New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Things are going pretty well.

Arkady

President
Perhaps the key difference between a conservative and a progressive is the perception of society's direction. If you think society is mostly in decline, then you are going to want to try to return to how things were done in the past, or at least you'll be very cautious about agreeing to new innovations, for fear that they will accelerate the slide. If you think society is mostly improving, then you are going to be reluctant to restore old ways of doing things, and you'll be fairly aggressive about implementing modernized approaches.

So, it shouldn't be surprising that conservative media tends to be so gloomy. Depicting a world in turmoil and attributing that to well-meaning innovations gone wrong is good conservative propaganda. The essential conservative news story is some variation on "what's the matter with kids these days?!"

If you take a step back and look at just about any measurable indicator, it doesn't support the notion of general decline, either in the US or globally. For example, in the US, the following things are true:

(1) Real per capita GDP has never been higher.
(2) Murder rates are nearly to record lows (since reliable data started being collected, at the start of the 20th century, murder rates were only lower than today for a few years in the 40s and 50s).
(3) High school dropout rates are at record lows and high school graduation rates at record highs. The percentage of Americans with college educations has never been higher.
(4) Life expectancy has never been higher.
(5) Productivity has never been higher.
(6) Teen pregnancy rates have never been lower.
(7) Median real household income isn't at a record, but it's only a few percentage points off the record, and higher than in any year prior to 1995.
(8) Inflation is extremely low and budget deficits have declined by over half in recent years.
(9) Household debt service payments are as low as they've ever been as a percent of disposable income, going back at least to 1980, where the data series starts.
(10) Economic growth cycles have become very long since the New Deal, while recessions have grown far less frequent and generally less lengthy and severe.

It's not just in the US that things are going pretty well. Earth as a whole has seen a huge rise in real GDP per capita, a fall in murder rates, a spike in education levels, surging productivity, lengthening lifespan, etc. We are also living through what is very likely the most peaceful time in all of human history, or at the very least the most peaceful time since the era of the Pax Romana during the height of the Roman Empire. Almost any measurable way you can think of to assess the average quality of life, globally, is going to show a big long-run improvement. There are some exceptions, but even those tend to be a mixed bag, rather than uniformly bad (e.g., global warming and CO2 pollution increases continue unabated, but we've made good progress on many other pollutants, especially in developed countries).

I think that once you see how things have generally been getting better over time, the idea of further progress is less scary. And I think that's why conservative propagandists focus so much on individual incidents that show problems. They want to create the perception that things are getting worse, because that favors the conservative policy approach. And they're very good at creating the perception, despite the facts. Polls will show the majority of Americans thinking all sorts of things have been getting worse, even when they're measurably getting much better.

An illustration of the power of a few well-publicized incidents to confuse people about the facts is the late-90s scare about school-house violence (following Columbine). 72% of poll respondents believed that juvenile crime was on the increase, at a time when it had actually fallen an astounding 56% in just five years!

http://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/school_house_hype.pdf

Kids faced less than half as much risk as they had just a few years earlier, but a large majority of people believed things were getting worse. In the face of the hype, the news that things have actually been getting so much better is hard for people to wrap their heads around. But the facts are out there.
 
Last edited:
And I think that's why conservative propagandists focus so much on individual incidents that show problems.

  • Ferguson to attempt to show massive racism in Police
  • The Confederate Flag to attempt to define racism in our DNA.
  • Trayvon Martin to attempt to show racism in hispanic-white people
  • Wedding Cakes for Gay Couples to attempt to illustrate homophobia in those who don't celebrate it.
  • Drawing Mohammad to attempt to reveal islamophobia
  • Asteroid Probe operators in Girl-laden shirts to attempt to display sexism.
There's been tons of instances were "individual incidents" have been used to show problems lately by fueling only irrational emotion... and it hasn't been by Conservatives.
 
