New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Violent Cities

Murder rate by city:

The countdown for the Top 30 Murder Capitals of America:


Rank
City

30 Chicago Heights, IL

29 Baton Rouge, LA

28 Buffalo, NY

27 Hattiesburg, MS

26 East Chicago, IN

25 Birmingham, AL

24 Desert Hot Springs, CA

23 Compton, CA

22 Myrtle Beach, SC

21 Fort Pierce, FL

20 Harvey, IL

19 Bridgeton, NJ

18 Flint, MI

17 Rocky Mount, NC

16 Pine Bluff, AR

15 Petersburg, VA

14 Newark, NJ

13 Baltimore, MD

12 Harrisburg, PA

11 Jackson, MS

10 Wilmington, DE

9 Trenton, NJ

8 Riviera Beach, FL

7 New Orleans, LA

6 Camden, NJ

5 Detroit, MI

4 Gary, IN

3 St. Louis, MO

2 Chester, PA

1 East St. Louis, IL

Our crime research reveals the 30 cities in America with the highest number of murders per 1,000 residents. Murder is the willful (non-negligent) killing of one human being by another. We limited our research to cities with 25,000 or more people. Data used for this research are 1) the number of murders reported to the FBI to have occurred in each city, and 2) the population of each city.

http://www.neighborhoodscout.com/top-lists/highest-murder-rate-cities/


Very straight-forward and easy to comprehend. No long-winded explanation required.
Their FAQ explaining their rankings runs to over 2000 words. They, apparently, thought a long-winded explanation was required. Anyway, their stats have the same problem I discussed above -- since they simply accept the lines on the official maps as the dividing point for each city, they end up comparing apples to oranges: in some of the listed cities, they're just measuring a dense urban core, whereas in others they measure the urban core plus surrounding suburban and rural areas.

For example, compare Chester, PA to Hattiesburg, MS. On their list, the former is much worse than the latter (2nd-highest murder versus 27th). On paper, they're of comprable size (34k versus 47k). Yet, when it comes to Chester, they're only counting a highly urbanized area (population density 7,020.3/sq mi). With Hattiesburg, they're counting a small urban area plus big stretches of rural settlement around it (population density 877/sq mi). You can see it in their own data, which shows Chester having clearly urban settlement patters (less than 10% of homes being single-family detatched, over 60% being row houses), while Hattiesburg has suburban settlement patters (over half of homes are single-family detached, less than 1% are row houses.) Obviously, if you compare an urban core, in one case, with a combination of of a smaller urban core and a whole bunch of surrounding 'burbs in the other, you're likely to find higher crime in the first case. It's just common sense.
 
Let's take the bottom ten, the real shitholes of America:

Houston - mayor Sylvester Turner, Democrat
Atlanta - mayor Kasim Reed, Democrat
Miami - mayor Tomas Regalado, Republican
San Francisco - mayor Ed Lee, Democrat
Chicago - mayor Rahm Emanuel, Democrat
St. Louis - mayor Francis Slay, Democrat
Kansas City - mayor Sly James, Independent (but is a DNC superdelegate)
Philadelphia - mayor Jim Kenney, Democrat
Baltimore - mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, Democrat
Detroit - mayor Mike Duggan, Democrat

Looks about right to me.
How about if you take the top ten?
 
Their FAQ explaining their rankings runs to over 2000 words. They, apparently, thought a long-winded explanation was required. Anyway, their stats have the same problem I discussed above -- since they simply accept the lines on the official maps as the dividing point for each city, they end up comparing apples to oranges: in some of the listed cities, they're just measuring a dense urban core, whereas in others they measure the urban core plus surrounding suburban and rural areas.

