New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Universal Background Checks

And my objections to it are similarly made in the spirit of conversation -- but when you fail to provide any solutions to the problems I've raised, do you strengthen or weaken the idea? You want more background checks? I want an ironclad protection of my civil liberties.

I once knew a defense attorney who said, "People are always saying that criminals get off on technicalities. I call those technicalities 'My client's constitutional rights."
I feel the same way about gun control proposals -- an inconvenience to my right to arms is just like an inconvenience to my right to speech. A right delayed is a right denied.

Really? Talk about an absurd reliance on rhetoric....so if that is the case let's require instantaneous delivery of weapons to your door. As soon as you think you need a gun....the government will FEDEX it to you. No sense in making you wait for a drive to the gun store.

You want an ironclad guarantee....just what form would that take? Your resistance to reasonable attempts at finding a solution will not do the job for you. Too bad you don't see that. One day there will be an even larger and more shocking massacre and there will be a rush to some solution any solution....much like the Patriot act after 911.
 
Really? Talk about an absurd reliance on rhetoric....so if that is the case let's require instantaneous delivery of weapons to your door. As soon as you think you need a gun....the government will FEDEX it to you. No sense in making you wait for a drive to the gun store.

You want an ironclad guarantee....just what form would that take? Your resistance to reasonable attempts at finding a solution will not do the job for you. Too bad you don't see that. One day there will be an even larger and more shocking massacre and there will be a rush to some solution any solution....much like the Patriot act after 911.


Yeah, a Somali kid will set off a bomb (not gun) in Minneapolis in the name of Allah.

Crazies will use bombs, poisons, and knives when guns are banned. I'd prefer a crazy w/ a gun than bombs or poison or even a knife in a classroom of toddlers.
 
Really? Talk about an absurd reliance on rhetoric....so if that is the case let's require instantaneous delivery of weapons to your door. As soon as you think you need a gun....the government will FEDEX it to you. No sense in making you wait for a drive to the gun store.

Before 1968, we had exactly that -- mail order firearms were a common phenomena. Sears and Montgomery-Ward could ship a semi-automatic rifle directly to your address. After the 1968 Gun Control Act made this illegal, crime rates actually increased for at least 5 years (GCA '68 didn't cause the increase -- but neither did a lack of mail-order guns ameliorate the increase).

You want an ironclad guarantee....just what form would that take? Your resistance to reasonable attempts at finding a solution will not do the job for you. Too bad you don't see that. One day there will be an even larger and more shocking massacre and there will be a rush to some solution any solution....much like the Patriot act after 911.

I've said it time and again -- you want universal background checks. I want no further requirements. You show me a background check law that comes with a guarantee that Feinstein (or someone like her) can't come back and ask for the construction of a registry, a ban on a type of weapons, etcetera, six months down the road, and you can get my support. Gun owners are expected to take a pig in a poke. "We just want this 'common sense' reform," -- which always come with the subtext of "for now, we'll ask for more later."
 
Before 1968, we had exactly that -- mail order firearms were a common phenomena. Sears and Montgomery-Ward could ship a semi-automatic rifle directly to your address. After the 1968 Gun Control Act made this illegal, crime rates actually increased for at least 5 years (GCA '68 didn't cause the increase -- but neither did a lack of mail-order guns ameliorate the increase).



I've said it time and again -- you want universal background checks. I want no further requirements. You show me a background check law that comes with a guarantee that Feinstein (or someone like her) can't come back and ask for the construction of a registry, a ban on a type of weapons, etcetera, six months down the road, and you can get my support. Gun owners are expected to take a pig in a poke. "We just want this 'common sense' reform," -- which always come with the subtext of "for now, we'll ask for more later."

Yeah, the Sears Catalog used to carry Thompsons....that was until people got sick of the gangsters spraying neighborhoods with them. Ah, the good old days.

Guarantee? Just how in hell would you write into law a bill that couldn't be repealed? Obama wants to know.
 
Yeah, the Sears Catalog used to carry Thompsons....that was until people got sick of the gangsters spraying neighborhoods with them. Ah, the good old days.

Guarantee? Just how in hell would you write into law a bill that couldn't be repealed? Obama wants to know.

