New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

TV Trends

Arkady

President
This was inspired by a post, below, about the series "Blackish" -- but it's enough off the subject that I didn't want to derail that thread.

Has anyone else noticed a shift in television, from a class perspective? It seems that there are cycles in TV, in terms of the tendency to feature poor and working class characters, and right now we're at an all-time low point for that.

For example, in the late 1970s, the top-rated show was "All in the Family" -- based around a lower-middle-class extended family living in a run-down house in Queens. Other top-10 shows included "Laverne and Shirley," "One Day at a Time," "Sanford and Son," "Taxi," "Alice," and "Little House on the Prairie." Each featured characters who were either lower class or barely clinging to middle class. This run-down aesthetic shows up in the movies of the era, too, like Rocky, Taxi Driver, Carrie, the Warriors, etc.

The early 80s had the start of "wealth porn." There were still a few hold-over working class shows from the 70s, but largely we got things like Dallas, Dynasty, Knots Landing, Falcon Crest, and Hart to Hart, as well as high-concept action shows like the A-Team and Knight Rider. There was also "aspirational" TV, with poorer characters relocated to rich settings, like the Jeffersons and Differn't Strokes. The procedurals often were rooted in wealth and glamour -- the Miami Vice cops drove around in a Ferrari, and Magnum PI lived in a huge mansion in Hawaii. Even the top family sitcom was based around a family where the mom was a lawyer and the dad a doctor, and money simply wasn't an issue for them. The only "blue collar" show that did well in the ratings was The Dukes of Hazzard, which might as well exist in a different galaxy for all its verisimilitude. The early 80s were a tough time, economically, with the highest unemployment rates of the post-Depression era in 1983, and there seemed to be an eagerness for escapism.

The late 80s weren't as gritty as the late 70s, but definitely moved back in that direction, with shows like Cheers, 227, A Different World, the Wonder Years, and especially Roseanne -- shows where a character's money troubles would often drive the plot, and the homes and workplaces looked nothing like a designer would put together. There were faded fabrics, cluttered surfaces, cramped quarters, etc.

The early 90s continued that, with the ongoing dominance of Roseanne and Cheers, plus a batch of working-class imitators, like Grace Under Fire. But, by the mid-to-late 90s, things had shifted away from that. Even when characters worked in jobs where they would be struggling in real life, they somehow occupied million-dollar apartments in Manhattan (e.g., Friends). That was the era of up-scale urban characters: Frasier, Seinfeld, Suddenly Susan, Veronica's Closet, and ER. In the wider economy, poverty was plunging and median incomes soaring, and the networks served up Yuppies by the boatload.

These days, I don't see any working-class shows anywhere near the top 10. The Big Bang Theory revolves around a bunch of guys with doctorates from top universities. Procedurals tend to be based not around working class police precincts and gritty neighborhoods, but instead around jet-setting investigators and their high-tech forensics, thwarting terrorists and genius criminals. Much of the lineup includes reality shows with big pay-days. "Modern Family" is a pretty standard offering for this era, in the dying sitcom genre, in that the three families include a wealthy retiree's family, a two-income family where one is a lawyer, and a second two-income family where one is the CEO of a small business and the other is a real estate agent. They take group vacations to places like Australia, and they all live in large, luxuriously appointed houses. Nobody sweats the cost of sending a kid to a top college.

I find this shift interesting. Based on how television went in the late 70s, one might have expected a shift towards grittier economic fair on television, during the Bush/Obama years, to reflect the struggles of the viewers. Instead, there seems to be a kind of escapism. People want to watch reality contest shows, or glossy procedurals. It's interesting that two eras with somewhat similar economic trends could have such strongly opposed aesthetics and preoccupations, within pop culture. Sure, there are some shows like "Two Broke Girls" with down-market focuses, but they're small niche offerings. It's hard to picture them, these days, dominating the ratings like Roseanne, All in the Family, and the Honeymooners once did.

