New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Armed citizen.

Since the anti gun rhetoric being spewed by the left has reached a fevered pitch, relating sob stories about some dimwit who accidentally shot himself, or some dimwit's kid who accidentally shot himself and other excuses to put additional limitations on firearm ownership, I am now going to point out that Citizens owning firearms is a far more positive thing than a negative one.

Without private firearm ownership, these people would most likely have met their ends at the hands of criminals.

Scott Stith was in his bedroom when he heard a loud crash coming from the first floor of his home. He grabbed his .45 cal. pistol and crept downstairs to investigate. He spotted the silhouette of a man, but did not fire because he had teenage sons in the house and was not 100 percent sure of his target. He called out only to discover the man was an intruder who had broken through the glass of the back door. Stith held the 29-year-old intruder at gunpoint until police arrived. Everyone involved was reportedly unharmed. (Sandusky Register., Milan, OH, 9/29/12)

Just before 2 a.m., a 25-year-old man shot another man in the head at Bonnie’s Food and Spirits after he was asked to leave. He then fatally shot another customer outside the pub. When he pointed his pistol at Mark Ktytor, however, Ktytor produced his own firearm and fired multiple rounds, leaving the assailant in critical condition. The suspect will be charged with criminal homicide and attempted homicide upon his release from the hospital. (The Times-Tribune, Plymouth, PA, 9/11/12)

Two armed men stormed into a Dollar General store one evening and attempted to rob it. While the men held the store manager at gunpoint, a 57-year-old man carrying a concealed .45 cal. handgun, who had been shopping at the store at the time of the robbery, took action. The customer did not hesitate to draw his gun and fire at the suspects. One of the men robbing the store suffered fatal wounds to the head, chest and shoulder. The second suspect fled, but was later caught and charged with robbery and felony murder. There were reportedly no other injuries. (The Florida Times-Union, Jacksonville, FL, 8/29/12)

Brianne Rodriguez heard a knock at her front door just before 9 a.m., but ignored it. A few minutes later, Rodriguez heard loud noises coming from her bedroom. When she went to investigate, she discovered a man wearing a ski mask in her home. The confrontation led to a struggle and Rodriguez was pushed to the floor and kicked in the face and ribs. The masked man then grabbed her screaming 2-year-old daughter and bolted for the door. Rodriguez quickly retrieved a shotgun she kept in her bedroom and followed. Upon seeing the gun, the man dropped the child and fled. He escaped with Rodriguez’s purse and some jewelry, but Rodriguez and her daughter sustained no serious injuries. (KSEE 24 NEWS, Fresno County, CA, 8/28/12)

When the ex-husband of a woman living at Windmill Cove Apartments was not granted access to his ex-wife’s home by employees of the apartment complex, he warned that he would kick in the door. His ex-wife and a 35-year-old male friend were inside when they heard yelling and someone violently kicking the door. When the door gave way and the man came inside, the friend fired several rounds from his handgun. The man suffered multiple gunshot wounds that proved fatal. (KSL, Sandy, UT, 9/2/12)

John Mutter was asleep in his bed around 2:15 a.m. when he was awakened by a man with a shotgun pointed at his head. Mutter, a paraplegic living alone, kept his own gun nearby for protection. He quickly grabbed his gun and fired multiple times killing the intruder. Police investigating the incident believed the man had entered the home looking for medication, money or anything of value. (The Columbus Dispatch, Johnstown, OH, 7/22/12)

Gerald Mirto, 67, heard noises coming from his backyard and went to investigate. When he noticed the screen door had been broken, Mirto spotted the culprit standing just outside. The 25-year-old suspect was not wearing any clothing and was asked to leave repeatedly. There was a struggle in which Mirto was bitten in the arm and punched in the head. Mirto was able to escape and retreat to the second floor of his home where he retrieved a handgun. He then found the intruder attempting to steal his television. The intruder reportedly instigated a second physical altercation. That is when Mirto shot the man in the chest. Police apprehended the intruder a short time later. (Milford Patch, Milford, CT, 7/23/12)



Martha Lewis was at home with her two daughters when she heard a loud noise. It was 3 a.m., so Lewis immediately called police and grabbed her gun. She went to her daughters’ room and told them each to get something with which to defend themselves. They were at the top of the stairs when a man, who had kicked in the door and entered the home, spotted them. When the man started up the stairs toward them, Lewis warned the intruder that she would shoot him. When he ignored her warnings, Lewis fired causing him to stumble outside where police found him. The 25-year-old male was hospitalized in stable condition. After the incident, Lewis said, “There’s so much talk about banning guns and gun control, but they’re for protection. There’s no way that I could have fought him off.” (The Blaze, Dora, AL, 8/17/12)

There's literally hundreds of these types of instances.
http://www.americanrifleman.org/BlogList.aspx?cid=25&id=21
 
You Can't tell the left anything Sarge, they're so intelligent they know everything. That is as long as it has nothing to do with the personal right of being safe.