For example, compare Chester, PA to Hattiesburg, MS. On their list, the former is much worse than the latter (2nd-highest murder versus 27th). On paper, they're of comprable size (34k versus 47k). Yet, when it comes to Chester, they're only counting a highly urbanized area (population density 7,020.3/sq mi). With Hattiesburg, they're counting a small urban area plus big stretches of rural settlement around it (population density 877/sq mi). You can see it in their own data, which shows Chester having clearly urban settlement patters (less than 10% of homes being single-family detatched, over 60% being row houses, while Hattiesburg has suburban settlement patters (over half of homes are single-family detached, less than 1% are row houses.) Obviously, if you compare an urban core, in one case, with a combination of of a smaller urban core and a whole bunch of surrounding 'burbs in the other, you're likely to find higher crime in the first case. It's just common sense.


Our crime research reveals the 30 cities in America with the highest number of murders per 1,000 residents. Murder is the willful (non-negligent) killing of one human being by another. We limited our research to cities with 25,000 or more people. Data used for this research are 1) the number of murders reported to the FBI to have occurred in each city, and 2) the population of each city.

Word count: 69


Meaningful comparisons among cities are difficult, because of the way borders are drawn. The tendency is for older, eastern, and coastal cities to have official borders drawn tightly around an urban core, while younger, western, and inland cities have wider borders that include non-urban areas. This means a comparison between two seemingly cities, in terms of population, may actually be comparing a big city to a small city plus a lot of surrounding areas.

For example, Boston and Oklahoma City have similar populations, if you rely on official borders. In Boston, you could walk from the city's center to its border in under an hour, yet across those borders it would look like a continuation of the same big city, just with a name change (e.g., Cambridge). Oklahoma City covers a footprint well over 12 times the size of Boston. It would take you three or four hours to walk from the city center to the official border, by which time you'd have passed through the suburbs and might find yourself in rural farmland. So, when you compare stats of official Boston to official OK City, you're really comparing a very big urban core, on one hand, to a small city plus its surrounding suburbs and exurbs, on the other.

That same issue pops up repeatedly. Newark, New Jersey and Anchorage, Alaska each have a little under 300,000 residents, but Newark has a land area of 24 square miles, while Anchorage has one of 1700 square miles. Again, any comparison would be between a huge inner city, on the one hand, and, on the other, a mixed area consisting of a small city, some suburbs, and vast stretches of rural settlement. Anchorage includes land so rural that the "city" is home to around 400 bears and its very own glacier.

So, how can one do a meaningful statistical comparison between, say, DC (land area of 61 miles), and Houston (land area 634 square miles)? Fortunately the FBI's Uniform Crime Reports have a solution. They report based on metropolitan statistical areas. MSAs ignore the official boundaries of a city and instead draw the line based on actual settlement patterns. Generally, this means lumping multiple smaller cities together, sometimes across state lines, into a single MSA. It's closer to what you'd see as the city if you looked down from a satellite without knowing where the artificial borders are. So, for example, Kansas City, MO and Kansas City, KS are treated as a single unit.

Using that standard, here are all the MSAs with populations over two million, from lowest murder rate to highest:


Word count: 432

I rest my case.

 
Our crime research reveals the 30 cities in America with the highest number of murders per 1,000 residents. Murder is the willful (non-negligent) killing of one human being by another. We limited our research to cities with 25,000 or more people. Data used for this research are 1) the number of murders reported to the FBI to have occurred in each city, and 2) the population of each city.

Word count: 69


Meaningful comparisons among cities are difficult, because of the way borders are drawn. The tendency is for older, eastern, and coastal cities to have official borders drawn tightly around an urban core, while younger, western, and inland cities have wider borders that include non-urban areas. This means a comparison between two seemingly cities, in terms of population, may actually be comparing a big city to a small city plus a lot of surrounding areas.

For example, Boston and Oklahoma City have similar populations, if you rely on official borders. In Boston, you could walk from the city's center to its border in under an hour, yet across those borders it would look like a continuation of the same big city, just with a name change (e.g., Cambridge). Oklahoma City covers a footprint well over 12 times the size of Boston. It would take you three or four hours to walk from the city center to the official border, by which time you'd have passed through the suburbs and might find yourself in rural farmland. So, when you compare stats of official Boston to official OK City, you're really comparing a very big urban core, on one hand, to a small city plus its surrounding suburbs and exurbs, on the other.

