New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Some hard truths:

indeed, particularly those killed by way of the signature strikes or by doing the humane thing -- rushing to help as many Bostonians rightly did.

This is why since the twin towers fell, I've argued that the twin sisters of ignorance and apathy figuratively replaced them. It's not that they weren't present before then, it's just that their shadows never darkened the entire land with such depth and breadth prior to it. I've also thought that the rise of islamophobia and the tolerance for it in some, and acceptance in many others, is what opened the door for the same for our resident racists in proportions previously unseen in the short history prior to it, when they were largely on the fringe of our society.

"This lesson is never learned because, it seems, many people don't want to learn it."

good post arky -- have a good one
 
Here is an uncomfortable, but important, way of looking at the Boston attack.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/apr/16/boston-marathon-explosions-notes-reactions

The quoted Tweet sums it up:

"I'm up for us 'all being Bostonians today,' but can we all be Yemenis & Pakistanis the day after? That's how empathy works."

I'm not aware that Boston is a haven for terrorists in quite the same way that some parts of Yemen and Pakistan are. But if you still think it's a good analogy, go with it....
 
I'm not aware that Boston is a haven for terrorists in quite the same way that some parts of Yemen and Pakistan are. But if you still think it's a good analogy, go with it....

That's your response?! Our sympathy for innocents who get maimed and killed, such as first responders in follow-up strikes, shouldn't be changed one bit by whether more or fewer of their neighbors might have been terrorists.
 
That's your response?! Our sympathy for innocents who get maimed and killed, such as first responders in follow-up strikes, shouldn't be changed one bit by whether more or fewer of their neighbors might have been terrorists.

I did not read your link until after I had posted. IF it is true that we are using secondary strikes to kill first responders, I am very much opposed to that. IF. But, as you like to say, that is simply an assertion.
 
We drop bombs and raid locales all over the world as long as we think we could possibly "get" a bad guy. And, care little of the collateral damage we leave behind. Then act surprised when someone does it to us. We really have no need to look further than our military operations to see where our terrorist both home and abroad have learned to just kill and or maim anyone in their way. Winning is the only thing that matters, apparently.
 
We drop bombs and raid locales all over the world as long as we think we could possibly "get" a bad guy. And, care little of the collateral damage we leave behind. Then act surprised when someone does it to us. We really have no need to look further than our military operations to see where our terrorist both home and abroad have learned to just kill and or maim anyone in their way. Winning is the only thing that matters, apparently.

Where we differ is that I do not think it is true that we "care little of the collateral damage". We have always regretted the loss of innocent civilian life. I do not believe that we are deliberately targeting innocent civilians. Unless you think those folks running the marathon in Boston and those watching it were guilty of some unspecified crime, it is clear that the Boston bomber DOES. As I noted in my previous reply to Arkady, IF it is true that we are using secondary strikes in our drone attacks, I think that is very wrong of us. But even that is nothing like the firebombing of Dresden in World War II, is it?
 
Yeah, well regretting it doesn't make the person any less dead. Does their family say.. "oh well.. you regret it, my bad.. we're all good here?". Hardly. Our Government advocates killing people - which frequently results in innocent people dying - all so WE can make ourselves feel better and safer. Sorry - you know what I don't want that on my conscience. It is NOT ok - to "accidentally" kill a bunch of Afghanis just so we get one bad guy - so we can pat ourselves on the back and say "good job.". So yes, they target innocents. And, if WE were serious about NOT targeting innocents, we wouldn't excute 99% of the military operations that we do. There is no difference between dropping a bomb on a village to get one bad guy and kill 100 villagers, than planting a bomb at a race for the shear purpose of killing innocents.


connie
 
Yeah, well regretting it doesn't make the person any less dead. Does their family say.. "oh well.. you regret it, my bad.. we're all good here?". Hardly. Our Government advocates killing people - which frequently results in innocent people dying - all so WE can make ourselves feel better and safer. Sorry - you know what I don't want that on my conscience. It is NOT ok - to "accidentally" kill a bunch of Afghanis just so we get one bad guy - so we can pat ourselves on the back and say "good job.". So yes, they target innocents. And, if WE were serious about NOT targeting innocents, we wouldn't excute 99% of the military operations that we do. There is no difference between dropping a bomb on a village to get one bad guy and kill 100 villagers, than planting a bomb at a race for the shear purpose of killing innocents.


connie

Basically, then, you are just saying we should stop fighting the terrorists. We should just surrender to them. Whatever they ask or want us to do, we should hop to it, right away! Because you certainly have not offered ANY OTHER METHOD for fighting terrorism.

