New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Universal Background Checks

Yes, i've been listening to you guys for a few years now and stand behind each and every word in my post.

National Registry... AWWWWWKKKK!!!

Then why do you never support a ban on such a registry? Of course, even if the registry was banned, that's no guarantee against the government attempting to create one -- that effort has been made via an attempt to track the NICS records used for new gun sales, in the face of a federal law banning the activity.
 
Depends on the situation.

For your tangent... if someone sells a car to an obviously drunk person and allows them to drive away and cause injury or death, yes, they bear some level of responsibility for said injury or death. If, however, they sell a car to someone who is not obviously drunk at the time, and that person later gets drunk, drives and causes injury or death, they bear no responsibility.

Yes. So we've established that it is legal to hold someone responsible for the actions of another we can move on.

Now, back to the issue of background checks. Since you cannot possibly know if someone is an ex-felon (unless we start tatooing ex-felons) and a background check is the only way to know...why is it a problem to require one?
 
Yes. So we've established that it is legal to hold someone responsible for the actions of another we can move on.

Now, back to the issue of background checks. Since you cannot possibly know if someone is an ex-felon (unless we start tatooing ex-felons) and a background check is the only way to know...why is it a problem to require one?

Because to give a UBC the force of law you have to keep a record of the transaction. I.e. serial number of the gun and the owner. DE FACTO national gun registry. Too many people won't tolerate that.
 
Yes. So we've established that it is legal to hold someone responsible for the actions of another we can move on.

Now, back to the issue of background checks. Since you cannot possibly know if someone is an ex-felon (unless we start tatooing ex-felons) and a background check is the only way to know...why is it a problem to require one?

Well, a background check is NOT the only way to know, for one thing. The vast number of face-to-face transfers are among people who know each other and hence know each other's records.

And then there is the fundamental fact that you'd have to have a record, and a record is a registry. I might even accept registration -- if I could get a solid guarantee that it would be the bottom line -- that someone like Schumer or Feinstein wouldn't ask for further restrictions. No one ever offers gun owners such a guarantee.
 
Well, a background check is NOT the only way to know, for one thing. The vast number of face-to-face transfers are among people who know each other and hence know each other's records.

And then there is the fundamental fact that you'd have to have a record, and a record is a registry. I might even accept registration -- if I could get a solid guarantee that it would be the bottom line -- that someone like Schumer or Feinstein wouldn't ask for further restrictions. No one ever offers gun owners such a guarantee.

Bullshit. Accept that record and they'll use it like England, Canada and Australia did to confiscate all guns. As a law abider and by then someone dependent on Obamacare you'll roll over like a trained pooch as might I (not to go to jail and be able to keep your needed albeit crappy health care).

Not an inch, Trapper, not an inch.
 
Yes. So we've established that it is legal to hold someone responsible for the actions of another we can move on.

Now, back to the issue of background checks. Since you cannot possibly know if someone is an ex-felon (unless we start tatooing ex-felons) and a background check is the only way to know...why is it a problem to require one?
Federal law already requires dealers to do a background check.

Do you know how many checks there were in 2012? 19.6 million. in 2011, it was 16.4 million, and in 2010 it was 2010 it was 14.4 million background checks through the existing NCIS system.
http://www.governing.com/gov-data/gun-background-checks-by-state-nics-chart.html

As for gun crime rates, the main reason people want more background checks...
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/...-drops-but-americans-think-its-worse/2139421/
The rate of non-fatal violent gun crime victimization dropped 75% in the past 20 years; The gun homicide rate dropped 49% in the same period, according to numbers Pew researchers obtained from the Bureau of Justice Statistics and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The problem is public perception...
56% of Americans believe gun crime is worse today than it was 20 years ago. And 84% believe in recent years, gun crime has either gone up or stayed the same.
The system, contrary to public perception, is working.
 
Bullshit. Accept that record and they'll use it like England, Canada and Australia did to confiscate all guns. As a law abider and by then someone dependent on Obamacare you'll roll over like a trained pooch as might I (not to go to jail and be able to keep your needed albeit crappy health care).

Not an inch, Trapper, not an inch.

Oh, in real life, I'm right there with you -- because in real life there's no way that we'd ever get the guarantee.
 
Federal law already requires dealers to do a background check.

Do you know how many checks there were in 2012? 19.6 million. in 2011, it was 16.4 million, and in 2010 it was 2010 it was 14.4 million background checks through the existing NCIS system.
http://www.governing.com/gov-data/gun-background-checks-by-state-nics-chart.html

As for gun crime rates, the main reason people want more background checks...
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/...-drops-but-americans-think-its-worse/2139421/

The problem is public perception...

The system, contrary to public perception, is working.

It is working as far as it goes. It is not working where ex-felons or people undergoing psychiatric care in those states that do not mandate reporting goes. Why are you against improving the law where the loopholes allow people like Dylan Klebold to buy guns?
 
Well, a background check is NOT the only way to know, for one thing. The vast number of face-to-face transfers are among people who know each other and hence know each other's records.

And then there is the fundamental fact that you'd have to have a record, and a record is a registry. I might even accept registration -- if I could get a solid guarantee that it would be the bottom line -- that someone like Schumer or Feinstein wouldn't ask for further restrictions. No one ever offers gun owners such a guarantee.