When the Simpsons first came out, it was a tribute/parody of a kind of entertainment that dominated for decades, with the schlubby working class dad struggling with day-to-day problems like how to afford his daughter's braces. These days, it's like a relic of a different era, since now most shows are built around attractive professionals working sexy jobs, generally in an immaculately designed workplace. Even when you have shows with similar premises, the aesthetics are light-years apart:

upload_2016-4-19_7-28-30.png upload_2016-4-19_7-28-45.png upload_2016-4-19_7-28-58.png

It would seem there are political implications when people respond to hard economic times with escapism instead of a focus on the reality.
 
Last edited:
None of that is of any interest to me. All I want to know is, when do we start getting nudity in regular programming like the Europeans have?
 
"These days, I don't see any working-class shows anywhere near the top 10."

its so funny to see how old guys are stuck to the notion of "network tv" and "top 10 shows"

there are 900 cable channels out there, and a bunch of web based shows too. you should change the channel sometime ark. these new shows - including the following - focus on middle America.

or, if you're determined to stay "old school", let's not forget 'the simpsons" - Americas longest running (30 years?) sitcom, about lower middle class folks.
 
This was inspired by a post, below, about the series "Blackish" -- but it's enough off the subject that I didn't want to derail that thread.

Has anyone else noticed a shift in television, from a class perspective? It seems that there are cycles in TV, in terms of the tendency to feature poor and working class characters, and right now we're at an all-time low point for that.

For example, in the late 1970s, the top-rated show was "All in the Family" -- based around a lower-middle-class extended family living in a run-down house in Queens. Other top-10 shows included "Laverne and Shirley," "One Day at a Time," "Sanford and Son," "Taxi," "Alice," and "Little House on the Prairie." Each featured characters who were either lower class or barely clinging to middle class. This run-down aesthetic shows up in the movies of the era, too, like Rocky, Taxi Driver, Carrie, the Warriors, etc.

The early 80s had the start of "wealth porn." There were still a few hold-over working class shows from the 70s, but largely we got things like Dallas, Dynasty, Knots Landing, Falcon Crest, and Hart to Hart, as well as high-concept action shows like the A-Team and Knight Rider. There was also "aspirational" TV, with poorer characters relocated to rich settings, like the Jeffersons and Differn't Strokes. The procedurals often were rooted in wealth and glamous -- the Miami Vice cops drove around in a Ferrari, and Magnum PI lived in a huge mansion in Hawaii. Even the top family sitcom was based around a family where the mom was a lawyer and the dad a doctor, and money simply wasn't an issue for them. The only "blue collar" show that did well in the ratings was The Dukes of Hazzard, which might as well exist in a different galaxy for all its verisimilitude. The early 80s were a tough time, economically, with the highest unemployment rates of the post-Depression era in 1983, and there seemed to be an eagerness for escapism.

The late 80s weren't as gritty as the late 70s, but definitely moved back in that direction, with shows like Cheers, 227, A Different World, the Wonder Years, and especially Roseanne -- shows where a character's money troubles would often drive the plot, and the homes and workplaces looked nothing like a designer would put together. There were faded fabrics, cluttered surfaces, cramped quarters, etc.

The early 90s continued that, with the ongoing dominance of Roseanne and Cheers, plus a batch of working-class imitators, like Grace Under Fire. But, by the mid-to-late 90s, things had shifted away from that. Even when characters worked in jobs where they would be struggling in real life, they somehow occupied million-dollar apartments in Manhattan (e.g., Friends). That was the era of up-scale urban characters: Frasier, Seinfeld, Suddenly Susan, Veronica's Closet, and ER. In the wider economy, poverty was plunging and median incomes soaring, and the networks served up Yuppies by the boatload.

These days, I don't see any working-class shows anywhere near the top 10. The Big Bang Theory revolves around a bunch of guys with doctorates from top universities. Procedurals tend to be based not around working class police precincts and gritty neighborhoods, but instead around jet-setting investigators and their high-tech forensics, thwarting terrorists and genius criminals. Much of the lineup includes reality shows with big pay-days. "Modern Family" is a pretty standard offering for this era, in the dying sitcom genre, in that the three families include a wealthy retiree's family, a two-income family where one is a lawyer, and a second two-income family where one is the CEO of a small business and the other is a real estate agent. They take group vacations to places like Australia, and they all live in large, luxuriously appointed houses. Nobody sweats the cost of sending a kid to a top college.