  • Ferguson to attempt to show massive racism in Police
  • The Confederate Flag to attempt to define racism in our DNA.
  • Trayvon Martin to attempt to show racism in hispanic-white people
  • Wedding Cakes for Gay Couples to attempt to illustrate homophobia in those who don't celebrate it.
  • Drawing Mohammad to attempt to reveal islamophobia
  • Asteroid Probe operators in Girl-laden shirts to attempt to display sexism.
There's been tons of instances were "individual incidents" have been used to show problems lately by fueling only irrational emotion... and it hasn't been by Conservatives.
To be clear, I'm not talking about using individual instances to display the existence of a problem. I'm talking about using them to push a narrative of a growing problem, in the face of clear data indicating that the problem is actually shrinking.... for example, pushing the idea that our schools have been getting worse, in the face of data showing falling dropout rates, rising test scores, and declining school-house violence.
 
To be clear, I'm not talking about using individual instances to display the existence of a problem. I'm talking about using them to push a narrative of a growing problem,
You don't think the narrative of the Ferguson debacle was to promote that White racist police forces is an epidemic???

My goodness, if you believed the media coverage, you'd probably assume that there's a dead black person on every street corner, with a white officer standing over them, one foot atop the carcus, posing for a photograph.


in the face of clear data indicating that the problem is actually shrinking.... for example, pushing the idea that our schools have been getting worse, in the face of data showing falling dropout rates, rising test scores, and declining school-house violence.

Well, it's easy to get rising test scores when you make the classes easier, which is what they've done.

There's even race-based standards in some areas. White students have to perform better than a black students to receive the same grade.

Meanwhile, even after making the high school standards easier, test scores have remained flat. It's safe to say our high school kids are generationally become less intelligent.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/05/07/naep-2013-high-school_n_5276767.html
 
Perhaps the key difference between a conservative and a progressive is the perception of society's direction. If you think society is mostly in decline, then you are going to want to try to return to how things were done in the past, or at least you'll be very cautious about agreeing to new innovations, for fear that they will accelerate the slide. If you think society is mostly improving, then you are going to be reluctant to restore old ways of doing things, and you'll be fairly aggressive about implementing modernized approaches.

So, it shouldn't be surprising that conservative media tends to be so gloomy. Depicting a world in turmoil and attributing that to well-meaning innovations gone wrong is good conservative propaganda. The essential conservative news story is some variation on "what's the matter with kids these days?!"

If you take a step back and look at just about any measurable indicator, it doesn't support the notion of general decline, either in the US or globally. For example, in the US, the following things are true:

(1) Real per capita GDP has never been higher.
(2) Murder rates are nearly to record lows (since reliable data started being collected, at the start of the 20th century, murder rates were only lower than today for a few years in the 40s and 50s).
(3) High school dropout rates are at record lows and high school graduation rates at record highs. The percentage of Americans with college educations has never been higher.
(4) Life expectancy has never been higher.
(5) Productivity has never been higher.
(6) Teen pregnancy rates have never been lower.
(7) Median real household income isn't at a record, but it's only a few percentage points off the record, and higher than in any year prior to 1995.
(8) Inflation is extremely low and budget deficits have declined by over half in recent years.
(9) Household debt service payments are as low as they've ever been as a percent of disposable income, going back at least to 1980, where the data series starts.
(10) Economic growth cycles have become very long since the New Deal, while recessions have grown far less frequent and generally less lengthy and severe.

It's not just in the US that things are going pretty well. Earth as a whole has seen a huge rise in real GDP per capita, a fall in murder rates, a spike in education levels, surging productivity, lengthening lifespan, etc. We are also living through what is very likely the most peaceful time in all of human history, or at the very least the most peaceful time since the era of the Pax Romana during the height of the Roman Empire. Almost any measurable way you can think of to assess the average quality of life, globally, is going to show a big long-run improvement. There are some exceptions, but even those tend to be a mixed bag, rather than uniformly bad (e.g., global warming and CO2 pollution increases continue unabated, but we've made good progress on many other pollutants, especially in developed countries).