That same issue pops up repeatedly. Newark, New Jersey and Anchorage, Alaska each have a little under 300,000 residents, but Newark has a land area of 24 square miles, while Anchorage has one of 1700 square miles. Again, any comparison would be between a huge inner city, on the one hand, and, on the other, a mixed area consisting of a small city, some suburbs, and vast stretches of rural settlement. Anchorage includes land so rural that the "city" is home to around 400 bears and its very own glacier.

So, how can one do a meaningful statistical comparison between, say, DC (land area of 61 miles), and Houston (land area 634 square miles)? Fortunately the FBI's Uniform Crime Reports have a solution. They report based on metropolitan statistical areas. MSAs ignore the official boundaries of a city and instead draw the line based on actual settlement patterns. Generally, this means lumping multiple smaller cities together, sometimes across state lines, into a single MSA. It's closer to what you'd see as the city if you looked down from a satellite without knowing where the artificial borders are. So, for example, Kansas City, MO and Kansas City, KS are treated as a single unit.

Using that standard, here are all the MSAs with populations over two million, from lowest murder rate to highest:


Word count: 432

I rest my case.
Click on the FAQ link. It runs to over 2000 words. What they do differently from me is that they embed the explanation on another page, assuming most people will be too lazy or stupid to wade through much text. I present it in-line, not caring if lazy and stupid people are going to whine about the long-winded explanation.
 
Their FAQ explaining their rankings runs to over 2000 words. They, apparently, thought a long-winded explanation was required. Anyway, their stats have the same problem I discussed above -- since they simply accept the lines on the official maps as the dividing point for each city, they end up comparing apples to oranges: in some of the listed cities, they're just measuring a dense urban core, whereas in others they measure the urban core plus surrounding suburban and rural areas.

For example, compare Chester, PA to Hattiesburg, MS. On their list, the former is much worse than the latter (2nd-highest murder versus 27th). On paper, they're of comprable size (34k versus 47k). Yet, when it comes to Chester, they're only counting a highly urbanized area (population density 7,020.3/sq mi). With Hattiesburg, they're counting a small urban area plus big stretches of rural settlement around it (population density 877/sq mi). You can see it in their own data, which shows Chester having clearly urban settlement patters (less than 10% of homes being single-family detatched, over 60% being row houses), while Hattiesburg has suburban settlement patters (over half of homes are single-family detached, less than 1% are row houses.) Obviously, if you compare an urban core, in one case, with a combination of of a smaller urban core and a whole bunch of surrounding 'burbs in the other, you're likely to find higher crime in the first case. It's just common sense.

The irony of seeing you complain about long-winded explanations is almost too much to bear.
 
Click on the FAQ link. It runs to over 2000 words. What they do differently from me is that they embed the explanation on another page, assuming most people will be too lazy or stupid to wade through much text. I present it in-line, not caring if lazy and stupid people are going to whine about the long-winded explanation.


I don't need to click on anything. I took your explanation, and I took the explanation provided on the main page of the article I quoted. Their explanation was clear and concise in exactly the way yours wasn't.

The fact that you are now resorting to name-calling bolsters my case. Feel free to carry on.
 
I don't need to click on anything.

Understood. Only an intellectually curious person would need to click on something to know what those stats they provided were actually indicating. I would fully expect you to regard that as an extraneous step, but for me it was very much necessary.
 
I don't need to click on anything. I took your explanation, and I took the explanation provided on the main page of the article I quoted. Their explanation was clear and concise in exactly the way yours wasn't.

The fact that you are now resorting to name-calling bolsters my case. Feel free to carry on.


much like "you dont understand, try re-reading my reply" is indicative of his losing position, his predictable insults and snark at the close of his failed aberrations are likewise scripted...[with alot of "presumably, could be, might have, is possible, etc." that forms the foundation for his "stories"...;)
 
Understood. Only an intellectually curious person would need to click on something to know what those stats they provided were actually indicating. I would fully expect you to regard that as an extraneous step, but for me it was very much necessary.

I'm sure it was for you. Without searching for a different document, you wouldn't have had a leg to stand on.

