New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Two Dead Hostages

You miss the point. You argue that Obama should have known about the IG investigation, even though the only way he could have known is if someone leaked it or if he were spying on the IG....

No. The White House should not be spying on the Inspector General's office and therefore the revelation that an investigation into the IRS, made in the media, may well have been the first time Obama heard about it....and should have been.


I'm not arguing that he should have known. I'm arguing that he did know.
 
So, it's low-cost failure as opposed to a high-cost failure, in your view.

Are those are only options?
No. We could certainly do better, and I hope we do. But, I think our first focus, given our horrific track record, is to avoid falling back into the high-cost failures. We're like a heroin junky who quit that drug but now fills that hole with junk food. It would be great if we could quit the junk food, too, but at least it's been a step in the right direction.
 
No. We could certainly do better, and I hope we do. But, I think our first focus, given our horrific track record, is to avoid falling back into the high-cost failures. We're like a heroin junky who quit that drug but now fills that hole with junk food. It would be great if we could quit the junk food, too, but at least it's been a step in the right direction.


What do you suggest?
 
What do you suggest?
I suggest thinking about foreign policy in a more medical way. Start with the fundamental principle "first, do no harm." If it's not clear that what you're doing is going to be a meaningful improvement, better not to do anything at all.

As I've pointed out before, I think when it comes to using the military, we're victims of bad analogies. We tend to think of military interventions as if they were precise in the manner of modern surgery. We even talk about them as "surgical strikes." But, if it's surgery, it's not like modern surgery, in a clean operating theater, where we've got MRIs to tell us what we're getting into, fresh blood standing by for infusion, anesthetics to immobilize the patient, and effective antibiotics to minimize the chance of infection. It's more like Civil War battlefield surgery. We're operating blind with filthy instruments, and even if our patient doesn't bleed out, there's a chance the inevitable infection is going to be worse than whatever we were treating.

That doesn't mean we NEVER operate. Doubtless many patients in the 19th century had their lives saved by that era's surgery, no matter how primitive it was. If you've got a gangrenous limb, better to take your chances hacking it off with a rusty saw while the screaming, writhing patient is held down, than to leave the patient to the inevitable painful death. There's a good chance he'll die anyway, and in any event he'll never walk again, but it's still his best chance. I think that's how we should think about using our military: only use it when it is truly a last resort -- only use it when there's simply no way that intervening is going to be worse than not intervening.

Using that analysis, for example, we never would have invaded Iraq in 2003. That Iraq wasn't like a patient with a gangrenous limb who'd inevitably die soon if we didn't cut. It was more like a patient with severe arthritis in the knee, which had hobbled it for a decade, but was neither getting better nor worse. That patient would be better without a filthy, drunken sawbones hacking away at him. If we hadn't set the stage for the ISIS infection to run rampant in Iraq, would the patient have recovered on its own from the Hussein regime? Tough to say. We don't tend to see those things coming in advance. But I there's some chance, and at least it would have been vastly cheaper for America, in terms of loss of American life, squandering of tax dollars, and the erosion of our moral standing around the world.
 
So what, precisely, would you do with ISIS and other such groups now?

Would you use the military?

Boots on the ground?

Drone warfare?

None of that?
 
Back
Top