New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Ryan Tax Brackets

Bluedog

Mayor
Regardless of how anyone feels about the entire plan, I think Congress should consider this:

10% under 250,000

25% over 250,000


Does anyone object to this part of the plan as a starting point?
 
I have always personally favored something along the lines of a ten percent consumption tax and a flat income tax of 15% or so that kicks in somewhere in the upper middle class (i.e. now somewhere north of $100,000).
 
I absolutely favor the Republican Party running on Ryan's "tax the poor" platform.

Seems perfectly fair....the working poor pay 10% MORE...and the rich pay 10% LESS. 10-10 (Much easier than 9-9-9)

:D
 
I absolutely favor the Republican Party running on Ryan's "tax the poor" platform.

Seems perfectly fair....the working poor pay 10% MORE...and the rich pay 10% LESS. 10-10 (Much easier than 9-9-9)

:D

I agree. The top poster's Ryan SHOULD put his ridiculous scheme front and center, and called upon to defend it's umpteen upsides and downsides. Clearly, Ryan's scheme makes the top-poster feel good. That's good. As it is...Ryan gets to hide behind the reality that no one takes him seriously. It would be fun and worthwhile, to flush him out.
 
Regardless of how anyone feels about the entire plan, I think Congress should consider this:

10% under 250,000

25% over 250,000


Does anyone object to this part of the plan as a starting point?

Yes.. Massive upwards wealth transfer.

Completely ignores what we know about relative Marginal Utility of income as a funciton of total income

Econometrically inefficient.

Encourages economically undesirable behaviours.
 
I have always personally favored something along the lines of a ten percent consumption tax and a flat income tax of 15% or so that kicks in somewhere in the upper middle class (i.e. now somewhere north of $100,000).

IOW completely regressive, upwards wealth transfer that dramatically encourages undesirable economic behaviour. That's a winner.
 
IOW completely regressive,

Not regressive, just less progressive.

Actually a flat income tax with zero deduction is neither regressive or progressive. If you make 10 times as much you pay 10 times as much, unlike the Marxist progressive income tax where if you make 10 times as much you pay as much as 350 times as much.
 
Encourages economically undesirable behaviours.

Oh, you mean like freedom to earn and keep as much property as you desire without fear of confiscation for redistribution.

Hey, let's give government all of the earnings. Then we can do like they do in North Korea where they have complete economic equality for the masses.

See you in the rice fields.
 
Not regressive, just less progressive.

Completely regressive. Flat taxes are inherently regressive since they ignore Marginal Utility falloffs. So while you pay 10 times more tax, you don't pay 10 times more of your disposable income.


VAT Taxes are 100% regressive because the wealthier you are the lower a percentage of your income you spend domestically in consumption.
 
Oh, you mean like freedom to earn and keep as much property as you desire without fear of confiscation for redistribution.

Name a societal structure that does not redistribute income and wealth... You cannot. The basic function of society is to redistribute wealth

Hey, let's give government all of the earnings. Then we can do like they do in North Korea where they have complete economic equality for the masses.
Hmm so having a tax rate higher than 35% is the same as 100%... I somehow suspect you don't have a degree in the STEM areas of study..
 
Name a societal structure that does not redistribute income and wealth... You cannot. The basic function of society is to redistribute wealth


Hmm so having a tax rate higher than 35% is the same as 100%... I somehow suspect you don't have a degree in the STEM areas of study..

Or any other area of study.
 
Yes.. Massive upwards wealth transfer.

Completely ignores what we know about relative Marginal Utility of income as a funciton of total income

Econometrically inefficient.

Encourages economically undesirable behaviours.

Ok. So how would you design the brackets?
 
Ok. So how would you design the brackets?

We should probably look at countries that are not historically running massive deficits and see how their tax code is structured, countries like Germany, Sweden, Finland, Norway, and Switzerland.
 
IOW completely regressive, upwards wealth transfer that dramatically encourages undesirable economic behaviour. That's a winner.

LOL! In fact it is "progressive" so you are completely off base in your criticism. And, lets face it, what you REALLY don't like about it is that it discourages consumption and provides incentives for people to save and invest - which leads to accumulation of wealth. And THAT'S what you really hate - the idea that it might stand in the way of your Marxist revolution by making more working class folks investors (and capitalists)...
 
