New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Universal Background Checks

So any 16 year old who consorts with bad guys should be killed? Face it, Nerobama killed a kid. Had Bush done this, you would have come unglued.

1. War isn't pretty. Sometimes innocent people get killed. The kid had the choice, as did the Al Qaeda leader. They chose badly.
2. Reading minds isn't your forte. You have no idea of what I'd have said or thought about Bush if the same circumstance had occurred on his watch. Find a single post of mine that I criticized Bush for something Obama or Clinton did.
 
All I can say is if the slaughtering of innocent children didn't change gun laws.....nothing will. We have become, ."oh another mass shooting"
 
and you know this how?

I know it no more than you know that she was telling the truth. The only person who can know the answer is herself.

Now, why don't you answer my question regarding what happens if I lose the "ammo purchase" card you want me to have for each of my guns.
 
I know it no more than you know that she was telling the truth. The only person who can know the answer is herself.

Now, why don't you answer my question regarding what happens if I lose the "ammo purchase" card you want me to have for each of my guns.

You are getting wrapped up in minutae. The details of implementation are easy. Getting people like you to agree to discuss a solution is the problem.

...how about this...record all guns on one card in the mag stripe. Lose the card, no problem, bring one gun to a gun store and get a new card by the serial number on that gun....because all guns on the previous card are linked by the card number...by the way, did I mention that I do database design. Now if the gun was stolen and you reported it stolen...the guy holding the gun is in deep shit.
 
I know it no more than you know that she was telling the truth. The only person who can know the answer is herself.

Now, why don't you answer my question regarding what happens if I lose the "ammo purchase" card you want me to have for each of my guns.

Ah, but you said she lied....as if you knew that to be true.
 
You are getting wrapped up in minutae. The details of implementation are easy. Getting people like you to agree to discuss a solution is the problem.

...how about this...record all guns on one card in the mag stripe. Lose the card, no problem, bring one gun to a gun store and get a new card by the serial number on that gun....because all guns on the previous card are linked by the card number...by the way, did I mention that I do database design. Now if the gun was stolen and you reported it stolen...the guy holding the gun is in deep shit.

No, I'm not getting wrapped up in minutia -- my civil rights are in the details if we presume implementation of your scheme.

As I understand it, I'd have some sort of ammo purchase card that would allow me to buy ammo for a specific weapon I own. Somehow this card would be issued by the state, but no record of it would be kept by the state (BTW, I'd have to have about 50 of these cards to encompass the ammo for my entire collection, and the idea doesn't even encompass ammo such as the 11.7x44R that I have to make from components).

The card is somehow lost, stolen or damaged. I'm presuming that the law would prevent me from legally having the gun or ammo for it without the card, so your option of bringing the (now unauthorized) firearm to the gun store seems impossible.

You're also resting a lot on the security of the store's database. Who is the administrator for that database? Who has access to it? If the government does, then we're back to "this is gun registration." If it doesn't, who has oversight to ensure that fact?

Bottom line, this looks like a huge complication to my civil right to keep and bear arms. Would you impose a similar restriction on the purchase of printers ink and press supplies?
 
No, I'm not getting wrapped up in minutia -- my civil rights are in the details if we presume implementation of your scheme.

As I understand it, I'd have some sort of ammo purchase card that would allow me to buy ammo for a specific weapon I own. Somehow this card would be issued by the state, but no record of it would be kept by the state (BTW, I'd have to have about 50 of these cards to encompass the ammo for my entire collection, and the idea doesn't even encompass ammo such as the 11.7x44R that I have to make from components).

The card is somehow lost, stolen or damaged. I'm presuming that the law would prevent me from legally having the gun or ammo for it without the card, so your option of bringing the (now unauthorized) firearm to the gun store seems impossible.

You're also resting a lot on the security of the store's database. Who is the administrator for that database? Who has access to it? If the government does, then we're back to "this is gun registration." If it doesn't, who has oversight to ensure that fact?

Bottom line, this looks like a huge complication to my civil right to keep and bear arms. Would you impose a similar restriction on the purchase of printers ink and press supplies?

Selective memory, eh Trap.

