New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Syria

Why would we talk about any of that? The people responsible for the OK attack were caught, tried, and convicted beyond a reasonable doubt by a jury of their peers.

Maybe because someone in a position to know more about OKC than you or I thought we should....like Bill Clinton's 1st CIA Director.
"This fascinating product of Jayna Davis' near-decade of brave, thorough, and dogged investigative reporting effectively shifts the burden of proof to those who would still contend that McVeigh and Nichols acted without the support of a group or groups from the Middle East.

When the final stories of these two incidents (1995 OKC bombing and the 1993 World Trade Center bombing) are finally told, those who permitted these investigations to stop short will owe big explanations to these two brave women. And the nation will owe them a debt of gratitude

R. James Woolsey
Director of Central Intelligence, 1993 -'95

But, I understand completely....you don't want to talk about it because you already know everything.
 
Lots of people were wrong in their guesses about Iraq and WMDs. But the vast majority of them didn't order the conquest of Iraq on that basis. Clinton was president for 8 years and we never invaded. Bush was the guy who ordered that invasion. He bears primary responsibility. Secondary responsibility goes to all the cheerleaders for war (Cheney, Wolfowitz, Powell, Rice, Lieberman, etc.). Tertiary responsibility goes to all those in Congress who foolishly voted to give Bush discretion in the matter.
A lot of the people were involved in that mess, but one name stands out, and I think Colin Powell would have been the first black president, had he not been fooled by the NSA and CIA reports, that there were WMD in Irac. I think the whole damned thing was an error, and a huge mistake made by our spies.
 
Lots of people were right. Wilson said that there was no way that the Iraqis could obtain yellowcake even if they tried....he was ignored. The State department experts said that there was no way that the aluminum tubes could be used for centrifuges and they were ignored in favor of the statement "Iraq has obtained thousands of aluminum tubes that can only be used for the purpose of enriching uranium for nuclear weapons".

The dems in congress were certainly foolish in either voting for the Authorization to use force or in not filibustering it.....just as the Supreme Court was foolish in making Bush president in the first place.
For me, the most damning thing was the way Bush willfully ignored all the signs that would have caused a sane man to take a step back and reexamine the case for war.

Picture that you're president, and for whatever reason you initially want to invade Iraq, based largely on the idea they have a big pile of WMDs. Only, as you move towards war, the case for that just keeps getting weaker. You find out that not only was the yellowcake claim incorrect, but it was a deliberate falsehood -- some unknown person forged a memo and then successfully injected it into our intelligence stream to trick us. In other words, there's some unidentified player out there with the desire and the ability to deceive who is trying to get us to start a war. And when weapons inspectors are readmitted to Iraq, they keep determining that various sites our tipsters told us were WMD depots or factories could never have been anything of the sort. In other words, many of our key intelligence sources are being identified as willful liars who are trying to fool us into taking Hussein down for them. Other countries, including key allies like France and Germany, see the warning signs. They have no love of Hussein, but they want to slow things down and give inspectors more time. If you were the president, what would you do? No doubt you'd slow things down, call for a re-review of the evidence, give inspectors more time, and work on figuring out who, exactly, has been manufacturing evidence to trick us into war. There was, after all, no rush -- Hussein had been contained for the better part of a decade and could be contained and deterred indefinitely while we made sure we had our facts right. That's how a sane president would have acted.

Instead, Bush rushes ahead, without even holding the promised Security Council vote on the matter. He was clearly not acting the way someone in his right mind would in that situation. He was consumed by bloodlust, and worried that if he slowed down the process, he would be denied his war.
 
Powell is now saying that he tried to persuade Bush to wait until the UN weapons inspectors came up with a definitive report, Cheney shot him down!

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/08/26/colin-powell-worried-us-g_n_3819987.html
Powell loved being a media darling and can't stand that he ruined his reputation by being a key player in the push for war. So, now he's trying to rehabilitate himself. He had his shot. If he'd resigned in protest when it became clear Bush wouldn't give inspectors time, it might have made a difference. It might have swung public opinion enough to scare Congress into revoking their authorization, and that might have stayed Bush's hand long enough for the war fever to pass. It might have saved thousands of Powell's countrymen pointless deaths, and saved taxpayers the trillions of dollars that will have been wasted in Iraq. Powell was in a rare position where he might have had the power to change the world in a very big, very positive way. But he missed his shot. Instead, he'll be remembered for the deceptive dog-and-pony show he put on at the UN.