I find this shift interesting. Based on how television went in the late 70s, one might have expected a shift towards grittier economic fair on television, during the Bush/Obama years, to reflect the struggles of the viewers. Instead, there seems to be a kind of escapism. People want to watch reality contest shows, or glossy procedurals. It's interesting that two eras with somewhat similar economic trends could have such strongly opposed aesthetics and preoccupations, within pop culture. Sure, there are some shows like "Two Broke Girls" with down-market focuses, but they're small niche offerings. It's hard to picture them, these days, dominating the ratings like Roseanne, All in the Family, and the Honeymooners once did.

When the Simpsons first came out, it was a tribute/parody of a kind of entertainment that dominated for decades, with the schlubby working class dad struggling with day-to-day problems like how to afford his daughter's braces. These days, it's like a relic of a different era, since now most shows are built around attractive professionals working sexy jobs, generally in an immaculately designed workplace. Even when you have shows with similar premises, the aesthetics are light-years apart:

View attachment 30866 View attachment 30867 View attachment 30868

It would seem there are political implications when people respond to hard economic times with escapism instead of a focus on the reality.

I think it's all consistent with cultural norms today. Escapism is all around us, particularly in mobile devices. Many people are physically somewhere, but not mentally there at all. Plus, they've activated addictive tendencies, as heavy social media and portable device users show major physical symptoms when they are separated from their said device.

The layperson overall far too often worships celebrities, and spends hours watching normal daily nuances of other people's lives on reality TV.

Political implications? I'm not sure there are any directly. I think as a parent it's your responsibility to steer your child away from being a social media/device addict, and develop them as a person, their character and intelligence. I think many parents use internet devices as escapes, and throw their kid in the other room with an iPad instead of bonding with them and being pushed to do the full job of a parent. Do this for years and years and it'll create bad habits for both people involved.
 
None of that is of any interest to me. All I want to know is, when do we start getting nudity in regular programming like the Europeans have?
I'm all for that, too. Is an occasional topless scene really too much to ask?
 
"These days, I don't see any working-class shows anywhere near the top 10."

its so funny to see how old guys are stuck to the notion of "network tv" and "top 10 shows"

there are 900 cable channels out there, and a bunch of web based shows too. you should change the channel sometime ark. these new shows - including the following - focus on middle America.

or, if you're determined to stay "old school", let's not forget 'the simpsons" - Americas longest running (30 years?) sitcom, about lower middle class folks.
I watch non-network shows frequently. I just finished 11/22/63, I just started the latest season of Kimmy Schmidt, I'm a regular view of Game of Thrones, John Oliver, and Better Call Saul, as well as a couple foreign series on Netflix. I also occasionally watch web series. The vast majority of what I watch doesn't appear on network TV. But the ratings of those kinds of shows aren't even in the ballpark of, say, NCIS, The Voice, or the Big Bang Theory. It's hard to get reliable numbers on how many viewers a typical Netflix original series episode draws, but most estimates put it somewhere in the 1-5 million range, compared to over 10 million, and as many as 20 million, for top network offerings. So, if you're going to assess the tastes of most Americans, looking to those niche offerings doesn't make much sense.

Also, note that I specifically mentioned the Simpsons, which shows how far consumption trends have changed. When it came out, it was fairly typical in its focus on middle-class folks. It wouldn't have seemed out of place with Roseanne, Married with Children, or even much older shows to which is pays obvious tribute, like All in the Family, the Honeymooners, and the Flintstones. Now it's sort of a living fossil -- something that has clung to life long after the era when its kind dominated the land.
 
The layperson overall far too often worships celebrities, and spends hours watching normal daily nuances of other people's lives on reality TV.

That's a genre I totally don't get. My wife watches the Kardashians, for example, and I don't get how a bright woman could give a crap about that stuff. I've occasionally gotten into a reality show --a couple early seasons of Survivor, for example-- but it was the game show aspect that interested me, not all the cut aways of contestants whining about one another, which is all the non-game-show reality shows have to offer. Why does anyone care about Kim's photo shoot or Honey Boo Boo's latest sugar high?