I never said that you have to carry the card to prove you are allowed to own the gun. I said you have to show the card to buy ammo.

I already pointed out that you could record the info for every gun you own on one card. When you sell the gun the purchase info on your card is invalid for that gun. Whether or not you'd want to erase and rewrite that card is an implementation detail.

The FBI would keep the data base. I've already told you what the database would look like. It would contain the serial number of the gun, the caliber, the date of the background check (not really necessary, but could be useful) and the serial number of the card. The card gets lost...no problem, the FBI does a lookup on that gun, gets the serial number of the card and recreates a new card. The dealer hands you a new card.

You keep making shit up to use as an objection....same shit, each and every time. In any case, the APL card is one way that we could improve on who has access to guns without a registration system. It is an idea that has been adopted by nobody...so it is just interesting conversation for me....

That has nothing at all to do with universal background checks.
 
S
elective memory, eh Trap.

I never said that you have to carry the card to prove you are allowed to own the gun. I said you have to show the card to buy ammo.

What about powder, primers and projectiles -- ammo components? Can I still buy them on-line at Cabelas as I can today?

I already pointed out that you could record the info for every gun you own on one card. When you sell the gun the purchase info on your card is invalid for that gun. Whether or not you'd want to erase and rewrite that card is an implementation detail.

But the way you set it up, before, the record of my ownership was on the card, and the card was issued via the store. Now, suppose I want to sell you the gun, but we go to a different store to get the background check done. How is the data removed from the first store's database? It sounds like we're talking a secure network connecting all FFLs -- and immediately I go to the assumption that this network would be administered via the good offices of the BATF -- meaning we're talking registry.

The FBI would keep the data base. I've already told you what the database would look like. It would contain the serial number of the gun, the caliber, the date of the background check (not really necessary, but could be useful) and the serial number of the card. The card gets lost...no problem, the FBI does a lookup on that gun, gets the serial number of the card and recreates a new card. The dealer hands you a new card.

If the FBI has the database, you're just flat out saying it's a registry. It's going to track the gun, the serial number (I'm not certain what you do about guns made before 1968 -- serial numbers weren't required before that date), caliber (what if I change the caliber?), and the serial number of the CARD -- the serial number of the card is attached to the card holder -- and it's a registry.

Oh -- and there's this -- I steal a gun. I take it to the gun store and say, "I lost my card, can you issue me a new one based on this serial number?" and walk out a few minutes later with a "legally owned" gun for which I can buy ammo.

You keep making shit up to use as an objection....same shit, each and every time. In any case, the APL card is one way that we could improve on who has access to guns without a registration system. It is an idea that has been adopted by nobody...so it is just interesting conversation for me....

No more than you are making up this system. I'm merely pointing out some real-world things about guns, gun sales, and federal bureacracy. The feds would no more allow the issuance of a card without the means to track the card than they would allow the issuance of an FFL to someone without means to track the FFL. You want universal background checks? Show a way that doesn't amount to registration -- your current proposal doesn't do that in the real world. It doesn't account for ammo components (handloading is among the fastest growing firearms related policies). It doesn't account for pre-68 guns with no serial numbers. It doesn't account for how a database of gun sales and serial numbers is NOT a registry of guns.[/quote]
 
Last edited:
1. War isn't pretty. Sometimes innocent people get killed. The kid had the choice, as did the Al Qaeda leader. They chose badly.
2. Reading minds isn't your forte. You have no idea of what I'd have said or thought about Bush if the same circumstance had occurred on his watch. Find a single post of mine that I criticized Bush for something Obama or Clinton did.

1: And if we;re going to be lobbing missiles at people you would think we would hit the right people.

2: Bullshit. You're one of the three biggest Obama apologists on the board.
 
1: And if we;re going to be lobbing missiles at people you would think we would hit the right people.

2: Bullshit. You're one of the three biggest Obama apologists on the board.

1. We did. Too bad the kid was standing too close.
2. Find a single post of mine that I criticized Bush for something Obama or Clinton did.
 
What about powder, primers and projectiles -- ammo components? Can I still buy them on-line at Cabelas as I can today?

That is funny. You think your purchase of these supplies isn't recorded by Cabelas? Target stores has a record of everything you purchase going back quite a while. So registration of your purchases isn't an issue, eh?