I think that once you see how things have generally been getting better over time, the idea of further progress is less scary. And I think that's why conservative propagandists focus so much on individual incidents that show problems. They want to create the perception that things are getting worse, because that favors the conservative policy approach. And they're very good at creating the perception, despite the facts. Polls will show the majority of Americans thinking all sorts of things have been getting worse, even when they're measurably getting much better.

An illustration of the power of a few well-publicized incidents to confuse people about the facts is the late-90s scare about school-house violence (following Columbine). 72% of poll respondents believed that juvenile crime was on the increase, at a time when it had actually fallen an astounding 56% in just five years!

http://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/school_house_hype.pdf

Kids faced less than half as much risk as they had just a few years earlier, but a large majority of people believed things were getting worse. In the face of the hype, the news that things have actually been getting so much better is hard for people to wrap their heads around. But the facts are out there.

One question:

If things are soooo peachy... so wonderful.... better than EVER before...

THEN WHY THE HELL DO PROGRESSIVES KEEP WANTING TO CHANGE THEM?

For instance... according to you, murder rates are way down. If that is so, why keep screwing around with the 2nd Amendment? All.the.time? Constantly, without letup?

#3: If dropout rates are at an all-time low and graduation rates at an all-time high, why confuse the kids with "new math" and "common core"? Why not stick with the tried-and-true? Also... have you ever considered that much of this "all-time high graduation rate" may be due to the fact that many schools have simply lowered the bar? Have you dealt with government employees who can't speak properly, and who don't know a damn thing about their jobs as soon as a question deviates from their script? Have you, lately, received a letter or e-mail that's chock full of grammatical and spelling errors? These people should be back in 4th grade, not "graduated" from high school.

College enrollment may be at an all-time high, but that's largely due to the fact that it's practically free for many, and being a student is a lot more "fun" for many than working at a job would be. We've had these "students-for-life" in Germany ever since I can remember. Whoopee do.

#9: Have you ever considered that maybe household debt is at an all-time low, again according to you, because many middle class and lower middle class people have lost their homes (therefore not having to pay the mortgage anymore), and either live with relatives, roommates, or on the street? I'm sure the 44,000 homeless people in L.A. don't have much debt, that's true... nor do the 8,000 or so in Boston.

You need to get out more and see how "the other half" lives, methinks...
 
Perhaps the key difference between a conservative and a progressive is the perception of society's direction. If you think society is mostly in decline, then you are going to want to try to return to how things were done in the past, or at least you'll be very cautious about agreeing to new innovations, for fear that they will accelerate the slide. If you think society is mostly improving, then you are going to be reluctant to restore old ways of doing things, and you'll be fairly aggressive about implementing modernized approaches.

So, it shouldn't be surprising that conservative media tends to be so gloomy. Depicting a world in turmoil and attributing that to well-meaning innovations gone wrong is good conservative propaganda. The essential conservative news story is some variation on "what's the matter with kids these days?!"

If you take a step back and look at just about any measurable indicator, it doesn't support the notion of general decline, either in the US or globally. For example, in the US, the following things are true:

(1) Real per capita GDP has never been higher.
(2) Murder rates are nearly to record lows (since reliable data started being collected, at the start of the 20th century, murder rates were only lower than today for a few years in the 40s and 50s).
(3) High school dropout rates are at record lows and high school graduation rates at record highs. The percentage of Americans with college educations has never been higher.
(4) Life expectancy has never been higher.
(5) Productivity has never been higher.
(6) Teen pregnancy rates have never been lower.
(7) Median real household income isn't at a record, but it's only a few percentage points off the record, and higher than in any year prior to 1995.
(8) Inflation is extremely low and budget deficits have declined by over half in recent years.
(9) Household debt service payments are as low as they've ever been as a percent of disposable income, going back at least to 1980, where the data series starts.
(10) Economic growth cycles have become very long since the New Deal, while recessions have grown far less frequent and generally less lengthy and severe.