Completely regressive. Flat taxes are inherently regressive since they ignore Marginal Utility falloffs. So while you pay 10 times more tax, you don't pay 10 times more of your disposable income.

You gotta love the left. "Marginal Utility Falloffs" BWAHAHAHAHAHA.

Sorry bub, you can take those Marginal Utility Falloffs and stick 'em where the sun don't shine.

No amount of blather can change the fact, that under a flat tax with no deductions, a person that earns 10 times as much pays 10 times as much.

And a consumption tax is the ideal tax for a free citizenry. Call it regressive if you want to, but the simple fact is that with a consumption tax, everybody pays taxes. Therefore everybody has a vested interest in the size, scope, and cost of government. This leads ultimately to smaller more cost efficient government, and ultimately more freedom and prosperity for the vast majority.

This country has been going downhill ever since the income tax was passed under the Marxist Woodrow Wilson, who didn't like the Constitution almost as much Obama.

Taking from success to reward dependency will ultimately bankrupt America. we've accumulated, under Democrats and progressive Republicans 10's of trillions of dollars in unfunded liabilities.

We've got about 4 years to straighten this all out. I won't be straightened out because all one party knows how to do is spend money in vast amounts that there is simply no way to ever pay for it all, and all the other party knows how to do is cower in fear from the Democrats and the media accusing them of 'starving the poor,' every time one of them has enough balls to tackle the problem.
 
You gotta love the left. "Marginal Utility Falloffs" BWAHAHAHAHAHA.

Sorry bub, you can take those Marginal Utility Falloffs and stick 'em where the sun don't shine.

No amount of blather can change the fact, that under a flat tax with no deductions, a person that earns 10 times as much pays 10 times as much.

And a consumption tax is the ideal tax for a free citizenry. Call it regressive if you want to, but the simple fact is that with a consumption tax, everybody pays taxes. Therefore everybody has a vested interest in the size, scope, and cost of government. This leads ultimately to smaller more cost efficient government, and ultimately more freedom and prosperity for the vast majority.

This country has been going downhill ever since the income tax was passed under the Marxist Woodrow Wilson, who didn't like the Constitution almost as much Obama.

Taking from success to reward dependency will ultimately bankrupt America. we've accumulated, under Democrats and progressive Republicans 10's of trillions of dollars in unfunded liabilities.

We've got about 4 years to straighten this all out. I won't be straightened out because all one party knows how to do is spend money in vast amounts that there is simply no way to ever pay for it all, and all the other party knows how to do is cower in fear from the Democrats and the media accusing them of 'starving the poor,' every time one of them has enough balls to tackle the problem.

Yes, the phrase "baffle folks with bullsh*t" comes to mind. All this "marginal utility of income" and "redistributing income up" and "fiscal multipliers" and "lack of demand" is just cover for Marxist economic philosophy. It can't stand on its own as it has been proven to fail again and again and again in the real world. So they make up convoluted economic theories to "prove" that despite its repeated failures in actual real life, it's not because the economics doesn't work - after all, they can "prove" it works in the laboratory (where no actual people get in the way of these "brilliant" concepts).
 
You gotta love the left. "Marginal Utility Falloffs" BWAHAHAHAHAHA.

Sorry bub, you can take those Marginal Utility Falloffs and stick 'em where the sun don't shine.

GREAT lets make tax policy by ignoring Economics... that's... like building a car while ignoring how motors and transmissions work.

No amount of blather can change the fact, that under a flat tax with no deductions, a person that earns 10 times as much pays 10 times as much.
so what? Earning 10 times as much reduces the pain of a 10% tax BY MORE THAN ten. Since taxes are a 'shared suffering", "fairness" is the equalization of the PAIN, not the pure $$ amount.

And a consumption tax is the ideal tax for a free citizenry. Call it regressive if you want to, but the simple fact is that with a consumption tax, everybody pays taxes.
And this is where building a car without knowing how motors work gets you in trouble. This statement simply is not true. Because you can only tax DOMESTIC production this way. So if I buy a Lincoln Navigator fo $60k I pay VAT on $60k. If I buy a BMW X6 for $60k, I pay vat on $10k. And if I fly to europe, drive my BMW for 6 mos in Europe, I PAY ZERO VAT

Now ignoring whether a tax is regresive or not is like ignoring whether an engine has wide torque band and runs on most fuels vs. an engine that requires Nitromethane to run and only produces torque at between 6,000 and 7,000 RPM. If you design cars ONLY with F1 engines in them, most cars will be useless. Same with a tax policy. If your taxes hit the Job Creating Middle Class the hardest, you will destroy the middle class

And without the middle class

  • You don't have a democracy
  • you don't have job creation

Well done, your TAX POLICY just turned us into Venezueala.

