New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

so here's a question

Judy1

Mayor
For those of you who think that employers should have a right to deny women employees birth control coverage as part of a group health insurance policy if it goes against their religious beliefs, would you also be in favor of an employer denying coverage for blood transfusions if their religious beliefs prohibit it?
 
For those of you who think that employers should have a right to deny women employees birth control coverage as part of a group health insurance policy if it goes against their religious beliefs, would you also be in favor of an employer denying coverage for blood transfusions if their religious beliefs prohibit it?

How about if one denies science as an antithesis to their religion, they are denied the benefits of science? How many "creationists" will suddenly become fully self sufficient and heal themselves? How many will stop using computers?

History has shown us the answers.
 
For those of you who think that employers should have a right to deny women employees birth control coverage as part of a group health insurance policy if it goes against their religious beliefs, would you also be in favor of an employer denying coverage for blood transfusions if their religious beliefs prohibit it?

Ms. Judy,

Thanks for the red herring. Birth control is an elective procedure, so they are two unrelated issues. You really should stop regurgitating the pap your handlers feed you. It make you look the uneducated boob.
 
For those of you who think that employers should have a right to deny women employees birth control coverage as part of a group health insurance policy if it goes against their religious beliefs, would you also be in favor of an employer denying coverage for blood transfusions if their religious beliefs prohibit it?

Or if some employer founded a religion, the central tenet being that man should not interefere with God's will through medicine, and should just let people live ir die without health care measures.
 
Ms. Judy,

Thanks for the red herring. Birth control is an elective procedure, so they are two unrelated issues. You really should stop regurgitating the pap your handlers feed you. It make you look the uneducated boob.

No, not all birth control is elective, its use is not exclusively for prevention of birth, there are several medical reasons for it, but that's really beside the point. Why are you so in favor of controlling women? How do you suppose men will take it if their wives all start refusing them sex. Be careful what you ask for, for you will surely get it. ;o)
 
No, not all birth control is elective, its use is not exclusively for prevention of birth, there are several medical reasons for it, but that's really beside the point. Why are you so in favor of controlling women? How do you suppose men will take it if their wives all start refusing them sex. Be careful what you ask for, for you will surely get it. ;o)

And blood transfusions are clearly elective. Indeed, Jehovah's Witnesses refuse them.

This guy tries to draw a distinction without a difference.
 
And blood transfusions are a medical necessity--birth control pills (when used for prevention of pregnancy) are not. If BC pills are needed to treat a medical condition, then they are covered. Why is that so hard to understand?
 
How about cosmetic surgery like Pelosi has, should all women have free access to BOTOX, or just the EX-Speaker of the House?
 
And blood transfusions are a medical necessity--birth control pills (when used for prevention of pregnancy) are not. If BC pills are needed to treat a medical condition, then they are covered. Why is that so hard to understand?

Isn't Viagra covered by insurance?
 
Actually pregnancy can be life threatening to some. Heart problems and pelvic infections leading to ectopic pregnancies lead some to want to avoid pregnancy, not because they're slvts, but because some men won't take no for an answer.

I would also ask if pregnancy is voluntary or not. If so, based on that premse, why should people be paying to cover the medical expenses of those who choose to have children?

How are public schools funded, only by people who have children? How about someone who puts seven children through the school system versus those that only put one, two or none at all?
 
ALL.....healthcare is "elective", despite someone above's effort to draw a distinction between blood transfusions and birth-control. Most of us "elect" to allow blood tranfusions, but some don't. Our personal opinions as to the elections of those who do not, don't magically make blood transfusions unelective. The same is the case with birth-control. Obviously, some elect TO avail themselves of birth-control and some elect not to.

I would challenge anyone to suggest a healthcare product that isn't elective. And....don't bother citing anything for which YOU don't think there's a choice. See if you can come up with something for which no choice is allowed.
 
How about cosmetic surgery like Pelosi has, should all women have free access to BOTOX, or just the EX-Speaker of the House?

Cosmetic surgery is not usually covered by insurance unless it is reconstructive in nature.
 
