New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Support for redistribution?

All that really demonstrates is that the GPA system is superior to the Income distribution system and should be held up as a model...and since in that model none are willing to surrender what they themselves have earned with their own hard work it is no real stretch to see how that principle applies to income distribution. The difference here being of course that one can cause you to starve to death physically and literally while the other is merely an assault on your mental abilities......
 
All that really demonstrates is that the GPA system is superior to the Income distribution system and should be held up as a model...and since in that model none are willing to surrender what they themselves have earned with their own hard work it is no real stretch to see how that principle applies to income distribution. The difference here being of course that one can cause you to starve to death physically and literally while the other is merely an assault on your mental abilities......

You seem to be arguing for a cap on incomes.

If the GPA aspect is superior...then doesn't it figure that no one should get more than a 4.0? Or the financial equivalent? Sure...OK...a bit of "extra credit" work might get one a 4.25...maybe a 4.5, but not a 10,000,036.5.
 
That's EXACTLY the point. People object to redistributing grades because of the sense they have that grades are fairly closely associated with the amount of work a person put in. If you altered the grade system to look more like our economic system --largely decoupling the rewards from the work-- redistributing some of the reward would be less objectionable. If, for example you could inherit a lifetime of good grades from your hard-working grandparent, the way you can inherit a lifetime upper-class income stream from a rich grandparent, the idea of "taxing" some of those grades and redistributing them would look a lot more reasonable. In fact, you could flip that around and say we essentially tax everyone 100% on their grades. You don't get to inherit ANY of your parent's or grandparent's "grade wealth." All those "A's" they earned go right back into the pot, with you having no more claim on them than the child of the lowest-scoring student of the prior generation. It's like 100% estate taxes. And you also start from zero at the start of every quarter or semester, or at least every year -- having to earn the next grade from scratch, just like everyone else, rather than being able to simply coast on the "interest" of grades earned in prior years.

It simply isn't a good analogy.
 
You seem to be arguing for a cap on incomes.

If the GPA aspect is superior...then doesn't it figure that no one should get more than a 4.0? Or the financial equivalent? Sure...OK...a bit of "extra credit" work might get one a 4.25...maybe a 4.5, but not a 10,000,036.5.

Sweet... that works for me.

Income caps and the rest goes to our government to pay down our debt.
 
Sorry, but if it takes you an essay to justify your position and argue mine...I'm not interested in what you have to say...especially given the fact that I would have to waste that much time in reading and responding.
 
I hate to say it, but it is already happening. I listened to an interesting piece on Freakanomics Radio on NPR a couple of weeks ago, talking about inflation, not of money, but of everything. Women that used to be considered fat, are now considered to be normal. The actually wastebands in pants and slacks have increase, but the size has remained the same (which explains why I have worn a size 36 since high school). They also talked about how the self esteme movement in schools have degraded the grading system, such that now, just about everybody gets As and Bs. A B-grade today, would have been considered just barely passing ten or twenty years ago.

I couldn't agree more. I see these young kids coming into my industry and they seem to have half a brain. They aren't good at math, and they have all the wrong ideas when it comes to every day life. It would be amusing if it weren't so serious...
 
Apples and oranges there chief...tell me how, for example, YOU deserve what I have earned. The very nature of your question suggests that someone else deserves something from me...now explain why that would be so.

Did you even comprehend my question and is that what my question asked or what I was inferring? Seems you are the one that is trying to suggest someone is claiming to deserve something from you that you don't feel they deserve.


Absolutely I was taught to share my toys...however, those toys remained mine and others were allowed to play with them on a temporary basis. Now, if you are going to assure me that the person being gifted the money that is being taken from me will reimburse me that money at a later time...sure, I'll share until your heart's content. Otherwise, it's not sharing...it's donating. Did your parents teach you that you were supposed to GIVE other kids your toys?

Who's being gifted money that is taken from you? You keep suggesting that every dollar taken from you by tax is gifted to someone who does not deserve it, but have not shown how that occurs. Wefare is NOT intended to be a gift, it is intended to offer relief for those who NEEEED it for the purpose of promoting the general welfare of the nation. In other words, rather than simply step over and kick those who are down on their luck and the children they have are by association struggling, whining about increses in crime by people who are out of work and without any help, those charged with upholding the Constitution, included in that, doing things that would "promote the general welfare" offer some means to do so. It is clear that those who receive assistance are not living in the lap of luxury on the tab of the federal government or without some responsibility on their part to NOT become dependent upon a lifetime of welfare IF they are at all capable of moving to an alternative once government assistance has helped them recover or survive while they found a means to become independent from that assistance. We know people abuse the system and we know the system has failings in enforcement of the rules regarding eligibility, compliance, fraud and abuse.