It's not just in the US that things are going pretty well. Earth as a whole has seen a huge rise in real GDP per capita, a fall in murder rates, a spike in education levels, surging productivity, lengthening lifespan, etc. We are also living through what is very likely the most peaceful time in all of human history, or at the very least the most peaceful time since the era of the Pax Romana during the height of the Roman Empire. Almost any measurable way you can think of to assess the average quality of life, globally, is going to show a big long-run improvement. There are some exceptions, but even those tend to be a mixed bag, rather than uniformly bad (e.g., global warming and CO2 pollution increases continue unabated, but we've made good progress on many other pollutants, especially in developed countries).

I think that once you see how things have generally been getting better over time, the idea of further progress is less scary. And I think that's why conservative propagandists focus so much on individual incidents that show problems. They want to create the perception that things are getting worse, because that favors the conservative policy approach. And they're very good at creating the perception, despite the facts. Polls will show the majority of Americans thinking all sorts of things have been getting worse, even when they're measurably getting much better.

An illustration of the power of a few well-publicized incidents to confuse people about the facts is the late-90s scare about school-house violence (following Columbine). 72% of poll respondents believed that juvenile crime was on the increase, at a time when it had actually fallen an astounding 56% in just five years!

http://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/school_house_hype.pdf

Kids faced less than half as much risk as they had just a few years earlier, but a large majority of people believed things were getting worse. In the face of the hype, the news that things have actually been getting so much better is hard for people to wrap their heads around. But the facts are out there.


good to know gun crime has been dropping for decades...but then,,i already knew this...someone should tell the liberals...
 
You don't think the narrative of the Ferguson debacle was to promote that White racist police forces is an epidemic???

I think most people on that side would admit police were at least as racist in the 1930s or 1950s, etc. so, I don't think it was about pushing a notion of social decline, much less doing so in the face of overwhelming evidence of improvement, but rather about highlighting the continuing seriousness of a problem.

Well, it's easy to get rising test scores when you make the classes easier, which is what they've done.

The NAEP scores are standardized and have nothing to do with how easy or hard a class is.

There's even race-based standards in some areas. White students have to perform better than a black students to receive the same grade.

Where? Evidence?

Meanwhile, even after making the high school standards easier, test scores have remained flat.

Test scores are rising for the lower grades and flat for the upper grades. This is because drop out rates have fallen. So, in the lower grades, where the dropout rate is insignificant, the tests reflect improving education, while in the upper grades, where we're testing low performing students who in earlier generations would have dropped out and not been tested, we're merely holding steady.

Think about it. If you test the top 70% of one group and the top 80% of another group and the average scores are the same, isn't that a pretty strong signal that the second group is doing better, as a whole, than the first? Despite having less elite members tested, they're still performing just as well as a group.

It's safe to say our high school kids are generationally become less intelligent.
. The drafting of that sentence notwithstanding, what evidence do you see for that?
 
I hate the way liberals like the top poster constantly try to blow smoke up my ass....I'm not a moron, I can read and I know better than what he's trying to sell me.
If you have a substantive critique, offer it. But if this is just a situation where the facts are at odds with your emotional assumptions, don't blame me.
 
THEN WHY THE HELL DO PROGRESSIVES KEEP WANTING TO CHANGE THEM?

When modernizing changes result in improvement, then doesn't it make sense to pursue more modernizing changes? Try to think of it in a less emotional context. Say you're a car engineer and you propose some changes for the traditional internal combustion engine -- say, electronic fuel injection in place of a carburetor. And say this results in the best horsepower and fuel efficiency performance in history. Do you now say "perfect, don't change anything ever again." Or do you point to the success of that change to argue for the idea that still more improvements can come with additional innovation? Today's cars are vastly better than those 100 years ago because generations of inventors never stopped tinkering, and today's society, likewise, is better than society 100 years ago because generations of liberals never stopped tinkering.

Also... have you ever considered that much of this "all-time high graduation rate" may be due to the fact that many schools have simply lowered the bar?

Yes. I considered and rejected it. If that were the case, we'd expect NAEP scores to have fallen, thanks to less rigorous education. That hasn't happened.