I do not believe, for a moment, that the ratio of innocent people killed, to 'bad guys' killed, is anything even remotely close to your ratio of 100 to 1. The U.S. government says that relatively few innocent civilians have been killed. It is possible, of course, that they are lying to us about that. But I have seen insufficient proof, or even evidence, of that; and you have not offered any.
 
Yeah, well you naively believe the relatively few. I am sure it is great comfort to those who have lost loved ones, and had others maimed and seriously injured that is relatively few. AS LONG as we operate with the idea that OUR lives are worth more than their lives - we are going to have people hating us.

I don't believe in "fighting" terrorism or preemtive attacks PERIOD. I believe in defending us, I believe in cultivating and using intelligence. I believe in small, isolated, targeted attacks - much like what was ultimately carried out to get Osama Bin Laden.

The world is not safe. WE are not safe. Our illusion of safety has finally be shattered. This IS our new normal. I advocate we learn to deal with it. And, we learn to improve our methods and processes to detect and intercept actions like this in future.

connie
 
Yeah, well you naively believe the relatively few. I am sure it is great comfort to those who have lost loved ones, and had others maimed and seriously injured that is relatively few. AS LONG as we operate with the idea that OUR lives are worth more than their lives - we are going to have people hating us.

I don't believe in "fighting" terrorism or preemtive attacks PERIOD. I believe in defending us, I believe in cultivating and using intelligence. I believe in small, isolated, targeted attacks - much like what was ultimately carried out to get Osama Bin Laden.

The world is not safe. WE are not safe. Our illusion of safety has finally be shattered. This IS our new normal. I advocate we learn to deal with it. And, we learn to improve our methods and processes to detect and intercept actions like this in future.

connie

The raid to get Osama bin Laden would be a very nice model, yes. But there are thousands of known terrorists just in that region of Pakistan which we have been targeting with drone attacks. Basically, you are arguing that we should be launching thousands of small-scale invasions of Pakistan. I don't think that would make us any more popular in Pakistan. To say the least. Even the raid to get Bin Laden aroused tremendous controversy in that country.

And, I need to add this: You can BET that our government, and our national defense establishment, is ALREADY doing everything they can to "improve our methods and processes to detect and intercept actions like this in future." So that suggestion or recommendation is pretty much meaningless, like a deficit hawk who says we should go after "waste, fraud, and abuse".
 
Yeah, well you naively believe the relatively few. I am sure it is great comfort to those who have lost loved ones, and had others maimed and seriously injured that is relatively few. AS LONG as we operate with the idea that OUR lives are worth more than their lives - we are going to have people hating us.

I don't believe in "fighting" terrorism or preemtive attacks PERIOD. I believe in defending us, I believe in cultivating and using intelligence. I believe in small, isolated, targeted attacks - much like what was ultimately carried out to get Osama Bin Laden.

The world is not safe. WE are not safe. Our illusion of safety has finally be shattered. This IS our new normal. I advocate we learn to deal with it. And, we learn to improve our methods and processes to detect and intercept actions like this in future.

connie

One more note: As the sole superpower of the world, we are ALWAYS going to have people hating us, no matter what we do or do not do. This is the inevitable fate of EVERY superpower, in any era of history. So you had better learn to deal with that.
 
Here is an uncomfortable, but important, way of looking at the Boston attack.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/apr/16/boston-marathon-explosions-notes-reactions

The quoted Tweet sums it up:

"I'm up for us 'all being Bostonians today,' but can we all be Yemenis & Pakistanis the day after? That's how empathy works."


We insist on drone warfare these days, because it is comparatively inexpensive and low risk for us. Drones, however, are indiscriminate in what they kill. They don't know the difference between the radical jihadist and the small child standing nearby. They just go boom. They have the added disadvantages of alienating potential allies in the area and hampering intelligence gathering efforts. Despite what some may try and tell you, they are not a perfect weapon. This administration is particularly enamored with them, however, and so I suppose the folks in Pakistan and Yemen will be enduring them for awhile.
 
