Arkady
President
This was inspired by a post, below, about the series "Blackish" -- but it's enough off the subject that I didn't want to derail that thread.
Has anyone else noticed a shift in television, from a class perspective? It seems that there are cycles in TV, in terms of the tendency to feature poor and working class characters, and right now we're at an all-time low point for that.
For example, in the late 1970s, the top-rated show was "All in the Family" -- based around a lower-middle-class extended family living in a run-down house in Queens. Other top-10 shows included "Laverne and Shirley," "One Day at a Time," "Sanford and Son," "Taxi," "Alice," and "Little House on the Prairie." Each featured characters who were either lower class or barely clinging to middle class. This run-down aesthetic shows up in the movies of the era, too, like Rocky, Taxi Driver, Carrie, the Warriors, etc.
The early 80s had the start of "wealth porn." There were still a few hold-over working class shows from the 70s, but largely we got things like Dallas, Dynasty, Knots Landing, Falcon Crest, and Hart to Hart, as well as high-concept action shows like the A-Team and Knight Rider. There was also "aspirational" TV, with poorer characters relocated to rich settings, like the Jeffersons and Differn't Strokes. The procedurals often were rooted in wealth and glamour -- the Miami Vice cops drove around in a Ferrari, and Magnum PI lived in a huge mansion in Hawaii. Even the top family sitcom was based around a family where the mom was a lawyer and the dad a doctor, and money simply wasn't an issue for them. The only "blue collar" show that did well in the ratings was The Dukes of Hazzard, which might as well exist in a different galaxy for all its verisimilitude. The early 80s were a tough time, economically, with the highest unemployment rates of the post-Depression era in 1983, and there seemed to be an eagerness for escapism.
The late 80s weren't as gritty as the late 70s, but definitely moved back in that direction, with shows like Cheers, 227, A Different World, the Wonder Years, and especially Roseanne -- shows where a character's money troubles would often drive the plot, and the homes and workplaces looked nothing like a designer would put together. There were faded fabrics, cluttered surfaces, cramped quarters, etc.
The early 90s continued that, with the ongoing dominance of Roseanne and Cheers, plus a batch of working-class imitators, like Grace Under Fire. But, by the mid-to-late 90s, things had shifted away from that. Even when characters worked in jobs where they would be struggling in real life, they somehow occupied million-dollar apartments in Manhattan (e.g., Friends). That was the era of up-scale urban characters: Frasier, Seinfeld, Suddenly Susan, Veronica's Closet, and ER. In the wider economy, poverty was plunging and median incomes soaring, and the networks served up Yuppies by the boatload.
These days, I don't see any working-class shows anywhere near the top 10. The Big Bang Theory revolves around a bunch of guys with doctorates from top universities. Procedurals tend to be based not around working class police precincts and gritty neighborhoods, but instead around jet-setting investigators and their high-tech forensics, thwarting terrorists and genius criminals. Much of the lineup includes reality shows with big pay-days. "Modern Family" is a pretty standard offering for this era, in the dying sitcom genre, in that the three families include a wealthy retiree's family, a two-income family where one is a lawyer, and a second two-income family where one is the CEO of a small business and the other is a real estate agent. They take group vacations to places like Australia, and they all live in large, luxuriously appointed houses. Nobody sweats the cost of sending a kid to a top college.
I find this shift interesting. Based on how television went in the late 70s, one might have expected a shift towards grittier economic fair on television, during the Bush/Obama years, to reflect the struggles of the viewers. Instead, there seems to be a kind of escapism. People want to watch reality contest shows, or glossy procedurals. It's interesting that two eras with somewhat similar economic trends could have such strongly opposed aesthetics and preoccupations, within pop culture. Sure, there are some shows like "Two Broke Girls" with down-market focuses, but they're small niche offerings. It's hard to picture them, these days, dominating the ratings like Roseanne, All in the Family, and the Honeymooners once did.
When the Simpsons first came out, it was a tribute/parody of a kind of entertainment that dominated for decades, with the schlubby working class dad struggling with day-to-day problems like how to afford his daughter's braces. These days, it's like a relic of a different era, since now most shows are built around attractive professionals working sexy jobs, generally in an immaculately designed workplace. Even when you have shows with similar premises, the aesthetics are light-years apart:

It would seem there are political implications when people respond to hard economic times with escapism instead of a focus on the reality.