And, as it it, perhaps you still don't.
 
I'm sure it was for you. Without searching for a different document, you wouldn't have had a leg to stand on.

And, as it it, perhaps you still don't.
If you ever suffer from an attack of intellectual curiosity, go ahead and click on the link and read about how they came up with the stats. It's interesting stuff. I clicked on it to see if they'd done something to address the issue I'd mentioned. They hadn't.
 
much like "you dont understand, try re-reading my reply" is indicative of his losing position, his predictable insults and snark at the close of his failed aberrations are likewise scripted...[with alot of "presumably, could be, might have, is possible, etc." that forms the foundation for his "stories"...;)


He seems to get frustrated whenever others don't roll over and allow him to control the narrative. Some people don't like being challenged I suppose, perhaps especially if they feel the case they are trying to make might not withstand too much scrutiny.
 
He seems to get frustrated whenever others don't roll over and allow him to control the narrative. Some people don't like being challenged I suppose, perhaps especially if they feel the case they are trying to make might not withstand too much scrutiny.


textbook narcissist...combine that with the mental disorder known as "liberalism" , and hes doomed from the start...
 
He seems to get frustrated whenever others don't roll over and allow him to control the narrative. Some people don't like being challenged I suppose, perhaps especially if they feel the case they are trying to make might not withstand too much scrutiny.

It's a level of insecurity one doesn't often see in adults.
 
Meaningful comparisons among cities are difficult, because of the way borders are drawn. The tendency is for older, eastern, and coastal cities to have official borders drawn tightly around an urban core, while younger, western, and inland cities have wider borders that include non-urban areas. This means a comparison between two seemingly cities, in terms of population, may actually be comparing a big city to a small city plus a lot of surrounding areas.

For example, Boston and Oklahoma City have similar populations, if you rely on official borders. In Boston, you could walk from the city's center to its border in under an hour, yet across those borders it would look like a continuation of the same big city, just with a name change (e.g., Cambridge). Oklahoma City covers a footprint well over 12 times the size of Boston. It would take you three or four hours to walk from the city center to the official border, by which time you'd have passed through the suburbs and might find yourself in rural farmland. So, when you compare stats of official Boston to official OK City, you're really comparing a very big urban core, on one hand, to a small city plus its surrounding suburbs and exurbs, on the other.

That same issue pops up repeatedly. Newark, New Jersey and Anchorage, Alaska each have a little under 300,000 residents, but Newark has a land area of 24 square miles, while Anchorage has one of 1700 square miles. Again, any comparison would be between a huge inner city, on the one hand, and, on the other, a mixed area consisting of a small city, some suburbs, and vast stretches of rural settlement. Anchorage includes land so rural that the "city" is home to around 400 bears and its very own glacier.

So, how can one do a meaningful statistical comparison between, say, DC (land area of 61 miles), and Houston (land area 634 square miles)? Fortunately the FBI's Uniform Crime Reports have a solution. They report based on metropolitan statistical areas. MSAs ignore the official boundaries of a city and instead draw the line based on actual settlement patterns. Generally, this means lumping multiple smaller cities together, sometimes across state lines, into a single MSA. It's closer to what you'd see as the city if you looked down from a satellite without knowing where the artificial borders are. So, for example, Kansas City, MO and Kansas City, KS are treated as a single unit.

Using that standard, here are all the MSAs with populations over two million, from lowest murder rate to highest:

