New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Stuff You Should Know -- Guns

Arkady

President
This is a general plug and a topic.

The plug is for a podcast I've been listening to for a few years: Stuff You Should Know. It's free, and can be found on iTunes, or the How Stuff Works mobile app, or YouTube, or here:

http://www.stuffyoushouldknow.com/podcasts/

There was also a Science Channel TV show starring the same people, based on a fictionalized version of the podcast:

http://www.stuffyoushouldknow.com/tvshow/

Every week the hosts take on a new topic, which they separately research then get together and discuss. It can be almost any topic. Past podcasts covered Air Force One, Incan history, the most painful way to die, and microlending. The two hosts are funny, and having the topics batted back and forth by relatively well-informed non-experts makes them a lot more memorable, so you can learn a lot.

As for the topic at hand, their most recent podcast was about guns, which is a frequent subject here. A lot of the research they came up with was the kind of thing most of us have already heard, but they went into an interesting angle I hadn't heard much about: whether carrying a gun actually alters your behavior. The idea is that the mere presence of a gun boosts testosterone and causes people to behave more aggressively, resulting in more violence. This could help to explain the studies that suggest that people are more likely to be killed while carrying a gun than when they aren't. Essentially, the idea is that you may take chances when you're armed that you'd avoid while unarmed (e.g., traveling in an unsafe part of town at night, or confronting some loud-mouthed jerk, etc.) with the idea that it's safe because you're packing heat. That may make it so the mere knowledge of the gun's presence actually causes you to put yourself at greater risk. George Zimmerman would be a good example. Would he have followed Trayvon Martin if he hadn't been carrying a firearm, or would he have waited for the proper authorities to do their job?

Interesting stuff.

One of the more frustrating aspects of this particular podcast is that the research the hosts are depending on is mostly quite dated, since Congress effectively stopped government funding of gun research, back in the 90s, because gun enthusiasts didn't like what the data were saying. The CDC researches all manner of ways people can die, in order to make people safer, but they're barred from spending any money to research guns if the results could be used to support gun control, so for practical purposes there's almost no new gun research being done in this country. As such, we have to rely on old studies or studies done in other countries (like one where Israel soldiers were barred from bringing their weapons home with them, resulting in a 40% drop in suicide rates over the weekend).

Anyway, well worth a listen.
 
I believe that. I don 't know what the answer is as guns are an important part of our country and always will be. I think you can see differences when you go through many states. New Mexico has a rich gun culture based on history and rural life and for them it is unlikely that they be anything but cautious and respectful because it is part of their being and survival. On the other hand there are states where almost nobody should own a gun in terms of not respecting them. I trust a rural cowboy more than I trust a yahoo buying a gun and becoming empowered by it.
 
I believe that. I don 't know what the answer is as guns are an important part of our country and always will be. I think you can see differences when you go through many states. New Mexico has a rich gun culture based on history and rural life and for them it is unlikely that they be anything but cautious and respectful because it is part of their being and survival. On the other hand there are states where almost nobody should own a gun in terms of not respecting them. I trust a rural cowboy more than I trust a yahoo buying a gun and becoming empowered by it.

What percentage of crimes with a firearm do you think are committed by "yahoos" and "rural cowboys" versus, say, gang members and illegal aliens? Care to take a guess?
 
What percentage of crimes with a firearm do you think are committed by "yahoos" and "rural cowboys" versus, say, gang members and illegal aliens? Care to take a guess?

There is no question that some are empowered by guns and do push it in areas they can easily walk away from. My point is that culturally, rural states probably show less propensity to act out because they have a gun. Remember anyone can own a gun. I would guess if I am wrong you'd see higher death rates reflected in rural communities or equal rates percentage wise. I am speaking about the toppost contention of propensity to act out if they have a gun not gangs or street crime.
 
What percentage of crimes with a firearm do you think are committed by "yahoos" and "rural cowboys" versus, say, gang members and illegal aliens? Care to take a guess?
I wouldn't have a clue. However, keep in mind it's not just the crimes. It's the accidents and the suicide, too. When you compare US stats to an amalgamation of our various international "peer" nations, it becomes pretty clear that we're talking about a huge increased mortality associated with our guns, when you count all three of those factors.
 