Do this for years and years and it'll create bad habits for both people involved.

It'll be interesting to see how the next generation grows up with regard to social media and portable computing, since they will have had it from birth. The current addicts are largely people who never had that stuff growing up, yet they still became addicted. I never even had a cell phone until my work required me to get one less than 15 years ago.... I'd made it through decades without one, yet now I feel naked when I walk around without a device. I'd imagine it will be still worse for those who never had a period without them.... though, in theory, maybe they'll be better at regulating those things in their lives, since they got started earlier. We'll see.
 
That's a genre I totally don't get. My wife watches the Kardashians, for example, and I don't get how a bright woman could give a crap about that stuff. I've occasionally gotten into a reality show --a couple early seasons of Survivor, for example-- but it was the game show aspect that interested me, not all the cut aways of contestants whining about one another, which is all the non-game-show reality shows have to offer. Why does anyone care about Kim's photo shoot or Honey Boo Boo's latest sugar high?
I'm not at all compelled to watch Reality TV either. I've watched an episode of a show here and there with a friend (as long as I'm allowed to commentate mind you), and what I have noticed is that they all follow the same exact formula. The same camera angles, and the same perspective, the same fillers... I mean, It obviously works, but it's the exact same product across the board.

It'll be interesting to see how the next generation grows up with regard to social media and portable computing, since they will have had it from birth. The current addicts are largely people who never had that stuff growing up, yet they still became addicted. I never even had a cell phone until my work required me to get one less than 15 years ago.... I'd made it through decades without one, yet now I feel naked when I walk around without a device. I'd imagine it will be still worse for those who never had a period without them.... though, in theory, maybe they'll be better at regulating those things in their lives, since they got started earlier. We'll see.

It's true someone can become addicted to something when it's a new factor that one wasn't accustomed to growing up.

However, I think those that grow up without knowing what it's like to not be "connected" will have significantly less intelligence, social skills, desire, and common sense overall. They'll be better and more effective in streamlining achievements due to the technology at their disposal.

I think technology used to boost production and ways of doing things can always be rationalized as some sort of improvement, but then you have to think of how many McDonalds workers are soon going to be out of work due to order-taking printing screens that are coming soon to a town near you.

I think we can rationalize social media in romantic ways.. connecting with those we might never have connected with, sharing interests with those who also share them. However, we also cut ourselves off from the randomness and diversity of life, and don't build the mental flexibility to exist in the world. I think we can already see this coming to fruition in the PC baby millenials, who can't seem to function well when things aren't perfect and don't go their way. I know every generation always poo-poos the next one, calling them the cliche adjectives. It's going to be there to an extent. The question is, to what extent is it warranted, and how all-encompassing is it? I think the inflexibility of the PC movement far worse than any lazy, grunge kids in the 90's, my generation, who I heard would ruin our country when I was growing up. At least grunge kids would say "f*ck it" and leave people alone, and not get all authoritarian about things.
 
I know every generation always poo-poos the next one, calling them the cliche adjectives. It's going to be there to an extent. The question is, to what extent is it warranted, and how all-encompassing is it? I think the inflexibility of the PC movement far worse than any lazy, grunge kids in the 90's, my generation, who I heard would ruin our country when I was growing up. At least grunge kids would say "f*ck it" and leave people alone, and not get all authoritarian about things.

I think this is just the "every generation always poo-pooing the next one" thing. I mean, take a look back in the bashing of Gen X and you'll see it was always rooted in Baby Boomer prejudices instead of facts. For example, as you say, the 90s kids were supposedly lazy. Yet every attempt to measure that, statistically, showed the opposite -- that they spent more time studying and working than their parents had at the same age. But Boomers had their preconceptions and tried to impose them on reality.