Boston-Cambridge-Newton, MA-NH M.S.A. 2.1
Minneapolis-St. Paul-Bloomington, MN-WI M.S.A. 2.2
Portland-Vancouver-Hillsboro, OR-WA M.S.A. 2.4
Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue, WA M.S.A. 2.9
San Diego-Carlsbad, CA M.S.A. 3.4
Cincinnati, OH-KY-IN M.S.A. 3.5
Washington-Arlington-Alexandria, DC-VA-MD-WV M.S.A. 3.6
New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA M.S.A. 3.8
Sacramento--Roseville--Arden-Arcade, CA M.S.A. 3.8
Denver-Aurora-Lakewood, CO M.S.A. 3.9
Tampa-St. Petersburg-Clearwater, FL M.S.A. 3.9
Dallas-Fort Worth-Arlington, TX M.S.A. 4.1
Riverside-San Bernardino-Ontario, CA M.S.A. 4.1
Pittsburgh, PA M.S.A. 4.2
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim, CA M.S.A. 5
Orlando-Kissimmee-Sanford, FL M.S.A. 5
San Antonio-New Braunfels, TX M.S.A. 5.1
Phoenix-Mesa-Scottsdale, AZ M.S.A. 5.3
Houston-The Woodlands-Sugar Land, TX M.S.A. 5.7
Atlanta-Sandy Springs-Roswell, GA M.S.A. 6.1
Miami-Fort Lauderdale-West Palm Beach, FL M.S.A. 6.3
San Francisco-Oakland-Hayward, CA M.S.A. 6.5
Chicago-Naperville-Elgin, IL-IN-WI M.S.A. 7.1
St. Louis, MO-IL M.S.A. 7.3
Kansas City, MO-KS M.S.A. 7.7
Philadelphia-Camden-Wilmington, PA-NJ-DE-MD M.S.A. 8.6
Baltimore-Columbia-Towson, MD M.S.A. 9.5
Detroit-Warren-Dearborn, MI M.S.A. 10.9

https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/u...rime-in-the-u.s.-2012/tables/6tabledatadecpdf

There are still big differences there between the best and the worst (you're over five times as likely to be murdered in the Detroit MSA than the Boston MSA). But, clearly that's much smaller than the difference between the worst and best of the big cities, where one may be twenty times worse than another due mostly to how borders are drawn.
HA! More bullshit stats!

Tell you what. Take your land/crime criteria and run a comparison between Denver and Detroit. Or El Paso and Detroit. Tell me whaddya find.

Then compare their politics and gun laws. Whaddya find?

Run a similar comparison with Oakland and some similarly sized Texas city.

Here's an idea! Why not slice and dice the source data and reassemble it in some OTHER way that promotes your narrative!

Yay stats!
 
HA! More bullshit stats!

Tell you what. Take your land/crime criteria and run a comparison between Denver and Detroit. Or El Paso and Detroit. Tell me whaddya find.

Then compare their politics and gun laws. Whaddya find?

Run a similar comparison with Oakland and some similarly sized Texas city.

Here's an idea! Why not slice and dice the source data and reassemble it in some OTHER way that promotes your narrative!

Yay stats!
If you have a data source summarizing the gun laws applicable to each of these MSAs in some sort of index, we could see if there are correlations. So, for example, are the state and local gun laws applicable to the St. Louis, KC, Philly, Baltimore, and Detroit MSAs tighter or loser, overall, than those applicable to Boston, Minneapolis, Portland, Seattle, and San Diego?
 
If you have a data source summarizing the gun laws applicable to each of these MSAs in some sort of index, we could see if there are correlations.
Why would I do that? You're the one hanging your hat on bullshit statistics not me.

But Wikipedia still works.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_Texas

I'm sure a Triple 9er like you should have no problem constructing some sort of. . .index.

Keep in mind, a scientific theory can never be proven. Only disproved. And Detroit has about the highest murder/violence/crime rate in America, run by Democrats for decades, and has very restrictive gun laws. So. . .

Comparison of just about any like sized city kicks giant gaping holes in your (ahem) "theory."
 
Why would I do that?

You brought up guns. I thought you might be trying to make some sort of argument.

For my part, I don't have much confidence in strictly local gun laws to have any impact, since it's just so easy to bring guns in from surrounding areas. But if you have some stats to test that idea, I'd be willing to reconsider.
 
You brought up guns.
You brought up violent cities. You saying guns play no role in that?

For my part, I don't have much confidence in strictly local gun laws to have any impact, since it's just so easy to bring guns in from surrounding areas.
"Surrounding areas?" Then why are you even talking about "Violent Cities?"

Nice back pedal.
 
Back
Top