New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

This says it all...

Chief Justice Roberts wrote that the words must be understood as part of a larger statutory plan. “In this instance,” he wrote, “the context and structure of the act compel us to depart from what would otherwise be the most natural reading of the pertinent statutory phrase.

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/26/us/obamacare-supreme-court.html?_r=0


America has ceased to exist thanks to SCOTUS. It quite clearly started when SCOTUS decided the results in the Florida election and picked George Bush as president.

I believe as an institution SCOTUS is no longer a viable and among many reasons should lead states to exercise their rights to plebiscite to exit the union.
 
Wow, that language is so telling. The fact that he is openly saying - that he read it with his eye on the political fall out and the larger policy - is honestly an abdication of his duties. He is supposed to read it - based on the Constitution. and make decisions - unpopular as they may be based on that .
 
Wow, that language is so telling. The fact that he is openly saying - that he read it with his eye on the political fall out and the larger policy - is honestly an abdication of his duties. He is supposed to read it - based on the Constitution. and make decisions - unpopular as they may be based on that .
This was Mister Baseball Umpire who was only going to call the pitches straight up as I recall. I could be wrong.
 
Wow, that language is so telling. The fact that he is openly saying - that he read it with his eye on the political fall out and the larger policy - is honestly an abdication of his duties. He is supposed to read it - based on the Constitution. and make decisions - unpopular as they may be based on that .
What he said was that the 4 words should be viewed in context and not as 4 words isolated from the rest of the act.
 
scotus didn't "decide the florida election".

they simply declined to allow Gore to petition for multiple recounts, in the districts he was losing, and no other districts. i believe the majority opinion was something along the lines of: "there is no right to recurring, mulitple vote recount until you finally get one you find to your liking"
 
What he said was that the 4 words should be viewed in context and not as 4 words isolated from the rest of the act.

yeah.. the "context and structure of the act".... i.e. the context of what it was trying to accomplish, versus a literal reading and a "departure from a natural reading of the pertinent phrase"...i.e what their job is. When a literal reading of the phrase needs context - it is actually supposed to go back to the legislature to FIX the law.


connie
 
yeah.. the "context and structure of the act".... i.e. the context of what it was trying to accomplish, versus a literal reading and a "departure from a natural reading of the pertinent phrase"...i.e what their job is. When a literal reading of the phrase needs context - it is actually supposed to go back to the legislature to FIX the law.


connie
I disagree as did 6 SCOTUS Justices.
 
I disagree as did 6 SCOTUS Justices.

Yes, they did, for political expediency. Which he is admitting in those quotes. They should be ashamed of themselves quite honestly. They admitted their disgusting lack of adherence to their job.
 
scotus didn't "decide the florida election".

they simply declined to allow Gore to petition for multiple recounts, in the districts he was losing, and no other districts. i believe the majority opinion was something along the lines of: "there is no right to recurring, mulitple vote recount until you finally get one you find to your liking"

Wrong.

That was the job of the FLORIDA Supreme Court not SCOTUS.
 
Back
Top