Arkady
President
Perhaps the key difference between a conservative and a progressive is the perception of society's direction. If you think society is mostly in decline, then you are going to want to try to return to how things were done in the past, or at least you'll be very cautious about agreeing to new innovations, for fear that they will accelerate the slide. If you think society is mostly improving, then you are going to be reluctant to restore old ways of doing things, and you'll be fairly aggressive about implementing modernized approaches.
So, it shouldn't be surprising that conservative media tends to be so gloomy. Depicting a world in turmoil and attributing that to well-meaning innovations gone wrong is good conservative propaganda. The essential conservative news story is some variation on "what's the matter with kids these days?!"
If you take a step back and look at just about any measurable indicator, it doesn't support the notion of general decline, either in the US or globally. For example, in the US, the following things are true:
(1) Real per capita GDP has never been higher.
(2) Murder rates are nearly to record lows (since reliable data started being collected, at the start of the 20th century, murder rates were only lower than today for a few years in the 40s and 50s).
(3) High school dropout rates are at record lows and high school graduation rates at record highs. The percentage of Americans with college educations has never been higher.
(4) Life expectancy has never been higher.
(5) Productivity has never been higher.
(6) Teen pregnancy rates have never been lower.
(7) Median real household income isn't at a record, but it's only a few percentage points off the record, and higher than in any year prior to 1995.
(8) Inflation is extremely low and budget deficits have declined by over half in recent years.
(9) Household debt service payments are as low as they've ever been as a percent of disposable income, going back at least to 1980, where the data series starts.
(10) Economic growth cycles have become very long since the New Deal, while recessions have grown far less frequent and generally less lengthy and severe.
It's not just in the US that things are going pretty well. Earth as a whole has seen a huge rise in real GDP per capita, a fall in murder rates, a spike in education levels, surging productivity, lengthening lifespan, etc. We are also living through what is very likely the most peaceful time in all of human history, or at the very least the most peaceful time since the era of the Pax Romana during the height of the Roman Empire. Almost any measurable way you can think of to assess the average quality of life, globally, is going to show a big long-run improvement. There are some exceptions, but even those tend to be a mixed bag, rather than uniformly bad (e.g., global warming and CO2 pollution increases continue unabated, but we've made good progress on many other pollutants, especially in developed countries).
I think that once you see how things have generally been getting better over time, the idea of further progress is less scary. And I think that's why conservative propagandists focus so much on individual incidents that show problems. They want to create the perception that things are getting worse, because that favors the conservative policy approach. And they're very good at creating the perception, despite the facts. Polls will show the majority of Americans thinking all sorts of things have been getting worse, even when they're measurably getting much better.
An illustration of the power of a few well-publicized incidents to confuse people about the facts is the late-90s scare about school-house violence (following Columbine). 72% of poll respondents believed that juvenile crime was on the increase, at a time when it had actually fallen an astounding 56% in just five years!
http://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/school_house_hype.pdf
Kids faced less than half as much risk as they had just a few years earlier, but a large majority of people believed things were getting worse. In the face of the hype, the news that things have actually been getting so much better is hard for people to wrap their heads around. But the facts are out there.
So, it shouldn't be surprising that conservative media tends to be so gloomy. Depicting a world in turmoil and attributing that to well-meaning innovations gone wrong is good conservative propaganda. The essential conservative news story is some variation on "what's the matter with kids these days?!"
If you take a step back and look at just about any measurable indicator, it doesn't support the notion of general decline, either in the US or globally. For example, in the US, the following things are true:
(1) Real per capita GDP has never been higher.
(2) Murder rates are nearly to record lows (since reliable data started being collected, at the start of the 20th century, murder rates were only lower than today for a few years in the 40s and 50s).
(3) High school dropout rates are at record lows and high school graduation rates at record highs. The percentage of Americans with college educations has never been higher.
(4) Life expectancy has never been higher.
(5) Productivity has never been higher.
(6) Teen pregnancy rates have never been lower.
(7) Median real household income isn't at a record, but it's only a few percentage points off the record, and higher than in any year prior to 1995.
(8) Inflation is extremely low and budget deficits have declined by over half in recent years.
(9) Household debt service payments are as low as they've ever been as a percent of disposable income, going back at least to 1980, where the data series starts.
(10) Economic growth cycles have become very long since the New Deal, while recessions have grown far less frequent and generally less lengthy and severe.
It's not just in the US that things are going pretty well. Earth as a whole has seen a huge rise in real GDP per capita, a fall in murder rates, a spike in education levels, surging productivity, lengthening lifespan, etc. We are also living through what is very likely the most peaceful time in all of human history, or at the very least the most peaceful time since the era of the Pax Romana during the height of the Roman Empire. Almost any measurable way you can think of to assess the average quality of life, globally, is going to show a big long-run improvement. There are some exceptions, but even those tend to be a mixed bag, rather than uniformly bad (e.g., global warming and CO2 pollution increases continue unabated, but we've made good progress on many other pollutants, especially in developed countries).
I think that once you see how things have generally been getting better over time, the idea of further progress is less scary. And I think that's why conservative propagandists focus so much on individual incidents that show problems. They want to create the perception that things are getting worse, because that favors the conservative policy approach. And they're very good at creating the perception, despite the facts. Polls will show the majority of Americans thinking all sorts of things have been getting worse, even when they're measurably getting much better.
An illustration of the power of a few well-publicized incidents to confuse people about the facts is the late-90s scare about school-house violence (following Columbine). 72% of poll respondents believed that juvenile crime was on the increase, at a time when it had actually fallen an astounding 56% in just five years!
http://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/school_house_hype.pdf
Kids faced less than half as much risk as they had just a few years earlier, but a large majority of people believed things were getting worse. In the face of the hype, the news that things have actually been getting so much better is hard for people to wrap their heads around. But the facts are out there.
Last edited:




