New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ticket to hell??

Yes, I understand that Gordon. I think I discussed that in my long post. Sometimes I have to circle the airport a couple of times to illustrate the point.

ETA, if you look into purification.....you'll see this in the Bible.

What's your answer then, gigi....why didn't God CLEARLY and DIRECTLY say there was a "Purgatory" in the Bible? "Heaven" and "Hell" are so noted...why did such a place miss open mentioning...and required the cryptography team in Rome to "discover" it?
 
and how about those unbaptized babies? the Church used to say they were stuck in Limbo, which is closer to the gates of Hell than the gates of Heaven, but now they're not so sure.

Oh, and how OLD can a kid get to be, and be unbaptized, and still get thrown in Limbo? A year old...two years old....four?
 
Where did I say God lied? THe Bible does say that a young faith is not ready for all of the doctrines and teachings that will be revealed in times to come. That included confession and purgatory and other dogmatic teachings. So what? I do not follow your big protest?

Do you have a problem with Jesus establishing one church, one hierarchy to be thee authority here on earth, or do you insist that any man can believe as he wishes?

Do you want all of the Scripture passages that this authority, the Catholic Church, has translated as a reference to purgatory, or will you not give them that authority even though JEsus did?

Do you demand God reveal all He needs to reveal on your time schedule or can it be more to his liking? Have you not noticed how the faith has changed with the cultures over 2000 years?

Why do you demand that God be crystal clear in every aspect of what is written? Can there be no good reason for teaching in parables? When he says we prophecy by "peering through a glass darkly" does that make you reject it all? Does God have to have the mentality of a human being in order to be legitimate or can he retain some mystery and superior understandings?

There is no contradiction between Rome and God on purgatory or any other doctrine for that matter. Just because Jesus did not tell his apostles they might go to purgatory means absolutely nothing in refuting its existence. Would you like for me to spell out ten different passages from the Bible that I maintain, and the Catholic Church maintains in most of the same instances, that refer to purgatory?

Why is this even considered a fallacy? Just because I speculated for the reasons God did not come real clear on purgatory in Scripture does not imply he did not want it taught or revealed in a more authoritative fashion through his church at a later time. Jesus did not tell his disciples to pray to Mary or pray the rosary either. ARe you now saying because the Catholic Church does teach the importance of that we are contradiciting God once again?

Like I said -- you nibble away at some aspect of the faith but totally ignore the greater truths and core dogmas that are evidenced and defended in many ways.
 
JV...let's go back and look at what you said-

Originally Posted by GordonGecko
JV-12, why is it there are CLEAR, DIRECT references to "Heaven" and "Hell" in the Bible....but we have to "de-code" passages to find "Purgatory"?


JV-12: "Because it is obvious to me that if God made it clear that purgatory was a place of mercy for those who are lukewarm, careless and selfish, then the nature of man would be to do "just enough" to get in. It would stifle good works and God's work. Most strive for heaven or strive to avoid hell which is far more noble than just being lazy about it."

Ergo, God DELIBERATELY left Puragatory un-clear and un-direct so as to make sure the "lukewarm, careless, selfish" wouldn't get slack.

Okay...let's accept that. So along comes the Roman Catholic Church and "de-codes" what God was "really saying" about Purgatory....what it was, that it was real, and starts PROCLAIMING IT LOUDLY around the world for nearly 2000 years.

Suddenly God's plan to keep it "subtle" even "hidden" from those lazy, careless, and selfish slackers....is shot to hell. (pun intended)

Now YOUR Church has suddenly "outed" what God wanted kept "vague" in the Bible....and by extension of YOUR reasoning as to why He kept it "vague"...

the Catholic Church just made it EASIER on the lazy, careless, and selfish "to do "just enough" to get in" and "stifle good works and God's work."

Or are you hoping people will NOT believe the RCC about "Purgatory" so as to keep God's initial plan for it unrevealed as He intended?!?!?!?
 
JV...let's go back and look at what you said-

Originally Posted by GordonGecko
JV-12, why is it there are CLEAR, DIRECT references to "Heaven" and "Hell" in the Bible....but we have to "de-code" passages to find "Purgatory"?


JV-12: "Because it is obvious to me that if God made it clear that purgatory was a place of mercy for those who are lukewarm, careless and selfish, then the nature of man would be to do "just enough" to get in. It would stifle good works and God's work. Most strive for heaven or strive to avoid hell which is far more noble than just being lazy about it."

Ergo, God DELIBERATELY left Puragatory un-clear and un-direct so as to make sure the "lukewarm, careless, selfish" wouldn't get slack.

Okay...let's accept that. So along comes the Roman Catholic Church and "de-codes" what God was "really saying" about Purgatory....what it was, that it was real, and starts PROCLAIMING IT LOUDLY around the world for nearly 2000 years.

Suddenly God's plan to keep it "subtle" even "hidden" from those lazy, careless, and selfish slackers....is shot to hell. (pun intended)

Now YOUR Church has suddenly "outed" what God wanted kept "vague" in the Bible....and by extension of YOUR reasoning as to why He kept it "vague"...

the Catholic Church just made it EASIER on the lazy, careless, and selfish "to do "just enough" to get in" and "stifle good works and God's work."