ORR
 
Since the anti gun rhetoric being spewed by the left has reached a fevered pitch, relating sob stories about some dimwit who accidentally shot himself, or some dimwit's kid who accidentally shot himself and other excuses to put additional limitations on firearm ownership, I am now going to point out that Citizens owning firearms is a far more positive thing than a negative one.

Without private firearm ownership, these people would most likely have met their ends at the hands of criminals.

Scott Stith was in his bedroom when he heard a loud crash coming from the first floor of his home. He grabbed his .45 cal. pistol and crept downstairs to investigate. He spotted the silhouette of a man, but did not fire because he had teenage sons in the house and was not 100 percent sure of his target. He called out only to discover the man was an intruder who had broken through the glass of the back door. Stith held the 29-year-old intruder at gunpoint until police arrived. Everyone involved was reportedly unharmed. (Sandusky Register., Milan, OH, 9/29/12)

Just before 2 a.m., a 25-year-old man shot another man in the head at Bonnie’s Food and Spirits after he was asked to leave. He then fatally shot another customer outside the pub. When he pointed his pistol at Mark Ktytor, however, Ktytor produced his own firearm and fired multiple rounds, leaving the assailant in critical condition. The suspect will be charged with criminal homicide and attempted homicide upon his release from the hospital. (The Times-Tribune, Plymouth, PA, 9/11/12)

Two armed men stormed into a Dollar General store one evening and attempted to rob it. While the men held the store manager at gunpoint, a 57-year-old man carrying a concealed .45 cal. handgun, who had been shopping at the store at the time of the robbery, took action. The customer did not hesitate to draw his gun and fire at the suspects. One of the men robbing the store suffered fatal wounds to the head, chest and shoulder. The second suspect fled, but was later caught and charged with robbery and felony murder. There were reportedly no other injuries. (The Florida Times-Union, Jacksonville, FL, 8/29/12)

Brianne Rodriguez heard a knock at her front door just before 9 a.m., but ignored it. A few minutes later, Rodriguez heard loud noises coming from her bedroom. When she went to investigate, she discovered a man wearing a ski mask in her home. The confrontation led to a struggle and Rodriguez was pushed to the floor and kicked in the face and ribs. The masked man then grabbed her screaming 2-year-old daughter and bolted for the door. Rodriguez quickly retrieved a shotgun she kept in her bedroom and followed. Upon seeing the gun, the man dropped the child and fled. He escaped with Rodriguez’s purse and some jewelry, but Rodriguez and her daughter sustained no serious injuries. (KSEE 24 NEWS, Fresno County, CA, 8/28/12)

When the ex-husband of a woman living at Windmill Cove Apartments was not granted access to his ex-wife’s home by employees of the apartment complex, he warned that he would kick in the door. His ex-wife and a 35-year-old male friend were inside when they heard yelling and someone violently kicking the door. When the door gave way and the man came inside, the friend fired several rounds from his handgun. The man suffered multiple gunshot wounds that proved fatal. (KSL, Sandy, UT, 9/2/12)

John Mutter was asleep in his bed around 2:15 a.m. when he was awakened by a man with a shotgun pointed at his head. Mutter, a paraplegic living alone, kept his own gun nearby for protection. He quickly grabbed his gun and fired multiple times killing the intruder. Police investigating the incident believed the man had entered the home looking for medication, money or anything of value. (The Columbus Dispatch, Johnstown, OH, 7/22/12)

Gerald Mirto, 67, heard noises coming from his backyard and went to investigate. When he noticed the screen door had been broken, Mirto spotted the culprit standing just outside. The 25-year-old suspect was not wearing any clothing and was asked to leave repeatedly. There was a struggle in which Mirto was bitten in the arm and punched in the head. Mirto was able to escape and retreat to the second floor of his home where he retrieved a handgun. He then found the intruder attempting to steal his television. The intruder reportedly instigated a second physical altercation. That is when Mirto shot the man in the chest. Police apprehended the intruder a short time later. (Milford Patch, Milford, CT, 7/23/12)



Martha Lewis was at home with her two daughters when she heard a loud noise. It was 3 a.m., so Lewis immediately called police and grabbed her gun. She went to her daughters’ room and told them each to get something with which to defend themselves. They were at the top of the stairs when a man, who had kicked in the door and entered the home, spotted them. When the man started up the stairs toward them, Lewis warned the intruder that she would shoot him. When he ignored her warnings, Lewis fired causing him to stumble outside where police found him. The 25-year-old male was hospitalized in stable condition. After the incident, Lewis said, “There’s so much talk about banning guns and gun control, but they’re for protection. There’s no way that I could have fought him off.” (The Blaze, Dora, AL, 8/17/12)

There's literally hundreds of these types of instances.
http://www.americanrifleman.org/BlogList.aspx?cid=25&id=21

Really, you think that the outcome is evident of what happened, or is it the story as you people wanted it told?

