New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The math that the left pretends doesn't exist...

Lukey

Senator
That chart makes the size of the problem abundantly clear. There are a lot of people already very concerned with the amount of debt the United States has. Imagine how they would feel if they were aware that with these liabilities conclude the number is 20 times larger.


This is a case of simple math.


Either tax rates increase in a massive way or the payments to seniors have to be cut significantly. The status quo doesn’t work. There just isn’t going to be anywhere close to enough money coming in to fund the payments going out.


The country can’t borrow its way out of a funding issue of this size.


http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...tainable-situation-i-have-seen-ever-my-career

We have run out of other people's money...
 
The left will not care until the gov check isn't deposited.........too late then.

"When they came for the Indians, I said nothing"--the I wasn't one deal
 
The affluenza problem is why there is no money left in government. Seems republicans can spend for war but not for humans. Go back to Ikes time and that is how you get out of the republicans dreamland of financial bliss.
 
The affluenza problem is why there is no money left in government. Seems republicans can spend for war but not for humans. Go back to Ikes time and that is how you get out of the republicans dreamland of financial bliss.

You know it's interesting how the left sees confiscatory tax policies as the answer to every revenue question. The "we're not Marxists" progressives are all about wealth redistribution as the singular feature of their entire agenda. And they always go back to the "look at Eisenhower tax rates" as their justification for their communist schemes to get their hands on the money of the "evil rich." But, in point of fact, those 90% marginal tax rates didn't really bring in any higher percent of GDP than did the lower rates in the 80s and 90s:

Screen Shot 2016-04-04 at 7.29.37 AM.png
So it isn't as simple as just raising rates. If your goal is to extract a HIGHER percent of GDP than the 8% or so that income taxes have been traditionally garnering, it will require vast new taxes, including on the middle class. I don't understand why the left is so adamant that they can raise all the revenue we need simply by raising taxes on "the rich." Oh yes, it's because they are a bunch of conniving liars...
 
Last edited:
by 2035 (based on current trendlines) the entire national budget will be consumed by just 3 things:

1 - social security
2 - interest on the national debt
3 - health care subsidies
 
That chart makes the size of the problem abundantly clear. There are a lot of people already very concerned with the amount of debt the United States has. Imagine how they would feel if they were aware that with these liabilities conclude the number is 20 times larger.


This is a case of simple math.


Either tax rates increase in a massive way or the payments to seniors have to be cut significantly. The status quo doesn’t work. There just isn’t going to be anywhere close to enough money coming in to fund the payments going out.


The country can’t borrow its way out of a funding issue of this size.


http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...tainable-situation-i-have-seen-ever-my-career

We have run out of other people's money...
Trump's One Good Idea?
"In 1999 Mr. Trump was running for president and broadcasting his ideas about the national debt.

"A November, 1999, article begins, 'Billionaire businessman Donald Trump has a plan to pay off the national debt, grant a middle class a tax cut, and keep Social Security afloat: tax rich people like himself. . . . By Trump's calculations, his proposed 14.25 percent levy on such net worth [on individuals with net worth over $10 million] would raise $5.7 trillion and wipe out the debt in one full swoop. . . . ‘Personally this plan would cost me hundreds of millions of dollars, but in all honesty, it's worth it,’ Trump said. ”:rolleyes:
http://therealnews.com/t2/component...-leet/2690-trumps-one-good-idea-soak-the-rich
 
That chart makes the size of the problem abundantly clear. There are a lot of people already very concerned with the amount of debt the United States has. Imagine how they would feel if they were aware that with these liabilities conclude the number is 20 times larger.


This is a case of simple math.


Either tax rates increase in a massive way or the payments to seniors have to be cut significantly. The status quo doesn’t work. There just isn’t going to be anywhere close to enough money coming in to fund the payments going out.


The country can’t borrow its way out of a funding issue of this size.


http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...tainable-situation-i-have-seen-ever-my-career

We have run out of other people's money...

OHHHHHHHH....now you've gone and done it....

You added 2+2 and made it equal to the politically incorrect sum of 4.....you are a baaaad person!!

Didn't you know that a committee met just last week down in DC and made that Illegal?
 
by 2035 (based on current trendlines) the entire national budget will be consumed by just 3 things:

1 - social security
2 - interest on the national debt
3 - health care subsidies
With all due respect, you really need to wrap your mind around the history surrounding the "miracle of compound interest."

"We are living today in a transition period much like that of Athens c. 330 BC when Aristotle wrote his Politics. Seeing inequality widen as his citystate became an empire, he described how wealthy families tend to emerge within democracies to become a financial oligarchy. Book V of Politics traces how these oligarchies indebt a rising proportion of the population to themselves, creating hereditary estates on which to found aristocratic dynasties. In time..."

http://store.counterpunch.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Killing-The-Host_PDF_V7.pdf
 
That chart makes the size of the problem abundantly clear. There are a lot of people already very concerned with the amount of debt the United States has. Imagine how they would feel if they were aware that with these liabilities conclude the number is 20 times larger.


This is a case of simple math.