Here is an uncomfortable, but important, way of looking at the Boston attack.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/apr/16/boston-marathon-explosions-notes-reactions

The quoted Tweet sums it up:

"I'm up for us 'all being Bostonians today,' but can we all be Yemenis & Pakistanis the day after? That's how empathy works."

What the article brings up is a true concern, "terrorism" has no consistent definition and many "states" have purposefully tried to "define" it as something that would not include their own actions. From where we're sitting, Nagasaki and Hiroshima were "necessary", yet the weight of the idea that they killed tens of thousands of innocent people seems to fly over the head of many and if not that fact, how it hurts our own credibility or fails to reduce our hypocrisy when it comes to trying to suggest others NOT do as we have done. We claim "defense", "necessity", "collateral damage".....yet not only deny others the same "claims" or "justifications", but speak of how horrific and heinous their acts are. They just look at us incredulously.

By the same token others do the same as we do and so goes the tit for tat, "you're worse than we are at doing the same thing" game.

One does not have to be religious to believe in what became repeated sagacious thought defined as the "ethic of reciprosity" Christ's "Golden Rule" was not original to Christ, just a reiteration of what others had offered before his time.

This board alone offers the kind of hatred, bitterness, anger and frustration that taken to an extreme leads to violence. A need to "strike out" or "strike back" at those who have done "us", individually, to loved ones or some other collective body, seems natural, but we have seen how "successful" vengeance and acts of revenge have been at bringing peace in the world. Northern Ireland was, but one example and focus for an era of time. At least in Ireland some peace has been found, even if there are remnants of hard to put away hatred, not unlike here and some in the south of this nation. Israel has been a nation how long? It has seen a sustained period of peace when?

Could there be some practical wisdom to turning the other cheek? How about disarming people with random acts of kindness? After each incident like this we speak of untold admiration for those, with no concern for their own safety, who rush in to help those in need. No less than New York, it was absolutely incredibly uplifting to see humanity in action in Boston. There is hope yet for the humane side of human beings for all those that seem set upon destroying it. The smoke from the first blast had not even cleared and people were rushing to help, the second blast went off and still people rushed toward, not away. One does not need a field of battle to see "heroes" or the humane acts of humans, nor do people do such things for medals and accolades.

The point of the latter is to suggest that perhaps, rather than passing along or expressing hatred and anger toward one another we more respectfully make our cases for our differences as well as sincerely listen to the cases of others, we might demonstrate our humane sides more often and consistently than seeing sudden blossoms of humanity when tragedies occur. We might also think about, in the interest of any ethic of reciprocity, whether we might be doing things to others, that they don't like anymore than we do.

Kids seem to understand this well. When they fight, as they inevitably seem to do in their learning about life, ask any one of those fighting if they like being kicked in the shins or punched in the face. They'll all say no (if there are any that say yes, that is a whole other discussion). The next question you ask them is, if they don't like being kicked in the shins or punched in the face, why are they doing it to someone else and if they think those they are doing it to like it any more than they do? I've seen many lightbulbs light up.

Take away the who and the why and this act remains the same. I believe it is reasonable to say that someone, represnting themselves or a group, foreign or domestic, did not mistakenly place bombs in trash cans near bleachers at the finish line of the Boston Marathon. One look and one listen to the video of the incident or any like it and one can see terrified people who at least for the moment were terrorized, unless there was some horrible mistake in the placement of explosives (by mistake) the act accomplished terrorizing and terrifying people whether that was its intent or not, whether for kicks, whether for some "statement", political or otherwise, it managed to terrorize and terrify. We can get technical on terms and definitions, but even if someone comes up and says I didn't mean to frighten or harm anyone, the event did so, and that is just one reason why "terrorism" has no universally agreed to definition and why people in the nations that have witnessed and felt things like "displays of shock and awe" or atomic bombs dropped by us, terrorism means something different than the one we have written to exclude our own state actions.

I think terrorism can be defined as an "act", "tactic", "event" with or without intent to terrifiy or terrorize, if as a result of an incident, people are terrified or feel terrorized for a period of time following it. Just as in degrees of murder, intent might affect what someone is actually charged with and if convicted, what an appropriate sentencing would be.