Actually pregnancy can be life threatening to some. Heart problems and pelvic infections leading to ectopic pregnancies lead some to want to avoid pregnancy, not because they're slvts, but because some men won't take no for an answer.

I would also ask if pregnancy is voluntary or not. If so, based on that premse, why should people be paying to cover the medical expenses of those who choose to have children?

How are public schools funded, only by people who have children? How about someone who puts seven children through the school system versus those that only put one, two or none at all?

Bingo!
 
If an owner of a pharmacy chooses, he/she can keep items from his shop that go against his religion (morning after pills, etc). The marketplace would determine whether his pharmacy succeeded or failed, but obviously, a pharmacy that refuses to sell condoms, birth control pills and anything else along those lines would probably not stay in business for very long. Problem solved. If that pharmacy owner provides and owns the insurance for his employees, then he can decide what benefits to offer, and prospective employees can either go for it, or decline the job based on a terrible package offered. I have had more than one job where only large-ticket items are paid for by my insurance. And I have had even more jobs where teeth cleaning was paid for but a root canal only had a small percentage paid and (for example) whitening procedures were not covered at all.

And yes. It is the employer's option as to what kind of insurance package he offers. It's an over-reach by the government to tell a private (non-government) employer what must be covered.

The problem we are facing now goes deeper than that. If a Catholic owned hospital chooses not to offer any insurance coverage for killing unborn babies or preventing the conception of those babies, the government does not (by the edict of our First Amendment) have the right to force them to go against the principles of their church and pay for women to kill their unborn children or keep from having children. Those hospitals can, of course, choose to pay for those things.............. but the government does not have the right to tell them what to do.

And, yes. If the Jehovah's Witness church owns a hospital that they have as a hallmark of their religion, they are not only Constitutionally able to deny blood transfusions at their hospital, but they can refuse to cover transfusions in the insurance they give to their employees. Now, I don't need to tell you that a hospital like that wouldn't be in business for long. But that's not our problem. It's theirs. And it is certainly not the right of our government to take control and start running their hospital in some way that goes against their religion.

Nobody is forced to work at a Catholic hospital that has less than desirable benefits. And nobody is forced to go to that hospital when sick.

But since I am in favor of sticking to our Constitution and do NOT consider it to be "fundamentally flawed", I think I will stick to strict interpretation with this one.
 
Yes, of course. But that doesn't change the First Amendment of our Constitution. The Catholic Hospital on the corner isn't the only one in town.
 
Yes, of course. But that doesn't change the First Amendment of our Constitution. The Catholic Hospital on the corner isn't the only one in town.

It could be. In Oregon, Providence (a catholic hospital system) has the only hospital in Hood River and Seaside.
 
The Supreme Court - throughout its history and including the current one, routinely rules based on what's "real", as opposed to absolutism. That's why we have the Supreme Court. One poster "feels" that the Catholic Hospital isn't the only one in town. But of course...in many towns, the reality is that the Catholic Hospital IS the only one.

And on a sidenote, it's been at least a century since any hospital in the U.S, has operated independently of the state. A hospital that tried operating absent any of the multitude of state regulations, oversight, and certifications, wouldn't have any "customers". For instance, would you go to a hospital where none of the doctors were licensed? All American hospitals - to include Catholic ones, are utterly dependent upon the state.
 
If an owner of a pharmacy chooses, he/she can keep items from his shop that go against his religion (morning after pills, etc). The marketplace would determine whether his pharmacy succeeded or failed, but obviously, a pharmacy that refuses to sell condoms, birth control pills and anything else along those lines would probably not stay in business for very long. Problem solved. If that pharmacy owner provides and owns the insurance for his employees, then he can decide what benefits to offer, and prospective employees can either go for it, or decline the job based on a terrible package offered. I have had more than one job where only large-ticket items are paid for by my insurance. And I have had even more jobs where teeth cleaning was paid for but a root canal only had a small percentage paid and (for example) whitening procedures were not covered at all.