As for the younger generation, some things about them drive me nuts -- I want to yell "get off my lawn" like the crusty middle-aged man I am. But, statistically, I've got to admit the kids are all right (albeit poorly served by their society). They're dropping out of school at record-low rates, they got knocked up as teens at record low rates, they're less violent than any generation since the 1950s, they're pursuing higher education at record high rates, they're less racist, less sexist, less homophobic, and have higher IQs than any generation before them. I get frustrated by them, but often their failures are simply an unavoidable lack of experience. For example, I have some young cousins who are stereotypical "Bernie Bros," and they post the dumbest crap in Facebook -- stuff that makes me cringe even as a fellow Sanders voter. But most of that dumb crap is simply attributable to the fact they have no adult memory of prior political cycles and thus no perspective. They're learning.

The political correctness of the Millenials can bug me a bit, too, since it comes across as a kind of cant -- like they're just mouthing stock phrases they heard somewhere, rather than examining their premises. But if the worst thing about a generation is that they're too shallow and callow in their sincere advocacy for the oppressed, then they're in pretty good shape. Their hearts are in the right place, anyway.
 
Their hearts are in the right place, anyway.

I think that's a monumental difference between us.

Ignorantly good intentions doesn't make the action righteous. On the contrary, I've noticed that being warm and fuzzy when yearning for social change quite often comes in conflict with the law, and rights we've established in America. An example would be wishing to ignore illegal immigration laws and simply label them "racist", while claiming that those who are against illegal immigration are "xenophobes" and "against immigration". This is a common cry by the baby PC community, and smear tactic, as nobody is against legal immigration.
 
An example would be wishing to ignore illegal immigration laws and simply label them "racist", while claiming that those who are against illegal immigration are "xenophobes" and "against immigration". This is a common cry by the baby PC community, and smear tactic, as nobody is against legal immigration.

Maybe there is an attempt to conflate the issues of legal and illegal immigration, but I think it's naive to imagine that xenophobia and hostility even to legal immigration aren't playing a big part in this. Trump's infamous "rapists" speech didn't distinguish between legal and illegal immigrants. And if you listen to the hateful masses lining up behind him, you'll hear a lot of raw xenophobia -- rhetoric that applies equally against the legal and the illegal immigrants.

For example, in an NPR interview with a Trump supporter, last week, she was asked why she supported Trump (whom she'd previously fought about a proposed boardwalk development) and her answer was "because I don't want to have to press one for English." You'll see the same kind of rhetoric on this board, where people are convinced (actual studies to the contrary notwithstanding), that Latin American immigrants these days are different from prior generations of immigrants in their refusal to assimilate, and lack of effort to learn English. There is a strong vein of xenophobia animating the anti-illegal-immigrant movement.

I notice that whenever I argue the issue, because of the hostility my own proposed solutions cause. I'm against illegal immigration, since I think underground economies tend to be ugly -- rife for human rights and labor abuses. So I'm interested in fighting illegal immigration. But my ideas don't appeal to xenophobes.

Specifically, I think a wall along the border is an expensive boondoggle, since it will be so easy to go over, under, and around, and since such a huge portion of undocumented workers come here legally, by way of visas, and simply overstay. Instead, I focus on three solutions:

(1) A pathway to citizenship for those here illegally, to accelerate the shrinkage of the underground economy.

(2) An increase in legal immigration, to help to fill the low-end labor niches that, if left unfilled, simply attract illegal immigrants.

(3) An effort to throw the book at illegal employers, to eliminate those niches on the demand side, where some real progress is theoretically possible. Specifically, I've proposed the idea of a program that provides visas to undocumented workers and their families if they provide testimony and assistance leading to the conviction of any illegal employer. If illegal employers can't count on undocumented workers keeping their mouths shut about the arrangement, and the penalties are stiff, then the arrangement becomes too big a risk for the employers and those jobs will dry up.

Those things all seem much more likely to reduce illegal immigration than quixotic walls, mass deportations, and turning the screws on suspected illegal immigrants. But they don't tend to be very popular among the anti-illegal-immigrant crowd, because they don't scratch their real itch. Even though there's good cause to expect they'd greatly diminish illegal immigration, they're not built around punishing foreigners, and would potentially increase the total immigrant population, so the appeal to xenophobes is minimal.
 