The Sears catalog is an unlikely source for gangsters, who probably bought locally. Immaterial, really, as we're not talking about fully-automatic weapons. You were attempting to make some statement that delaying individual civil rights is not the same thing as denying them. Do you feel the same about a speedy trial? Or would holding someone until the trial, but never having a trial, strike you as somehow wrong?

Well, delaying my ability to exercise my rights is the same concept. If you can delay it 10 minutes, you can delay it 24 hours -- if you can delay it a week, you can delay it indefinitely.

The problem you pose about legislation is the reason that I will oppose any new gun legislation. You are absolutely right that it is impossible for this Congress to act so as to bind the actions of a future Congress. In the absence of such a guarantee, I've seen that I have no reason to trust the opposition. I've seen them make claims about firearms and firearms owners that are untrue. I've seen them call for a short-term action, and then attempt to extend that into perpetuity. I've seen them vote in favor of a restriction saying "this is enough," and then come back in the next Congressional session seeking more.

Why should I give an inch? Especially when it amounts to giving a mile one inch at a time? I've asked before, and never received an answer -- what's in it for the gun owner? All we seem to be expected to do is smile and pretend the erosion of our rights incrementally is better than their denial all at once.
 
The Sears catalog is an unlikely source for gangsters, who probably bought locally. Immaterial, really, as we're not talking about fully-automatic weapons. You were attempting to make some statement that delaying individual civil rights is not the same thing as denying them. Do you feel the same about a speedy trial? Or would holding someone until the trial, but never having a trial, strike you as somehow wrong?

Well, delaying my ability to exercise my rights is the same concept. If you can delay it 10 minutes, you can delay it 24 hours -- if you can delay it a week, you can delay it indefinitely.

The problem you pose about legislation is the reason that I will oppose any new gun legislation. You are absolutely right that it is impossible for this Congress to act so as to bind the actions of a future Congress. In the absence of such a guarantee, I've seen that I have no reason to trust the opposition. I've seen them make claims about firearms and firearms owners that are untrue. I've seen them call for a short-term action, and then attempt to extend that into perpetuity. I've seen them vote in favor of a restriction saying "this is enough," and then come back in the next Congressional session seeking more.

Why should I give an inch? Especially when it amounts to giving a mile one inch at a time? I've asked before, and never received an answer -- what's in it for the gun owner? All we seem to be expected to do is smile and pretend the erosion of our rights incrementally is better than their denial all at once.

Yeah, that is what we all should say about anything...what's in it for me. If preventing an ex-felon or other individual who should not own a gun isn't enough then I guess the conversation with you is useless....it is far more important that if you have a spontaneous urge to give a gun to your nephew hits you, God forbid you have to make a trip to the gun store.

I hope the event never occurs that you have a child or someone you know killed by somebody with a gun that a change you opposed may have prevented....
 
Yeah, that is what we all should say about anything...what's in it for me. If preventing an ex-felon or other individual who should not own a gun isn't enough then I guess the conversation with you is useless....it is far more important that if you have a spontaneous urge to give a gun to your nephew hits you, God forbid you have to make a trip to the gun store.

I hope the event never occurs that you have a child or someone you know killed by somebody with a gun that a change you opposed may have prevented....


I notice you still didn't answer the question. No, simply denying someone who has forfeited their rights is not sufficient. It would be easy to imprison more criminals if we simply denied the accused their civil rights, but we don't do that. Neither do we achieve additional safety by interfering with the rights of non-criminals in the name of keeping rights from being misused by criminals.

How would this change prevent anything? Background checks, even universal ones, do not keep very many criminals from getting guns. As I've pointed out repeatedly, Cho, Loughner, Holmes and Alexis all underwent background checks -- their massacres went forward just as though the background checks hadn't occurred. So at best, you might keep guns out of the hands of someone with a criminal record, but at worst you interfere with the rights of millions of citizens without any result at all.

So I ask again -- why should we give an inch?
 
Yeah, that is what we all should say about anything...what's in it for me. If preventing an ex-felon or other individual who should not own a gun isn't enough then I guess the conversation with you is useless....it is far more important that if you have a spontaneous urge to give a gun to your nephew hits you, God forbid you have to make a trip to the gun store.

