New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Universal Background Checks

I find it annoying that you refuse to let reality interfere with your beliefs, and that you don't acknowledge firearms ownership as a civil right. I find it especially annoying that you keep demanding I give mine away; it's mine.... if you want to piss yours away I won't stop you, but you don't get to take me down with you.

When did I demand you give yours away? Are you ADHD or what? That you create your own reality, in spite of all the posts of mine you've read, is pretty annoying.
 
When did I demand you give yours away? Are you ADHD or what? That you create your own reality, in spite of all the posts of mine you've read, is pretty annoying.

What's annoying is I've asked you about how you are going to stop crazies from using bombs, poisons, or knives when guns are difficult to get and/or banned. Even a couple of dumb asses could figure out how to make pressure cooker bombs. Shut up about your UBC idea. It is a crock pot bomb of unworkable shiest. :0)

love ya MV.
 
When did I demand you give yours away? Are you ADHD or what? That you create your own reality, in spite of all the posts of mine you've read, is pretty annoying.
You want me and every other gun owner to allow condition after condition after condition to be placed on the exercise of our rights. If this was asked of any other civil right, the ACLU would be coming after ya'll with pitchforks and torches in hand, but they turn punk when it's about the 2A. Every one of these bullshit conditions has the stated goal of making things "safer", but every one of them fails to do so, and leads ya'll right back asking for more. NO!!! No more.... I don't want to hear about one more or hoop I have to jump through or even so much as a single piece of paper; none of these laws work at making anyone "safer". They work at annoying the living shit out of gun owners which was the goal all along, discouragement thru harassment. Take this bullshit somewhere else.....
 
You want me and every other gun owner to allow condition after condition after condition to be placed on the exercise of our rights. If this was asked of any other civil right, the ACLU would be coming after ya'll with pitchforks and torches in hand, but they turn punk when it's about the 2A. Every one of these bullshit conditions has the stated goal of making things "safer", but every one of them fails to do so, and leads ya'll right back asking for more. NO!!! No more.... I don't want to hear about one more or hoop I have to jump through or even so much as a single piece of paper; none of these laws work at making anyone "safer". They work at annoying the living shit out of gun owners which was the goal all along, discouragement thru harassment. Take this bullshit somewhere else.....

You're awful whiny this morning. There was no point to having background checks if there were going to be so many loopholes. That was the fault of people who wanted no gun control at all and only accepted half measures. Less than half of all gun sales are subject to background checks. It is idiotic to argue that everyone should be allowed to buy guns, but you have no solution to the guns that are easily bought by criminals.

Take your own whines to where you can get all the cheese you need....there is no right to sell guns to criminals for you to defend.
 
You're awful whiny this morning. There was no point to having background checks if there were going to be so many loopholes. That was the fault of people who wanted no gun control at all and only accepted half measures. Less than half of all gun sales are subject to background checks. It is idiotic to argue that everyone should be allowed to buy guns, but you have no solution to the guns that are easily bought by criminals.

Take your own whines to where you can get all the cheese you need....there is no right to sell guns to criminals for you to defend.
I got a headache.... The point to instituting BCs was so that when they failed, ya'll could use that as an excuse to ask for more restrictions. Like you're doing now.....
My solution to criminals is to arrest them and put them in jail for the crimes they commit, (assault, murder, robbery, etc.) not try to dream up new crimes I can get them for, (failing to do a BC before selling a pistol to my BIL? Seriously?). I don't care if a guy has a gun felon or no, I care if he's using it to hurt or threaten someone. If he isn't hurting anybody, then what's your problem?
 
I got a headache.... The point to instituting BCs was so that when they failed, ya'll could use that as an excuse to ask for more restrictions. Like you're doing now.....
My solution to criminals is to arrest them and put them in jail for the crimes they commit, (assault, murder, robbery, etc.) not try to dream up new crimes I can get them for, (failing to do a BC before selling a pistol to my BIL? Seriously?). I don't care if a guy has a gun felon or no, I care if he's using it to hurt or threaten someone. If he isn't hurting anybody, then what's your problem?

So the people who first put BCs in place put loopholes in so they could fail? That is a pretty silly statement. In fact the NRA said "Oh, ok....background checks for FFL holders....but not gun shows or person to person private sales" and created a huge problem. Even the idea of an FFL holder converting his inventory to his own personal collection and then selling without a BC is nuts.