Has anyone else noticed a shift in television, from a class perspective? It seems that there are cycles in TV, in terms of the tendency to feature poor and working class characters, and right now we're at an all-time low point for that.
For example, in the late 1970s, the top-rated show was "All in the Family" -- based around a lower-middle-class extended family living in a run-down house in Queens. Other top-10 shows included "Laverne and Shirley," "One Day at a Time," "Sanford and Son," "Taxi," "Alice," and "Little House on the Prairie." Each featured characters who were either lower class or barely clinging to middle class. This run-down aesthetic shows up in the movies of the era, too, like Rocky, Taxi Driver, Carrie, the Warriors, etc.
The early 80s had the start of "wealth porn." There were still a few hold-over working class shows from the 70s, but largely we got things like Dallas, Dynasty, Knots Landing, Falcon Crest, and Hart to Hart, as well as high-concept action shows like the A-Team and Knight Rider. There was also "aspirational" TV, with poorer characters relocated to rich settings, like the Jeffersons and Differn't Strokes. The procedurals often were rooted in wealth and glamour -- the Miami Vice cops drove around in a Ferrari, and Magnum PI lived in a huge mansion in Hawaii. Even the top family sitcom was based around a family where the mom was a lawyer and the dad a doctor, and money simply wasn't an issue for them. The only "blue collar" show that did well in the ratings was The Dukes of Hazzard, which might as well exist in a different galaxy for all its verisimilitude. The early 80s were a tough time, economically, with the highest unemployment rates of the post-Depression era in 1983, and there seemed to be an eagerness for escapism.
The late 80s weren't as gritty as the late 70s, but definitely moved back in that direction, with shows like Cheers, 227, A Different World, the Wonder Years, and especially Roseanne -- shows where a character's money troubles would often drive the plot, and the homes and workplaces looked nothing like a designer would put together. There were faded fabrics, cluttered surfaces, cramped quarters, etc.
The early 90s continued that, with the ongoing dominance of Roseanne and Cheers, plus a batch of working-class imitators, like Grace Under Fire. But, by the mid-to-late 90s, things had shifted away from that. Even when characters worked in jobs where they would be struggling in real life, they somehow occupied million-dollar apartments in Manhattan (e.g., Friends). That was the era of up-scale urban characters: Frasier, Seinfeld, Suddenly Susan, Veronica's Closet, and ER. In the wider economy, poverty was plunging and median incomes soaring, and the networks served up Yuppies by the boatload.
These days, I don't see any working-class shows anywhere near the top 10. The Big Bang Theory revolves around a bunch of guys with doctorates from top universities. Procedurals tend to be based not around working class police precincts and gritty neighborhoods, but instead around jet-setting investigators and their high-tech forensics, thwarting terrorists and genius criminals. Much of the lineup includes reality shows with big pay-days. "Modern Family" is a pretty standard offering for this era, in the dying sitcom genre, in that the three families include a wealthy retiree's family, a two-income family where one is a lawyer, and a second two-income family where one is the CEO of a small business and the other is a real estate agent. They take group vacations to places like Australia, and they all live in large, luxuriously appointed houses. Nobody sweats the cost of sending a kid to a top college.
I find this shift interesting. Based on how television went in the late 70s, one might have expected a shift towards grittier economic fair on television, during the Bush/Obama years, to reflect the struggles of the viewers. Instead, there seems to be a kind of escapism. People want to watch reality contest shows, or glossy procedurals. It's interesting that two eras with somewhat similar economic trends could have such strongly opposed aesthetics and preoccupations, within pop culture. Sure, there are some shows like "Two Broke Girls" with down-market focuses, but they're small niche offerings. It's hard to picture them, these days, dominating the ratings like Roseanne, All in the Family, and the Honeymooners once did.
When the Simpsons first came out, it was a tribute/parody of a kind of entertainment that dominated for decades, with the schlubby working class dad struggling with day-to-day problems like how to afford his daughter's braces. These days, it's like a relic of a different era, since now most shows are built around attractive professionals working sexy jobs, generally in an immaculately designed workplace. Even when you have shows with similar premises, the aesthetics are light-years apart:

It would seem there are political implications when people respond to hard economic times with escapism instead of a focus on the reality.
Last edited: