New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ticket to hell??

Amen.

You gotta reject Christ, He will not reject you.

Jesus is about getting people into Heaven and Salvation, not denying them Heaven and Salvation.
 
That is not a position that can be justified by the Bible. If what you say is true, then there was never any need for a Paschal Lamb. According to the Bible, all of us are condemned at birth by the inherited original sin of Adam and Eve.

You have invented your own religion - one that is in harmony with your personal feelings. There is nothing inherently wrong with that, but it is dishonest to call it "Christianity".

Sure it's Biblical, NightSwimmer. And it's VaticanII Catholic teaching. I didn't invent that.
 
ill settle for any answer

Gabe, the most common answer I've heard is that he visited them the three days he was dead.

My church, The Church of the Lackadaisical Unicorn, teaches that while he was dead he travel up through Mexico and when he got to Texas said, "This is surely hell, so I'll tell them who I am." (Nothing personal, Gramps, everyone has to live somewhere!)
 
Yes it is. Check out your Catechism and you also might want to look at the salvation section in Catholic Answers to Fundamentalist Questions".

There's plenty to read on the topic in both.

I never said that your position couldn't be justified by the Roman Catholic Church - I only said that it could not be justified by the Bible.

Baptism of the dead can be justified by the Book of Mormon, but not by the Bible.

That said, Biblical justification alone certainly doesn't prove veracity. It merely represents consistency.
 
I never said that your position couldn't be justified by the Roman Catholic Church - I only said that it could not be justified by the Bible.

Baptism of the dead can be justified by the Book of Mormon, but not by the Bible.

That said, Biblical justification alone certainly doesn't prove veracity. It merely represents consistency.

Yes you did say that it couldnt' be justified by the RC Church. I told you it was VaticanII teaching and you said "No, it isn't."

And we believe it can be justified by the Bible. You can't look for the single Line in Scripture. You have to look at the story of Who the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are throughout the Bible. You have to understand that God knows the hearts of each man and the individual journey he takes in ways that we don't. Very big parts of our faith are our belief about intention, and the Mercy of God.
And if you are looking for a line in the Bible, I believe there is something in the Old Testament that states The believer will be punished more severely than the nonbeliever. In other words, if you know the law of God but don't follow it, you'll be punished more severely than the one who didn't know it.
 
I am sorry for the misunderstanding. I never meant to imply that you cannot justify non-Biblical beliefs via Catholic Church doctrine. You can most certainly do that.
 
I am sorry for the misunderstanding. I never meant to imply that you cannot justify non-Biblical beliefs via Catholic Church doctrine. You can most certainly do that.

But it has never been done.

Contrary to what some people, like yourself I guess, like to say and teach, our beliefs about God all come from the Bible....the whole Bible.


It's kind of ironic because on the one hand, people, particularly non believers, will become annoyed at the stark black and white, all or nothing way that they feel fundamentalists portray Jesus by quoting Scripture lines and insisting on literal acceptance. They complain that fundamentalist interpretation of the Bible doesn't make Christ a very compassionate and understanding Character. That it doesnt' justify those Christian laws that are universal throughout. Yet on the other hand, some, and again, it's particularly non-believers, will criticize faiths that interpret the Word, all of it, see it as one Word, and see God as the One who said ALL of what He did.


One example would be that Jesus never said to fast on Fridays. But Jesus talked about fasting and prayer. So the Church gives a directive to make Friday a day of fasting in order to impart the teaching of Christ to the faithful and help them to follow His teaching. And then there'll be people who will claim that Friday observance is a man made law.
 
All laws are man-made, but you are free to believe whatever you choose to believe. I have no particular animosity toward Roman Catholicism versus any other variation of Christianity.
 
That is not a position that can be justified by the Bible. If what you say is true, then there was never any need for a Paschal Lamb. According to the Bible, all of us are condemned at birth by the inherited original sin of Adam and Eve.

You have invented your own religion - one that is in harmony with your personal feelings. There is nothing inherently wrong with that, but it is dishonest to call it "Christianity".

I wrote this a few days ago and forgot about it. Probably will have the same effect whether I sent it or not?


NS – I believe the Bible is contradictory in many ways (ostensibly), but maybe for very good reasons. It does not want anyone to relax on their “select” knowledge of eternal truths. Yes, maybe you can get to heaven just based on faith, but then again, maybe you won’t. Yes, the unbelievers are at a real disadvantage, but then again, the believer is far more accountable for his mis-steps and the punishments could be far greater.

Note that nowhere in the Bible does Jesus instruct his apostles or disciples to write anything down for the final authority. He does oblige them to preach the good news to all corners of the world, for a very compelling reason, no doubt. So the Bible is not the be all and end all of God’s clear authority on all important matters, since it is subject to misinterpretation and misuse. The Church however is a more authenticated body, the one established by Christ, the one Peter is the head, the one that gave us the Bible, the one that sits in Rome with all its glory and all its sins. The one Jesus said “I give thee the keys of the kingdom” and “whatsoever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven.”