I wouldn't have a clue. However, keep in mind it's not just the crimes. It's the accidents and the suicide, too. When you compare US stats to an amalgamation of our various international "peer" nations, it becomes pretty clear that we're talking about a huge increased mortality associated with our guns, when you count all three of those factors.

Comparing lion attack stats in Botswana with the stats here also shows a huge increased mortality associated with their lions, but I can't see what that, or your point, has to do with the price of tea in China...
 
There is no question that some are empowered by guns and do push it in areas they can easily walk away from. My point is that culturally, rural states probably show less propensity to act out because they have a gun. Remember anyone can own a gun. I would guess if I am wrong you'd see higher death rates reflected in rural communities or equal rates percentage wise. I am speaking about the toppost contention of propensity to act out if they have a gun not gangs or street crime.

I think one way to think of the urban/rural difference is to think of guns as the spark and people as the tinder. If you're somewhere without a lot of tinder, you can have a source of sparks and you aren't going to get many fires. If you're somewhere with a bunch of tinder, the same number of sparks is much more dangerous.

Just to give a practical example of urban vs. rural context, consider a scenario where some jackass insists on having loud parties all hours of the night and absolutely refuses to shut up. If he's in an apartment building where fifty other households are close enough to be kept up late and inconvenienced by his party, you're going to have serious friction. Let's say one of them is a hot head who goes to the neighbor's apartment with the plan to shoot out the stereo to make a point, only the neighbor is also a hothead with a gun, and someone winds up dead. Now, transfer that to a rural area. In order to draw a circle big enough to involve fifty other households, you might be a mile away from the source of noise, so the chance of anyone being shooting mad about it is basically zilch.

So, I'd argue that it's not that rural people are more respectful of guns. I've heard of too many drunk hunters doing some seriously stupid crap to believe that. Rather, it's just that in a rural area the setting is such that a dumb guy with a gun is less likely to result in a body count than if the exact same dumb guy is living in a dense inner city setting, where he'll be interacting with lots of other dumb people in tight, tense quarters.
 
I think one way to think of the urban/rural difference is to think of guns as the spark and people as the tinder. If you're somewhere without a lot of tinder, you can have a source of sparks and you aren't going to get many fires. If you're somewhere with a bunch of tinder, the same number of sparks is much more dangerous.

Just to give a practical example of urban vs. rural context, consider a scenario where some jackass insists on having loud parties all hours of the night and absolutely refuses to shut up. If he's in an apartment building where fifty other households are close enough to be kept up late and inconvenienced by his party, you're going to have serious friction. Let's say one of them is a hot head who goes to the neighbor's apartment with the plan to shoot out the stereo to make a point, only the neighbor is also a hothead with a gun, and someone winds up dead. Now, transfer that to a rural area. In order to draw a circle big enough to involve fifty other households, you might be a mile away from the source of noise, so the chance of anyone being shooting mad about it is basically zilch.

So, I'd argue that it's not that rural people are more respectful of guns. I've heard of too many drunk hunters doing some seriously stupid crap to believe that. Rather, it's just that in a rural area the setting is such that a dumb guy with a gun is less likely to result in a body count than if the exact same dumb guy is living in a dense inner city setting, where he'll be interacting with lots of other dumb people in tight, tense quarters.

This is your explanation for the massive levels of gun crime in places like Chicago, Detroit, LA and Oakland? Really?
 
Comparing lion attack stats in Botswana with the stats here also shows a huge increased mortality associated with their lions, but I can't see what that, or your point, has to do with the price of tea in China...
If the stats showed fairly constant accident/suicide/crime rates, among the wealthy nations, and all that varied was the form they took from one country to another, then it would devastate the case for gun control. Then we could say, for example, "nearly everyone who decides to kill someone is going to find a way, so all gun control does is move some people from the firearm-homicide column to the non-firearm homicide column." But that's not what the data show, here in the real world. They show that our severely elevated firearm-homicide rate is not offset by a depressed rate of homicides using other implements. In other words, some meaningful number of people who kill other people would not have done so if firearms were not readily available. And that makes perfect common sense if you think through scenarios honestly -- scenarios where, for example, a person experiencing just a brief moment of blind, homicidal rage would calm down enough not to kill anyone within just a few seconds, but that few seconds was enough to leave a corpse because that's all it takes when a gun is at hand.
 