Here is an example of exactly why a debate with you is useless..

The vast number of face-to-face transfers are among people who know each other and hence know each other's records.

Something you can't possibly know, yet are perfectly happy to offer as fact....

And then there is the fundamental fact that you'd have to have a record, and a record is a registry.

How is that a fact? It is your opinion and doesn't agree with mine. We have background checks from gun stores now. Is there a registry? No.
 
It is working as far as it goes. It is not working where ex-felons or people undergoing psychiatric care in those states that do not mandate reporting goes. Why are you against improving the law where the loopholes allow people like Dylan Klebold to buy guns?

The law didn't and doesn't allow Dylan Klebold to buy guns. He was under-age. Someone else bought for him - someone who not only was above legal age, but also someone who could have passed a legal background check.
 
It is working as far as it goes. It is not working where ex-felons or people undergoing psychiatric care in those states that do not mandate reporting goes. Why are you against improving the law where the loopholes allow people like Dylan Klebold to buy guns?
Please show me where I said I was against improving existing gun law, as opposed to instituting new laws?
 
Here is an example of exactly why a debate with you is useless..

The vast number of face-to-face transfers are among people who know each other and hence know each other's records.

Something you can't possibly know, yet are perfectly happy to offer as fact....

And then there is the fundamental fact that you'd have to have a record, and a record is a registry.

How is that a fact? It is your opinion and doesn't agree with mine. We have background checks from gun stores now. Is there a registry? No.

I can't provide numbers, but I have a lot more experience in the firearms world than you do -- most transfers are among people who know each other.

The NICS check generates a record. Past presidential administrations have illegally used that record to build a registry, even though doing so is expressly against the federal law creating the system. If they're willing to abuse the existing system, how much more willing would they be to abuse the comprehensive system that you desire?

Further, how would such a background check work without a registry. You own a gun (it's not registered). You sell it to me. How does anyone know that we didn't go to a dealer and get a background check for the sale? No one does -- unless of course, there's a registry.
 
The law didn't and doesn't allow Dylan Klebold to buy guns. He was under-age. Someone else bought for him - someone who not only was above legal age, but also someone who could have passed a legal background check.

We keep covering the same ground.

1. Robyn Anderson said she would not have bought the guns if she'd have had to undergo a background check.
2. The difference would be that I support making the seller liable for selling without a background check. It is nuts to think that anyone would sell a gun without a background check if they could be held responsible for a crime committed with that gun if they didn't do the BC. Robyn Anderson did not go to jail because it is legal to "give" a gun as a gift, even if it was to a minor and that is what she said she did.
 
The law didn't and doesn't allow Dylan Klebold to buy guns. He was under-age. Someone else bought for him - someone who not only was above legal age, but also someone who could have passed a legal background check.
correct.
http://www.vpc.org/studies/wgun990420.htm
Robyn Anderson, a friend of Klebold and Harris, bought the shotguns and the Hi-Point 9mm Carbine at The Tanner Gun Show in December of 1998 from unlicensed sellers. Because Anderson purchased the guns for someone else, the transition constituted an illegal "straw purchase." Klebold and Harris bought the TEC-DC9 from a pizza shop employee named Mark Manes, who knew they were too young to purchase the assault pistol, but nevertheless sold it to them for $500.
I am unaware of anything in Anderson's background which a check would have flagged.

As for Manes, he broke the law and was sentenced to 6 years in prison for his crime.
http://extras.denverpost.com/news/shot1113.htm
For selling the semiautomatic handgun Dylan Klebold used to kill four people and wound two others at Columbine High School, Mark Manes was sentenced Friday to six years in prison.
The 22-year-old former Columbine student also was sentenced to three years, to be served simultaneously, for possessing an illegally sawed-off shotgun during target practice with Klebold and Eric Harris. The six-year term was for selling a handgun to minors.
 
I can't provide numbers, but I have a lot more experience in the firearms world than you do -- most transfers are among people who know each other.

The NICS check generates a record. Past presidential administrations have illegally used that record to build a registry, even though doing so is expressly against the federal law creating the system. If they're willing to abuse the existing system, how much more willing would they be to abuse the comprehensive system that you desire?

Further, how would such a background check work without a registry. You own a gun (it's not registered). You sell it to me. How does anyone know that we didn't go to a dealer and get a background check for the sale? No one does -- unless of course, there's a registry.

1. You can't provide numbers......
2. "Past presidential administrations"? No...that was being done by the FBI to research large numbers of gun sales to individuals who did not have an FFL and it was a one time deal, unless you have additional information.
3. I've already covered your last question (in spades). Why do you continue to ask it again?
 
correct.
http://www.vpc.org/studies/wgun990420.htm

I am unaware of anything in Anderson's background which a check would have flagged.

As for Manes, he broke the law and was sentenced to 6 years in prison for his crime.
http://extras.denverpost.com/news/shot1113.htm
1. She stated she would not have bought the guns if a background check had been required. Would she have bought the guns if passing them to Klebold would have required one? How about if she'd been liable for anything he'd have done with them if she didn't do a background check on him.
2. Maynes went to jail for 6 years for his part in the massacre at Columbine and you are ok with that? I'm not.
 
Back
Top