New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Two Dead Hostages

Both sides have their pros and cons. With drone warfare, your ability to gather reliable intel is impaired, as is your ability to win converts in the area on an ideological level. Ultimately, if we do not win the ideological battle, it is very difficult to imagine how we can win at all.

In short, there are no easy, one-size-fits-all solution. It would be a mistake to think there is.

The difference is that drones are already on scene so the decision to strike is not as pre planned; it is opportunity driven. The other methods have to be deployed. So intel has to be gather before they are undertaken.
 
Look, you and I both know that whatever barck Obama tells you, you are going to accept without question. If George Bush said the same thing, you wouldn't be so trusting. I won't be so trusting in either case. If Barack Obama says something that sounds absurd ("I only know what it says in the newspapers"), I'm not going to buy it, and you are.

No. You and I don't know that. What is pretty much guaranteed is that the version of events the republicans here and in the media report is probably going to be bullshit.

I listen to what the president says and evaluate from there. You seem to wait to find out what the Fox News version of reports is....

For instance...IG investigations. They would not report to the White House that an investigation was under way if the White House could be a target....you don't seem to get that....
 
No. You and I don't know that. What is pretty much guaranteed is that the version of events the republicans here and in the media report is probably going to be bullshit.

I listen to what the president says and evaluate from there. You seem to wait to find out what the Fox News version of reports is....

For instance...IG investigations. They would not report to the White House that an investigation was under way if the White House could be a target....you don't seem to get that....



Believe what you wish, and if you want to delude yourself, so be it. You live in a world of good guys and bad guys, where Democrats are always right and Republicans are always evil, a fantasy world that you enjoy. You can stay there and pretend if you like, but don't be upset if not everyone is going to join you. Enjoy.
 
The difference is that drones are already on scene so the decision to strike is not as pre planned; it is opportunity driven. The other methods have to be deployed. So intel has to be gather before they are undertaken.



The most effective method of gathering good intel is with "boots on the ground". Absent that, you rely on less reliable means, and quite naturally get less reliable data. There is no perfect answer.
 
Believe what you wish, and if you want to delude yourself, so be it. You live in a world of good guys and bad guys, where Democrats are always right and Republicans are always evil, a fantasy world that you enjoy. You can stay there and pretend if you like, but don't be upset if not everyone is going to join you. Enjoy.

1. You clearly have not read very many of my posts. I was a republican for about 30 years and worked on the McCain campaign in 2000. I re-registered as a democrat because of Bush and Rove.
2. I have not supported every policy of Obama's.
3. I most frequently post when you guys make shit up and I find in researching the facts just how outreageous the claims are.....(ie...the "forged" birth certificate)....
4. The fact is that finding bad guys among the republicans just isn't very hard to do.....finding stupidity among the democrats is equally easy....but evil is not so evident.
 
....War is a messy business, and 'collateral damage', unfortunately, happens. It does serve to point out that drone warfare has its problems too. The CIA did not find out the hostages were being held at the location targeted until it was all over - a serious gad in our intel. With drones, your ability to gather such intel is severely limited, and valuable pieces of information such as that are not gathered. Drone warfare has its benefits over "boots on the ground", of course, but it has its drawbacks too......

Fog of war. We do our best, but sometimes friendly fire happens.

Still, attacking a building with a highly accurate missile is preferable to carpet bombing the entire camp because it's less likely to kill innocent people.
 
1. You clearly have not read very many of my posts. I was a republican for about 30 years and worked on the McCain campaign in 2000. I re-registered as a democrat because of Bush and Rove.
2. I have not supported every policy of Obama's.
3. I most frequently post when you guys make shit up and I find in researching the facts just how outreageous the claims are.....(ie...the "forged" birth certificate)....
4. The fact is that finding bad guys among the republicans just isn't very hard to do.....finding stupidity among the democrats is equally easy....but evil is not so evident.


And the next time this President says something, anything, you'll shake your head up and down in vigorous agreement.

You don't have to convince me, it's enough that you know.
 
And the next time this President says something, anything, you'll shake your head up and down in vigorous agreement.

You don't have to convince me, it's enough that you know.