I hope the event never occurs that you have a child or someone you know killed by somebody with a gun that a change you opposed may have prevented....
There it is, right on time.... the emotional cheap shot. Ya'll always pull that out of your ass when you can't answer the questions.
 
I notice you still didn't answer the question. No, simply denying someone who has forfeited their rights is not sufficient. It would be easy to imprison more criminals if we simply denied the accused their civil rights, but we don't do that. Neither do we achieve additional safety by interfering with the rights of non-criminals in the name of keeping rights from being misused by criminals.

How would this change prevent anything? Background checks, even universal ones, do not keep very many criminals from getting guns. As I've pointed out repeatedly, Cho, Loughner, Holmes and Alexis all underwent background checks -- their massacres went forward just as though the background checks hadn't occurred. So at best, you might keep guns out of the hands of someone with a criminal record, but at worst you interfere with the rights of millions of citizens without any result at all.

So I ask again -- why should we give an inch?

I answer your questions...you ask them again. Do you ever read the reply?
 
There it is, right on time.... the emotional cheap shot. Ya'll always pull that out of your ass when you can't answer the questions.

Right. Emotion should have nothing at all to do with the conversation. Let's just keep it to "what's in it for me".
 
Right. Emotion should have nothing at all to do with the conversation. Let's just keep it to "what's in it for me".
When we're discussing civil rights and law you're damn right decisions shouldn't be made from emotion. And for the record, I seriously doubt anyone else on this board has lost as many friends to gunfire as I have, and you don't see me demanding anyone give up their rights.
 
Right. Emotion should have nothing at all to do with the conversation. Let's just keep it to "what's in it for me".

Emotion shouldn't have anything to do with the conversation. Legislation based on people's emotions is universally bad legislation -- rushed through in the heat of the moment without consideration of its downrange impact. The Patriot Act springs to mind.

And yes, our system of government is designed to emphasize and protect the rights of the individual. "What's in it for me?" is a wholly legitimate question -- one that you have not made any real attempt to answer.
 
Emotion shouldn't have anything to do with the conversation. Legislation based on people's emotions is universally bad legislation -- rushed through in the heat of the moment without consideration of its downrange impact. The Patriot Act springs to mind.

And yes, our system of government is designed to emphasize and protect the rights of the individual. "What's in it for me?" is a wholly legitimate question -- one that you have not made any real attempt to answer.

I disagree. I did answer your question.
 
When we're discussing civil rights and law you're damn right decisions shouldn't be made from emotion. And for the record, I seriously doubt anyone else on this board has lost as many friends to gunfire as I have, and you don't see me demanding anyone give up their rights.

You've lost friends to gunfire in the streets of the US?
 
When we're discussing civil rights and law you're damn right decisions shouldn't be made from emotion. And for the record, I seriously doubt anyone else on this board has lost as many friends to gunfire as I have, and you don't see me demanding anyone give up their rights.

1. There is no constitutional arguments against background checks.
2. I was not appealing to anyone's emotions. I offered an answer to "what's in it for me".
 
1. There is no constitutional arguments against background checks.
2. I was not appealing to anyone's emotions. I offered an answer to "what's in it for me".
1. But they just don't seem to work, do they? Yet you continue to want to "double-down" on a bad idea...
2. Oh, the hell you weren't.....
 
1. But they just don't seem to work, do they? Yet you continue to want to "double-down" on a bad idea...
2. Oh, the hell you weren't.....
1. Gee, where is your "unconstitutional" argument....now it's just...."But they don't work" crap.
2. What is in it for him is the process that just might make it harder for ex-felons to buy guns. How emotional is that?
 
Breaking News at 5: four shooters arrested for shooting in Chicago......if 'O' had 'son's they would look like 'O'..........
 
1. Gee, where is your "unconstitutional" argument....now it's just...."But they don't work" crap.
2. What is in it for him is the process that just might make it harder for ex-felons to buy guns. How emotional is that?
1. Pointing out that a dysfunctional system, that you continuously want to make ever more restrictive, is an infringement on my constitutional rights, while true, hasn't really made any impact on you, MV. Thought I'd try something different....
2. If you think I'm OK with giving up my civil liberties because it "just might" help, you're out of your mind. I'm not OK with giving them up if you had irrefutable proof that it would help.
 
Back
Top