And yes. It is the employer's option as to what kind of insurance package he offers. It's an over-reach by the government to tell a private (non-government) employer what must be covered.

The problem we are facing now goes deeper than that. If a Catholic owned hospital chooses not to offer any insurance coverage for killing unborn babies or preventing the conception of those babies, the government does not (by the edict of our First Amendment) have the right to force them to go against the principles of their church and pay for women to kill their unborn children or keep from having children. Those hospitals can, of course, choose to pay for those things.............. but the government does not have the right to tell them what to do.

And, yes. If the Jehovah's Witness church owns a hospital that they have as a hallmark of their religion, they are not only Constitutionally able to deny blood transfusions at their hospital, but they can refuse to cover transfusions in the insurance they give to their employees. Now, I don't need to tell you that a hospital like that wouldn't be in business for long. But that's not our problem. It's theirs. And it is certainly not the right of our government to take control and start running their hospital in some way that goes against their religion.

Nobody is forced to work at a Catholic hospital that has less than desirable benefits. And nobody is forced to go to that hospital when sick.

But since I am in favor of sticking to our Constitution and do NOT consider it to be "fundamentally flawed", I think I will stick to strict interpretation with this one.

No one is forced to have children, so by your argument and premise, pay for your own pregnancies and births please, don't ask others to pay for your choices. By your same premise, no one is forced to use birth control against their will, only to provide equitable coverage across the board for all employees, that same as is provided for all those who choose to have 10 or 15 children, by those that have none, or only a few.

How much more does this have to be rehashed? The measure was defeated in Congress, the polls show how many women use birth control, even against their beliefs, the Komen Foundation heard the word on their attempts to shut off funding to Planned Parenthood, Rush Limbaugh's bosses are still trying to figure out their losses. Can you take a hint?

The problem appears to be a refusal to face reality, not unlike a refusal to believe Copernicus and Galileo and thus trying to try one as a heretic for stating a new reality. Any reality in your household in terms of birth control use? If so, do you call your family members the same thing Rush Limbaugh calls them based on their use of contraceptives? Sorry, but you seem to be confused in your arguments Jen and you don't seem to have a good grasp of the Constitution if you think anyone is kept from practicing their beliefs. One can believe that birth control is not acceptable and not use it. No infringement on practicing their beliefs. They don't have to force someone else to practice their beliefs either. Ironically, the government is trying to be less discriminatory than a Christian religion here by saying if one covers drugs and medicines for anyone, all eligible drugs and medicines must be covered equitably. Some suggest that others must adopt their religious beliefs or be discriminated against.

How would Christ have handled it? Would Christ have said, 'Father, condemn them for what they have done, only those who believe as I do are worthy of your forgiveness'?

http://onpoint.wbur.org/2012/03/01/leaving-religion-behind

People aren't putting their faith in a God away, they are putting their faith in humanly organized religion aside because of all the disparities, contradictions, manipulations and hypocrisies of some who claim to be what they do not act to be.

There you go calling abortion murder again. Why would someone NOT want to try to avoid being pregnant, having to contemplate terminating a pregnancy and being called a murderer. I suppose being called a slvt is better than being called a murderer by all those good “Christians”. How does one “kill an unborn”? Is that like killing the dead? What are the unborn names, how are they baptized? How does anyone know their gender? They’re unborn, no? Why is there such a problem with life beginning at birth??
 
And you believe that because of that it's okay for the government to force the Catholic church to kill unborn babies and provide and pay for things it believes will send people straight to hell........... and then continue to preach on Sunday that those things are wrong? How can anyone believe that the government should be so assertive over freedom that it can force such a thing? I can't.
 
And you believe that because of that it's okay for the government to force the Catholic church to kill unborn babies and provide and pay for things it believes will send people straight to hell........... and then continue to preach on Sunday that those things are wrong? How can anyone believe that the government should be so assertive over freedom that it can force such a thing? I can't.

Huh?

You can't kill an unborn baby.

In any case, Catholic entities don't have to pay for contraception. Their insurance companies do.
 
Back
Top