Can you imagine if Powell had been honorable enough to resign, that way? He'd probably be president today, if the war had gone forward despite his resignation. About the time it became clear there were no WMDs and the Iraq war was going to be extremely bloody and extremely expensive, Powell's approval ratings would have shot through the roof among liberals, centrists, and moderate Republicans. The media would have swooned for him like nobody in history. They'd portray him as the wise man --the dutiful old soldier-- who saw the disaster that was coming and tried to spare his country. He could have gotten elected as an independent, if he wanted.
 
Lots of people were right. Wilson said that there was no way that the Iraqis could obtain yellowcake even if they tried....he was ignored. The State department experts said that there was no way that the aluminum tubes could be used for centrifuges and they were ignored in favor of the statement "Iraq has obtained thousands of aluminum tubes that can only be used for the purpose of enriching uranium for nuclear weapons".

The dems in congress were certainly foolish in either voting for the Authorization to use force or in not filibustering it.....just as the Supreme Court was foolish in making Bush president in the first place.

Oh please more of your [Unwelcome language removed] worship of Joe Wilson, who claimed to have verified forgeries that he never saw. Who op-ed directly contradicted his original debriefing, the man who was forced to admit in his testimony before the SIC that he used "liteary flair" in the telling of his story about his trip.

Something need I remind you the Butler report, a scathing report of the British intelligence failures leading up to the war in Iraq still stands by.

Joe Wilson has no credibility.
 
Yeah, which democrats voted to disband the Iraqi army and dismantle the entire Iraqi government workforce? I'd like to know, because that is when the insurgency began. When the Bush administration said that we'd be out of Iraq in weeks, not months....should the democrats have believed them? When the Bush administration said that the Iraqis had bought thousands of aluminum tubes that could only be used for centrifuges to make nuclear weapons....should they have called him a liar in a joint session of congress?

The fact is that the dems allowed themselves to be maneuvered into a political corner just before the election. Karl Rove did a remarkable job of using war to gain political points. Are you proud of that? I wish the dems had shown more spine than they did....but the fact is that the resolution would have passed without democratic votes.

The war was entirely the decision of Bush and Cheney, regardless of the vote. The vote did not require an invasion....it allowed it.

Pure cry baby bullshit. The war went south and they moved to 1) take as much political advantage as they possibly could 2) Save there political asses.
 
Maybe because someone in a position to know more about OKC than you or I thought we should....like Bill Clinton's 1st CIA Director.


R. James Woolsey
Director of Central Intelligence, 1993 -'95

But, I understand completely....you don't want to talk about it because you already know everything.

Woolsey was a islamaphobic flake. Clinton felt the political need to include in his administration someone from the neoconservative faction of the party (back before the neocons had completely discredited themselves), so he staffed Woolsey and then had the good sense not to consult with him. Like his fellow neocons, Woolsey jumped at any shred of a theory that he thought might support a push to conquer Iraq. He was one of the PNAC goons who was calling for us to launch an invasion back in the 90s.
 
Oh please more of your [Unwelcome language removed] worship of Joe Wilson, who claimed to have verified forgeries that he never saw. Who op-ed directly contradicted his original debriefing, the man who was forced to admit in his testimony before the SIC that he used "liteary flair" in the telling of his story about his trip.

Something need I remind you the Butler report, a scathing report of the British intelligence failures leading up to the war in Iraq still stands by.

Joe Wilson has no credibility.
Wilson, of course, must be destroyed. He broke with the warmongering effort in the run-up to war, and so he must be discredited, his wife's career must be ruined, and every other effort must be made to send a simple message: support a war and you'll be applauded, no matter how wrong you are, oppose it and you'll be annihilated, even if it turns out you were right all along. That message is an important one to send, to make sure that in the future the public isn't exposed to anything that might contradict the official case for whatever half-baked wars the neocons want to start next.
 
