New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Trust me...

And you tell Knot you don't know where he/she is going. I have no idea what you're trying to say, unless maybe you're saying laws are made to be broken.
 
So you agree Native Americans were right to defend their land from the people that pushed them off of it and stole it from them?

Now wouldn't that be an interesting switch. I could go for some of that today even.
 
And you tell Knot you don't know where he/she is going. I have no idea what you're trying to say, unless maybe you're saying laws are made to be broken.
I'm saying that when this law doesn't have the effect you want it to, its expanded upon, and expanded upon, and this "loophole" needs to be closed, now this one... and there is never any end to it. The restrictions just continue; I get the impression that some of the folks who come up with this stuff want me to ask permission for everything, when the Government should be asking us for it.
 
We're supposed to be a civilized society, at least that is what we were told about European society. So why would any part of this society needs 'tools of war'? Is this just a continuation of the European need for superiority over the rest of mankind, the 'we get what we want because we can kill more efficiently'?
 
So you agree Native Americans were right to defend their land from the people that pushed them off of it and stole it from them?

Now wouldn't that be an interesting switch. I could go for some of that today even.
Not sure where we got on this subject, but yes, of course they were right to defend their lands. Wahbooz, do you know what he's trying to say?
 
We're supposed to be a civilized society, at least that is what we were told about European society. So why would any part of this society needs 'tools of war'? Is this just a continuation of the European need for superiority over the rest of mankind, the 'we get what we want because we can kill more efficiently'?
"Need?" Why must I justify my actions? I haven't hurt anyone...
 
I would assume that Knot is referring to the fact that Europeans created their own set of laws that simply stated that Europeans had the only right to determine land ownership. I believe it stemmed from the theory of Manifest Destiny, which was propagated by weapons.
 
What is the purpose of that 'action'? What would the purpose of the same 'action' taken by another person? You don't know, but if you open that hole in the dike, you leave that hole open for some NeoNazi like the one who was just arrested. He had a list of Jewish and Black leaders he intended to take down, and he openly declared war on his 'enemies'. How many more might follow that very same loophole?
 
What is the purpose of that 'action'? What would the purpose of the same 'action' taken by another person? You don't know, but if you open that hole in the dike, you leave that hole open for some NeoNazi like the one who was just arrested. He had a list of Jewish and Black leaders he intended to take down, and he openly declared war on his 'enemies'. How many more might follow that very same loophole?
So, the possibility that somebody, somewhere, might do something, justifies laws that won't prevent anything, but will force me to get permission to exercise my rights? No, thanks...
 
Then just maybe you make yourself a contributing factor in a war that takes place at some point in time. Perhaps you unwittingly make yourself a contributor to the neoNazi's war on American society.
 
Then just maybe you make yourself a contributing factor in a war that takes place at some point in time. Perhaps you unwittingly make yourself a contributor to the neoNazi's war on American society.
Come on... You don't get to lay blame for somebody else's actions at my feet; especially actions they haven't taken yet.
 
Hey, you guys seem to want to operate under the 'give me an inch, and I'll take a mile' philosophy. The sounds I'm hearing is 'I don't want anyone to take my handgun away from me', which is not what is being suggested, and pushing it to 'I also want the right to own a machine gun'.
 
Hey, you guys seem to want to operate under the 'give me an inch, and I'll take a mile' philosophy. The sounds I'm hearing is 'I don't want anyone to take my handgun away from me', which is not what is being suggested, and pushing it to 'I also want the right to own a machine gun'.
We do have the right to own a machine gun... you just have to jump through a lot of hoops to do it legally. BTW, what is being suggested? We wandered so far off the res I don't remember...
 
I suggest Bernard is suggesting 'where does it end?' Ok, so you perceive that you do have the right to own a machine gun, so what's next? Someone going to suggest they do have the right to own a flame thrower, or perhaps a tank killer? Hell, why not go all the way to an ICBM or a nuke. Hell the neighbor now has the right to own a machine gun, we now need something to counter that. Hell let's forget civilized society operating under a central government, and let's have every state warring with it's neighbor. Where does it end?
 
