New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The first Amendment

In other words,
they cannot pass a law that says you can pray in school, any more than they could pass a law that says, you CANT pray in school.

And thats what the TP is asking.
If the congress cannot pass a law allowing or disallowing prayer in school, who exactly can?
The scotus? ( I know the scotus doesnt pass laws) so dont get on me about that.
States?
 
And thats what the TP is asking.
they cannot pass a law that says you can pray in school, any more than they could pass a law that says, you CANT pray in school.
Wrong. Congress and local lege's can make laws that apply in a civic manner. Disruptive behaviour of any sort in a school can be banned. Clearly a religious observance that involved the sacrifice of an animal would be disruptive. Since there are religions that do that as part of their practice, you cannot consider their observance disruptive but allow other similarly intrusive and disruptive observances.

So Congress CAN pass laws that protect individual rights.

And that includes my SECULAR right to not have another person use public resources to promote their particular brand of faith (prayer by the Valedictorian in the role of valedictorian as opposed to a private personal prayer before making the valedictorian speech).

You keep making stuff up that isn't true about the Constitution. Its amazing how little you know about it.
 
Let me ask the question in a different way.
Suppose a States (any State) legislators say in their constitution,
" The congress of the State shall make no laws governing the turning of right on a red signal"
The question is,
can cities make such laws one way or another?
Not a meaningful question. Cities derive their Constitutional authority purely as delegates of the State government and have no independent authority. States vs. the Foederal government are different.

You are demonstrating that you don't understand constitutional structuer at all.
 
Wrong. Congress and local lege's can make laws that apply in a civic manner. Disruptive behaviour of any sort in a school can be banned. Clearly a religious observance that involved the sacrifice of an animal would be disruptive. Since there are religions that do that as part of their practice, you cannot consider their observance disruptive but allow other similarly intrusive and disruptive observances.

So Congress CAN pass laws that protect individual rights.

And that includes my SECULAR right to not have another person use public resources to promote their particular brand of faith (prayer by the Valedictorian in the role of valedictorian as opposed to a private personal prayer before making the valedictorian speech).

You keep making stuff up that isn't true about the Constitution. Its amazing how little you know about it.



I KNOW DAMN WELL YOU CAN READ.
I said, and you agreed with me that the states leg CAN make laws.
ARe you actually saying that the US Congress can pass a law forbidding or allowing prayer in school?
If you arent, then are on the same page.
I do not know why you do not understand what I am asking
 
Disruptive behaviour of any sort in a school can be banned. Clearly a religious observance that involved the sacrifice of an animal would be disruptive.
Not by the US Congress as the 1st specifically says,
"Shall make no law"
 
Let me make this real, real, I mean real easy.
YES or NO.

Can the US Congress pass a law that says
"US citizens have to pray in school"

Can the US Congress pass a law that says
"US Citizens cannot pray in school"
 
Let me make this real, real, I mean real easy.
YES or NO.

Can the US Congress pass a law that says
"US citizens have to pray in school"
No

Can the US Congress pass a law that says
"US Citizens cannot pray in school"
Depends. If the prayer is disruptive or structured in a manner that the school is advocating it then such a law can and does exist. If it is PERSONAL and PRIVATE then no.

You are trying to make something so simple that it no longer addresses the complexity of the situation. And that is wrong.
 
I KNOW DAMN WELL YOU CAN READ.
I said, and you agreed with me that the states leg CAN make laws.
ARe you actually saying that the US Congress can pass a law forbidding or allowing prayer in school?
If you arent, then are on the same page.
I do not know why you do not understand what I am asking
Oh I understand why you are asking. But your basis is a bogus basis.

Congress CANNOT pass laws that establish a state organized religion - and neither can states.
But it CAN pass laws that prevents such an establishment either officially or de facto by favouring some faiths over others.

Thus it CAN pass laws limiting the circumstances in which religious observance can be carried out in a government organized setting (schools). Prayer (which is only one form of religious observance) that is disruptive can be banned because of the general CIVIC ban on disruptive behaviour in schools.

Prayer that assumes the mantle of school sponsored or authorized (led by someone imbued with authority - even a parent volunteer) such as a valedictorian speech ALSO can be prohibitted since that is favouring one faith over another.

But PRIVATE PERSONAL, non-disruptive observance cannot (be it prayer to oneself or the wearing of a Hindu facial "dot".


So your point of generalizing that States and Congress cannot in ANY WAY ban or regulate prayer in schools is wrong.
 
No


Depends. If the prayer is disruptive or structured in a manner that the school is advocating it then such a law can and does exist. If it is PERSONAL and PRIVATE then no.

You are trying to make something so simple that it no longer addresses the complexity of the situation. And that is wrong.

The original question on
the TP is suppose to be a simple question.

I am glad that you and I agree that the answer is no
 
Former Attorney General Ed Meese thought so. He thought it would be perfectly permissible for an individual STATE to have an offical religion. So the state of Utah, for instance, could make the Mormon religion mandatory for all of the citizens of that state.

Of course, Ed Meese was a grade-A knucklehead......