Or are you hoping people will NOT believe the RCC about "Purgatory" so as to keep God's initial plan for it unrevealed as He intended?!?!?!?


That's right Gordon... all in God's appointed time. You know Jesus came to earth and died around 30 AD. And by so doing made it easier for the lazy, careless and selfish to get to heaven, too.

But you cannot buy into anything the Church teaches. You have this foregone wish that Christianity, especially Catholicism, is a fraud and you set out to prove that in the most "weak" ways as far as I am concerned. You do not care how much evidence there is for it, you do not care how much sense it makes ---- your salient quest is to find those nuggets that cause doubt in some peoples' minds. And as long as you can point to that and ignore the 1000 lb. lion in the room, you can act as though you are onto something.

I explained to you higher above in this thread much of what you repeat here once again. Why did you not just address all my comments or questions right there? Why do you avoid a lot of germane questions I pose?

Why do you deny the supernatural even though it is all around you? How can you cling to a godless world and a godless evolution and feel good about your "logic" or your future?

If you read an honest history of the Church you might be amazed how many supernatural manifestations have taken place via the many canonized saints and what God revealed to them at that appointed time to edify Church teachings. Purgatory would be one of them. Of course every person who was visited by a soul from purgatory (and there have many credible testimonies) are liars. God is just a sadistic prankster, and that's all you can figure out.
 
That's right Gordon... all in God's appointed time. You know Jesus came to earth and died around 30 AD. And by so doing made it easier for the lazy, careless and selfish to get to heaven, too.

But you cannot buy into anything the Church teaches. You have this foregone wish that Christianity, especially Catholicism, is a fraud and you set out to prove that in the most "weak" ways as far as I am concerned. You do not care how much evidence there is for it, you do not care how much sense it makes ---- your salient quest is to find those nuggets that cause doubt in some peoples' minds. And as long as you can point to that and ignore the 1000 lb. lion in the room, you can act as though you are onto something.

I explained to you higher above in this thread much of what you repeat here once again. Why did you not just address all my comments or questions right there? Why do you avoid a lot of germane questions I pose?

Why do you deny the supernatural even though it is all around you? How can you cling to a godless world and a godless evolution and feel good about your "logic" or your future?

If you read an honest history of the Church you might be amazed how many supernatural manifestations have taken place via the many canonized saints and what God revealed to them at that appointed time to edify Church teachings. Purgatory would be one of them. Of course every person who was visited by a soul from purgatory (and there have many credible testimonies) are liars. God is just a sadistic prankster, and that's all you can figure out.

Nothing you just said.....explains away the illogic.
 
Nothing you just said.....explains away the illogic.

What's interesting is that often we see people, including non-Christians, (maybe especially non-Christians) use teaching and principles from the Bible to manufacture hypocrisy in the conservative viewpoint. When it's an argument about public services in the way of financial assistance, people will eagerly go through Scripture and find what they need to interpet the meaning they want to create. And they'll come up with all these arguments for why Jesus would support OWS, or be a fan of public assistance, just from the words He DID speak. But Jesus never mentioned OWS. He never mentioned government assistance. But you won't hear these people that ascribe certain points of view to Jesus complaining that Jesus never actually spoke the specific words "protest" and "welfare".
And then again, when it comes to abortion, many of the same people will spin right around and say "Nowhere in the Bible can you find the word 'abortion'".

Clearly, when it suits these people, they'll interpret and derive an understanding from the Word. When it suits them, they'll depend on the literal Word.

And atheists who want to argue with believers will often complain about both approaches and cite both for explanation of their disbelief. It just depends on who they're arguing against. If they're arguing against more fundamental literalist beliefs, they'll complain about how harsh and unforgiving God is for not having mercy on the person who doesn't know Him. If they're arguing against Catholics, what they'll do, as is illustrated here, is fight against our belief in God's mercy for the person ignorant of Him. And when they can't quite make God out to be that hard case, they'll move the argument. Now that they can't make that case for how unsympathetic God is, it's about either He's a liar or the Church has it wrong and God really is that hard case they talk about elsewhere.

Gordon, the need for purification before entering the Kingdom is discussed throughout the Bible. If JV's got the patience to go look up the Verse numbers for you, God bless him/her. Personally, I think it's futile. I don't think you're interested in learning anything about what a faith you purport to curious about believes. I'm more inclined to agree with JV about your quest for what you feel you can turn inside out. But if you're really curious, you are capable of doing the research yourself. Is the word " Purgatory" in the Bible? You know what? I really don't know. Is the place of the dead and necessity for what goes on in Purgatory discussed in the Bible? Absolutely.


You also have to be careful. If you're not comfortable with poking fun at and criticizing the "irrationality" of Judaism, you might want to rethink and verify some of the things you claim about Catholicism. Purgatory and indulgences are just two of our beliefs that originate with Judaism. Jesus doesn't deny these. His coming changes them. And maybe before we make ignorant comments about indulgences, we might want to look into what they actually are and how they're "purchased". They most certainly are "transferable".
 
