New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Syria

My take on this:

Turkey is one of the biggest supporters of the rebels. They see Assad as a headache, a potential source of volatility, and they want to get rid of him. The U.S. has been reluctant to provide substantial aid to the rebels because its rulers would like to save on blood and treasure by not getting involved. But now Turkey is facing a serious crisis of its own with the potential to break out into a nationwide rebellion and/or a major upsurge in Kurdish nationalism (in Turkey, Syria, Iraq, etc.). So now the U.S. is acting to help free Turkey's government to take decisive action to crush the protests without having to worry about losing its influence in Syria, while trying to minimize the amount of influence al-Qaeda/al-Nusra has among the rebels.

This complicates things for Israel. A few weeks ago, it looked like Assad was going to be able to crush the rebellion and restore the "normalcy" of his dictatorship. Now, it looks like the war will drag on for many more months, considerably raising the likelihood of the war spreading across Israel's borders (and Lebanon's) and/or Assad's chemical weapons getting into Hizballah's hands. This considerably raises the chances of Israeli intervention on a bigger scale, especially since Israel will be looking for every opportunity to reassert its special relationship with the U.S. and preventing the U.S. and Iran's new government from reaching a negotiated end to the Syrian conflict and a new modus vivendi in the Middle East at the expense of Israel's interests.

Russia doesn't have a lot of alternatives as far as potential client regimes in the Middle East. The relationship with Assad has been very good for Russian interests, and they will fight tooth and nail to keep him in power. But the fulcrum of U.S. influence is no longer Israel but now Iraq, so if Israel gets into a direct confrontation with Russia as is looking increasingly likely, we can expect the U.S. to back off and let Israel get crushed. Israel is no longer as useful to the U.S., but it continues to be a huge liability in terms of diplomacy in the Arab world. Every month this drags out raises the likelihood that the U.S. will stab Israel in the back.
 
The U.S. has been reluctant to provide substantial aid to the rebels because its rulers would like to save on blood and treasure by not getting involved.

The US has been reluctant to become involved because the US doesn't want to be seen as backing either side in this conflict. The mere perception of US support would be a poison pill for whomever winds up in power when this insurgency is all said and done.

The funny thing about you conspiracy theorists is that you wind up implicitly backing Assad by default. Some hero you got there...
 
I'm not a conspiracy theorist and in fact I am sympathetic to the rebels--who could succeed without American support if they had a correct political line.

The fact is, there's a REASON why "the mere perception of US support would be a poison pill for whomever winds up in power" and it is called decades of American imperialist exploitation.
 
The US has been reluctant to become involved because the US doesn't want to be seen as backing either side in this conflict. The mere perception of US support would be a poison pill for whomever winds up in power when this insurgency is all said and done.

The funny thing about you conspiracy theorists is that you wind up implicitly backing Assad by default. Some hero you got there...

Actually the US is champing at the bit to go in. It's already been decided to send more money and arms to the 'rebels'.

Meet the guys who could be the next rulers of Syria.

Zionism, Jewish extremism and a few other nasty items making our world uninhabitable today
The Ugly Truth


Syria rebels ‘beheaded a Christian and fed him to the dogs’ as fears grow over Islamist atrocities

​
​
​
​
​
​
​
3 Votes​


ai2.cdn.turner.com_cnn_dam_assets_130528114034_syrian_rebels_aleppo_horizontal_gallery.jpg
ed note–there is something SOOOOOO familiar about this…hmmm, let me seee. OH YEAH–this is EXACTLY what Israel did during Operation Cast Lead
dailymail.co.uk
  • Christian Andrei Arbashe, 38, was kidnapped and beheaded by rebel fighters in northern town of Ras Al-Ayn on the Turkish border
  • News came as pro-government forces celebrated their victory against rebels near Aleppo Airport
Syrian rebels beheaded a Christian man and fed his body to dogs, according to a nun who says the West is ignoring atrocities committed by Islamic extremists.
The nun said taxi driver Andrei Arbashe, 38, was kidnapped after his brother was heard complaining that fighters against the ruling regime behaved like bandits.
She said his headless corpse was found by the side of the road, surrounded by hungry dogs. He had recently married and was soon to be a father.