#9: Have you ever considered that maybe household debt is at an all-time low, again according to you, because many middle class and lower middle class people have lost their homes (therefore not having to pay the mortgage anymore), and either live with relatives, roommates, or on the street?
. It's not just according to me. The official data confirms. If you'd like a link, I'd be happy to provide.

As for your alternate theory, it leads to yet another item of improvement: the astonishing decline of homelessness in America:

http://www.theatlantic.com/business...ng-decline-of-homelessness-in-america/279050/
 
When modernizing changes result in improvement, then doesn't it make sense to pursue more modernizing changes? Try to think of it in a less emotional context. Say you're a car engineer and you propose some changes for the traditional internal combustion engine -- say, electronic fuel injection in place of a carburetor. And say this results in the best horsepower and fuel efficiency performance in history. Do you now say "perfect, don't change anything ever again." Or do you point to the success of that change to argue for the idea that still more improvements can come with additional innovation? Today's cars are vastly better than those 100 years ago because generations of inventors never stopped tinkering, and today's society, likewise, is better than society 100 years ago because generations of liberals never stopped tinkering.



Yes. I considered and rejected it. If that were the case, we'd expect NAEP scores to have fallen, thanks to less rigorous education. That hasn't happened.

. It's not just according to me. The official data confirms. If you'd like a link, I'd be happy to provide.

As for your alternate theory, it leads to yet another item of improvement: the astonishing decline of homelessness in America:

http://www.theatlantic.com/business...ng-decline-of-homelessness-in-america/279050/

You ignore what you don't like, don't you? For instance:
Have you dealt with government employees who can't speak properly, and who don't know a damn thing about their jobs as soon as a question deviates from their script? Have you, lately, received a letter or e-mail that's chock full of grammatical and spelling errors? These people should be back in 4th grade, not "graduated" from high school.

These are NOT exceptions... they're the rule. Don't try to tell ME our kids are getting smarter... they're not. At least not your average student who gets pushed through schools and is allowed to graduate just to improve "The Numbers".

How about
College enrollment may be at an all-time high, but that's largely due to the fact that it's practically free for many, and being a student is a lot more "fun" for many than working at a job would be. We've had these "students-for-life" in Germany ever since I can remember. Whoopee do.
Nothing on that?

And how about THIS reality:
Have you ever considered that maybe household debt is at an all-time low, again according to you, because many middle class and lower middle class people have lost their homes (therefore not having to pay the mortgage anymore), and either live with relatives, roommates, or on the street?
Many people I know lost their homes and lightened their "debt load" considerably... some of them are renting a cheap apartment, some of them have moved in with their children/parents/other relatives, and some of them share an apartment with strangers. BUT YEAH... a smaller "debt load". Congratulations.

Then there's this:

The number of homeless children in the U.S. has surged in recent years to an all-time high, amounting to one child in every 30, according to a comprehensive state-by-state report that blames the nation's high poverty rate, the lack of affordable housing and the impacts of pervasive domestic violence.Titled "America's Youngest Outcasts," the report being issued Monday by the National Center on Family Homelessness calculates that nearly 2.5 million American children were homeless at some point in 2013.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/11/17/child-homelessless-us_n_6169994.html

The number of homeless students in the United States reached a record high during the 2012-13 school year, according to the latest data from the U.S. Department of Education.

The report released Monday shows that homeless children enrolled in public preschool and grades K-12 jumped 8 percent from the previous school year to hit 1,258,182.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/09/23/homeless-students_n_5864414.html
 
Yes, of course. You are absolutely correct. And the people see it and back you up 100%:

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/other/direction_of_country-902.html

Oops!

As is par for your course you cherry pick a few stats, tell some half truths and wrap the whole thing in a very misleading narrative. The facts:

A) GDP is a misleading indicator which rewards growth of government, and even with that advantage, the Obama Administration has had to institute double counting of intellectual property to get it as high as it is. Real, private sector GDP is likely still below the levels reached in the late 90s. And we are needing about $3 of debt to produce each additional $1 of GDP since the recession.