Either tax rates increase in a massive way or the payments to seniors have to be cut significantly. The status quo doesn’t work. There just isn’t going to be anywhere close to enough money coming in to fund the payments going out.


The country can’t borrow its way out of a funding issue of this size.


http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...tainable-situation-i-have-seen-ever-my-career

We have run out of other people's money...
There is a long-term mismatch between Social Security funding and Social Security obligations. Sooner or later that will require funding to rise or payments to fall. There's no need to panic, though. We have a simple solution that could balance the books as far out as anyone can realistically do projections: just eliminate the Social Security tax cap. Rich guys like me get a windfall part way through the year, when the government essentially says that because we're rich we're allowed to stop paying into Social Security, while working stiffs are expected to contribute all year. Eliminate that windfall, and have the rich pay in for the whole year like everyone else, and the added revenues make SS solvent as far out as we can realistically project. And it wouldn't even be particularly hard on the wealthy (since we already grow used to the smaller paychecks in the first part of the year, before the windfall kicks in). A few decades down the road, if it turns out that won't be enough, simply subject investment income to SS taxes the same way as money people actually earn, and that'll do it.
 
There is a long-term mismatch between Social Security funding and Social Security obligations. Sooner or later that will require funding to rise or payments to fall. There's no need to panic, though. We have a simple solution that could balance the books as far out as anyone can realistically do projections: just eliminate the Social Security tax cap. Rich guys like me get a windfall part way through the year, when the government essentially says that because we're rich we're allowed to stop paying into Social Security, while working stiffs are expected to contribute all year. Eliminate that windfall, and have the rich pay in for the whole year like everyone else, and the added revenues make SS solvent as far out as we can realistically project. And it wouldn't even be particularly hard on the wealthy (since we already grow used to the smaller paychecks in the first part of the year, before the windfall kicks in). A few decades down the road, if it turns out that won't be enough, simply subject investment income to SS taxes the same way as money people actually earn, and that'll do it.

You get that "windfall" (since when is keeping your own money a "windfall???) because your benefits are capped, which suggests taxible income should also be capped. So I guess you have found the magic tax tree that when you shake it all the revenue your little progressive heart could want will come raining down. Actually, social security is supposed to be "insurance" and not a wealth redistribution scheme. Of course, you "we're not Marxists" lefties never met a policy you didn't seek to turn into a wealth distribution scheme, so no surprise there.
 
Last edited:
You get that "windfall" (since when id keeping your own money a "windfall???) because your benefits are capped, which suggests taxible income should also be capped.

Benefits rise at a different rate than payments long before you get to the cap. The basic Social Security benefits formula is 90% of the first $856 in average indexed monthly earnings, plus 32% of earnings between $856 and $5157 per month, then 15% for those above $5157. So, obviously someone who earned an average of $10,000 per year would get back far more of the value he paid in than someone who earned an average of $110,000 per year. Each would pay in the same flat percentage, but the first person would get back something worth 90% of his average income, while the latter would get back something closer to 18% of his average income.

Obviously, those who are paying in 15.3% of their earnings (employer plus employee portion), yet only retiring on 18% after all those years, aren't getting back all the value they put in. Instead, they're essentially subsidizing the less fortunate. And the higher you rise in the income scale, up to $118,500 per year, the more you subsidize the less fortunate. Then, suddenly, that stops. For no discernible reason, although the lower-upper class is expected to contribute more to the retirements of the less fortunate than the upper-middle class does, the upper-upper class isn't expected to contribute any more than the lower-upper class does. Why? Why not simply continue the same formula? Why this special relief just for the very wealthy?

Actually, social security is supposed to be "insurance" and not a wealth redistribution scheme.

It's both and always has been. As you can see from the formula I posted, Social Security already shifts money from workers near that $118,500 cap to retirees who make a lot less. The only question is why we aren't consistent in that redistribution -- why it's OK to redistribute from the lower-upper class, but not from the upper-upper class (other than because the upper-upper class owns the politicians, obviously).
 
If you don't have the money to pay off Social Security, it's a scam.

If you don't have the gold to back up your currency, it's a scam.

Liberal economists love to tread in the theoretical waters as far as money, but the cold truth is that they don't have what the people are owed, their own money.
 
Trump's One Good Idea?
"In 1999 Mr. Trump was running for president and broadcasting his ideas about the national debt.

"A November, 1999, article begins, 'Billionaire businessman Donald Trump has a plan to pay off the national debt, grant a middle class a tax cut, and keep Social Security afloat: tax rich people like himself. . . . By Trump's calculations, his proposed 14.25 percent levy on such net worth [on individuals with net worth over $10 million] would raise $5.7 trillion and wipe out the debt in one full swoop. . . . ‘Personally this plan would cost me hundreds of millions of dollars, but in all honesty, it's worth it,’ Trump said. ”:rolleyes:
http://therealnews.com/t2/component...-leet/2690-trumps-one-good-idea-soak-the-rich

That's an interesting idea.... I wonder what his net worth baseline was. And of course, the concern is if it is done once, it could done again and again, likely each time affecting less rich people. This looks like a classic slippery slope thingy to me. The practical side of me likes this, the principled side doesn't. But what is politics if not going against your principles sometimes to accomplish something?
 