ai.dailymail.co.uk_i_pix_2012_12_31_article_2255103_16B282D6000005DC_681_634x433.jpgVolatile fighting: The news of the kidnapping and beheading of Mr Arbashe came as pro-government forces celebrated their victory against rebels at the Air Defence Base in Tal Hassil near Aleppo Airport last night
Sister Agnes-Mariam de la Croix said: ‘His only crime was his brother criticised the rebels, accused them of acting like bandits, which is what they are.’
There have been a growing number of accounts of atrocities carried out by rogue elements of the Syrian Free Army, which opposes dictator Bashar al-Assad and is recognised by Britain and the West as the legitimate leadership.

More…


Sister Agnes-Miriam, mother superior of the Monastery of St James the Mutilated, has condemned Britain and the west for supporting the rebels despite growing evidence of human rights abuses. Murder, kidnapping, rape and robbery are becoming commonplace, she says.
‘The free and democratic world is supporting extremists,’ Sister Agnes-Miriam said from her sanctuary in Lebanon. ‘They want to impose Sharia Law and create an Islamic state in Syria.’

ai.dailymail.co.uk_i_pix_2012_12_31_article_2255103_169039ED000005DC_240_634x429.jpgFatal opinion: The man’s brother had criticised the behaviour of members of the Free Syrian Army, seen here during heavy clashes with government forces north of Aleppo earlier this month
The 60-year-old Carmelite nun claims the west has turned a blind eye to growing evidence of a ‘fifth column’ of fanatics within the rag-tag ranks that make up the Free Syrian Army that they back to oust Assad.
One of the most effective fighting forces is the Jabat Al-Nusra, which has an ideology similar to Al Qaeda.
‘The uprising has been hijacked by Islamist mercenaries who are more interested in fighting a holy war than in changing the government,’ she said.
‘It has turned into a sectarian conflict. One in which Christians are paying a high price.’
The rebel attacked the northern town of Ras Al-Ayn, on the Turkish border, last month. The fighters entered the Christian quarter, ordering civilians to leave and leaving their homes.
‘More than 200 families were driven out in the night,’ Sister Agnes-Miriam says. ‘People are afraid. Everywhere the deaths squads stop civilians, abduct them and ask for ransom, sometimes they kill them.’

ai.dailymail.co.uk_i_pix_2012_12_31_article_2255103_16981754000005DC_927_634x406.jpgThreat: Sister Agnes-Mariam said that rebel fighters, pictured, are targeting Christians in Syria in a bid to make it a Muslim state
Militants wearing black bandanas of Al Qaeda recently laid siege to the Monastery of St James the Mutilated, located between Damascus and Homs, for two days in an attempt to prevent Christmas celebrations, the nun claims.
An estimated 300,000 Christians have been displaced in the conflict, with 80,000 forced out of the Homs region alone, she claims.
Many have fled abroad raising fears that Syria’s Christian community may vanish – like others across Middle East, the birthplace of Christianity.
Al Assad, a member of the Alawite Muslim sect, claims only his regime can protect Syria’s minorities from domination from the Sunni Muslims majority.
Meanwhile the fighting continues to rage with government forces retaking control of a key district in the city of Homs yesterday.
The latest violence comes after United Nations peace envoy Lakhdar Brahimi warned of ‘hell’ for Syria if no political solution could be found.
Russia has stated the conflict is becoming increasingly militarised and sectarian and risks bringing chaos to the whole region.
Some 44,000 people have been killed since the uprising against the Al Assad regime began in March 2011.
 
So, I'm curious. What would this magical, "correct political line" be?

A Syrian rebellion with a leadership that was committed to both democratic revolution and social revolution, willing to work with other rebel factions as strategy dictated but not wed to any of them, pro-Russian, pro-Iranian, anti-U.S., anti-Israel, secularist, would win massive working-class support. There's nothing magical about it, it's based on tested political principles that worked for Lenin, Tito, Castro, and Ho Chi Minh.
 