Last edited:
This is your explanation for the massive levels of gun crime in places like Chicago, Detroit, LA and Oakland? Really?
That's part of the explanation. If you look almost anywhere in the world or any time in history, you'll find elevated violent crime rates in the cities, relative to rural areas. It's an almost immutable fact of sociology. But, that doesn't mean all cities are equal. Other factors include poverty, racial tensions, the drug war, income inequality, and the presence of guns. So, you'll find some cities where violent crime is practically unknown (though still higher than in surrounding rural areas), such as Munich. And you'll find some cities where it's rampant, like New Orleans, Detroit, and St. Louis.
 
This is a general plug and a topic.

The plug is for a podcast I've been listening to for a few years: Stuff You Should Know. It's free, and can be found on iTunes, or the How Stuff Works mobile app, or YouTube, or here:

http://www.stuffyoushouldknow.com/podcasts/

There was also a Science Channel TV show starring the same people, based on a fictionalized version of the podcast:

http://www.stuffyoushouldknow.com/tvshow/

Every week the hosts take on a new topic, which they separately research then get together and discuss. It can be almost any topic. Past podcasts covered Air Force One, Incan history, the most painful way to die, and microlending. The two hosts are funny, and having the topics batted back and forth by relatively well-informed non-experts makes them a lot more memorable, so you can learn a lot.

As for the topic at hand, their most recent podcast was about guns, which is a frequent subject here. A lot of the research they came up with was the kind of thing most of us have already heard, but they went into an interesting angle I hadn't heard much about: whether carrying a gun actually alters your behavior. The idea is that the mere presence of a gun boosts testosterone and causes people to behave more aggressively, resulting in more violence. This could help to explain the studies that suggest that people are more likely to be killed while carrying a gun than when they aren't. Essentially, the idea is that you may take chances when you're armed that you'd avoid while unarmed (e.g., traveling in an unsafe part of town at night, or confronting some loud-mouthed jerk, etc.) with the idea that it's safe because you're packing heat. That may make it so the mere knowledge of the gun's presence actually causes you to put yourself at greater risk. George Zimmerman would be a good example. Would he have followed Trayvon Martin if he hadn't been carrying a firearm, or would he have waited for the proper authorities to do their job?

Interesting stuff.

One of the more frustrating aspects of this particular podcast is that the research the hosts are depending on is mostly quite dated, since Congress effectively stopped government funding of gun research, back in the 90s, because gun enthusiasts didn't like what the data were saying. The CDC researches all manner of ways people can die, in order to make people safer, but they're barred from spending any money to research guns if the results could be used to support gun control, so for practical purposes there's almost no new gun research being done in this country. As such, we have to rely on old studies or studies done in other countries (like one where Israel soldiers were barred from bringing their weapons home with them, resulting in a 40% drop in suicide rates over the weekend).

Anyway, well worth a listen.


The only thing that matters about guns is this...I would rather have one and not need it, than need one and not have it.
 
I believe that. I don 't know what the answer is as guns are an important part of our country and always will be. I think you can see differences when you go through many states. New Mexico has a rich gun culture based on history and rural life and for them it is unlikely that they be anything but cautious and respectful because it is part of their being and survival. On the other hand there are states where almost nobody should own a gun in terms of not respecting them. I trust a rural cowboy more than I trust a yahoo buying a gun and becoming empowered by it.

I see.

I was raised around guns my whole life. I was taught how to use them, to respect them, and would never dream of using one to harm another human being unless it would prevent a person from serious or grave harm.

According to you, I live in the wrong area to own guns. How do you figure out who gets to keep them and who you confiscate them from? And also according to you, I may be considered "stockpiling", and a target for confiscation. Now tell me how I would need to bow and kiss your ring to get you to show me your good graces and allow me to keep the numerous guns I own.

Better yet, show me some statistics that show "stockpiling" is a threat. Out of 1,000 "stockpilers", how many ever commit a crime?
 
I see.