The decision to invade Iraq was not mentioned in the Authorization to Use Force. In fact Bush lied and said that the use of force would be the last option after all diplomatic avenues had failed. He lied because he ordered the callup of reserves and for deployment of invasion forces almost as soon as the bill was signed.

"The President is Authorized to use the Armed Forces of The United States as he determines to be necessary and appropriate in order to defend the national security of the United States against the continuing threat posed by Iraq; and enforce all relevant United Nations Security Council resolutions regarding Iraq."

But they had no idea what they were voting for........
 
Wilson, of course, must be destroyed. He broke with the warmongering effort in the run-up to war, and so he must be discredited, his wife's career must be ruined, and every other effort must be made to send a simple message: support a war and you'll be applauded, no matter how wrong you are, oppose it and you'll be annihilated, even if it turns out you were right all along. That message is an important one to send, to make sure that in the future the public isn't exposed to anything that might contradict the official case for whatever half-baked wars the neocons want to start next.

Please see previous post.
 
CJ, do you have an inside track to the WH, because everyone in the US is still guessing what he will do, and I am waiting to see what he does do. He is surely smart enough to know that 77% of Americans oppose any unilateral military action.

There was a newsfeed on Yahoo News yesterday indicating this....but I guess I should backtrack and say it wasn't confirmed. But if they're looking for tomorrow to be the day...has he gotten the ok from both the UN and Congress yet? (I really have not heard) And I'm sure he smart enough to know we're against it, but I don't think he really cares.
 
There was a newsfeed on Yahoo News yesterday indicating this....but I guess I should backtrack and say it wasn't confirmed. But if they're looking for tomorrow to be the day...has he gotten the ok from both the UN and Congress yet? (I really have not heard) And I'm sure he smart enough to know we're against it, but I don't think he really cares.
CJ, Were pretty much at the same point. We are waiting to see what happens. I do think that he had better care, because we still have impeachment options.
 
For me, the most damning thing was the way Bush willfully ignored all the signs that would have caused a sane man to take a step back and reexamine the case for war.

Picture that you're president, and for whatever reason you initially want to invade Iraq, based largely on the idea they have a big pile of WMDs. Only, as you move towards war, the case for that just keeps getting weaker. You find out that not only was the yellowcake claim incorrect, but it was a deliberate falsehood -- some unknown person forged a memo and then successfully injected it into our intelligence stream to trick us. In other words, there's some unidentified player out there with the desire and the ability to deceive who is trying to get us to start a war. And when weapons inspectors are readmitted to Iraq, they keep determining that various sites our tipsters told us were WMD depots or factories could never have been anything of the sort. In other words, many of our key intelligence sources are being identified as willful liars who are trying to fool us into taking Hussein down for them. Other countries, including key allies like France and Germany, see the warning signs. They have no love of Hussein, but they want to slow things down and give inspectors more time. If you were the president, what would you do? No doubt you'd slow things down, call for a re-review of the evidence, give inspectors more time, and work on figuring out who, exactly, has been manufacturing evidence to trick us into war. There was, after all, no rush -- Hussein had been contained for the better part of a decade and could be contained and deterred indefinitely while we made sure we had our facts right. That's how a sane president would have acted.

Instead, Bush rushes ahead, without even holding the promised Security Council vote on the matter. He was clearly not acting the way someone in his right mind would in that situation. He was consumed by bloodlust, and worried that if he slowed down the process, he would be denied his war.
Hi A, I pretty much agree with every thing you said, and I think Baby George was trying to finish the war that his daddy started.
 
"The President is Authorized to use the Armed Forces of The United States as he determines to be necessary and appropriate in order to defend the national security of the United States against the continuing threat posed by Iraq; and enforce all relevant United Nations Security Council resolutions regarding Iraq."

But they had no idea what they were voting for........

The vote allowed Bush to make decisions that could have gone either way....he chose stupid.
 
Pure cry baby bullshit. The war went south and they moved to 1) take as much political advantage as they possibly could 2) Save there political asses.

Bullshit? Who of the democrats was responsible for disbanding the Iraqi army? Who of them voted to dismantle the Iraqi government by banning anyone who had ever been a member of the Baath party from being in the government? Which democrat said "No, Shinseki is wrong. We don't need that many troops."?
I don't remember, but I'm pretty sure that all of those decisions were Bush's.
 