That is different that the suggestion than the intent of welfare programs and the intent of additional taxation of those who can still live comfortably after paying additional taxes. It is not only inaccurate, but dishonest to suggest the intent and practice of welfare programs are to provide lifelong support for lazy people who are perfectly capable of making a living for themselves. It is not only inaccurate, but dishonest to suggest that a higher tax rate on people that can absorb it is the equivalent of robbing them of money that will be paid directly to provide lifelong support for lazy people who are perfectly capable of making a living for themselves. While, as explained, there are people who abuse, defraud and look the other way (problems that occur in all sectors public or private), it is a myth that either wefare programs or higher tax rates on the wealthy are what you are trying to portray them as.


Perhaps you should go back and reread my post...I qualified my statement...notice the "for many, not all, that includes their lot in life." There are exceptions...and, I'm referring to their financial situation, not the place they choose to reside.

People's lot in life are a complex mix of many things. By your qualification, perhaps you would agree, not all the wealthy "deserve" what they have, just as not all the poor deserve to be poor. Not all the poor are poor because they choose to be and not all the wealthy "earned" the wealth, privileges and leg ups they have taken advantage of. Some people are very wealthy and give most of their annual income away and live very modestly themselves or place their massive incomes into foundations intended to perpetuate charitable giving past the survival of those who create the foundations. As we have seen, some of the very wealthy have no problems at all with paying a higher rate of tax, especially as they are more able to absorb it and STILL live in the lap of luxury, while some others seem to think they somehow need multiplies of what they could possibly use in mulitiple lifetimes, simply because they feel they "earned" it all and not a single other soul had anything to do with it. There are exceptions to everything. As already mentioned, it is dishonest to portray the welfare system as you appear to describe it and to describe higher tax rates on the wealthy as taking from them to then hand all that is taken from them to people who have not "earned it", "deserve it" or "need it". First of all, as also mentioned, not all people feel that way and wefare programs are not intended to offer support for people who do not need it. Beyond that, additional revenue raised from the wealthy who will still be living with multiples of what others live with, will not go directly from the hands it is collected from and into the hands of people who do not need it or even to the coffers of the welfare system

I didn't judge people here...simply allude to the situation where some people choose an easy path in life then complain about how their life sucks because of the decisions they made...I have a sister-in-law that fits that mold to a tee. I don't feel sorry for the situation she finds herself in now because while her other sisters were attending college and making a successful path for their lives, she was content to sit at home and smoke pot with her husband when they got off of their below average paying jobs.

So ditch digging, working in the fields, driving a truck, working on an assembly line are an "easy path in life" in your estimation and those were all "decisions" they made? So people can choose all things in their life and there is nothing outside their lives, like other people's lives or the fact that if all people were CEO's nothing of what CEO's manage would actually be produced or done? I'm not surte what planet you live on, but the one I live on, life happens and that includes all manner of disasters and tragedies that people have no control over, no matter how hard they work or earn what they have. It is unrealistic to say people who are born into wealthy families do not have advantages of connections to and support from other wealthy families if nothing else and access to better education situations as well as job situations and it is not only people who do not have wealth who know that, but A LOT of people who do have wealth who know full well the advantages they have or that they strive to give their offspring. What some people are fighting for and others, like you seem to be fighting against is promoting the general welfare of all the people in this nation for the purpose of raising up the overall level of the nation, making it competitive and keeping it productive, employed and by doing so increasing the chances MORE people can enjoy a higher standard of living, BUT oine that is also stable and sustainable. That means a highly consumptive, greedy, gluttonous and wasteful lifetyle is NOT sustainable if all people attain it or even try to. To raise the level of a sustainable standard of living, adjustments to the current high standard of living have to be made for the simple and practical reason that if every should have the same ambition, work hard and earn every penny they have to become a highly paid person, the earth coiuld not support their lifestyles if they were typical of the highest standards of living that have been found in our society up until the notion that a high standard of living must also include being sustainable.

China has almost 4 times the population of the U.S., India is not far behind. If all people make the choices and decisions you seem to believe are measures of success, do you seriously believe in a world where everyone can acheive lives like Mitt Romney or Donald Trump simply from hard work, "earnig it" and "deserving it"? Who's going to populate the factory assembly lines? Who's going to mine the raw materials, mow the lawns of everyone's multiple estates...plant the seed, grow and harvest fruits and vegetables? Where are all the resources going to come from to fulfill the excessive demand?

I'm not sure if some people know of or can comprehend the meaning and definitions of the words "myopic" and "egocentric", or that there are people on earth besides them all of whom are looking for a way to survive, some of them thinking about how to make survival sustainable so the offspring they bring into this world and love, have at least as much of a chance at a sustainable life as any generations before them or more, but realize money only represents a value, not survival, since all the money in the world cannot buy a life gone or buy necessary for life to exist resources when they have been exhausted and no longer exist.