I'm inclined to agree. Without international and regional support, a US affiliated intervention would be too risky in terms of outcomes. Assad is done with. It's the what and the who that replaces Assad that are vital to US interests. That's for sure.

My hope is that a post-Assad security agreement is brokered between Assad's opponents and the regional and international powers that will have to support internal Syrian security until a representative functioning government can emerge.

Sarin gas or not, the Syrian war and it's aftermath are a major policy consideration for the US going forward.

In light of what is happening now, could you elaborate on our interests in Syria? I hope you are having a good Labor Day break.

God Speed,
David
 
The US interest in Syria is in a stable, democratic government that represents the will of the democratic majority (Sunni anti-Assad opposition) and protects the rights of Syria's ethnic minorities (Alawite, Shia, Christian). A Syrian government that represented the basic wishes of its people is the best chance for developing a comprehensive peace settlement and for the normalization of relations between Syria, its neighbors and the US. It's important to understand that a Syrian government representing the will of the Syrian majority doesn't mean a Syrian policy dictated by Washington. What it will mean are policy issues arising and settling based upon a real politik that includes fundamental disagreements as part of the diplomatic relationship.

The US position has been that "Assad must go" since 2011 -- regime change in Damascus, even as the administration is denying that is the goal of the proposed retaliatory strikes or of US policy. The efforts to shape the administration message on Syria are not helped by the administration's own policy statement inconsistencies.

From WaPo (8-18-11)

President Obama and European leaders called Thursday for Syrian President Bashar al-Assad to resign, after months of his violent crackdown on protesters. The rhetorical escalation was backed by new U.S. sanctions designed to undermine Assad’s ability to finance his military operation.

“The future of Syria must be determined by its people, but President Bashar al-Assad is standing in their way,” Obama said in a written statement. “For the sake of the Syrian people, the time has come for President Assad to step aside.”

Obama’s first explicit call for Assad to resign — something critics have pressured him to do — culminated months of calibrated diplomacy that has included three rounds of sanctions and a gradual policy shift toward regime change in a nation long at odds with U.S. policy in the Middle East.

http://articles.washingtonpost.com/...yrian-president-bashar-al-assad-syrian-people

A similar example would be the issue of the chemical weapon "red line" in which a warning was delivered and then walked back. The administration called for Assad's ouster, armed his opponents, denied it called for regime change, called for a strike in punishment, and called for dialogue and a political solution. Multiple confused policy impulses, maybe each worthy of consideration on its own, but not adding up to a coherent whole. Sort of like putting one foot on the accelerator and one foot on the brake. For better or worse, that's what we have got.

If it can be said that it's in the national security interests of the US to have a stable democratic majority based government in Syria, then Obama's 2011 declaration that Assad must go was correct. Likewise, his decision to provide weapons to the rebels following a small scale chemical attacks last spring was also correct. Those decisions are only correct if the goal is regime change through force or through diplomacy.

With respect to a US strike, it's impossible to predict what the short or long term consequences are. There is a noticeable lack of enthusiastic endorsements for a US led strike or a NATO led strike without UN or Arab League approval. Instead, there are calls by the Arab League for the UN to take the lead on the Syria crisis. This means that world opinion seems to favor, a diplomatic solution in which Russia would act as the guarantor of the interests of the Assad regime. Presumably, rebels groups and their sponsors would act as the guarantor for the interests of the opposition.

Unless the UN approves a strike or the Arab League calls for a NATO led operation, the world community favors a diplomatic solution over an expanded war backed by the local, regional and international supporters and opponents of the Assad government.

Wish I had better answers but I'm not wild for a strike unless we define the mission as part of regime change and build a coalition with the legal standing to justify western intervention, regime change, and a realistic post-Assad plan for developing Syrian civil society. Clearly the US is not prepared to go it alone and would be very unwise to do so.
 
The US interest in Syria is in a stable, democratic government that represents the will of the democratic majority (Sunni anti-Assad opposition) and protects the rights of Syria's ethnic minorities (Alawite, Shia, Christian). A Syrian government that represented the basic wishes of its people is the best chance for developing a comprehensive peace settlement and for the normalization of relations between Syria, its neighbors and the US. It's important to understand that a Syrian government representing the will of the Syrian majority doesn't mean a Syrian policy dictated by Washington. What it will mean are policy issues arising and settling based upon a real politik that includes fundamental disagreements as part of the diplomatic relationship.