It has already been ruled constitutional to not allow ex-felons to either vote or own guns. Do you know what the word recidivism pertains to? The likelihood that someone who has committed a felony will commit another one.....Having committed a crime means that part of the punishment is that you can't own a gun. You don't seem to mind that there are no uniform rules for people ordered to undergo psychiatric care being reported to the BC database. How would it ever work with each state making their own rules? That is why strict gun control in NYC or Chicago could never work if you could drive out of the city and fill the trunk of your car with handguns.
 
I disagree. I did answer your question.

No, you did not. You deplored the fact that I asked the question -- you did nothing to say anything about "what in it for the gun owner." Another question is, "how do you go about protecting the civil rights of the gun owner?"
 
So the people who first put BCs in place put loopholes in so they could fail? That is a pretty silly statement. ...
Just as an aside, it's the same argument some liberals make about the ACA... that the Republicans got all kinds of bad stuff put into it just so that when it passed, it would fail.
 
So the people who first put BCs in place put loopholes in so they could fail? That is a pretty silly statement. In fact the NRA said "Oh, ok....background checks for FFL holders....but not gun shows or person to person private sales" and created a huge problem. Even the idea of an FFL holder converting his inventory to his own personal collection and then selling without a BC is nuts.

It's also essentially impossible to do. Even if you have a curio and relic license you have to log the purchases and sales into your records.

It has already been ruled constitutional to not allow ex-felons to either vote or own guns.

But it is also unconstitutional to require the felon to make any record that he has a gun. In the case Haynes v. US, SCOTUS ruled that felons cannot be required to register guns because it violates their 5th Amendment rights.

Do you know what the word recidivism pertains to? The likelihood that someone who has committed a felony will commit another one.....Having committed a crime means that part of the punishment is that you can't own a gun. You don't seem to mind that there are no uniform rules for people ordered to undergo psychiatric care being reported to the BC database. How would it ever work with each state making their own rules? That is why strict gun control in NYC or Chicago could never work if you could drive out of the city and fill the trunk of your car with handguns.

Rules that make perfect sense in Wyoming or Montana make no sense in LA and vice versa. One size doesn't fit all.
 
No, you did not. You deplored the fact that I asked the question -- you did nothing to say anything about "what in it for the gun owner." Another question is, "how do you go about protecting the civil rights of the gun owner?"

I guess the answer was too subtle for you...HERE IS THE ANSWER
preventing an ex-felon or other individual who should not own a gun from being able to buy one.
 
I guess the answer was too subtle for you...HERE IS THE ANSWER
preventing an ex-felon or other individual who should not own a gun from being able to buy one.

I'm sorry, but that's not "in it" for the typical gun owner. What do you offer them? What protection do you offer their civil rights?
 
It's also essentially impossible to do. Even if you have a curio and relic license you have to log the purchases and sales into your records.

I swear...having a conversation with you gets harder and harder....the conversation was about loopholes to rules about background checks.....remember? What the hell does logging the sale have to do with that?

But it is also unconstitutional to require the felon to make any record that he has a gun. In the case Haynes v. US, SCOTUS ruled that felons cannot be required to register guns because it violates their 5th Amendment rights.

And that is related to background checks how, exactly?

Rules that make perfect sense in Wyoming or Montana make no sense in LA and vice versa. One size doesn't fit all.

Oh, I see...so it makes no sense to close the loopholes on background checks then...right?
 
I swear...having a conversation with you gets harder and harder....the conversation was about loopholes to rules about background checks.....remember? What the hell does logging the sale have to do with that?


I don't know -- you introduced it when you introduced the fallacy of FFLs converting their inventory to private stock and then selling them without background checks.

But it is also unconstitutional to require the felon to make any record that he has a gun. In the case Haynes v. US, SCOTUS ruled that felons cannot be required to register guns because it violates their 5th Amendment rights.

And that is related to background checks how, exactly?

Simple -- under that ruling, the felon could not legally be forced to undergo a background check. Doing so would be forcing him to admit he was violating the law -- a violation of his 5th Amendment rights as cited in the court case Hayne v. U.S.