[/quote]This country has been going downhill ever since the income tax was passed under the Marxist Woodrow Wilson,[/quote]
Right.... being the first to put a Man on the Moon was so downhill. Particularly since Russia, Germany and France were more advanced than us at that time with bigger per capita economies.

Taking from success to reward dependency will ultimately bankrupt America
So why do you want to bankrupt the middle class? The middle class is the ultimate success model. and yet you want to transfer wealth from them. Why?

We've got about 4 years to straighten this all out.
RIGHT.. and then what?
 
Ok. So how would you design the brackets?
Econometrically. Look I can give you a table like the hypotehtical one below, but I don't have the team of econometricians that the CBO or OMB Has. but the goal should be to essentially have a tax rate curve that approximates the Marginal Utility of Income Curve.

Becasue despite the continual arguements about how "the xame percentage is Fair" ... in every Behavioural Econ study where this has been looked at, the vast majority of subjects HAVE AN INHERENT SENSE OF MARGINAL UTILITY... This even applies down to primates (even though some of the experiments were tainted by cheating the researcher did in other studies).

Put 3 chimps in cages together in a room. And delay one feeding by a few hours. Then come in and give one Chimp 10 bannanas, another chimp 4 and the last chimp nothing. the Chimp with 10 will give the chimp with none 2-3 bannanas and the chimp with 4 will give him 1. That's Marginal Uitility of Income in play RIGHT THERE.

Its also FISCALLY the smart thing to do. The Fiscal Multiplier for spending by the lowest Quintile approachs 3.0. So every $1 you take from them Reduces GDP growth by $3.00 and thats about the top end of what Government FMs are

The Fiscal Multiplier for spending by the upper quintile IS BELOW 0.7. So every $1 you take from them Reduces GDP Growth by only 70 cents. And that's EASY for the Government to DOUBLE.



As for "job creation"... CALPERS which is mostly middle class participants, is One Pension Plan, in One Industry in One State. And yet it has MORE INVESTED IN JOB CREATION than the 10 wealthiest Americans... COMBINED. You hear a lot about "institutional investors" "driving the market"... well "Institutional Investors" are the pros who are investing MIDDLE CLASS PENSIONS. THEY ARE THE JOB CREATORS. So again, transferring wealth out of the middle class REDUCES JOB GROWTH.

So what we need is a progressive income tax system that takes into consideration the Laffer Curve and what we know about Marginal Utility of Income (which is quite a lot BTW)
Well the Laffer Curve PEAKS at 70% Marginal Rates sccording to the WSJ. We know that Marginal Utility drops to as low as 1% over $1 mil/yr in income... but we also know that when tax rates exceed 90%, you see capital flight out of the economy.

So you have to be pragmatic. Top marginal rate is 70% and the rest is curved based on Marginal Utility of Income - I've made a wild guestimate based on hiustorical tax rates, but its hardly the real starting point. For that you'd have to dig into OMB and CBO data at a level that I don't have time for.



Laffer.jpg

$0-$10k = 0% tax
$10k-$15k = 5% tax
$15k-$20k = 7% Tax
$20k-$30k = 10% tax
$30k-$40k = 15% tax
$40k-$50k = 25% tax
$50k-$70k = 35% tax
$70k-$100k = 40% Tax
$100k-$150k = 50% Tax
$150k-$200k = 60% Tax
$200k-$350k = 65% Tax
$350k+ = 70% Tax
 
Funny aside as to this redwing obsession with forcing those at the economic bottom, to pay federal income taxes...If we were to insist on their paying federal income taxes, that tax wouldn't fall to them. It would fall to the "job creators", who would have to raise wages to cover the tax.

Ronald Reagan "got it". Ronald Reagan's dead and forgotten (by the redwing).
 
Back
Top