

People like you keep claiming "success" where there is, indeed, none. Which is why you must cling at all cost to the fiction that recessions aren't all (essentially) the same. In fact, recessions ARE all the same, in that they are market dislocations that must be worked off before growth can resume. What makes them "different" are the policy choices made by governments when they occur. That is what determines if and when the recovery arrives. When the government stays out of the way, as it did in 1920/21 and 1987, the recovery soon arrives, and growth resumes its pre-downturn trajectory. When the government intervenes, using massive amounts of "stimulus" (read: fake economic activity) and (especially) regulatory "reform" designed to "cure" the "failures" of the markets, the recovery is delayed. In such instance, the government is saying (to the markets, and those who participate in them) "the beatings will continue until morale improves." Is it any wonder that in such instances, (economic) morale never improves? This isn't rocket science...

If the two guys on the desert island are producing something that neither one wants...there is no demand. DUH!

Let's say one guy spends his time fishing and the other spends his time shoveling sand into a large pile....will he be able to trade a pile of sand for some fish to eat? No. So the fisherman has an aggregate demand of enough fish for one person per day and the sand pile construction guy has production, but no demand.

As far as your continued insistence that all recessions/depressions are the same because they are all market dislocations that are solved by doing nothing....The depression of 1920 was not the same as 1929 any more than a 1960 corvette is the same as a 2017 Cadillac except in the most generic of descriptions...yes they are both cars. Yes 1920 and 1929 were both depressions.

1920 was caused by a widespread factory shutdown to retool for civilian products and a Fed action which dramatically increased interest rates. What market clearing took place? The depression eased as factories reopened. The decrease in demand for military goods was offset by the increase in demand for civilian products which had accumulated over time.....

The depression of 1929 was not related to a voluntary shutdown of production and the related unemployment. It was not related to something as simple as interest rates. It was a global financial meltdown due to an overreliance on debt and market valuations that didn't match actual value...much like 2007. When the bubble burst it meant trillions of dollars of value disappeared overnight....just like in 1929.

In the runup to the crash in 1929 the government did not interfere. The crash of 1929 and the loss of two million jobs in 1930 was just the start. The 25% unemployment that we got to by the end of 1932 could have been repeated in 2009....if we followed your advice.

Trump now says we have the lowest unemployment in 17 years and claims credit for it. Is he lying? Of course I would say he is....he's done nothing to create jobs and the trend has been on this trajectory for years.
 
If the two guys on the desert island are producing something that neither one wants...there is no demand. DUH!

Let's say one guy spends his time fishing and the other spends his time shoveling sand into a large pile....will he be able to trade a pile of sand for some fish to eat? No. So the fisherman has an aggregate demand of enough fish for one person per day and the sand pile construction guy has production, but no demand.

As far as your continued insistence that all recessions/depressions are the same because they are all market dislocations that are solved by doing nothing....The depression of 1920 was not the same as 1929 any more than a 1960 corvette is the same as a 2017 Cadillac except in the most generic of descriptions...yes they are both cars. Yes 1920 and 1929 were both depressions.

1920 was caused by a widespread factory shutdown to retool for civilian products and a Fed action which dramatically increased interest rates. What market clearing took place? The depression eased as factories reopened. The decrease in demand for military goods was offset by the increase in demand for civilian products which had accumulated over time.....

The depression of 1929 was not related to a voluntary shutdown of production and the related unemployment. It was not related to something as simple as interest rates. It was a global financial meltdown due to an overreliance on debt and market valuations that didn't match actual value...much like 2007. When the bubble burst it meant trillions of dollars of value disappeared overnight....just like in 1929.

In the runup to the crash in 1929 the government did not interfere. The crash of 1929 and the loss of two million jobs in 1930 was just the start. The 25% unemployment that we got to by the end of 1932 could have been repeated in 2009....if we followed your advice.

Trump now says we have the lowest unemployment in 17 years and claims credit for it. Is he lying? Of course I would say he is....he's done nothing to create jobs and the trend has been on this trajectory for years.