The US position has been that "Assad must go" since 2011 -- regime change in Damascus, even as the administration is denying that is the goal of the proposed retaliatory strikes or of US policy. The efforts to shape the administration message on Syria are not helped by the administration's own policy statement inconsistencies.

From WaPo (8-18-11)



http://articles.washingtonpost.com/...yrian-president-bashar-al-assad-syrian-people

A similar example would be the issue of the chemical weapon "red line" in which a warning was delivered and then walked back. The administration called for Assad's ouster, armed his opponents, denied it called for regime change, called for a strike in punishment, and called for dialogue and a political solution. Multiple confused policy impulses, maybe each worthy of consideration on its own, but not adding up to a coherent whole. Sort of like putting one foot on the accelerator and one foot on the brake. For better or worse, that's what we have got.

If it can be said that it's in the national security interests of the US to have a stable democratic majority based government in Syria, then Obama's 2011 declaration that Assad must go was correct. Likewise, his decision to provide weapons to the rebels following a small scale chemical attacks last spring was also correct. Those decisions are only correct if the goal is regime change through force or through diplomacy.

With respect to a US strike, it's impossible to predict what the short or long term consequences are. There is a noticeable lack of enthusiastic endorsements for a US led strike or a NATO led strike without UN or Arab League approval. Instead, there are calls by the Arab League for the UN to take the lead on the Syria crisis. This means that world opinion seems to favor, a diplomatic solution in which Russia would act as the guarantor of the interests of the Assad regime. Presumably, rebels groups and their sponsors would act as the guarantor for the interests of the opposition.

Unless the UN approves a strike or the Arab League calls for a NATO led operation, the world community favors a diplomatic solution over an expanded war backed by the local, regional and international supporters and opponents of the Assad government.

Wish I had better answers but I'm not wild for a strike unless we define the mission as part of regime change and build a coalition with the legal standing to justify western intervention, regime change, and a realistic post-Assad plan for developing Syrian civil society. Clearly the US is not prepared to go it alone and would be very unwise to do so.

Thank you for responding. Your post are always very thoughtful. I read nothing with which I disagree.

God Speed,
David
 
When President Obama made his case for our involvement in Libya, he did NOT make the "mushroom cloud" case, nor did he make the "$10 a gallon gas" case. He made the very simple AMERICAN case that since the United States of America had the capability of forestalling a bloodbath in Libya, the U.S.A. had a moral AND patriotic duty to do so.

As we now know, President Obama - the ELECTED Commander-in Chief of the United States, ignored both left-kookian AND right-half-shoutian sniping, and did exactly what HE though best. AND as we now know.....he did so with historic and remarkable competence and success.

Now....we're confronted with a similar situation in Syria. Syria poses no existential security threat to the U.S., nor does it pose an oil-price threat. What it poses, is a moral and patriotic threat. IMHO, our Commander-in-Chief has an obligation to confront the first two - physical and/or energy threat - no matter the navel-contemplativeness of his politic. He is NOT obligated to address our American moral/patriotic foundation. IF the majority of Americans in the guise of their elected Congressional representatives would prefer that the United States run and hide from its historically accepted obligation, more power to the majority of Americans. BUT....they can't hold this feeling AND expect that the United States of America will remain the greatest nation the world has ever known.
 
When President Obama made his case for our involvement in Libya, he did NOT make the "mushroom cloud" case, nor did he make the "$10 a gallon gas" case. He made the very simple AMERICAN case that since the United States of America had the capability of forestalling a bloodbath in Libya, the U.S.A. had a moral AND patriotic duty to do so.

As we now know, President Obama - the ELECTED Commander-in Chief of the United States, ignored both left-kookian AND right-half-shoutian sniping, and did exactly what HE though best. AND as we now know.....he did so with historic and remarkable competence and success.