I suggest Bernard is suggesting 'where does it end?' Ok, so you perceive that you do have the right to own a machine gun, so what's next? Someone going to suggest they do have the right to own a flame thrower, or perhaps a tank killer? Hell, why not go all the way to an ICBM or a nuke. Hell the neighbor now has the right to own a machine gun, we now need something to counter that. Hell let's forget civilized society operating under a central government, and let's have every state warring with it's neighbor. Where does it end?
OK, forget the reductio ad absurdium nonsense about ICBMs and such. As to the rest, well are you at war with your neighbors now? Do you expect to be? No? Then why do you care what he has if there is no reason to think he wants to use it on you?
 
Well, maybe my neighbor's bad parenting is going to lead to their child becoming a serial killer in a couple decades, but we don't get to pre-emptively step-in until a crime is committed, or at least until there is evidence that there may be a crime in progress. Why does this thinking prevail on all the rights but the ones that concern guns?


You sound a bit confused, but very much subjective and selfish where the world is all about what you want, not about any consideration of the rights, desires or freedoms of anyone that wants something different than what you want.

With regard to guns, the mere possession of them under the premise of "self-defense" implies a pre-emptive use which is not without further scrutiny and involves an act with an implement designed specifically for effectiveness in killing or severe wounding. "Self-defense" is not simply something someone claims and that is the end of it, there must be a legal determination that any violent act that involves physical injury or death MUST be determined, without the shadow of doubt, to be defensive, for what should be obvious reasons. Otherwise, one could simply walk around popping off whomever they like and simply state they were doing it because they felt threatened by those they popped off. Kinda like a suggestion that killing over 100 thousand people with atomic bombs was a "defensive" move to "save" lives, nevermind the lives "saved" could never be proven nor would those killed in order to "save" lives nor their surviving loved ones necessarily wrap their heads around how killing 100 thousand plus men, women and children was "saving" lives or not acting in the same manner as those that were deemed to act offensively, but who's going to argue such a point with those who were the only possessors (and users) of such weaponry at the time?


The second amendment does not specifically mention "guns", it states "arms". Arms come in many shapes and forms and a "right" to "self defense" is not synonymous with a "right" to keep and bear arms. One may defend themselves in many ways with a variety of "arms" that do not include firearms or guns. the Second Amendment also clearly describes what is "necessary to the security of a free state" and it ain't the a "right of the people to keep an bear arms. It IS "a well-regulated Militia" and in 1792 all citizens (in those days the only recognized "citizens" were free white men) were legally obligated to enroll in, train with and supply their own arms to, "a well-regulated Militia". The purpose of this was not a personal self-defense, but a common defense, as stated and charged in the Preamble of the Constitution of the United States. "A well regulated Militia" was the founders solution to their skepticism and fear of standing militaries populated by professional soldiers with a singular loyalty. They felt that "a well regulated Militia" of every state populated by the citizens of those states, would be less subject to a singular loyalty and the "soldiers" would not be professional, but soldiers trained in warlike fighting who did not spend full time as soldiers. Based on this set up, it would not make practical sense for either the federal or local state role of well-regulated Militia to leave a window open for any state to restrict the keeping and bearing of arms by those obligated under law to not just be enrolled in and train with a well regulated Militia, but to furnish their own arms to it. It would be like your state or local laws requiring you to have smoke, fire and CO alarms in your home, without making sure you had access to their purchase.