I was raised around guns my whole life. I was taught how to use them, to respect them, and would never dream of using one to harm another human being unless it would prevent a person from serious or grave harm.

According to you, I live in the wrong area to own guns. How do you figure out who gets to keep them and who you confiscate them from? And also according to you, I may be considered "stockpiling", and a target for confiscation. Now tell me how I would need to bow and kiss your ring to get you to show me your good graces and allow me to keep the numerous guns I own.

Better yet, show me some statistics that show "stockpiling" is a threat. Out of 1,000 "stockpilers", how many ever commit a crime?

Yes all gun owners are always responsible, always. I did not name states that you see less gun respect did I so why assume? You don't have to kiss my ring because I was not talking to or necessarily about you. What made you internalize my point to reflect YOU? I did not mention stockpiling on this thread.
Reaching much? Read Arkady's response to my post as that is how you present a valid argument.
 
I think one way to think of the urban/rural difference is to think of guns as the spark and people as the tinder. If you're somewhere without a lot of tinder, you can have a source of sparks and you aren't going to get many fires. If you're somewhere with a bunch of tinder, the same number of sparks is much more dangerous.

Just to give a practical example of urban vs. rural context, consider a scenario where some jackass insists on having loud parties all hours of the night and absolutely refuses to shut up. If he's in an apartment building where fifty other households are close enough to be kept up late and inconvenienced by his party, you're going to have serious friction. Let's say one of them is a hot head who goes to the neighbor's apartment with the plan to shoot out the stereo to make a point, only the neighbor is also a hothead with a gun, and someone winds up dead. Now, transfer that to a rural area. In order to draw a circle big enough to involve fifty other households, you might be a mile away from the source of noise, so the chance of anyone being shooting mad about it is basically zilch.

So, I'd argue that it's not that rural people are more respectful of guns. I've heard of too many drunk hunters doing some seriously stupid crap to believe that. Rather, it's just that in a rural area the setting is such that a dumb guy with a gun is less likely to result in a body count than if the exact same dumb guy is living in a dense inner city setting, where he'll be interacting with lots of other dumb people in tight, tense quarters.

City folk go hunting too - that may be where the stories come from. lol I think you made some good points and no doubt density comes into it but I'm not convinced that another part not factored in is the rural view of guns as an integral part of their survival even today as they mold their lives as their families handed down to them. They still use it for protection and hunting out of need. That ingredient and possibly even respect seems to be missing in many urban environments. I only have questions as there is no way to prove that point. I have no way of knowing if in the Zimmerman empowerments happen more in cities than in more rural communities. I get the sense that for rural it is part of life, for city it is a statement with a leaning toward empowerment. Just tossing that out there.

As a side semi-related point, people in rural hunting and fishing areas seriously respect the environment and are part of recovery of wilderness whereas in city outskirts deer getting shot out of season, or in preserves, on riverbanks, or along highways is not unheard of. My husband is from Montana and at some point even they hated reckless out of state city hunters invading the area and shooting at everything that moved.
 
The only thing that matters about guns is this...I would rather have one and not need it, than need one and not have it.

I suppose we could say that about any weapon. I'd rather have a shoulder-fired surface-to-air missile and not need it, than to need it and not have it. But if giving up the right to have such a weapon is the cost I pay for keeping them out of the hands of the vast majority of other people, I'd prefer that -- I fly for business a lot, and I don't like the notion of countless yahoos running around near airports armed that way. So, the infinitesimal chance I may need one, some day, isn't as big a factor in my thinking as the risk associated with letting people, generally, own them.

My thoughts about other weapons are similar. I'm not just looking at them from the perspective of the value for me, personally, but rather from the perspective of the indirect impact on me of others having those weapons. It's possible, for example, to think of scenarios where I'd be safer if I were free to own a mortar that fires high-explosive shells... but it's a lot easier to think of scenarios where I'd be less safe if people generally were free to own them. Somewhere between that and the single-shot rifles, there's a tilting point, for me, where the utility of allowing general ownership outweighs the risk. I think nearly everyone passes that kind of tipping point, somewhere between kitchen knives and H-bombs. We merely disagree on where the point lies.
 
