New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Universal Background Checks

1. Pointing out that a dysfunctional system, that you continuously want to make ever more restrictive, is an infringement on my constitutional rights, while true, hasn't really made any impact on you, MV. Thought I'd try something different....
2. If you think I'm OK with giving up my civil liberties because it "just might" help, you're out of your mind. I'm not OK with giving them up if you had irrefutable proof that it would help.
1. No...the dysfunctional system is that it only covered less than half of all gun sales....changing that is a step in the right direction and you still have not told me where in the constitution it says background checks are not allowed.
2. No...there is no civil liberty that is taken away by requiring background checks. If there were then the BCs required when you buy a gun at a gun store would already have been thrown out.
 
1. No...the dysfunctional system is that it only covered less than half of all gun sales....changing that is a step in the right direction and you still have not told me where in the constitution it says background checks are not allowed.
2. No...there is no civil liberty that is taken away by requiring background checks. If there were then the BCs required when you buy a gun at a gun store would already have been thrown out.
So, let me suggest something; we go to UBCs like you want, all transfers require a BC, ok? Say we do this for 10 years, and when this measure fails to keep prohibited persons from obtaining guns, at the end of that 10yr period we do away with all BCs period. Sound good?
As for #2, I'm pretty sure you and I have different things in mind, when the words "civil liberties" and "freedom" are being used.....
 
So, let me suggest something; we go to UBCs like you want, all transfers require a BC, ok? Say we do this for 10 years, and when this measure fails to keep prohibited persons from obtaining guns, at the end of that 10yr period we do away with all BCs period. Sound good?

And what yardstick would we use to determine success or failure?

As for #2, I'm pretty sure you and I have different things in mind, when the words "civil liberties" and "freedom" are being used....

Since you seem to think it is your constitutional right to sell guns to who ever you choose...yes

.

It really is too bad that all legislation isn't written with a series of checks that either require change or repeal of the expected results don't match actual.
 
It really is too bad that all legislation isn't written with a series of checks that either require change or repeal of the expected results don't match actual.
BTW, I also believe that free men don't ask permission to do things they have every right to do, they just do them.
 
BTW, I also believe that free men don't ask permission to do things they have every right to do, they just do them.

It is almost always the case that one person's rights may infringe on someone else's. It isn't always black and white, that your right to do something is not an infringement of my rights....smoking comes to mind.
 
Sure thing. You gonna call Obama or should I?
So if a law repeatedly fails to perform as advertised then you'd be ok with scrapping the whole idea? That's strange because BCs have never worked for shit, and yet you continually want to expand them....
 
So if a law repeatedly fails to perform as advertised then you'd be ok with scrapping the whole idea? That's strange because BCs have never worked for shit, and yet you continually want to expand them....

How could it work if only sales at gun stores are covered?

The law against murder seems to be failing....should we repeal it?
 
How could it work if only sales at gun stores are covered?

The law against murder seems to be failing....should we repeal it?
The law against murder is working just fine; when someone commits one we arrest them and charge them and prosecute them. We don't do that to all the folks who haven't murdered anyone.....
 
The law against murder is working just fine; when someone commits one we arrest them and charge them and prosecute them. We don't do that to all the folks who haven't murdered anyone.....

And the law related to background checks works well as far as preventing criminals from buying guns at gun stores.
 
And the law related to background checks works well as far as preventing criminals from buying guns at gun stores.
Really? Loughner, Cho, Alexis...... I sure am glad I put up with this BS in order to keep folks like this from buying guns in a store.... oh wait :rolleyes:. And then all those gang shootings and street crime are actually committed by underage bangers who are already prohibited by their age and their extensive criminal records, and so they don't shop at the local gun store much. You were in one the other day you said; did you see any teenage gangbangers in there?
 
Really? Loughner, Cho, Alexis...... I sure am glad I put up with this BS in order to keep folks like this from buying guns in a store.... oh wait :rolleyes:. And then all those gang shootings and street crime are actually committed by underage bangers who are already prohibited by their age and their extensive criminal records, and so they don't shop at the local gun store much. You were in one the other day you said; did you see any teenage gangbangers in there?

I get so tired of answering the same NRA talking points....

1. Only 19 states have mandated that court direct psychiatric care is reported.
2. Loughner was expelled unless he underwent psychiatric care. There is no requirement to report that action. Too bad. Maybe if we found a way to have required that to have been reported lives would have been saved.
3. Cho was ordered by a court to undergo psych care. It wasn't reported.

How many of those gang bangers are buying their guns at Cabellas? None? Hmm, so I guess that part of the BC rules works. So where to they get their guns? The FBI did a survey. More than half of the prisoners participating in the survey said they got their guns from family and friends. Very few said they'd used stolen guns. How would BCs stop that? I'd make it part of the law that if you sold a gun without a BC to someone who commits a crime, you are liable for prosecution as an accomplice...

I've told you all this before. Write it down. Please don't ask again. It is annoying.
 
I get so tired of answering the same NRA talking points....

1. Only 19 states have mandated that court direct psychiatric care is reported.
2. Loughner was expelled unless he underwent psychiatric care. There is no requirement to report that action. Too bad. Maybe if we found a way to have required that to have been reported lives would have been saved.
3. Cho was ordered by a court to undergo psych care. It wasn't reported.

How many of those gang bangers are buying their guns at Cabellas? None? Hmm, so I guess that part of the BC rules works. So where to they get their guns? The FBI did a survey. More than half of the prisoners participating in the survey said they got their guns from family and friends. Very few said they'd used stolen guns. How would BCs stop that? I'd make it part of the law that if you sold a gun without a BC to someone who commits a crime, you are liable for prosecution as an accomplice...

I've told you all this before. Write it down. Please don't ask again. It is annoying.
I find it annoying that you refuse to let reality interfere with your beliefs, and that you don't acknowledge firearms ownership as a civil right. I find it especially annoying that you keep demanding I give mine away; it's mine.... if you want to piss yours away I won't stop you, but you don't get to take me down with you.
 
I find it annoying that you refuse to let reality interfere with your beliefs, and that you don't acknowledge firearms ownership as a civil right. I find it especially annoying that you keep demanding I give mine away; it's mine.... if you want to piss yours away I won't stop you, but you don't get to take me down with you.

You changed your avatar!!! Wth?

Firearms aren't the civil right. Individual self defense is the right. As technology goes forward I expect that concept to be respected. I'm getting my light saber dammit. :0)
 
Back
Top