I liked your comments Gigi, and I agree with you. No, I do not think Gordon really does have a willing ear to hear the truth. I believe he has an agenda and ignores those questions that are hard to address, or the evidence that is hard to deny.

I will be glad to provide Scripture references for purgatory, there are many, at a later date. I am less inclined to try to explain to Gordon or anyone else why Jesus did not come out and preach hard about purgatory, nor am I inclined to keep addressing his postulation that the Catholic Church violated God's wishes by making the truth of it more evident.
 
I liked your comments Gigi, and I agree with you. No, I do not think Gordon really does have a willing ear to hear the truth. I believe he has an agenda and ignores those questions that are hard to address, or the evidence that is hard to deny.

I will be glad to provide Scripture references for purgatory, there are many, at a later date. I am less inclined to try to explain to Gordon or anyone else why Jesus did not come out and preach hard about purgatory, nor am I inclined to keep addressing his postulation that the Catholic Church violated God's wishes by making the truth of it more evident.

Thanks, JV. I think some of the things that some Christians and definitely many of the atheists have a hard time with is the fact that Jesus, in His infinite wisdom, chose the men who would build His Church and teach us about Him, about the Kingdom, about our responsibilities, etc...put that doctrine up for us, and that He Himself has guided and inspired all of Church teaching. He didn't die and defeat death so we could be misled and therefore doomed for 2000 years.
The next thing that's troublesome to many is that He continues to teach us Himself. Through the experiences of the saints, through allowing His mother to appear and instruct and warn us. Contrary to what people like to say, our faith is Biblical. But instruction and practice doesn't end there because God has not ended His instruction there. He has continued to instruct and command things since. But, all of those things He continues to reveal and remind us of can still be traced back to the Book, to what we know from the Book, to be true about Him.


Fulton Sheen said "There are a hundred people in the world who hate Catholicism. But there are 100 million who hate what they think is Catholicism." And that's largely due to distortions that began very deliberately. The malice may be greatly diluted now, but the misconceptions are still very much alive.
 
My "agenda"...is truth and LOGIC. Your statement that God "didn't want Purgatory known CLEARLY (in the Bible) so that people wouldn't 'get slack'"....I accepted.

I then asked the next logical question....if God wanted it kept un-clear...isn't the Roman Catholic Church going AGAINST God by not only revealing it, but promoting the idea???

You can't answer that...at all. And the absolute HYPOCRISY of YOU attacking ME for "ignoring questions that are hard to answer" is stunning!!!

And as we have known for a long time, dating back to The Fray, when that happens....you insult the person asking the question you have no answer for.
 
You can believe in any philosopher that ever existed but don't introduce the notion that a belief based upon super natural beings is somehow a rational course of action, it is purely irrational at its core. There is nothing to keep anyone from using religion as a foundational system to navigate life without buying into the paranormal aspects of imaginary and unprovable Gods. Every single Atheist I know would gladly accept God for being a real entity if there was any proof supporting it that could stand the test of a rational inquiry. All you have to do is prove it and you will get almost universal acceptance by most of humanity. Until you do, you will have to rely upon faith which is no different than believing you can fly simply because you had a dream once that you could fly.
 
You can believe in any philosopher that ever existed but don't introduce the notion that a belief based upon super natural beings is somehow a rational course of action, it is purely irrational at its core. There is nothing to keep anyone from using religion as a foundational system to navigate life without buying into the paranormal aspects of imaginary and unprovable Gods. Every single Atheist I know would gladly accept God for being a real entity if there was any proof supporting it that could stand the test of a rational inquiry. All you have to do is prove it and you will get almost universal acceptance by most of humanity. Until you do, you will have to rely upon faith which is no different than believing you can fly simply because you had a dream once that you could fly.


Faith and experience.

That's the thing. You experience God's love when you're open to it. You still get it when you're not, but you don't recognize it when you're not open to it. But when you open the door, God definitely comes through it and let's you know He has.

Elsewhere, God has definitely proven Himself through His Son, and through others since. But these are dismissed as
censored.gif
censored.gif
censored.gif
censored.gif
censored.gif
delusions or conspiracies. Really what else would you want God to do? He shows you something. People write it all down.Documentation is made. Proof of the authenticity of the documents at least is made. The stories are corroborated by both believers and non believers. He's done nothing less then making the sun touch the earth in the presence of thousands of people, many who were there simply to disprove his existence, and still that's not proof enough. There's probably nothing God could do that people wouldn't dismiss as either never having happened, or as mass hysteria.

I don't know why that word got censored. It's simply booky with a k.
Is that normal?
 
a mentally deranged unemployed carpenter comes along and claims to be the son of a god and you call that proof?? lol.
 
John 14:6
Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, and the truth, and the life: no one cometh unto the Father, but by me.

This only means that Jesus is the sole judge, it does not mean that only true Christians make it.


im saying this interpretation is nonsense.
 
Back
Top