The vote allowed Bush to make decisions that could have gone either way....he chose stupid.
Exactly true -- but that doesn't excuse anyone who voted for it.

The best defense you could make sounds something like this: "I thought the best way to get Iraq to comply without the need for a war was to make it clear that Bush had all the discretion he needed to move forward without having to come back to Congress, so Hussein no longer felt he had the ability to play various US factions against each other. That way he'd have to step up and make his best offers to Bush."

In the abstract, that's not terrible reasoning. In business, we do it all the time: make it clear that the people in the negotiating room have the requisite discretion to make decisions, so if they threaten to walk away from the deal if the other side doesn't make some concession, the other side takes that seriously, rather than assuming they're making threats they lack the power to follow through on. But, that strategy is only a wise one if you trust the discretion of the guy you're putting in the room to act with your authority. No reasonable person would have trusted Bush with serious authority. He'd long ago plainly demonstrated that he was a lazy, dishonest moron in the thrall of virulently pro-war neoconservatives. No sensible person would have entrusted such a jackass to negotiate the terms of his cable contract, much less the terms of a standoff that might end in a full-scale war. Every politician who voted to hand Bush that authority earned undying infamy for that colossal mistake.
 
Oh please more of your [Unwelcome language removed] worship of Joe Wilson, who claimed to have verified forgeries that he never saw. Who op-ed directly contradicted his original debriefing, the man who was forced to admit in his testimony before the SIC that he used "liteary flair" in the telling of his story about his trip.

Something need I remind you the Butler report, a scathing report of the British intelligence failures leading up to the war in Iraq still stands by.

Joe Wilson has no credibility.


None of what you say gets you around the fact that the administration
1. Ignored that Wilson and two other sources all said that there was no way that Niger was sending yellowcake to Iraq.
2. The report that the Iraqies had attempted to get yellowcake was a forgery.
3. The State department and the energy department had both said that there was no way the aluminum tubes could be used for nuclear weapons....didn't stop Bush from announcing to the world that they could ONLY be used for nucular weapons.

You think Wilson has no credibility? The facts support Wilson, not Bush/Cheney. There was no attempt to get yellowcake, the tubes couldn't possibly have been used for nuclear weapons and Wilson wasn't the only one telling the administration that they were wrong.....even before Bush went on TV to repeat the lies.
 
Exactly true -- but that doesn't excuse anyone who voted for it.

The best defense you could make sounds something like this: "I thought the best way to get Iraq to comply without the need for a war was to make it clear that Bush had all the discretion he needed to move forward without having to come back to Congress, so Hussein no longer felt he had the ability to play various US factions against each other. That way he'd have to step up and make his best offers to Bush."

In the abstract, that's not terrible reasoning. In business, we do it all the time: make it clear that the people in the negotiating room have the requisite discretion to make decisions, so if they threaten to walk away from the deal if the other side doesn't make some concession, the other side takes that seriously, rather than assuming they're making threats they lack the power to follow through on. But, that strategy is only a wise one if you trust the discretion of the guy you're putting in the room to act with your authority. No reasonable person would have trusted Bush with serious authority. He'd long ago plainly demonstrated that he was a lazy, dishonest moron in the thrall of virulently pro-war neoconservatives. No sensible person would have entrusted such a jackass to negotiate the terms of his cable contract, much less the terms of a standoff that might end in a full-scale war. Every politician who voted to hand Bush that authority earned undying infamy for that colossal mistake.

No disagreement from me. Rove manouvered the dems into a situation where if they voted against it he intended to use it against them for political advantage. If they voted for it he'd use it to get a pass for Bush if it all went south....and it did.

Few politicians these days show much spine. Unfortunately the ones who do usually get screwed by the voters.
 
While I understand the need to take out Syria's chemical weapons capability something I support. I would also like to say that I have absolutely no confidence in this Administration when it comes to anything what-so-ever.

Not a particularly religious person but......god help us all.


Maybe Obama will ask Bush for advice because he did so well.
 
Back
Top