Why would anyone for a minute considering doing such a thing as producing something nobody wants? Naturally the anti-capitalist left will instantly assume the "stupid capitalists" will make whatever they want, and cause a market dislocation, without "the competent guiding hand of government" to keep everything in sync. And the fact, of course, is that nothing could be further from the truth. Producers make what people want, or they go out of business fast. Only under "the competent guiding hand of government" can these kinds of market dislocations actually be sustained (think: electric vehicles), which of course, simply points out starkly the kinds of things governments do that get in the way of an economic recovery (Obama's "green" agenda riddled his "stimulus" bill, which, of course, is why it failed).

So the idea that recessions are like cars is rather self serving, don't you think? After all, a car can't be left alone to repair itself, so it plays into your false assertion that economies need "fixed" during downturns. I'm sure the Keynesians will all be nodding their heads at your suggestion, but actually beyond the fact that internal combustion cars across eras all run on a system that boils down to air, fuel and spark (which can actually be used to support my suggestion that, under the hood, all recessions are the same), your position in this thread functionally is the mirror image of the auto analogy. We know that, if left alone, economies will always recover (quite well, actually, based on history). There are only two instances where the economy did not recover for an extended period of time, both when market loathing Presidents decided to use their great powers to tinker under the hood, despite knowing a lot less about economics than the average dude does about working on a car. There's an appropriate auto analogy!
 
Why would anyone for a minute considering doing such a thing as producing something nobody wants? Naturally the anti-capitalist left will instantly assume the "stupid capitalists" will make whatever they want, and cause a market dislocation, without "the competent guiding hand of government" to keep everything in sync. And the fact, of course, is that nothing could be further from the truth. Producers make what people want, or they go out of business fast. Only under "the competent guiding hand of government" can these kinds of market dislocations actually be sustained (think: electric vehicles), which of course, simply points out starkly the kinds of things governments do that get in the way of an economic recovery (Obama's "green" agenda riddled his "stimulus" bill, which, of course, is why it failed).

So the idea that recessions are like cars is rather self serving, don't you think? After all, a car can't be left alone to repair itself, so it plays into your false assertion that economies need "fixed" during downturns. I'm sure the Keynesians will all be nodding their heads at your suggestion, but actually beyond the fact that internal combustion cars across eras all run on a system that boils down to air, fuel and spark (which can actually be used to support my suggestion that, under the hood, all recessions are the same), your position in this thread functionally is the mirror image of the auto analogy. We know that, if left alone, economies will always recover (quite well, actually, based on history). There are only two instances where the economy did not recover for an extended period of time, both when market loathing Presidents decided to use their great powers to tinker under the hood, despite knowing a lot less about economics than the average dude does about working on a car. There's an appropriate auto analogy!

Unreal...I brought up cars to point out the problem with your comparing one depression to another and saying they are the same...you then start comparing cars to depressions.

Why would someone produce a product nobody wants? How many Edsels did Ford produce vs how many they sold?

In any case, you missed the point. I was pointing out the problem with your putting the cart before the horse....demand drives production, not the other way around.
 
Unreal...I brought up cars to point out the problem with your comparing one depression to another and saying they are the same...you then start comparing cars to depressions.

Why would someone produce a product nobody wants? How many Edsels did Ford produce vs how many they sold?

In any case, you missed the point. I was pointing out the problem with your putting the cart before the horse....demand drives production, not the other way around.

You brought up "different" cars in an effort to support your suggestion that "all recessions are different." Despite the overall analogy being an apples to neutron bombs comparison, there is a kernel in it that supports my suggestion that the recessions are all (essentially) the same - the fact that they ( the 1960 Corvette and the 2017 Cadillac) both run on air, fuel and spark. So under the hood, they are basically the same, just like economic downturns.

How many Edsels did Ford sell? All of them! Except for the ones they put in their museum. That is how markets work - if you make something no one wants, you must cut the price until they do, and if that price is below cost, then you must shut that business down. That is a market dislocation, and it happens all the time.

When the economy enters a downturn, because those dislocations exist, prices must be adjusted and, if necessary, businesses must close. Not to worry, as new ones will replace them. Unless, of course, you have big government involved trying to make employers keep wages (and prices) high, as FDR did to piss poor effect in the 1930s to using government money to bail out banks and insurance companies and auto companies, as Bushbama did to piss poor effect in the mid-00s.