Now....we're confronted with a similar situation in Syria. Syria poses no existential security threat to the U.S., nor does it pose an oil-price threat. What it poses, is a moral and patriotic threat. IMHO, our Commander-in-Chief has an obligation to confront the first two - physical and/or energy threat - no matter the navel-contemplativeness of his politic. He is NOT obligated to address our American moral/patriotic foundation. IF the majority of Americans in the guise of their elected Congressional representatives would prefer that the United States run and hide from its historically accepted obligation, more power to the majority of Americans. BUT....they can't hold this feeling AND expect that the United States of America will remain the greatest nation the world has ever known.

Good Morning~

While I agree that we have a moral obligation to do something about the use of chemical weapons, we still need to do this in concert with the world community. Furthermore, we are not the world's police, so we do not have the right to intervene any place any time we decide that we have such a moral obligation.

I am not questioning the notion that we should do something: I am saying that what we do has to be done right and smart. Building a case with the world community, the UN, keeps us on the moral high ground. In addition, it boxes in nations that support whomever is using the weapons. It puts Russia in a position of defending the indefensible and questions why Iran would support such a heinous behavior. By the way, I came across this website in which the Iranian government is alleging that they informed us a number of months ago that insurgents were bring chemical weapons into Syria. I know nothing else about it, but I am curious to know if others have heard this. http://www.presstv.ir/detail/2013/09/02/321735/war-no-solution-to-syria-crisis/

There is now information coming in that Syrians, especially Sunnis, are more concerned about al Qaeda linked fighters than al Assad. If we go into the country militarily in any way that helped those insurgents, our efforts will be counter-productive. http://www.worldtribune.com/2013/05/31/nato-data-assad-winning-the-war-for-syrians-hearts-and-minds/

Our country enabled another to use those vile weapons and have never been held to account for it. If we are going to build trust with people in the Middle East, we have to show by example how to address such atrocities and their perpetrators. We want to stop the use of this stuff, so building strong commitment to permanently banning their use will be more effective then going it along.

God Speed,
David
 
Last edited:
Good Morning~

While I agree that we have a moral obligation to do something about the use of chemical weapons, we still need to do this in concert with the world community. Furthermore, we are not the world's police, so we do not have the right to intervene any place any time we decide that we have such a moral obligation.

I am not questioning the notion that we should do something: I am saying that what we do has to be done right and smart. Building a case with the world community, the UN, keeps us on the moral high ground. In addition, it boxes in nations that support whomever is using the weapons. It puts Russia in a position of defending the indefensible and questions why Iran would support such a heinous behavior. By the way, I came across this website in which the Iranian government is alleging that they informed us a number of months ago that insurgents were bring chemical weapons into Syria. I know nothing else about it, but I am curious to know if others have heard this. http://www.presstv.ir/detail/2013/09/02/321735/war-no-solution-to-syria-crisis/

There is now information coming in that Syrians, especially Sunnis, are more concerned about al Qaeda linked fighters than al Assad. If we go into the country militarily in any way that helped those insurgents, our efforts will be counter-productive. http://www.worldtribune.com/2013/05/31/nato-data-assad-winning-the-war-for-syrians-hearts-and-minds/

Our country enabled another to use those vile weapons and have never been held to account for it. If we are going to build trust with people in the Middle East, we have to show by example how to address such atrocities and their perpetrators. We want to stop the use of this stuff, so building strong commitment to permanently banning their use will be more effective then going it along.

God Speed,
David


I've noted this in past and I know a lot of people either disagree with me or simply aren't picking up what I'm putting down. But....as far as I'm concerned, we ARE the world's policemen, whether we like if or not. So...it's not necessarily about our having the "right", as our having the "obligation".

In order to suggest that we aren't the world's policemen, you either have to make the case that the world currently HAS no policeman, or that some other entity is the world's policeman. And, if you think it's the UN, let's discuss their enforcement capability (or lack thereof).
 
I've noted this in past and I know a lot of people either disagree with me or simply aren't picking up what I'm putting down. But....as far as I'm concerned, we ARE the world's policemen, whether we like if or not. So...it's not necessarily about our having the "right", as our having the "obligation".

