New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Tag Feature Update

Minotaur

Governor
Due to some issues the Tag feature has been removed. We wish to send our "Thank You" to all those who helped test it the last few days.

Min & Jen
 
It's unfortunate it was abused. Tags were helpful for searches (finding topics you want to discuss) and tags are also good to bring in more posters. Major fail again for the aholes that had to f it up.
 
Respectfully Dave I disagree about their usefullness. for any info retreival system to be useful, its abstraction system ie Taxonomy, has to be consistent and have good transitive closure. Self-defined tags miss on both. Frankly I was kinda surprised they were in operation. I've never ever seen them work in any blogging system. They work fine when the taxonomy is defined by a professional librarian or archivist and then the team applying them is trained and periodically tested and retrained, but outside of that, they really don't work as well as a constrainable free form search.

But to the extent you may feel that I and others abused them - I appologize - I just never took them seriously.
 
It's unfortunate it was abused. Tags were helpful for searches (finding topics you want to discuss) and tags are also good to bring in more posters. Major fail again for the aholes that had to f it up.

I agree Dave. I predicted they would be removed when I saw how they were being [ab]used. Sucks that so many features are removed due to children unable to behave. I have seen tags used to great effect, but you just can't have anything on this board that is in any way vulnerable to abuse or it will be taken advantage of.
 
Sucks that so many features are removed due to children unable to behave. I have seen tags used to great effect, but you just can't have anything on this board that is in any way vulnerable to abuse or it will be taken advantage of.

You speak the truth.
 
Respectfully Dave I disagree about their usefullness. for any info retreival system to be useful, its abstraction system ie Taxonomy, has to be consistent and have good transitive closure. Self-defined tags miss on both. Frankly I was kinda surprised they were in operation. I've never ever seen them work in any blogging system. They work fine when the taxonomy is defined by a professional librarian or archivist and then the team applying them is trained and periodically tested and retrained, but outside of that, they really don't work as well as a constrainable free form search.

But to the extent you may feel that I and others abused them - I appologize - I just never took them seriously.


"But to the extent you may feel that I and others abused them - I appologize - I just never took them seriously. "




well we won't have to worry about that anymore ;)
 
If Tags are gone - shouldn't the awards associated with them also go? Since now no-one else can achieve them and in essence the awards are "rewarding" those who most abused the system
 
Back
Top