Now, there is no legal requirement for all able bodied citizens between any ages to enroll in, train with or furnish their own arms to, a well-regulated Militia (that which is "necessary to the security of a free state", thus without more specific definition in the 2nd Amendment, there is nothing to specify what types of arms are defined or not defined and what "the people" refers to since "the people" can be described as any "grouping", all inclusive or segmented and described in conjuction with a definer. In the case of the 2nd Amendment, there is nothing to say yay or nay to the idea that if the authors of the 2nd Amendment intended an inalienable right that extended without exception, to all citizens and defined any sort of arms in existence at any time in history, they would need only have stated that, "the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed" Clear, concise and without much to argue to the contrary, but the 2nd Amendment does not simply say "the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed". The first part of the 2nd Amendment describes what is "necessary to the security of a free state" and it does not identify "the right to keep and bear arms as what is necessary, but "a well-regulated Militia". By definition of Militia, there are "people" that must keep and bear arms in order to meet the definition and as already explained, in that day and age, a "well regulated Militia" was defined by a set of parameters and "people" than it is defined by currently, yet the need for "the people" who populate "a well regulated Militia" to keep and bear arms has not changed, it is the only consistency as is the notion and necessity of a "common defense". There is no reason to add meanless or disconnected fluff to the 2nd Amendment, thus there is a tie to the "right to keep and bear arms" to what is "necessary to the security of a free state" as well as the tie to a "well regulated Militia" and it "being necessary to the security of a free state" to a "common defense" as well as Article One, section 8 and the legislative powers regarding Militia.
 
OK, forget the reductio ad absurdium nonsense about ICBMs and such. As to the rest, well are you at war with your neighbors now? Do you expect to be? No? Then why do you care what he has if there is no reason to think he wants to use it on you?

Why would he have it if he didn't expect a need to use it? In additon, was there any reason for anyone in Newtown to suspect Adam Lanza would use his mother's guns on her or them? You contradict your own "logic".
 
We do have the right to own a machine gun... you just have to jump through a lot of hoops to do it legally. BTW, what is being suggested? We wandered so far off the res I don't remember...

Isn't jumping through hoops to do something legally, infringing on something considered a "right"? If one has to jump through hoops, to do something legally there would seem to be the implication that their securing a legal means to keep and bear something is not guaranteed.

In addition, it such hoop jumping can be instituted at the level you're talking about, where is there a defined limitation, up or down, on what weapons need some sort of regulation (hoop jumping) in order to obtain what is claimed to be an a "right" that cannot be infringed upon?

If one cannot infringe upon a "right" I would assume that would mean no requirement to jump through hoops or any other scrutiny need be applied, yet I imagine if you had children and your paranoid schizophrenic neighbor decided to "defend himself" by planting his yard with landmines and several bunker type M134 Minigun nests, you, hopefully as a responsible parent, would have some concerns, if not serious objections, for obvious and practical reasons.
 
That you shouldn't ask, not of me. European society has always been at war with someone, it's just a trait they've carried with them from the beginning of time. They were welcomed, and even accepted as neighbors. How well did that work? It's as simple as Europeans taking a breath, give them an inch and they take a mile. Simply put I'd be a fool to not accept that a war with my neighbors would happen, given they had the capacity to make war. All you have to do is pay attention to what history teaches you. And why would that be nonsense for someone to one day decide he should have an ICBM, just because they perceive it to be their right. You discover that someone found a loophole, or 'backdoor', in a law, and like magic they have a right to own a machine gun. Well now, they have one, I deserve to have one. This is what you're saying, so what keeps the rest of society from saying the same thing?

Yes, I know, let them right? Sure, why not. then let's see where the next step is. And the one after that, and the one after that, and the one after that. 'For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction'.

Why would I think 'he would want to use it on you?' It's a fact of nature, and has been since the beginning of time, and I've got 500 years of evidence to that. It's what is known as 'bad code' in men. Just take a look at the movie Treasure of the Sierra Madre. Yes it's a movie, about man's worst trait. They can't help themselves.
 
You sound a bit confused, but very much subjective and selfish where the world is all about what you want, not about any consideration of the rights, desires or freedoms of anyone that wants something different than what you want.

With regard to guns, the mere possession of them under the premise of "self-defense" implies a pre-emptive use which is not without further scrutiny and involves an act with an implement designed specifically for effectiveness in killing or severe wounding. "Self-defense" is not simply something someone claims and that is the end of it, there must be a legal determination that any violent act that involves physical injury or death MUST be determined, without the shadow of doubt, to be defensive, for what should be obvious reasons. Otherwise, one could simply walk around popping off whomever they like and simply state they were doing it because they felt threatened by those they popped off. Kinda like a suggestion that killing over 100 thousand people with atomic bombs was a "defensive" move to "save" lives, nevermind the lives "saved" could never be proven nor would those killed in order to "save" lives nor their surviving loved ones necessarily wrap their heads around how killing 100 thousand plus men, women and children was "saving" lives or not acting in the same manner as those that were deemed to act offensively, but who's going to argue such a point with those who were the only possessors (and users) of such weaponry at the time?


The second amendment does not specifically mention "guns", it states "arms". Arms come in many shapes and forms and a "right" to "self defense" is not synonymous with a "right" to keep and bear arms. One may defend themselves in many ways with a variety of "arms" that do not include firearms or guns. the Second Amendment also clearly describes what is "necessary to the security of a free state" and it ain't the a "right of the people to keep an bear arms. It IS "a well-regulated Militia" and in 1792 all citizens (in those days the only recognized "citizens" were free white men) were legally obligated to enroll in, train with and supply their own arms to, "a well-regulated Militia". The purpose of this was not a personal self-defense, but a common defense, as stated and charged in the Preamble of the Constitution of the United States. "A well regulated Militia" was the founders solution to their skepticism and fear of standing militaries populated by professional soldiers with a singular loyalty. They felt that "a well regulated Militia" of every state populated by the citizens of those states, would be less subject to a singular loyalty and the "soldiers" would not be professional, but soldiers trained in warlike fighting who did not spend full time as soldiers. Based on this set up, it would not make practical sense for either the federal or local state role of well-regulated Militia to leave a window open for any state to restrict the keeping and bearing of arms by those obligated under law to not just be enrolled in and train with a well regulated Militia, but to furnish their own arms to it. It would be like your state or local laws requiring you to have smoke, fire and CO alarms in your home, without making sure you had access to their purchase.

Now, there is no legal requirement for all able bodied citizens between any ages to enroll in, train with or furnish their own arms to, a well-regulated Militia (that which is "necessary to the security of a free state", thus without more specific definition in the 2nd Amendment, there is nothing to specify what types of arms are defined or not defined and what "the people" refers to since "the people" can be described as any "grouping", all inclusive or segmented and described in conjuction with a definer. In the case of the 2nd Amendment, there is nothing to say yay or nay to the idea that if the authors of the 2nd Amendment intended an inalienable right that extended without exception, to all citizens and defined any sort of arms in existence at any time in history, they would need only have stated that, "the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed" Clear, concise and without much to argue to the contrary, but the 2nd Amendment does not simply say "the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed". The first part of the 2nd Amendment describes what is "necessary to the security of a free state" and it does not identify "the right to keep and bear arms as what is necessary, but "a well-regulated Militia". By definition of Militia, there are "people" that must keep and bear arms in order to meet the definition and as already explained, in that day and age, a "well regulated Militia" was defined by a set of parameters and "people" than it is defined by currently, yet the need for "the people" who populate "a well regulated Militia" to keep and bear arms has not changed, it is the only consistency as is the notion and necessity of a "common defense". There is no reason to add meanless or disconnected fluff to the 2nd Amendment, thus there is a tie to the "right to keep and bear arms" to what is "necessary to the security of a free state" as well as the tie to a "well regulated Militia" and it "being necessary to the security of a free state" to a "common defense" as well as Article One, section 8 and the legislative powers regarding Militia.
Well, I'm not going to spend a lot of time on this, so I'm just gonna say "wrong".
 
Back
Top