Rules that make perfect sense in Wyoming or Montana make no sense in LA and vice versa. One size doesn't fit all.

Oh, I see...so it makes no sense to close the loopholes on background checks then...right?

I know of no "loopholes" on background checks. I don't acknowledge the idea that my private transactions should be subject to such checks -- that doesn't mean I'm using a loophole if I sell one of my guns.[/quote]
 
I'm sorry, but that's not "in it" for the typical gun owner. What do you offer them? What protection do you offer their civil rights?

Really? So you feel comfortable speaking for all gun owners and know that none of them care about ex-felons and people ordered to undergo psychiatric are being able to buy guns....funny thing but the polls disagree with you. Most people are in favor of universal background checks.

Your civil rights are well protected and, in my opinion, need no additional protections...but feel free to come up with any ideas of your own.
 
Really? So you feel comfortable speaking for all gun owners and know that none of them care about ex-felons and people ordered to undergo psychiatric are being able to buy guns....funny thing but the polls disagree with you. Most people are in favor of universal background checks.

Your civil rights are well protected and, in my opinion, need no additional protections...but feel free to come up with any ideas of your own.

No, I don't think many of them worry about ex felons. Are ex felons even really the problem? The current call for expanded background checks stems largely from the mass shooters -- all but one of whom had passed a background check, and none of whom had felony records.

I don't feel unsafe with the laws as they are -- if you want to change them, you have to offer a protection for the civil rights of the law abiding as well as the restriction you want -- otherwise you'll never get it off the ground politically.
 
Last edited:
I don't know -- you introduced it when you introduced the fallacy of FFLs converting their inventory to private stock and then selling them without background checks.

How is it a fallacy? How does logging the sale accomplish the same thing as a background check? I guess you must be in Europe. Too early for cocktails here.

Simple -- under that ruling, the felon could not legally be forced to undergo a background check. Doing so would be forcing him to admit he was violating the law -- a violation of his 5th Amendment rights as cited in the court case Hayne v. U.S.

Absolute rubbish. Do you have any court rulings that background checks are unconstitutional?

I know of no "loopholes" on background checks. I don't acknowledge the idea that my private transactions should be subject to such checks -- that doesn't mean I'm using a loophole if I sell one of my guns.

Having a law that says gun sales require a background check EXCEPT......establishes loopholes. Playing semantics with me isn't going to win any debating points. The purpose of the background checks is clear. The exceptions defeat that purpose.
 
No, I don't think many of them worry about ex felons. Are ex felons even really the problem? The current call for expanded background checks stems largely from the mass shooters -- all but one of whom had passed a background check, and none of whom were had felony records.

I don't feel unsafe with the laws as they are -- if you want to change them, you have to offer a protection for the civil rights of the law abiding as well as the restriction you want -- otherwise you'll never get it off the ground politically.

The only reason Universal background checks didn't pass is entirely due to the NRA, not the political reality of what the voters wanted.

I've already answered the issues of the rash of mass shootings and how they got guns, yet you continue to bring them up as if it is fresh evidence supporting your opinions..you're wrong....


Time to go to work....later.....
 
So the people who first put BCs in place put loopholes in so they could fail? That is a pretty silly statement. In fact the NRA said "Oh, ok....background checks for FFL holders....but not gun shows or person to person private sales" and created a huge problem. Even the idea of an FFL holder converting his inventory to his own personal collection and then selling without a BC is nuts.

It has already been ruled constitutional to not allow ex-felons to either vote or own guns. Do you know what the word recidivism pertains to? The likelihood that someone who has committed a felony will commit another one.....Having committed a crime means that part of the punishment is that you can't own a gun. You don't seem to mind that there are no uniform rules for people ordered to undergo psychiatric care being reported to the BC database. How would it ever work with each state making their own rules? That is why strict gun control in NYC or Chicago could never work if you could drive out of the city and fill the trunk of your car with handguns.

Well, trap covered most of your comments (and he was right on every point, BTW) so I'm not going to go over it again. I will say that this idea that the world will only be an acceptable place after everyone in it follows the rules that you believe they should, reminds me of some jihadis I met who felt the same way about Sharia law. Now I didn't really like that way of thinking but as long as they were just talking and not doing I left them alone. The one's who tried to convert their beliefs to reality, got shot...
 
Back
Top