B) The murder rate is an artifact of the demographics. As the population became younger (like when the baby boomers hit their young adulthood) the murder rate increased. As it is now aging, the murder rate is down. Presto changeo - don't look at what's happening behind the curtain.

C) The drop out rate is down largely due to the "success" of the "learning support" system for kids with learning disabilities. I have first hand knowledge of this as my son has learning disabilities. He graduated but his educational level is probably 10th grade at best. The learning support staff did the work for him. But he has a good work ethic and has always held a job (only two different employers over the past eight years). How many of the inner city kids that are "graduating" with 9th or 10th grade education levels have the work ethic that will enable them to find and keep jobs without any skills? Look at the youth unemployment rate for your answer (hint: not very many).

D) Life expectancy has never been higher and it is being achieved through very expensive end of life care where the old folks spend their last three, five, seven years or so in nursing homes on the taxpayers' dime. This is not sustainable as the baby boomers are getting ready to hit their 70s.

E) Productivity has never been higher, but its growth rate has never been lower:

Screen Shot 2015-06-25 at 8.38.25 AM.png
And in fact, as anyone can see, has been declining (and is now negative).

F) Teen pregnancy is down due to increased use of contraceptives. Yay - you got one right!

G) Median real income is, as you say, down. But the really bad news is that it has never recovered since the recession:

Screen Shot 2015-06-25 at 8.43.47 AM.png
And the reason for this is the decline in economic opportunity during the Obama years. And, of course, puts the lie to your claim that the decline in Labor Force Participation Rate is strictly due to "demographics." As anyone with a rudimentary understanding of math can figure out, if that were the case the median incomes would be recovering as younger workers moved into the higher paying jobs being vacated by "retiring" baby boomers.

H) Inflation as measured by BLS is low, but try telling that to the average American consumer:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/americans-reallocate-their-dollars-1417476499

As the cost of rent, food, energy, education and health care have all been on a relentless rise. Which conveniently doesn't show up in overall inflation as measured by BLS.

Budget deficit has declined, but is set to head back up even under the consistently too rosy growth scenarios as used by the CBO:

Screen Shot 2015-06-25 at 8.59.44 AM.png
And, of course, as the debt load grows, the economy slows - this is abjectly unsustainable.

I) Debt "service" payments are low because the Fed has engineered extremely low (i.e. ZIRP) interest rates in response to the ongoing Obama depression. Debt levels to personal income ratios are still above where they were when we last had a real economic growth story in play:

Screen Shot 2015-06-25 at 9.03.46 AM.png

And so, as interest rates normalize, the picture becomes worse.

J) The business cycle - seriously, there has been no recovery since the Bush recession. The real world is suffering through the Obama depression. GDP growth rate for the US has all but disappeared:

Screen Shot 2015-04-20 at 1.23.40 PM.png
The business cycle has been held at bay by the permanent recession, kept marginally above negative growth by unprecedented Fed policy actions and growth of government spending. This is not the picture of a real, actual, yes we can feel it recovery.

And you sir, are an unrepentant propagandist who has just been exposed. Anyone who can uncover the facts behind your misleading narrative will instantly recognize the need to run screaming from the progressive economic agenda and back to levels of government spending and regulation that we had under Clinton, which is when we last had a real economic recovery.
 
Perhaps the key difference between a conservative and a progressive is the perception of society's direction. If you think society is mostly in decline, then you are going to want to try to return to how things were done in the past, or at least you'll be very cautious about agreeing to new innovations, for fear that they will accelerate the slide. If you think society is mostly improving, then you are going to be reluctant to restore old ways of doing things, and you'll be fairly aggressive about implementing modernized approaches.

So, it shouldn't be surprising that conservative media tends to be so gloomy. Depicting a world in turmoil and attributing that to well-meaning innovations gone wrong is good conservative propaganda. The essential conservative news story is some variation on "what's the matter with kids these days?!"