I suppose we could say that about any weapon. I'd rather have a shoulder-fired surface-to-air missile and not need it, than to need it and not have it. But if giving up the right to have such a weapon is the cost I pay for keeping them out of the hands of the vast majority of other people, I'd prefer that -- I fly for business a lot, and I don't like the notion of countless yahoos running around near airports armed that way. So, the infinitesimal chance I may need one, some day, isn't as big a factor in my thinking as the risk associated with letting people, generally, own them.

My thoughts about other weapons are similar. I'm not just looking at them from the perspective of the value for me, personally, but rather from the perspective of the indirect impact on me of others having those weapons. It's possible, for example, to think of scenarios where I'd be safer if I were free to own a mortar that fires high-explosive shells... but it's a lot easier to think of scenarios where I'd be less safe if people generally were free to own them. Somewhere between that and the single-shot rifles, there's a tilting point, for me, where the utility of allowing general ownership outweighs the risk. I think nearly everyone passes that kind of tipping point, somewhere between kitchen knives and H-bombs. We merely disagree on where the point lies.


It is NOTHING short of inane hyperbole to equate guns with a "shoulder-fired surface-to-air missile".

It's a ridiculous analogy and you lost all credibility with it as your example.
 
It is NOTHING short of inane hyperbole to equate guns with a "shoulder-fired surface-to-air missile".

It's a ridiculous analogy and you lost all credibility with it as your example.

I realize it makes you very uncomfortable to think your stances through honestly, but it would be very productive if you'd at least try.

All weapons can be placed on a fairly smooth spectrum of destructiveness from bare fists on up to H-bombs. There's a big gap in how many people you could kill in just a few seconds with, say, a shoulder-fired SAM vs. a sling shot, but it's just a difference of magnitude. In exactly the same sense, there's a big gap in how many people you can kill in just a few seconds with a muzzle-loading black-powder musket and a heavy machine gun. At some point, the perceived additional utility of an additional level of destructiveness is going to be outweighed by the perceived additional social problems associated with it, and we'll draw a line and say "after this point, private ownership isn't allowed."

You do it, and I do it too. We each have weapons on one side of a line that we want in the hands of private individuals, and weapons on the other side that we don't, because they're just too dangerous. The big difference is that honest people admit that ultimately they're drawing a line at a more or less arbitrary place, along a spectrum of possible locations for the line, based on practical considerations. Dishonest people prefer to pretend that wherever they happened to draw the line is the necessary and unalterable position for that line (possibly based on some "invisible ink" provision in the second amendment explaining what are not "arms"), and that anyone who would compare something from one side of their line to something from the other is making a ridiculous analogy and so they're entitled to stick their fingers in their ears and say "nah, nah, I can't hear you."
 
I realize it makes you very uncomfortable to think your stances through honestly, but it would be very productive if you'd at least try.

All weapons can be placed on a fairly smooth spectrum of destructiveness from bare fists on up to H-bombs. There's a big gap in how many people you could kill in just a few seconds with, say, a shoulder-fired SAM vs. a sling shot, but it's just a difference of magnitude. In exactly the same sense, there's a big gap in how many people you can kill in just a few seconds with a muzzle-loading black-powder musket and a heavy machine gun. At some point, the perceived additional utility of an additional level of destructiveness is going to be outweighed by the perceived additional social problems associated with it, and we'll draw a line and say "after this point, private ownership isn't allowed."

You do it, and I do it too. We each have weapons on one side of a line that we want in the hands of private individuals, and weapons on the other side that we don't, because they're just too dangerous. The big difference is that honest people admit that ultimately they're drawing a line at a more or less arbitrary place, along a spectrum of possible locations for the line, based on practical considerations. Dishonest people prefer to pretend that wherever they happened to draw the line is the necessary and unalterable position for that line (possibly based on some "invisible ink" provision in the second amendment explaining what are not "arms"), and that anyone who would compare something from one side of their line to something from the other is making a ridiculous analogy and so they're entitled to stick their fingers in their ears and say "nah, nah, I can't hear you."

Horseshit. No one I know wants a rocket launcher. No one.

Hyperbole at it's craziest.

To attempt to make an argument on gun control that equates rocket launchers with Glock 9s is utter and complete horseshit.
 
Back
Top