So when you run out of steam on an argument...is your tactic always going to be to attack the messenger? Your sarcasm related to the president not knowing anything if he doesn't read it in the paper is just so much hyperbole...and you know it. My answer to you was about a couple of specific incidents. You can't respond in any meaningful way, so the answer is to make like you know something you don't.

And whenever Obama opens his mouth you can run around calling him a liar without actually checking your facts...because, after all....you know better. Have you met JackoffDallas? You seem to have the same point of view.
 
Last edited:
So when you run out of steam on an argument...is your tactic always going to be to attack the messenger? Your sarcasm related to the president not knowing anything if he doesn't read it in the paper is just so much hyperbole...and you know it. My answer to you was about a couple of specific incidents. You can't respond in any meaningful way, so the answer is to make like you know something you don't.


I suggested that something the President said might not be true. You can't accept that as a possibility, so you immediately did what you will always do, launch an argument that it's impossible for it not to be true. You believe whatever he tells you to. If George Bush had said the same thing and I called him on it, there's no way you would have defended him in the same fashion. You can kid yourself that that's not true if you want to, it's fine with me.
 
I suggested that something the President said might not be true. You can't accept that as a possibility, so you immediately did what you will always do, launch an argument that it's impossible for it not to be true. You believe whatever he tells you to. If George Bush had said the same thing and I called him on it, there's no way you would have defended him in the same fashion. You can kid yourself that that's not true if you want to, it's fine with me.

Let me remind you of what you wrote:

I'm happy he didn't claim that the first he knew of it was when he read about it in the newspaper - a refreshing change.

I responded with a couple of incidents (out of three or four) as to why he may not have known before hand.
 
Let me remind you of what you wrote:

I'm happy he didn't claim that the first he knew of it was when he read about it in the newspaper - a refreshing change.

I responded with a couple of incidents (out of three or four) as to why he may not have known before hand.


I stand by my statement 100%.
 
Drone warfare has a price:

(Reuters) - A U.S. drone strike in January targeting an al Qaeda compound in Pakistan near the Afghan border inadvertently killed an American and an Italian who had been held hostage for years by the group, U.S. officials said on Thursday.

President Barack Obama apologized and took "full responsibility" for all counterterrorism operations, including this one.

The deaths were a setback for the long-running U.S. drone strike program that has targeted Islamist militants in Pakistan, Afghanistan and elsewhere, and has often drawn criticism in those countries and from civil liberties groups in the United States.

Killed in the January drone strike were aid workers Warren Weinstein, an American held by al Qaeda since 2011, and Giovanni Lo Porto, an Italian who went missing in Pakistan in 2012, as well as Ahmed Farouq, an American who was an al Qaeda leader, U.S. officials said.


Complete text: http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/04/23/us-usa-security-hostages-idUSKBN0NE1MI20150423


I am not blaming the President, or the Pentagon or the CIA or anyone else for this (other than al Qaeda). War is a messy business, and 'collateral damage', unfortunately, happens. It does serve to point out that drone warfare has its problems too. The CIA did not find out the hostages were being held at the location targeted until it was all over - a serious gad in our intel. With drones, your ability to gather such intel is severely limited, and valuable pieces of information such as that are not gathered. Drone warfare has its benefits over "boots on the ground", of course, but it has its drawbacks too.

The last two administrations has killed an awful lot of people in the Middle East in the last 14+ years, and there's more chaos than ever over there. How effective has this strategy been? You decide.
All warfare has its price. I think Obama's drone strategy has been a failure, but at least the price for that failure has been relatively low (relative to the death toll and taxpayer hit of full-scale invasions).
 
All warfare has its price. I think Obama's drone strategy has been a failure, but at least the price for that failure has been relatively low (relative to the death toll and taxpayer hit of full-scale invasions).


So, it's low-cost failure as opposed to a high-cost failure, in your view.

Are those are only options?
 
Should they and do they are two different things. A different debate for a different thread.

You miss the point. You argue that Obama should have known about the IG investigation, even though the only way he could have known is if someone leaked it or if he were spying on the IG....

No. The White House should not be spying on the Inspector General's office and therefore the revelation that an investigation into the IRS, made in the media, may well have been the first time Obama heard about it....and should have been.
 
Back
Top