Yes, some people find all they need do is live in and think about an insular world and an attitude that says as long as they have theirs, nothing else, no wider picture, no others need be considered. Others realize how much all things are innterconnected and insular human created worlds do not exist in a vacuum of self-sufficiency, they depend on all that makes the exisitence of life possible on earth. If some humans destroy that in their pursuit of personal hedonism, it destroys it for all humans, many of whom prefer to live more conservatively, modestly and in a manner that the environment of earth that makes the existence of life possible, can sustain, based on humans being stewards and maintaining a sustainable balance between their needs and desires and what is required for their natural environment (the one that makes the existence of life possible) to sustain its function. That means doing things like NOT fishing more fish out of the sea than is needed to replenish the amount taken out, not cutting more timber than can grow back before returning for more cutting...etc...etc... Some seem to have a difficult time computing why destroying their sources of sustenance and life support systems is not a good idea when they feel their jobs are threatened (apparently NOT being able to compute how their current job activities is what will put them out of a job in the slightly longer term, unless they adjust what they are doing.)

Longer term thinking beyond ourselves may benefit us all in that we might consider and realize the pitfalls of "staying the course" when that course is headed for the rocks unless adjusted.

Again, if you can convince me that someone else DESERVES something that I made...perhaps you can change my mind. Do you, for instance, have a room set up in your house for homeless people to sleep in when the weather gets bad? If so, why not? Are they not deserving of a room in the house YOU bought?

Actually, I haven't set up a room in my house for the homeless, I contribute independently and pay taxes to support organizations and programs that help feed and provide space for more than one homeless person. I don't feel they should simply be walked over as if they did not exist or perhaps necessarily choose to be homeless or have full mental capacity to care for themselves. Perhaps you think otherwise and they are deserving of nothing. While I have paid for my current home fully, for my first home, it was actually a bank, that used the deposits of people like me to fund the purchase of my home, upfront of of my being able to afford the entire amount and until I was able to pay off not only what I was loaned, but the charges in return for the bank (and other people's deposits, funding what I could not. It was a cooperative agreement all around. Yes, strangers who may not have anywhere to go at certain times in their lives because of life's circumstances are welcome in my home, not because I'm keeping tabs and an accounting of whether they "earned" or "deserved" it, but because I was taught that is what being humane and treating people as I would want to be treated was all about. What were you taught?




Yes, they all deserve their wealth and connections in the same manner my son deserves the wealth and connections I and my family have built when I die. Got news for you chief...life ain't fair, but it still happens regardless of the fairness of the situation. Taking more money from the wealthy doesn't fix the problem of someone elses lack of wealth and connections...it's an attempted punishment to make the envious feel like they got to poke a stick in the eye of those evil "did better than I" folks.

Your son deserves what you will pass onto him why, because he earned it and worked hard for it or because he's your son? Isn't that a hereditary thing? Do you like calling people you don't know chief? I agree life ain't fair, that seems to be what you're whining about. As I have illustrated many times. Money represents the value of goods and services traded. The holding up or hoarding of money to the extents that it sets up the situation where those who possess those great pools of money have far more than they need while and are causing the starvation of their nation's economy as they have more than they need and the places that need a minimal amount to survive are not getting even the minimal. That means great wealth in the hands of a few is choking off all the rest in a given society or economy. It also means MORE pressure on those that possess the majority of currency to make up for what those who are choked off can no longer do.

When that pressure is felt personally or in perception, they whine and howl that they are unfairly being asked to make up for all the functions of those they have choked off by holding onto money that is not meant for accumulating and hoarding, but meant for trade, commerce and otherwise circulating, just like human blood. Blood pooled all in one leg provides more blood than that leg can use while depriving all other parts of the body of the blood they need to function. Some people are able to comprehend that. Others whine that one leg deserves more blood than it can use or needs.



There's no "hereditary monarchy or just aristocracy or plutarchy" about it. Each of those are a type of government and none of them exist in this country.

I didn't say they did or did not exist in this country, only that this country was founded on opposition to monarchy and designed with a capacity to check and balance undue influence and power, based on the founders knowledge of history and how figures in history have used great wealth for undue influence and to maintain power.


Absolutely the ones with wealth and connections have a bigger advantage...but that's the way it's always been, the way it is in every single corner of the earth now,
and the way it will be in the future. Difference is...I'm not envious of those people and lie awake at night trying to figure out some way to punish their success...many on your side of politics are and do.


You know nothing about me or whether I AM one of those you like to claim anyone might be jealous of or not. Regardless of whether I am or not, you ignore or discount all the people that ARE wealthy who have no problems with higher tax rates on themselves. Are you trying to suggest they are "envious" of themselves?