Yes, "demand" drives production, but only in that we produce in order to pay for our "demand." And in that sense, you in fact do not get to consume until you have produced something. This is as essential a fact as the fact that water is wet. Look at it this way - you can actually engage in production, without consumption (which is the act of funding a demand). But you simply cannot consume without (someone, somewhere, engaging in) production. To suggest otherwise is stupid, but you are welcome to keep doing it.

Actually, what you are doing here is conflating consumption and demand, which is the logical fallacy in which all Keynesians engage. So yes, demand can exist without production, and it does all the time (because it is infinite). But consumption is actually not just demand, or "wanting something" - it is the financial fulfillment of demand. The idea that that must come before any production can occur completely turns logic on its head? Without production, where does the means to trade for anything come from? The government just conjures it out of thin air? Because that is what you are (in effect) saying here. LOL!
 
You brought up "different" cars in an effort to support your suggestion that "all recessions are different." Despite the overall analogy being an apples to neutron bombs comparison, there is a kernel in it that supports my suggestion that the recessions are all (essentially) the same - the fact that they ( the 1960 Corvette and the 2017 Cadillac) both run on air, fuel and spark. So under the hood, they are basically the same, just like economic downturns.

How many Edsels did Ford sell? All of them! Except for the ones they put in their museum. That is how markets work - if you make something no one wants, you must cut the price until they do, and if that price is below cost, then you must shut that business down. That is a market dislocation, and it happens all the time.

When the economy enters a downturn, because those dislocations exist, prices must be adjusted and, if necessary, businesses must close. Not to worry, as new ones will replace them. Unless, of course, you have big government involved trying to make employers keep wages (and prices) high, as FDR did to piss poor effect in the 1930s to using government money to bail out banks and insurance companies and auto companies, as Bushbama did to piss poor effect in the mid-00s.

Yes, "demand" drives production, but only in that we produce in order to pay for our "demand." And in that sense, you in fact do not get to consume until you have produced something. This is as essential a fact as the fact that water is wet. Look at it this way - you can actually engage in production, without consumption (which is the act of funding a demand). But you simply cannot consume without (someone, somewhere, engaging in) production. To suggest otherwise is stupid, but you are welcome to keep doing it.

Actually, what you are doing here is conflating consumption and demand, which is the logical fallacy in which all Keynesians engage. So yes, demand can exist without production, and it does all the time (because it is infinite). But consumption is actually not just demand, or "wanting something" - it is the financial fulfillment of demand. The idea that that must come before any production can occur completely turns logic on its head? Without production, where does the means to trade for anything come from? The government just conjures it out of thin air? Because that is what you are (in effect) saying here. LOL!

Nice dance. No, the corvette and the Cadillac are dramatically different...and that was my point.

Ford produced a total of 118,287 Edsels. They sold 116,000. Production did not drive demand.

When factories closed to retool for civilian products that meant that production went negative and unemployment soared. That meant that demand dropped only due to the lack of resources to buy products. There was no unemployment insurance then. So how can the government help improve that downward cycle? Unemployment insurance...so that in a consumer economy you do not lose millions of consumers. You seem to think the answer is to let people make less money as it turns into an employer's market....Is that right?
 
Nice dance. No, the corvette and the Cadillac are dramatically different...and that was my point.

Ford produced a total of 118,287 Edsels. They sold 116,000. Production did not drive demand.

When factories closed to retool for civilian products that meant that production went negative and unemployment soared. That meant that demand dropped only due to the lack of resources to buy products. There was no unemployment insurance then. So how can the government help improve that downward cycle? Unemployment insurance...so that in a consumer economy you do not lose millions of consumers. You seem to think the answer is to let people make less money as it turns into an employer's market....Is that right?

You keep mis-stating the "production drives demand" argument as something it isn't, and then declaring victory.

It's pretty simple really - when a factory shuts down and people are out of work, and they get a check from the government so they can keep CONSUMING (stop calling it "demand" - they keep "demanding" food when they don't get that check, they just can't CONSUME it), where does that funding come from? If it isn't coming from someone's past, current or future PRODUCTION, is it just pulled out of Krugman's ass???
 
Back
Top