Out of 330 million guns and the same amount of people I can say for sure some times the outcome of something may well end up like your stories, but very often people who resist instead of calling the police are KILLED DEADER THAN A DOOR KNOB.
These stories are not the norm, you can take it to the bank.
 
600 people killed a year in accidental gun deaths. I guess those are acceptable losses for the anecdotes about "defending a home against an intruder"?
 
Sarge, these are anecdotes about armed citizens stopping gun crimes. You'd have to put some statistics out there to see what the effect of armed citizens is on the commission of gun crimes.

The number of incidents of non-fatal violent crime involving guns was 326,090 in 2009 according to DOJ stats. http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/glance/tables/firearmnonfataltab.cfm

Among those encounters, what is the number of times that the victim was armed and stopped the commission of a violent crime? You've cited a link claiming hundreds of examples of such encounters but the anecdotes go back as far as 1964.

The American Rifleman link provides ~100 examples where an armed victim stopped a violent crime from 1964 through 2012.

Forgetting that the example set ranges from 1964 through 2012, what would be the deterrent rate of armed victims stopping an armed offender during the commission of a violent crime?

100/326,090 = 0.0003 x 100 = 0.03%. That's a negligible rate as far as deterrence and it includes examples stretching back to 1964.

There are numbers that can be looked at. According to the DOJ, from 1987 - 1992, the percent of times an armed victim encountered an armed offender was ~0.42% of the time during the commission of a violent crime. The percent of times an armed victim is present during the commission of a violent crime is ~1.2%.

http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/ascii/hvfsdaft.txt

So, a good estimate of the chances for an armed victim to stop a violent crime is somewhere between 0.42% and 1.2% of the time a violent crime is committed. These represent maximum estimates since the number of times an armed victim is present during a violent crime doesn't mean the armed victim stopped the crime.
 
ARM: You're data is skewed by the fact that many deterred crimes are unreported. "Gimme you're money," -- the would-be victim produces a gun, the would-be robber runs off, and the police are never called. The DoJ then has no figures about that crime.

I can provide estimates from an analysis of county-by-county crime statistics, but my assumption is you'll criticize the source or methodology of the analysis.
 
ARM: You're data is skewed by the fact that many deterred crimes are unreported. "Gimme you're money," -- the would-be victim produces a gun, the would-be robber runs off, and the police are never called. The DoJ then has no figures about that crime.

I can provide estimates from an analysis of county-by-county crime statistics, but my assumption is you'll criticize the source or methodology of the analysis.

The problem is the lack of data. There should be some numbers available. It's not valid to try to assess the effect of the victim being armed by ~100 anecdotes over a 50 year interval. That's meaningless because the number of anecdotes -- even if all are true -- is dwarfed by the total number of violent crimes or even the number of violent crimes with guns.

The estimate that an armed victim is present between 0.42% - 1.2% of the time a violent crime was committed seems a reasonable maximum estimate of deterrence given the DOJ data from 1987-1992. The 0.42% is the chance that both the victim and the offender were armed. The 1.2% is the chance that the victim was armed during a violent crime.

So, if the argument is that guns deter violent crime, the opportunity to deter is between 0.42% -- 1.2% of all the violent crimes committed between 1987 - 1992.

It's interesting to me that gun right advocates prefer the anecdotal rather than the statistical when the argument is that widespread access to guns deters crime.
 
The problem is the lack of data. There should be some numbers available. It's not valid to try to assess the effect of the victim being armed by ~100 anecdotes over a 50 year interval. That's meaningless because the number of anecdotes -- even if all are true -- is dwarfed by the total number of violent crimes or even the number of violent crimes with guns.

The estimate that an armed victim is present between 0.42% - 1.2% of the time a violent crime was committed seems a reasonable maximum estimate of deterrence given the DOJ data from 1987-1992. The 0.42% is the chance that both the victim and the offender were armed. The 1.2% is the chance that the victim was armed during a violent crime.

So, if the argument is that guns deter violent crime, the opportunity to deter is between 0.42% -- 1.2% of all the violent crimes committed between 1987 - 1992.