Your contentions might make sense as long as you ignore and hope others have not noticed or are not wealthy people who are all for paying higher rates of taxes. Perhaps you hope no one talks about or thinks about why some wealthy people have no problems with higher tax rates on themselves and others do or discusses the definitions, meanings and possible recognitions and signs of greed and gluttony as opposed to those who have no problems with liberality or any discussion of what at least one major religion lists as some of the "deadliest" sins and what it lists as human virtues and what might have been long considered the virtues that are cures for the deadliest sins.

Maybe hard to square on a lot of levels, but harder to square at the highest levels. How easy is it to write it off and dismiss it as "envy"? Certainly a lot, if not most people have an interest in achieving a very basic level of comfort and security in their lives. Where that level lis exactly is unclear and varies in a relative sense, but there seems little doubt where the departure from a comfort and security level most people would be grateful to one that is far in excess of that. The "American Dream" has gone from a modest comfort and security level to the wildest fantasies of Gordon Gekko (Bonfires of the Vanities) and the notion that "greed is good". I'm not sure why anyone might be envious of those addicted to MORE and those who don't seem to take the time to be satisfied, grateful and appreciative of what they have and all that has contributed to it. Some people do not define the "pursuit of happiness" as an obsessiion about having more, more, more, far more than they could ever use and yet never enough. Some others that have found massive good fortune, whether they feel they were the soul creator, earner and "deserver" of it or not, are more than happy to give more of it up. You don't seem to account for them in your "discussion", nor do you seem to want to recognize discussion of them.


Absolutely it cuts both ways...in my post, however, I posted exactly what was said in the video...nothing had to be translated...did you even watch the video and listen to the responses?

It sure appears as though you were trying to suggest all others should asnswer as you would and seemed to refuse responses that went contrary to what you were thinking (translating) they woud or should feel or those asked the question in the video should feel.

I've answered all the questions asked of me when the person responding answered my questions first...however, it is my topic and I will not allow others to change the subject without answering me first. And, btw, it was you that showed up five hours later to respond...that doesn't qualify as trying to dodge jack squat.[/QUOTE]

How can one argue with someone that appears to be obsessive about what they claim as their possessions or appears to have some issues regarding how soon or late someone posts on a board they posted to designed to be open for discussion? Your purpose in posting what you did in a forum such as this was what? To get only responses that agreed with you as validation of your opinion or construct? Why do you keep using the determination (without demonstrating how or why) of what is or is not on topic to avoid responding to that which does not appear to agree with you, but does appear to be related to the topic? Several people have noted how it seeems to be a dodge, regardless of when I "showed up" to note the same.
 
Sweet... that works for me.

Income caps and the rest goes to our government to pay down our debt.

And talk about incentives. Just award the student a lifetime salary dependent upon their GPA. The 4.0 gets...say...$500,000 a year. The 3.0 gets...$250,000....the 2.0 $125,000...Less than that gets $40,000. Employees could enhance income with bonuses...you know...for extra credit.

If you knew the exact financial result of your college work...I'm guessing we'd see better grades across the board. And fewer frat parties...
 
Hey, where's my $500,000??? I was a straight-A student from second grade through grad school. Fat lot of good it has ever done me. Now, I just get people telling me how 'over-qualified' I am.
 
Hey, where's my $500,000??? I was a straight-A student from second grade through grad school. Fat lot of good it has ever done me. Now, I just get people telling me how 'over-qualified' I am.

Well...we need to move to the "superior system" JO was shilling for instead of the irrational one we currently utilize...

Hey...I get the same noise about qualifications and I was a solid C student with just a few college credits. A in the classes I cared about...E was our opposite...in the classes I didn't.
 
Is that how you "earn" money? Ignore and dismiss anything that requires you to use your mind or does not agree with you?
You know what it's all about because you read a headline or didn't read it at all?

You don't seem to be comprehending simple explanations and now you appear to be dodging longer ones why? Think of what all the people looking in here are guessing.

While in school we had to write essays and papers with minimums word counts. We couldn't be lazy, nor could the teachers or professors be if they were to grade and critique us on content. They had to read it and read it all if they were honest and fair. I would say their work was harder than ours, at least for the honest ones interested in helping students really learn as opposed to those that seemed more interested in trying to demonstrate the power they held over any students based on their grading pen. Perhaps they were feeling insecure and powerless in some way and needed to assure themselves all the time that they could somehow make or break lives.

I will admit, text books trying to teach us something were not much fun to read and often a lot to read and comprehend.
 
KnotaFrayed: Think of what all the people looking in here are guessing.

LeRoy: Well, I'm thinking he's lazy, which makes me wonder how he earned all that money he's going to pass on to his undeserving (and ne'er do well?) son.
 
Back
Top