In order to suggest that we aren't the world's policemen, you either have to make the case that the world currently HAS no policeman, or that some other entity is the world's policeman. And, if you think it's the UN, let's discuss their enforcement capability (or lack thereof).


The World can do without Dirty Cops.
 
The World can do without Dirty Cops.

I've made the case that some entity WILL assume the role of cop. Shit....if the "Saturday Sewing Circle" doesn't elect officers, one gal will assume the roll of "boss" and a few others will take umbrage.

So...whether you think we "need" a world policeman(men) or not, is a moot point. We'll have one whether we like it or not. You obviously don't like the U.S. in this role. Hell....a lot of Americans don't like the U.S. in this role! So, who do you propose in the alternative?
 
Last edited:
The US has been reluctant to become involved because the US doesn't want to be seen as backing either side in this conflict. The mere perception of US support would be a poison pill for whomever winds up in power when this insurgency is all said and done.

The funny thing about you conspiracy theorists is that you wind up implicitly backing Assad by default. Some hero you got there...

CFR Strategist Praises Al-Qaeda Bombings In Syria


Senior Council on Foreign Relations fellow Ed Husain has hailed the presence of Al-Qaeda terrorists in Syria, praising their fighting prowess in aid of FSA rebels while also lauding the increasing number of successful bombings carried out by Al-Qaeda fighters.

“The Syrian rebels would be immeasurably weaker today without al-Qaeda in their ranks. By and large, Free Syrian Army (FSA) battalions are tired, divided, chaotic, and ineffective. Feeling abandoned by the West, rebel forces are increasingly demoralized as they square off with the Assad regime’s superior weaponry and professional army,” writes Husain, a Senior Fellow for Middle Eastern Studies with the CFR.

Al-Qaeda fighters, however, may help improve morale. The influx of jihadis brings discipline, religious fervor, battle experience from Iraq, funding from Sunni sympathizers in the Gulf, and most importantly, deadly results. In short, the FSA needs al-Qaeda now,” he adds.

Husain goes on to celebrate the fact that Al-Qaeda’s role in carrying out terrorist bombings in cities like Damascus and Aleppo has intensified, writing that “The group’s strength and acceptance by the FSA are demonstrated by their increasing activity on the ground –from seven attacks in March to sixty-six “operations” in June.”

His fervor for Al-Qaeda terrorist attacks – which have included targets such as schools and TV stations - is matched by the Obama administration as well as Ambassador Susan Rice, who have applauded terror bombings as a useful tool in destabilizing Bashar Assad’s government.

However, by the end of his article Husain is using the presence of Al-Qaeda fighters in Syria - put there with the aid of NATO powers - as another reason for military intervention in Syria.

“The planning to minimize al-Qaeda’s likely hold over Syrian tribes and fighters must begin now as the Obama administration ramps up its support to rebel groups,” he writes.

http://www.cfr.org/syria/al-qaedas-specter-syria/p28782

America has, since 9/11 put the whole world, as if in a prison, with armed guards every where and tanks and all sorts of horrible shit. We have all been bombarded with the evil of Al Qaeda for years we heard little else ...and now ...Al Qaeda are suddenly the 'Good Guys' and an intelligent well educated secular leader of a country which is difficult to rule is the baddie ......What? pardon? Are we hearing this right? huh? .................... Nah really it is not good enough , this lie just isn't good enough. Try another one we might just swallow one without Al Qaeda being your Heros ................
 
I've made the case that some entity WILL assume the role of cop. Shit....if the "Saturday Sewing Circle" doesn't elect officers, one gal will assume the roll of "boss" and a few others will take umbrage.

So...whether you think we "need" a world policeman(men) or not, is a moot point. We'll have one whether we like it or not. You obsiously don't like the U.S. in this role. Hell....a lot of Americans don't like the U.S. in this role! So, who do you propose in the alternative?


You are not policemen you are the Mafia ................... get real fairsheet, my dear:)

Your hegemony time is up, over, but if you try hanging on to it by bombing the oldest inhabited City in the World it will backfire so badly on you, you won't know what hit you ...................
 
Back
Top