New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Second Amendment

Well, that's the most blatantly wrong statement I've read in a while... but I like that you commit to a position. LOL

If it's so "blatantly wrong" - tell me - who ya gonna call if someone sneaks up behind you, bops you on the head, and steals your gun?
 
Do I know who it was? (We are speaking hypothetically, right?)

This is an overarching philospophical question, so you don't "get" to narrow and define the terms! But, let's say it was five masked guys, all twice your size and each is armed to the teeth with a Bushmaster, a Glock, and a K-Bar.
 
This is an overarching philospophical question, so you don't "get" to narrow and define the terms! But, let's say it was five masked guys, all twice your size and each is armed to the teeth with a Bushmaster, a Glock, and a K-Bar.

Ok, but if they have all that why are they stealing my gun? (Although, my 1911 is a pretty sweet piece) And why didn't they just shoot me and take it? And if they're sneaking up behind me, what's all the masks for? Would I recognize them? How'd they know I had a gun?

Get's silly quick, don't it? :D
 
No, you're trying to make it sound silly, in a failed effort at supporting your original misapprehension. My challenge isn't silly, simply because you're not comprehending it. Or...perhaps you DO know that the right answer is some iteration of "I'd call the police", but you know that if you gave that answer, you'd shoot a big-assed hole in your "blatantly wrong"!
 
No, you're trying to make it sound silly, in a failed effort at supporting your original misapprehension. My challenge isn't silly, simply because you're not comprehending it. Or...perhaps you DO know that the right answer is some iteration of "I'd call the police", but you know that if you gave that answer, you'd shoot a big-assed hole in your "blatantly wrong"!

Honestly, if I knew who did it, I'd go and get my gun back. Some things a man does himself...
 
The "I'd get it back myself" angle is rote and intellectually pathetic. I'd have more respect for yo, had you acknowledged the question and admitted that you'd prefer to stick with your own feelings.
 
Yes or no...

Does the 2nd amendment apply to the right of INDIVIDUALS to own guns for their protection? Regardless of any militia affiliation?

Yes or no, does the 2nd amendment make background checks illegal for sales between individuals....
 
The "I'd get it back myself" angle is rote and intellectually pathetic. I'd have more respect for yo, had you acknowledged the question and admitted that you'd prefer to stick with your own feelings.

Fair enough; I did make light of the question. It's a difficult one to answer because there are so many factors that we aren't addressing. That's why I dodged... Well, that, and the fact that it's usually not a good idea to discuss felonies on the internet. :D
 
Individuals in service to "the common defense" are the ones that must maintain a right as individuals to keep and bear arms in order to fulfill their duty and service to "the common defense". If one is not in service or duty to "the common defense" there is no relation to any right for them to keep and bear arms or "weapons in common use". for that purpose.

"in common use" refers to what use?

Except that there is no link between the common defense and my individual right to my own arms.
 
The supreme court has ruled both ways on the matter. In 1939 they ruled that the 2nd amendment did not grant a right to own weapons that would not be effective for use by a militia....

Now they've ruled that the 2nd has nothing at all to do with membership in a militia.

I'll go with what they decide, because my opinion is meaningless. I am not arguing in favor of banning or confiscating guns.

Now, answer my question....
 
The supreme court has ruled both ways on the matter. In 1939 they ruled that the 2nd amendment did not grant a right to own weapons that would not be effective for use by a militia....

Now they've ruled that the 2nd has nothing at all to do with membership in a militia.

Wrong on both counts. Weapons can be restricted if they're not suitable for use in a militia. The individual right to weapons is not linked to the militia -- two different rulings on two different subjects. The Miller case is silent on the individual right to keep and bear arms.

I'll go with what they decide, because my opinion is meaningless. I am not arguing in favor of banning or confiscating guns.

Well, not all of them anyway, right?
 
Honestly, if I knew who did it, I'd go and get my gun back. Some things a man does himself...

He's not much of a man if he gets on a public forum and tells blatant lies about what other posters SUPPOSEDLY said without backing it up. INTERNET BULLIES are a dime a dozen.
 
1. There are reasonable limits on the types of guns available for civilian ownership. We have already gone back and forth about whether or not there should be no limits....I don't think there has been an intelligent conversation about guns that shouldn't be available for sale today. Streetsweepers, Mac-10, any gun that can easily be converted to full auto....
2. I've never posted anything supporting confiscation of firearms.

Weapons can be restricted if they're not suitable for use in a militia

And I wrote "the 2nd doesn't grant the right to have a gun not suitable for the militia".....and you think I'm wrong?

And no, I haven't posted anything in support of confiscating guns.
 
Back
Top