I believe it would be very difficult to describe the reaction of people experiencing the event without inclusion of various forms of the verb "terrify".

I think that if instead of teaching anger and vengeance, bitterness and retribution, we thought about and expressed more ways to "turn the other cheek" in such incidents, those seeking the power, through publicity and emotion to shut civil society down by terrifying and terrorizing, will gain less traction. I wouldn't expect we could eliminate all such tragedies, but reduce them in number and not make the infamous famous or credible by doing just what they expected or hoped.
 
We insist on drone warfare these days, because it is comparatively inexpensive and low risk for us. Drones, however, are indiscriminate in what they kill. They don't know the difference between the radical jihadist and the small child standing nearby. They just go boom. They have the added disadvantages of alienating potential allies in the area and hampering intelligence gathering efforts. Despite what some may try and tell you, they are not a perfect weapon. This administration is particularly enamored with them, however, and so I suppose the folks in Pakistan and Yemen will be enduring them for awhile.

Offhand, I can't recall anyone arguing that drones are "a perfect weapon". And while you are right that drones are indiscriminate in who they kill, they are nevertheless a major advance in precision warfare over what we had before, whether it be in Vietnam, or in World War II, or in the Civil War. I am SURE you don't think the firebombing of Dresden was an example of a preferable form of warfare.
 
Offhand, I can't recall anyone arguing that drones are "a perfect weapon". And while you are right that drones are indiscriminate in who they kill, they are nevertheless a major advance in precision warfare over what we had before, whether it be in Vietnam, or in World War II, or in the Civil War. I am SURE you don't think the firebombing of Dresden was an example of a preferable form of warfare.


The drone missile is certainly preferable to 1940's and 1960's technology, if that's your argument. They offer advantages over boots on the ground, as well as disadvantages, the amount of 'collateral damage' being chief among them. It is a terror weapon, much like the pressure cooker bombs in Boston, only far more deadly. Every time we use one we should be mindful of that.
 
The drone missile is certainly preferable to 1940's and 1960's technology, if that's your argument. They offer advantages over boots on the ground, as well as disadvantages, the amount of 'collateral damage' being chief among them. It is a terror weapon, much like the pressure cooker bombs in Boston, only far more deadly. Every time we use one we should be mindful of that.

I tend to think we should be using them much more sparingly than we have been. I'll give you that.
 
I did not read your link until after I had posted. IF it is true that we are using secondary strikes to kill first responders, I am very much opposed to that. IF. But, as you like to say, that is simply an assertion.

Yes, at this point it's simply an assertion. I wouldn't advocate executing the people allegedly responsible for launching those strikes against first responders, for their war crimes, until AFTER a judge and jury had established, beyond a reasonable doubt, at a proper trial, with benefit of counsel, that they had, indeed, done such a thing. However, there''s plenty of basis for the assertion:

http://www.businessinsider.com/us-drone-tweets-reveal-double-tap-plan-2012-12
 
I don't really care if the rest of the world hates us or not. It is a fact of life and it is well accepted by me. Doesn't mean we get to just go kill them though. Doesn't mean we should't expect them to try to kill us. Or expect that our own countrymen will try to kill others considering the appalling lack of respect for life that our Government has shown.

connie
 
Where we differ is that I do not think it is true that we "care little of the collateral damage". We have always regretted the loss of innocent civilian life. I do not believe that we are deliberately targeting innocent civilians. Unless you think those folks running the marathon in Boston and those watching it were guilty of some unspecified crime, it is clear that the Boston bomber DOES. As I noted in my previous reply to Arkady, IF it is true that we are using secondary strikes in our drone attacks, I think that is very wrong of us. But even that is nothing like the firebombing of Dresden in World War II, is it?

Leroy, if you will notice, some people will make wild assumptions and then get incensed at what they assume these assumptions mean. They start with the assumption that anything the US does to protect our interests (people) will result in collateral damage and loss of innocent lives. They extrapolate from their "out of the anus" assumptions that Obama is just sitting in his office rubbing his hands and chuckling while ordering indiscriminate hits on innocent civilians. They never seem to acknowledge that these hits are made to protract AMERICANS.
 
Back
Top