It's scary to imagine what would be possible if the first amendment didn't apply to state or local governments. It wouldn't even have to stop at proclaiming an official state religion. We could be forced to actually tithe to the favored state church and to worship there, while attending church services for any other faith could be made a jailable offense. It could also be made illegal to criticize the governor, and newspapers and other media outlets could be required to submit to official state censorship to rid them of anything the state didn't want published. Meanwhile, citizens could be prevented from assembling in public.
 
It's scary to imagine what would be possible if the first amendment didn't apply to state or local governments. It wouldn't even have to stop at proclaiming an official state religion. We could be forced to actually tithe to the favored state church and to worship there, while attending church services for any other faith could be made a jailable offense. It could also be made illegal to criticize the governor, and newspapers and other media outlets could be required to submit to official state censorship to rid them of anything the state didn't want published. Meanwhile, citizens could be prevented from assembling in public.
Well this actually was the case in many places shortly before ratification. Baptists fgzmple in MA had to pay a special tax and were not allowed to vote.
 
@Arkady

Will OsamaCare recipients be allowed to posses a bible or anti-govt pamphlets such as the constitution at government owned/managed health care facilities?
 
Oh I understand why you are asking. But your basis is a bogus basis.

Congress CANNOT pass laws that establish a state organized religion - and neither can states.
But it CAN pass laws that prevents such an establishment either officially or de facto by favouring some faiths over others.

Thus it CAN pass laws limiting the circumstances in which religious observance can be carried out in a government organized setting (schools). Prayer (which is only one form of religious observance) that is disruptive can be banned because of the general CIVIC ban on disruptive behaviour in schools.

Prayer that assumes the mantle of school sponsored or authorized (led by someone imbued with authority - even a parent volunteer) such as a valedictorian speech ALSO can be prohibitted since that is favouring one faith over another.

But PRIVATE PERSONAL, non-disruptive observance cannot (be it prayer to oneself or the wearing of a Hindu facial "dot".


So your point of generalizing that States and Congress cannot in ANY WAY ban or regulate prayer in schools is wrong.

Thats where you are reading me wrong.
I am not talking about states, I am talking about the US Congress.

I will rephrase you answer, (leavig out "states" then perhaps you will get my point

So your point of generalizing that Congress cannot in ANY WAY ban or regulate prayer in schools is wrong.[/QUOTE][/B]
Now am I wrong?
 
The original question on
the TP is suppose to be a simple question.
Except it can only be as simple as is necessary to cover all the issues BUT NO SIMPLER.... So there is no single "no" or "yes" answer in this case.

You trying to make it so is like trying to make quantum mechanics go away because you prefer Newtonian physics at the particle level because it is simpler. It is simpler. It is also so profoundly wrong that as Fenyman opined "its not even wrong".
 
It's scary to imagine what would be possible if the first amendment didn't apply to state or local governments. It wouldn't even have to stop at proclaiming an official state religion. We could be forced to actually tithe to the favored state church and to worship there, while attending church services for any other faith could be made a jailable offense. It could also be made illegal to criticize the governor, and newspapers and other media outlets could be required to submit to official state censorship to rid them of anything the state didn't want published. Meanwhile, citizens could be prevented from assembling in public.

Most of the examples on this thread are consistant to how courts have read the 1st, including the SCOTUS.
The threads purpose was not any of the courts opinions, rather the question of whether the US CONGRESS shall make or shall not make laws is regards to FOS, ect.
The answer, is a resonding "no"


And thats all I was asking.
 
@Arkady

Will OsamaCare recipients be allowed to posses a bible or anti-govt pamphlets such as the constitution at government owned/managed health care facilities?

Assuming that was just some childish gibbering, and you meant Obamacare, then you needn't fear that a slightly more activist government in the healthcare arena will mean censorship of that sort. Keep in mind, we already have a substantial portion of our population that is covered by a single-payer socialized healthcare system: Medicare. Add in Medicaid, and we've long been covering an even bigger portion than that with something that is considerably more socialized than the private-insurer healthcare system implemented under Obamacare. And Medicare isn't even the most socialized part of our healthcare system. I should know. I was born in a government-owned hospital, on the taxpayer dime, under the care of a doctor who worked directly for the federal government. That didn't mean my mother wasn't allowed to have a Bible. When that level of EXTREMELY socialized care didn't result in the kind of censorship you fear, why would a mere mandate to buy private health insurance do so?
 
Except it can only be as simple as is necessary to cover all the issues BUT NO SIMPLER.... So there is no single "no" or "yes" answer in this case.

You trying to make it so is like trying to make quantum mechanics go away because you prefer Newtonian physics at the particle level because it is simpler. It is simpler. It is also so profoundly wrong that as Fenyman opined "its not even wrong".

Whats wrong about what I ask?
Can the US congress pass a law making an issue of say, freedom of the press?

Simple answer?
"No"
 
Whats wrong about what I ask?
Can the US congress pass a law making an issue of say, freedom of the press?

Simple answer?
"No"

Why is the answer "no"?

Because the 1st says they cant.
Its really that simple
 
Back
Top