But the way you set it up, before, the record of my ownership was on the card, and the card was issued via the store. Now, suppose I want to sell you the gun, but we go to a different store to get the background check done. How is the data removed from the first store's database? It sounds like we're talking a secure network connecting all FFLs -- and immediately I go to the assumption that this network would be administered via the good offices of the BATF -- meaning we're talking registry.

There was no link to you in the FBI database. When the gun store printed off your card they'd include a picture of you on the card, but there would not be a record of your personal identification anywhere except for on the card itself.

If the FBI has the database, you're just flat out saying it's a registry. It's going to track the gun, the serial number (I'm not certain what you do about guns made before 1968 -- serial numbers weren't required before that date) (but most guns manufactured back as far as 1918 do) , caliber (what if I change the caliber?), and the serial number of the CARD -- the serial number of the card is attached to the card holder -- and it's a registry.

You constantly seem to want to change the definition of registry. The record of your gun and the caliber does not have a link to your name and address.

Oh -- and there's this -- I steal a gun. I take it to the gun store and say, "I lost my card, can you issue me a new one based on this serial number?" and walk out a few minutes later with a "legally owned" gun for which I can buy ammo.

If you reported the gun stolen then the guy trying to get a new APL would be apprehended. If you hadn't reported it yet then as soon as you do the card would be invalid and the next time he tries to get bullets he goes to jail. If you never report the gun stolen then the next time you try to buy ammo for another gun on that card....you have a problem, because your card is now invalid, since it was reissued.

No more than you are making up this system. I'm merely pointing out some real-world things about guns, gun sales, and federal bureacracy. The feds would no more allow the issuance of a card without the means to track the card than they would allow the issuance of an FFL to someone without means to track the FFL. You want universal background checks? Show a way that doesn't amount to registration -- your current proposal doesn't do that in the real world. It doesn't account for ammo components (handloading is among the fastest growing firearms related policies). It doesn't account for pre-68 guns with no serial numbers. It doesn't account for how a database of gun sales and serial numbers is NOT a registry of guns.

I've shown one way. You seem to think that picking nits in that idea means that there is no way that anything can be done. In fact I've already explained that we can have universal background checks, charge someone as an accomplice if they transfer a gun without a background check and a crime is committed (by someone who couldn't pass a BC)....and we'd get a huge change in the availability of guns for known felons or people undergoing psych care who can't pass a BC. Most people wouldn't have a problem....and what matters is not perfect compliance, but a majority.
 
Last edited:
Because to give a UBC the force of law you have to keep a record of the transaction. I.e. serial number of the gun and the owner. DE FACTO national gun registry. Too many people won't tolerate that.

Actually, no you don't. If you sold a gun to me and I am an ex-felon and commit a crime with that gun....you can be sure I'd throw you under the bus. If I have any evidence to offer that I got the gun from you....IE a canceled check, the date I bought it...a description of you and your name and address...you're screwed.
 
Actually, no you don't. If you sold a gun to me and I am an ex-felon and commit a crime with that gun....you can be sure I'd throw you under the bus. If I have any evidence to offer that I got the gun from you....IE a canceled check, the date I bought it...a description of you and your name and address...you're screwed.

I have no idea what point you're trying to make. If I sold a gun to you legally under a UBC law the transfer would be recorded. Your name and the guns serial number would go in a database. A default national gun registry to be used to confiscate all legal weapons.

If there is an illegal transfer w/ or w/o UBC none of what you said about buses, checks, dates, or descriptions makes any sense. You need some real world experiences MV.
 
I have no idea what point you're trying to make. If I sold a gun to you legally under a UBC law the transfer would be recorded. Your name and the guns serial number would go in a database. A default national gun registry to be used to confiscate all legal weapons.

If there is an illegal transfer w/ or w/o UBC none of what you said about buses, checks, dates, or descriptions makes any sense. You need some real world experiences MV.

Nobody is talking about implementing registration except for you and Trap.
 
a door knob everyone should have:; wait, libs probably scare to open the door.

1236304_437497126370521_1029295466_n.jpg
 
Back
Top