Last edited:
.......These days, I don't see any working-class shows anywhere near the top 10. The Big Bang Theory revolves around a bunch of guys with doctorates from top universities. Procedurals tend to be based not around working class police precincts and gritty neighborhoods, but instead around jet-setting investigators and their high-tech forensics, thwarting terrorists and genius criminals....
As usual, your bias is appallingly apparent.

You cherry-pick the shows to prove your point instead of letting the data reveal the trend.

While I agree that TV shows tend to go in trends, there are plenty of middle class shows on television. The educated scientists aren't rich, a point that comes up on occasion. They're middle class. "The Middle" is about a lower middle class family as is "Mom". "Mike & Molly" are about dead-center Middle Class while "Modern Family" are upper middle class.

The procedurals are all middle class even if their jobs are exotic. Unless you think police officers make a ton of cash like [Unwelcome language removed] lawyers cheating the public, I fail to see how you can justify them as being rich.

http://tvaholics.blogspot.com/2016/03/complete-nielsen-ratings-february-22-28.html
 
None of that is of any interest to me. All I want to know is, when do we start getting nudity in regular programming like the Europeans have?
If I want nudity ...I'll see that with my wife. But don't have a problem with nudity
 
Maybe there is an attempt to conflate the issues of legal and illegal immigration, but I think it's naive to imagine that xenophobia and hostility even to legal immigration aren't playing a big part in this. Trump's infamous "rapists" speech didn't distinguish between legal and illegal immigrants. And if you listen to the hateful masses lining up behind him, you'll hear a lot of raw xenophobia -- rhetoric that applies equally against the legal and the illegal immigrants.

For example, in an NPR interview with a Trump supporter, last week, she was asked why she supported Trump (whom she'd previously fought about a proposed boardwalk development) and her answer was "because I don't want to have to press one for English." You'll see the same kind of rhetoric on this board, where people are convinced (actual studies to the contrary notwithstanding), that Latin American immigrants these days are different from prior generations of immigrants in their refusal to assimilate, and lack of effort to learn English. There is a strong vein of xenophobia animating the anti-illegal-immigrant movement.

I notice that whenever I argue the issue, because of the hostility my own proposed solutions cause. I'm against illegal immigration, since I think underground economies tend to be ugly -- rife for human rights and labor abuses. So I'm interested in fighting illegal immigration. But my ideas don't appeal to xenophobes.

Specifically, I think a wall along the border is an expensive boondoggle, since it will be so easy to go over, under, and around, and since such a huge portion of undocumented workers come here legally, by way of visas, and simply overstay. Instead, I focus on three solutions:

(1) A pathway to citizenship for those here illegally, to accelerate the shrinkage of the underground economy.

(2) An increase in legal immigration, to help to fill the low-end labor niches that, if left unfilled, simply attract illegal immigrants.

(3) An effort to throw the book at illegal employers, to eliminate those niches on the demand side, where some real progress is theoretically possible. Specifically, I've proposed the idea of a program that provides visas to undocumented workers and their families if they provide testimony and assistance leading to the conviction of any illegal employer. If illegal employers can't count on undocumented workers keeping their mouths shut about the arrangement, and the penalties are stiff, then the arrangement becomes too big a risk for the employers and those jobs will dry up.

Those things all seem much more likely to reduce illegal immigration than quixotic walls, mass deportations, and turning the screws on suspected illegal immigrants. But they don't tend to be very popular among the anti-illegal-immigrant crowd, because they don't scratch their real itch. Even though there's good cause to expect they'd greatly diminish illegal immigration, they're not built around punishing foreigners, and would potentially increase the total immigrant population, so the appeal to xenophobes is minimal.

(1)...The pathway to more Democrats voters

(2). I am a democratic...I think Illegals made legal can clean my toilets...and those coming here legally are qualified to do the same.

(3) You've proposed making criminal behavior

I think your proposal deserves a big red X
 
This was inspired by a post, below, about the series "Blackish" -- but it's enough off the subject that I didn't want to derail that thread.

Has anyone else noticed a shift in television, from a class perspective? It seems that there are cycles in TV, in terms of the tendency to feature poor and working class characters, and right now we're at an all-time low point for that.

