New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Unversal E-Verify or Nothing

wobblies

Mayor
If immigrant legislation doesn't have universal employment verification as the center piece of reform, don't bother. If we don't insure that employers are legally and effectively required to employ eligible workers, all we will be doing is telling our youth that they will have to compete with trespasers for available jobs forever.

1986 legislation did nothing to stop illegal immigration, and the real onslaught began during the GWB presidency; employers began to systematically replace Americans with cheaper illegal labor that they often sent head hunters across the border to recruit. Unionized mostly black workers, for example, were efficiently replaced within a decade in Los Angeles. Employers replaced local hurricane-affected workers with illegal labor for much of the clean up af Katrina.

Many, especially Liberals and Radicals, have demonstrated much more concern for illegal immigrants than for the Americans that are being displaced. Many, especially Conservatives, have shown more concern for the need of employers to drive down wages than the economic security of fellow citizens. With all the talk about reform there has been virtually no interest in the general of Americans whose economic stability is put at risk.

E-verify has the potential to make sure that only eligible workers are employed. That requires, however, that the Social Security data base is cleaned up. In the meantime, a solid procedure needs to be established for illegal immigrants to establish a continuous presence in the country. Furthermore, a minimum residency perioid should be the basis for eligibility for a legal status: we don't have to assume that everyone here illegal should be entitled to stay here.

We don't even know how many people are here illegally. While the Pew-reported number has stabilized since the near depression, reform without E-verify will only lure more people here once the economy really rebounds. Furthermore, there is a myth building process under way to paint illegal immigrants has being driven by a desire to become patriotic US citizens rather than taking our jobs. There is no proof of that myth beyond publicized, anecdotal examples, and dual-citizenship only undermines any loyaly to this country.

The driving force of immigration reform must be the welfare of our citizens, especially our youth. Any amnesty for anyone in the country illegally has to be made possible only after the interest of our citizens is protected.

God Speed,
David
 
I don't care which excuse Republicans cite, so long as they block any and all immigration reform legislation.

I think that it will be very good for the Republican Party to shut down any attempt to pass an immigration reform bill during this session of Congress.

Please, oh please GOP. Please don't pass immigration reform. Do whatever it takes to prevent this from happening. Think about the children!
 
Apparently, you aren't familiar with E-verify: It has the potential to be a magic bullet to insure that only eligible workers can gain employment. Refusing to implement the system universally along with attendant Social Security reforms allows employers to continue to exploit foreign illegal workers and avoid using American workers. We need proactive legislation to address the issue. Do you want the GOP to cover for employers who use illegal labor or not?

I don't care which excuse Republicans cite, so long as they block any and all immigration reform legislation.

I think that it will be very good for the Republican Party to shut down any attempt to pass an immigration reform bill during this session of Congress.

Please, oh please GOP. Please don't pass immigration reform. Do whatever it takes to prevent this from happening. Think about the children!
 
Apparently, you aren't familiar with E-verify: It has the potential to be a magic bullet to insure that only eligible workers can gain employment. Refusing to implement the system universally along with attendant Social Security reforms allows employers to continue to exploit foreign illegal workers and avoid using American workers. We need proactive legislation to address the issue. Do you want the GOP to cover for employers who use illegal labor or not?

Why bother?

30M illegals are going to become citizens, creating a huge voting block for the democrat socialist party, where they will vote themselves more welfare, more govt services and have the rich middle-class pay for it.
 
E-Verify... D-Verify...

Whatever it takes for the GOP to block immigration reform -- I'm down with it!

I'd also like to see some more bills to outlaw abortion and mandate school prayer.

We're all counting on the House Republicans to keep the faith on these important issues.
 
I agree about E-verify. You know what happens now if you as an employer employee an illegal and file a W2 with a bad social security number.

NOTHING. Not a damn thing. First of all, they get around to letting you know that up to a year AFTER you file the W2 - so it could well be a year after the person left your employ. Then they just tell you to double check before you file next year's. Do they ever ask for a copy of the I-9 and related documentation. Do they tell you to send a copy of the social security card? Do they tell you to rescind employment immediately. Nope. So why bother complying. They don't actually enforce their own damn laws as it is. And, part of that is because as employers we aren't necessarily responsible for making sure all the info is legit. We can't accept anythign that is obviously a fake but if it looks good we have to take it.

BUT - if we all had to use E-verify and THEN you still hired someone. Now, there is some teeth. You knew day one. You didn't have to wait up to two years to find out if the guy as legit or not. You know right then, so they can really start enforcing employer penalties. And - they can perhaps round the people up and deport them right away so we don't have the situations where they are here for years and otherwise good people so we feel bad about sending them back.

connie
 
When Social Security was created, the federal government went out of their way to assure that Social Security numbers could not be used for legal ID.

E-verify is online and operational, and has been for some time now. Anyone who cares to check an employee's credentials prior to hiring can use it freely and easily. It only takes a few mouse clicks.
 
It is online and operational and it is NOT required. Furthermore it was restricted until recently to only certain employers. So it was not available for everyone to check even if they wanted to. Until it is required and it is required that you do not offer employment to someone who doesn't pass it - people will still ignore it.


connie
 
It is online and operational and it is NOT required. Furthermore it was restricted until recently to only certain employers. So it was not available for everyone to check even if they wanted to. Until it is required and it is required that you do not offer employment to someone who doesn't pass it - people will still ignore it.




connie


They'll do so at their own peril, since it is illegal to hire an undocumented alien. Some folks will certainly violate the law, no matter what is done. They'll just take their chances. More employers have been prosecuted for hiring illegals under the Obama administration that at any time in our history, and that's a fact.
 
It must be frustrating to try to use the system and only have the government fail you. Have you had this experience? I ask because some critics have said that the government intervenes aggressively and forces employers into a position that they sometimes fire eligible employees ratther than trying to figure out what the problem is. As someone who is not an employer, I would think that such experiences should be shared. It is clear that the system is based upon a flawed data base, so having a bureaucracy that needs to be reformed only reinforces the need for the government to prepare itself for an effective use of the system. Thanks for you time and response.
 
When the legislation was originally passed, we were concerned about the possibility of having to show ID cards as a violation of our privacy. That concern would be superceded by a need to verify one's eligibility to work in this country. By the way, you haven't answered the question: do you support universal E-verify?

When Social Security was created, the federal government went out of their way to assure that Social Security numbers could not be used for legal ID.

E-verify is online and operational, and has been for some time now. Anyone who cares to check an employee's credentials prior to hiring can use it freely and easily. It only takes a few mouse clicks.
 
When the legislation was originally passed, we were concerned about the possibility of having to show ID cards as a violation of our privacy. That concern would be superceded by a need to verify one's eligibility to work in this country. By the way, you haven't answered the question: do you support universal E-verify?


I don't have a problem with it. It will certainly improve over time.

My primary concern is that the GOP find a way to kill any and all immigration reform bills that should come before them for consideration.
 
Thank you for responding. The problem is that you are creating an easy way for ineligible workers to take jobs from Americans. Besides, do you have to show ID to work now? If not, there would be no reason that I can think of where you would have to show ID under a reform system but only to demonstrate your eligibility to work here.
 
Back
Top