New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The solution to abortion.

Boltlady

Governor
Too many people seem to have no idea at all of the devastation an unwanted pregnancy can cause in a woman's life. Since I'm not big on killing things, I think that adoption is the best answer. The problem as I see though is too many people insist on waiting too long for that to happen.

The law seems to be looking at the 'mother' and the life she is carrying as two separate entities. So be it. The 'mother' should have the full rights to her own body as a separate entity and if she doesn't wish to accept the responsibility for developing another, she shouldn't have to. The answer is really quite simple.

The doctor should extract the life within her without killing it. Then it could be put into a petrie dish or something similar depending on what stage it has achieved. If others are then able to keep it alive, it becomes their responsibility as they have adopted it. If it was meant to become another person then it will. If not, it won't make it. That way nobody has killed it.

BTW there have already been some interesting experiments done in keeping cells alive.

http://www.alexchiu.com/bulletin/messages/219.html
 
Fact is, we all die eventually.

If your idea were taken to it's extreme, then we would soon be rescuing an egg a month from every woman in menses and gathering up the output of youthful boys' masturbation so that no potential human life would be "wasted".

An embryo is a part of a woman's body. If it offends her, then she should pluck it out, as recommended in Matthew 18:9.
 
I think too that a more sensible and practical conversation should be had about how many children we have entering our overflowing societies.
There are so many confliction messages being thrown at us all the time.
for eg When a 'Star' has a baby it is 'sexy' when a poor single girl down the street has a baby it's 'a shame' who is to say which of the two will be the better and most loving mother ? and ect
I was sent to a mother and baby home when I was pregnant with my daughter ( 60's) I saw the agonies of those women giving up their babies because 'society' demanded they should.
We all, I think, need to start being realistic, practical about the issue ( no pun intended ) as you are being Boltlady but this idea I see going horribly wrong and being exploited even horror storyish.

I agree that it takes to long to have unwanted babies adopted now a days though. I know of a 'crack baby' who because it had to go through the courts and who should have been because her Ma didn't want her adopted soon after birth, it took until the little thing was two years old, she was in foster care until then ............ On the other hand the SS take some children from parents without real cause and have them adopted. The whole thing is a mess. You are right it all needs re evaluating.

Birth control education though should be more than simply practical shouldn't it ? Shouldn't it take in all that which makes our need to create new life ? And if we are not to create new life what do we replace that need within us, with ?
 
Fact is, we all die eventually.

If your idea were taken to it's extreme, then we would soon be rescuing an egg a month from every woman in menses and gathering up the output of youthful boys' masturbation so that no potential human life would be "wasted".

An embryo is a part of a woman's body. If it offends her, then she should pluck it out, as recommended in Matthew 18:9.

Since I am not a follower of scriptures, I have no idea of what "Matthew 18:9" recommends, but that embryo is only a part of that woman's body as a parasite.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100610065758AAn7st0

Personally, I'm very much in favor of the 'morning after' pill. That way nothing gets started if you don't want it to.
 
Queen, you said: "Birth control education though should be more than simply practical shouldn't it ? Shouldn't it take in all that which makes our need to create new life ? And if we are not to create new life what do we replace that need within us, with ?"

To me, if a woman doesn't want to have her own children but feels a need to add to the quality of life for the children that others choose to have, there are many service industries that are not only available, but needed. She could become a part of one or more of them.
 
But Boltlady the biggest problem is with those who are ruled more by emotions or rather by their natural needs being stronger than by whats best on a practical or societal ( is there such a word ?) level and not by thinking whats best. And it begins with the young does it not ?
 
Technology may change the debate, mostly for the "pro-lifers".

What happens when it becomes possible to remove the embryo or fetus...and freeze it, without destroying it, and it is still capable of being re-implanted into another woman's womb and fully festating...or even re-implanting back into the same women, months even years later.

Will they argue AGAINST such a procedure? They couldn't with their current rationale. Nothing is "killed".
 
of course adoption is the best answer. but women want to choose after the time to choose has passed. sex is a choice (incest/rape exception mongrels relax...yes yes there should be an exception). maybe a little responsibility - and women have more to bear than a man does since they ultimately bear the consequence; blame mother nature - pre conception is prefereable to trading one life for another, after
 
Fact is, we all die eventually.

If your idea were taken to it's extreme, then we would soon be rescuing an egg a month from every woman in menses and gathering up the output of youthful boys' masturbation so that no potential human life would be "wasted".