Going further” the Roman Catholic Church and various councils do not condemn any soul that was not exposed to Christian teaching. Quite the contrary. But it surely emphasizes evangelization for an immeasurable importance nonetheless. (consider the sufferings of purgatory for centuries, if those could be avoided one would then understand the virtue of becoming a more devout soul.) Neither do I see where the Bible “condemns” anyone for not being baptized, but even if it does I am perfectly comfortable with the apparent contradictions. Because it also says the following in reference to “non-followers” of Christ:

Acts 10:34-35
Opening his mouth, Peter said: "I most certainly understand now that God is not one to show partiality, but in every nation the man who fears Him and does what is right is welcome to Him.

Romans 2:14-15
“For when Gentiles who do not have the Law do instinctively the things of the Law, these, not having the Law, are a law to themselves, in that they show the work of the Law written in their hearts, their conscience bearing witness and their thoughts alternately accusing or else defending them”


Romans 5:12-13
Brothers and sisters: Through one man sin entered the world, and through sin, death, and thus death came to all men, inasmuch as all sinned --- for up to the time of the law, sin was in the world, though sin is not accounted when there is no law.


John 9:39-41
"I came into this world," said Jesus, "to judge men, that those who do not see may see, and that those who do see may become blind." These words were heard by those of the Pharisees who were present, and they asked Him, "Are *we* also blind?" "If you were blind," answered Jesus, "you would have no sin; but as a matter of fact you boast that you see. So your sin remains!"
 
Yes, there are contradictions in the Bible. There are even different versions of the Bible. There are also accepted Catholic doctrines that are extra-Biblical. Purgatory is one such example.

It is fine to believe that one may gain eternal life or enter into the Kingdom of Heaven without confessing Jesus as one's Saviour (the earliest known practitioners of Christianity had no knowledge of Jesus of Nazareth), but such a belief is in direct conflict with the most fundamental concept of modern Christianity - that the birth and subsequent sacrificial killing of Christ was a requirement for the salvation of mankind from the stain of original sin.

Romans 6:23
For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.

Isaiah 64:6
But we are all as an unclean thing, and all our righteousnesses are as filthy rags; and we all do fade as a leaf; and our iniquities, like the wind, have taken us away.

John 14:6
Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, and the truth, and the life: no one cometh unto the Father, but by me.

Personally, I'm all for making Heaven and eternal life available to everyone, but that is one of many reasons why I no longer call myself a Christian.
 
But it has never been done.

Contrary to what some people, like yourself I guess, like to say and teach, our beliefs about God all come from the Bible....the whole Bible.
Really? So the power of holy water comes from the bible?

And which bible btw? the pre-Nicean Creed books or the ones that hundreds of years after the death of the supposed christ, were redacted to eliminate the parts that didn't help the catholic church consolidate power?
 
Yes, there are contradictions in the Bible. There are even different versions of the Bible. There are also accepted Catholic doctrines that are extra-Biblical. Purgatory is one such example.

The reality of purgatory is very much found in Scripture in many passages, at least ten I could site and expound on.



It is fine to believe that one may gain eternal life or enter into the Kingdom of Heaven without confessing Jesus as one's Saviour (the earliest known practitioners of Christianity had no knowledge of Jesus of Nazareth), but such a belief is in direct conflict with the most fundamental concept of modern Christianity - that the birth and subsequent sacrificial killing of Christ was a requirement for the salvation of mankind from the stain of original sin.

Who is arguing against that? If Jesus did not become incarnate, suffer and die for our sins no one would be in heaven, ever. But that in no way guarantees any man a place in heaven, ask those in hell. Christ becomes the sole judge through which every man shall be judged. And those who think their belief alone, void of obedience or sincere care, are in for a shock. That is why God’s mercy is surely the most manifest in his gift of purgatory, else hell would be the only option (for most).



Isaiah 64:6
But we are all as an unclean thing, and all our righteousnesses are as filthy rags; and we all do fade as a leaf; and our iniquities, like the wind, have taken us away.


And through baptism we are made white as snow, but do we remain that way? No, we become defiled, but can be made clean again. For those who die with unrepented sin on their souls, they must be made pure in purgatory. Because Scripture also says “nothing defiled shall enter the kingdom of heaven.” It is obviously not talking of only those in hell, because that is a given they are beyond having any chance of entering.

John 14:6
Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, and the truth, and the life: no one cometh unto the Father, but by me.


This only means that Jesus is the sole judge, it does not mean that only true Christians make it.

Personally, I'm all for making Heaven and eternal life available to everyone, but that is one of many reasons why I no longer call myself a Christian.

Well you can check that one off your list for reasons not to believe because eternal life is available to everyone. Or are you demanding that God defile pure holiness and love by letting Hitler and Satan in, no matter how much they hate God?
 
Well you can check that one off your list for reasons not to believe because eternal life is available to everyone. Or are you demanding that God defile pure holiness and love by letting Hitler and Satan in, no matter how much they hate God?

Godwin's law dictates that this thread is dead. Maybe if we kill something and pour it's blood onto the thread, it will magically come back to life? I'm not holding my nephesh waiting for that to happen.
 
Godwin's law dictates that this thread is dead. Maybe if we kill something and pour it's blood onto the thread, it will magically come back to life? I'm not holding my nephesh waiting for that to happen.

That’s funny, never heard of it. :)

Oddly, I hesitated putting Hitler in their with satan because even Hitler cannot be judged by man, so the Catholic Church would never make a statement like I just did.

Using Hitler is highly unoriginal or lazy as well. Sometimes he tag teams off with Judas.
 
Back
Top