For example, in the late 1970s, the top-rated show was "All in the Family" -- based around a lower-middle-class extended family living in a run-down house in Queens. Other top-10 shows included "Laverne and Shirley," "One Day at a Time," "Sanford and Son," "Taxi," "Alice," and "Little House on the Prairie." Each featured characters who were either lower class or barely clinging to middle class. This run-down aesthetic shows up in the movies of the era, too, like Rocky, Taxi Driver, Carrie, the Warriors, etc.

The early 80s had the start of "wealth porn." There were still a few hold-over working class shows from the 70s, but largely we got things like Dallas, Dynasty, Knots Landing, Falcon Crest, and Hart to Hart, as well as high-concept action shows like the A-Team and Knight Rider. There was also "aspirational" TV, with poorer characters relocated to rich settings, like the Jeffersons and Differn't Strokes. The procedurals often were rooted in wealth and glamour -- the Miami Vice cops drove around in a Ferrari, and Magnum PI lived in a huge mansion in Hawaii. Even the top family sitcom was based around a family where the mom was a lawyer and the dad a doctor, and money simply wasn't an issue for them. The only "blue collar" show that did well in the ratings was The Dukes of Hazzard, which might as well exist in a different galaxy for all its verisimilitude. The early 80s were a tough time, economically, with the highest unemployment rates of the post-Depression era in 1983, and there seemed to be an eagerness for escapism.

The late 80s weren't as gritty as the late 70s, but definitely moved back in that direction, with shows like Cheers, 227, A Different World, the Wonder Years, and especially Roseanne -- shows where a character's money troubles would often drive the plot, and the homes and workplaces looked nothing like a designer would put together. There were faded fabrics, cluttered surfaces, cramped quarters, etc.

The early 90s continued that, with the ongoing dominance of Roseanne and Cheers, plus a batch of working-class imitators, like Grace Under Fire. But, by the mid-to-late 90s, things had shifted away from that. Even when characters worked in jobs where they would be struggling in real life, they somehow occupied million-dollar apartments in Manhattan (e.g., Friends). That was the era of up-scale urban characters: Frasier, Seinfeld, Suddenly Susan, Veronica's Closet, and ER. In the wider economy, poverty was plunging and median incomes soaring, and the networks served up Yuppies by the boatload.

These days, I don't see any working-class shows anywhere near the top 10. The Big Bang Theory revolves around a bunch of guys with doctorates from top universities. Procedurals tend to be based not around working class police precincts and gritty neighborhoods, but instead around jet-setting investigators and their high-tech forensics, thwarting terrorists and genius criminals. Much of the lineup includes reality shows with big pay-days. "Modern Family" is a pretty standard offering for this era, in the dying sitcom genre, in that the three families include a wealthy retiree's family, a two-income family where one is a lawyer, and a second two-income family where one is the CEO of a small business and the other is a real estate agent. They take group vacations to places like Australia, and they all live in large, luxuriously appointed houses. Nobody sweats the cost of sending a kid to a top college.

I find this shift interesting. Based on how television went in the late 70s, one might have expected a shift towards grittier economic fair on television, during the Bush/Obama years, to reflect the struggles of the viewers. Instead, there seems to be a kind of escapism. People want to watch reality contest shows, or glossy procedurals. It's interesting that two eras with somewhat similar economic trends could have such strongly opposed aesthetics and preoccupations, within pop culture. Sure, there are some shows like "Two Broke Girls" with down-market focuses, but they're small niche offerings. It's hard to picture them, these days, dominating the ratings like Roseanne, All in the Family, and the Honeymooners once did.

When the Simpsons first came out, it was a tribute/parody of a kind of entertainment that dominated for decades, with the schlubby working class dad struggling with day-to-day problems like how to afford his daughter's braces. These days, it's like a relic of a different era, since now most shows are built around attractive professionals working sexy jobs, generally in an immaculately designed workplace. Even when you have shows with similar premises, the aesthetics are light-years apart:

View attachment 30866 View attachment 30867 View attachment 30868

It would seem there are political implications when people respond to hard economic times with escapism instead of a focus on the reality.

Political News/Current Events this IS not............one would think a well educated lawyer would have known to post this elsewhere........General perhaps.....
 
Back
Top