There is a long-term mismatch between Social Security funding and Social Security obligations. Sooner or later that will require funding to rise or payments to fall. There's no need to panic, though. We have a simple solution that could balance the books as far out as anyone can realistically do projections: just eliminate the Social Security tax cap. Rich guys like me get a windfall part way through the year, when the government essentially says that because we're rich we're allowed to stop paying into Social Security, while working stiffs are expected to contribute all year. Eliminate that windfall, and have the rich pay in for the whole year like everyone else, and the added revenues make SS solvent as far out as we can realistically project. And it wouldn't even be particularly hard on the wealthy (since we already grow used to the smaller paychecks in the first part of the year, before the windfall kicks in). A few decades down the road, if it turns out that won't be enough, simply subject investment income to SS taxes the same way as money people actually earn, and that'll do it.

It's always amusing when a marxist refers to keeping what you earned as a "windfall". You must get excited every time you receive an unexpected paycheck. But really, you've mastered Orwellian doublespeak like few others have. LOL
 
It's always amusing when a marxist refers to keeping what you earned as a "windfall". You must get excited every time you receive an unexpected paycheck. But really, you've mastered Orwellian doublespeak like few others have. LOL
If you define windfall as something unexpected, it's not truly a windfall, since I know just when I'll hit the cap and so I expect the sudden increase in my paychecks. But I experience it as a windfall in the sense that I got used to the lower paychecks for the first part of the year, when I was expected to pay into Social Security just like the "little people," and then one day that cut stops coming out of my paycheck and I get a sudden boost in my pay. It feels like a kind of bonus, since I'm not doing any more work than I was earlier in the year, yet I'm taking home a lot more. We could eliminate that, so same way we eliminated the Medicare tax cap back in the early 1990s.
 
If you define windfall as something unexpected, it's not truly a windfall, since I know just when I'll hit the cap and so I expect the sudden increase in my paychecks. But I experience it as a windfall in the sense that I got used to the lower paychecks for the first part of the year, when I was expected to pay into Social Security just like the "little people," and then one day that cut stops coming out of my paycheck and I get a sudden boost in my pay. It feels like a kind of bonus, since I'm not doing any more work than I was earlier in the year, yet I'm taking home a lot more. We could eliminate that, so same way we eliminated the Medicare tax cap back in the early 1990s.

It's not a bonus. You've paid your share and you keep the rest. If it really bothers you, send the Social Security Administration an extra check every month until year end. In the meantime, your marxist fantasy of extracting even more wealth from others who cap (like me) at gunpoint needs to remain just a fantasy.
 
It's not a bonus. You've paid your share and you keep the rest.

Yes. And my argument is my share should be higher.

If it really bothers you, send the Social Security Administration an extra check every month until year end.

No. I"m not interested in unilaterally footing this bill while letting other rich people free-load. I'm interested in a change that would remove the tax cap for all of us.

We've made a very similar change already with Medicare. Until the early Clinton years, rich people got to stop paying into Medicare part-way through the year. Then that tax cap went away. That wasn't a fantasy. It was just a simple reform that allowed us to shore up some much needed social spending in a way that didn't create any extra burden on the vast majority of Americans, and was easily borne by the very wealthy. The wealthy are the one group that's doing better and better -- we can bear a little upward adjustment in our tax burden in the interest of the greater good.
 
Yes. And my argument is my share should be higher.



No. I"m not interested in unilaterally footing this bill while letting other rich people free-load. I'm interested in a change that would remove the tax cap for all of us.

We've made a very similar change already with Medicare. Until the early Clinton years, rich people got to stop paying into Medicare part-way through the year. Then that tax cap went away. That wasn't a fantasy. It was just a simple reform that allowed us to shore up some much needed social spending in a way that didn't create any extra burden on the vast majority of Americans, and was easily borne by the very wealthy. The wealthy are the one group that's doing better and better -- we can bear a little upward adjustment in our tax burden in the interest of the greater good.

Keeping what you earn according to the law isn't "free-loading". Collecting a monthly check from the government when you're able-bodied and don't work is free-loading. Know the difference. I encourage you to increase your payments to the SSA. In the meantime, as I said, keep wealth redistribution at gunpoint in your fantasy life.
 
Keeping what you earn according to the law isn't "free-loading". Collecting a monthly check from the government when you're able-bodied and don't work is free-loading. Know the difference. I encourage you to increase your payments to the SSA. In the meantime, as I said, keep wealth redistribution at gunpoint in your fantasy life.
The free-loading I'm referring to would be another rich person being entitled to stop paying into Social Security part-way through the year because someone like me voluntarily pays extra to shore up the system. What I'm advocating, instead of that kind of invitation to free-loading, is an across-the-board rule change that would require us rich people to pay into Social Security the whole year, just like poor and middle class people already have to, rather than us getting a special "rich guy's tax holiday" for the balance of the year.
 
Back
Top