Arkady
President
Their FAQ explaining their rankings runs to over 2000 words. They, apparently, thought a long-winded explanation was required. Anyway, their stats have the same problem I discussed above -- since they simply accept the lines on the official maps as the dividing point for each city, they end up comparing apples to oranges: in some of the listed cities, they're just measuring a dense urban core, whereas in others they measure the urban core plus surrounding suburban and rural areas.Murder rate by city:
The countdown for the Top 30 Murder Capitals of America:
Rank City
30 Chicago Heights, IL
29 Baton Rouge, LA
28 Buffalo, NY
27 Hattiesburg, MS
26 East Chicago, IN
25 Birmingham, AL
24 Desert Hot Springs, CA
23 Compton, CA
22 Myrtle Beach, SC
21 Fort Pierce, FL
20 Harvey, IL
19 Bridgeton, NJ
18 Flint, MI
17 Rocky Mount, NC
16 Pine Bluff, AR
15 Petersburg, VA
14 Newark, NJ
13 Baltimore, MD
12 Harrisburg, PA
11 Jackson, MS
10 Wilmington, DE
9 Trenton, NJ
8 Riviera Beach, FL
7 New Orleans, LA
6 Camden, NJ
5 Detroit, MI
4 Gary, IN
3 St. Louis, MO
2 Chester, PA
1 East St. Louis, IL
Our crime research reveals the 30 cities in America with the highest number of murders per 1,000 residents. Murder is the willful (non-negligent) killing of one human being by another. We limited our research to cities with 25,000 or more people. Data used for this research are 1) the number of murders reported to the FBI to have occurred in each city, and 2) the population of each city.
http://www.neighborhoodscout.com/top-lists/highest-murder-rate-cities/
Very straight-forward and easy to comprehend. No long-winded explanation required.
For example, compare Chester, PA to Hattiesburg, MS. On their list, the former is much worse than the latter (2nd-highest murder versus 27th). On paper, they're of comprable size (34k versus 47k). Yet, when it comes to Chester, they're only counting a highly urbanized area (population density 7,020.3/sq mi). With Hattiesburg, they're counting a small urban area plus big stretches of rural settlement around it (population density 877/sq mi). You can see it in their own data, which shows Chester having clearly urban settlement patters (less than 10% of homes being single-family detatched, over 60% being row houses), while Hattiesburg has suburban settlement patters (over half of homes are single-family detached, less than 1% are row houses.) Obviously, if you compare an urban core, in one case, with a combination of of a smaller urban core and a whole bunch of surrounding 'burbs in the other, you're likely to find higher crime in the first case. It's just common sense.