An embryo is a part of a woman's body. If it offends her, then she should pluck it out, as recommended in Matthew 18:9.

bring on euthenasia
 
But Boltlady the biggest problem is with those who are ruled more by emotions or rather by their natural needs being stronger than by whats best on a practical or societal ( is there such a word ?) level and not by thinking whats best. And it begins with the young does it not ?

Well Queen, I do have some experience in all of this. Like you, my 1st was born out of wedlock in 1961. That pretty much made me frowned upon by 'society' and led me into an incredibly bad marriage. He was raised catholic and was quite happy that we had 3 more children for a total of 4. That was great of course until the marriage became so intolerable that it ended in a VERY messy divorce. He then chose not to pay the support for those children and I spent 10 years of my life scrambling and scraping to feed, clothe and keep a roof over their heads. I had to do that after not having been able to develop any sort of career or even friends. We were married for 13 years and in that time we moved 10 times, often 1000s of miles away from the last place. I really had to live by my wits.

It would be great if I was able to say that the kids all turned out fine, but they didn't. They were all terribly scarred by an erratic upbringing and the horrible struggles that went on through the marriage and then the depravation that followed. That led them to drugs and alcohol and those battles are still being fought.

I really took my responsibilities as a parent very seriously and tried very hard for things to be different but I was up against some terrible odds. It would have been better if I had known to make different choices.
 
That would then come up against the other major teaching of the church which is that we should not interfere with contraception. Thus why no BC. You can use natural methods to determine and plan around your fertile periods. But, you should not use condoms, withdrawal, ABC, etc in order to prevent contraception. This is also why the church does not endorse IVF.
 
There actually is already a practice referred to as "snowflake" adoption. Where people will put embryos created via IVF up for adoption and a woman can choose to be implanted with those embryos. So, this would sort of be along those lines.
 
Well Queen, I do have some experience in all of this. Like you, my 1st was born out of wedlock in 1961. That pretty much made me frowned upon by 'society' and led me into an incredibly bad marriage. He was raised catholic and was quite happy that we had 3 more children for a total of 4. That was great of course until the marriage became so intolerable that it ended in a VERY messy divorce. He then chose not to pay the support for those children and I spent 10 years of my life scrambling and scraping to feed, clothe and keep a roof over their heads. I had to do that after not having been able to develop any sort of career or even friends. We were married for 13 years and in that time we moved 10 times, often 1000s of miles away from the last place. I really had to live by my wits.

It would be great if I was able to say that the kids all turned out fine, but they didn't. They were all terribly scarred by an erratic upbringing and the horrible struggles that went on through the marriage and then the depravation that followed. That led them to drugs and alcohol and those battles are still being fought.

I really took my responsibilities as a parent very seriously and tried very hard for things to be different but I was up against some terrible odds. It would have been better if I had known to make different choices.

To some of that ditto, I never did the marrage bit though :) And with sorrow two of my three were aborted.

Our priorities have been wrong haven't they and we carry them on and on and on putting plasters on huge weeping wounds. Children are our love ...............priority number one? As in 'our' meaning our society/tribe, well it should be and would e if we stopped for a min and really thought about where we were going instead of blindly stumbling forward always onward down the same rocky path, the bed of thorns which we bring our precious jewels into.
 
I am pro abortion on demand.

After all, the people who would even consider having an abortion aren't the kind of people we want raising kids anyways.

As for adoption? There are already too many kids with no future who will never get adopted. Why add to that pool?
 
Sounds to me like you want to put the idea behind "The Handmaiden's Tale" into an actual policy. How very republicon of you.
 
Really? Women who want to have an abortion because they already have more kids than they can afford shouldn't have kids? Ass backwards.
 
how many pro abortionists also endorse the death penalty?

Here's one! The problem with the death penalty is that we don't use it enough. I think all those child molestors should be injected and left to die not to mention rapists, murderers,cop killers, and crooked politicians.
 
That would then come up against the other major teaching of the church which is that we should not interfere with contraception. Thus why no BC. You can use natural methods to determine and plan around your fertile periods. But, you should not use condoms, withdrawal, ABC, etc in order to prevent contraception. This is also why the church does not endorse IVF.

But that wouldn't be interfering with conception. Once you've got a zygote, or a fetus, you're already past the point of conception. This would be preventing abortion.
 
Back
Top