If you take a step back and look at just about any measurable indicator, it doesn't support the notion of general decline, either in the US or globally. For example, in the US, the following things are true:

(1) Real per capita GDP has never been higher.
(2) Murder rates are nearly to record lows (since reliable data started being collected, at the start of the 20th century, murder rates were only lower than today for a few years in the 40s and 50s).
(3) High school dropout rates are at record lows and high school graduation rates at record highs. The percentage of Americans with college educations has never been higher.
(4) Life expectancy has never been higher.
(5) Productivity has never been higher.
(6) Teen pregnancy rates have never been lower.
(7) Median real household income isn't at a record, but it's only a few percentage points off the record, and higher than in any year prior to 1995.
(8) Inflation is extremely low and budget deficits have declined by over half in recent years.
(9) Household debt service payments are as low as they've ever been as a percent of disposable income, going back at least to 1980, where the data series starts.
(10) Economic growth cycles have become very long since the New Deal, while recessions have grown far less frequent and generally less lengthy and severe.

It's not just in the US that things are going pretty well. Earth as a whole has seen a huge rise in real GDP per capita, a fall in murder rates, a spike in education levels, surging productivity, lengthening lifespan, etc. We are also living through what is very likely the most peaceful time in all of human history, or at the very least the most peaceful time since the era of the Pax Romana during the height of the Roman Empire. Almost any measurable way you can think of to assess the average quality of life, globally, is going to show a big long-run improvement. There are some exceptions, but even those tend to be a mixed bag, rather than uniformly bad (e.g., global warming and CO2 pollution increases continue unabated, but we've made good progress on many other pollutants, especially in developed countries).

I think that once you see how things have generally been getting better over time, the idea of further progress is less scary. And I think that's why conservative propagandists focus so much on individual incidents that show problems. They want to create the perception that things are getting worse, because that favors the conservative policy approach. And they're very good at creating the perception, despite the facts. Polls will show the majority of Americans thinking all sorts of things have been getting worse, even when they're measurably getting much better.

An illustration of the power of a few well-publicized incidents to confuse people about the facts is the late-90s scare about school-house violence (following Columbine). 72% of poll respondents believed that juvenile crime was on the increase, at a time when it had actually fallen an astounding 56% in just five years!

http://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/school_house_hype.pdf

Kids faced less than half as much risk as they had just a few years earlier, but a large majority of people believed things were getting worse. In the face of the hype, the news that things have actually been getting so much better is hard for people to wrap their heads around. But the facts are out there.
http://market-ticker.org/akcs-www?post=230269
 
STOP RIGHT THERE !!!!

Your very first point is a massive deception. "GDP per captita" has nothing to do with the living standards of workers. GDP is simply the sum total of the goods and services sold by American companies.

The fact that the revenue of goods sold is MUCH higher than the average household income is a sign of concern, not celebration.

It reinforces all the criticism levelled at the Obama administration for the past 6 years. We are becoming a nation of part time workers; workers without benefits; "on call" workers; Uber drivers, people on welfare, and people who have given up looking for work and are not even counted as unemployed any more.

I think its wonderful (for GM) that the average price of pickup truck has gone up about $10,000 in (inflation adjusted) real terms over the past decade. But that doesn't actually help workers or consumers.

Same story with pricey iPhones, $4,000 UHD 4K televisions, and $600 manolo blahnik pumps. Goods priced so that only the well to do can afford them might result in a surging GDP, but food stamp use is still at record levels.

Anyone who thinks these are the best of times is either an idiot, or liar.
 
I can't quite decide which is true of the top poster. His posts are nothing but constant, unfailing propaganda for the current administration... what does that make him?

there are many who, when they find themselves neck deep in horseshit, struggle desperately to find the pony underneath...

and others who find themselves in simular positions who simply seek a way out of the manure pile...
 
I can't quite decide which is true of the top poster. His posts are nothing but constant, unfailing propaganda for the current administration... what does that make him?

i dont think he's an idiot. he cherry picks statistics that only give one side of the picture.

i continue to naively believe that criticizing both parties when they hurt our nation is more logical and effective than continually backing a loser, no matter how bad things get.

one approach is evidence based. the other is partisan politics at its worst.

you decide
 
Back
Top