It's interesting to me that gun right advocates prefer the anecdotal rather than the statistical when the argument is that widespread access to guns deters crime.

Well, there are far more than ~100 anecdotes. The NRA compiles that many each year in "The Armed Citizen." I personally don't care if there is a deterent effect. Seat belts may deter accidents, but I don't wear mine to deter accidents, but to protect me if an accident occurs. People who carry firearms don't do so in order to have a deterrent affect (althought there are some studies that indicate such an effect exists), but to protect themselves if they're assaulted or threatened.
 
Really, you think that the outcome is evident of what happened, or is it the story as you people wanted it told?

Out of 330 million guns and the same amount of people I can say for sure some times the outcome of something may well end up like your stories, but very often people who resist instead of calling the police are KILLED DEADER THAN A DOOR KNOB.
These stories are not the norm, you can take it to the bank.

More people are murdered with hammers than are murdered with guns. More people with guns save themselves from people that are trying to kill them with hammers.
 
600 people killed a year in accidental gun deaths. I guess those are acceptable losses for the anecdotes about "defending a home against an intruder"?

How many people are killed per year in accidental automobile crashes. Guess we ought to ban automobiles too.

Why don't we just ban everything that could possible kill us? Liberal stupidity.
 
How many people are killed per year in accidental automobile crashes. Guess we ought to ban automobiles too.

Why don't we just ban everything that could possible kill us? Liberal stupidity.

And you offer conservative stupidity.

Cars have been made safer...and continue to be made safer. The purpose of an automobile is to move goods and people for commerce. Our vehicular death rate has decreased as these mandated safety laws have come on line. From seat belts to airbags...we have tried to limit death by car.

Apply the same attitude to guns.

The purpose of a gun is to kill.
 
And you offer conservative stupidity.

Cars have been made safer...and continue to be made safer. The purpose of an automobile is to move goods and people for commerce. Our vehicular death rate has decreased as these mandated safety laws have come on line. From seat belts to airbags...we have tried to limit death by car.

Apply the same attitude to guns.

The purpose of a gun is to kill.

Guns have been made safer, too. The guns used in Columbine and Newtown didn't malfunction, they were misused. We have tried to limit cars to make them safer for their own operators, not to keep them from being stolen and misused.
 
Guns have been made safer, too. The guns used in Columbine and Newtown didn't malfunction, they were misused. We have tried to limit cars to make them safer for their own operators, not to keep them from being stolen and misused.

Incorrect. Car theft has been addressed as well, by manufacturers and independent entrepreneurs. Both continue to make efforts to limit that abuse as well. I need a electronic key to start one of my cars. Even if you have a matching key ...the car will not run unless that key has been programmed. Theft isn't impossible, but is more difficult.
 
All this is about as good as your TP story yesterday Sarge. Shotguns, rifles, six shooters.. NOBODY is talking about taking those away.

But we'll continue to anticipate your barrage of false equivalencies. ;-)
 
Incorrect. Car theft has been addressed as well, by manufacturers and independent entrepreneurs. Both continue to make efforts to limit that abuse as well. I need a electronic key to start one of my cars. Even if you have a matching key ...the car will not run unless that key has been programmed. Theft isn't impossible, but is more difficult.

But nothing in those protections keeps you from speeding, or from ramming your car through a crowded shopping mall, and even the most high-tech security system is subject to being hot wired. Modern cars are stolen on a daily basis.
The firearms used in the Newtown shooting were akin to a family member taking your high tech keys and using the car to commit a crime. In neither case would the inanimate object be at fault.
 
All this is about as good as your TP story yesterday Sarge. Shotguns, rifles, six shooters.. NOBODY is talking about taking those away.

But we'll continue to anticipate your barrage of false equivalencies. ;-)

Feinstein has called for taking them all away -- "Mr. and Mrs. North America, send them in." Six shooters are handguns. The Brady Campaign used to have a different name -- it was the "National Coalition to Ban Handguns."

Handguns were bad because they could be concealed. Semiautomatic weapons are bad because you can fire them fast (no faster than a double-action six shooter, in actuality, but explaining that to a person with limited firearms knowledge is nearly impossible). Shotguns are bad because they can be sawed off. That pretty much leaves bolt-action rifles -- but if they're scoped, they're then "sniper" rifles and then they're bad, too.
 
No Trap, you're wrong about Feinstein. She when she said "taking them all away" she was speaking of assault weapons. The quote was snagged out of context.

But you're correct.. i've tried to be careful in my use of the word "nobody" and should have preceded it with the word "virtually" or some such to avoid the gross generalization.

There are a FEW who support a ban on all firearms. They don't represent a mainstream left opinion.
 
Back
Top