New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

War

I thought my original post condemned all unnecessary war. But it seemed only fair to point out that the biggest "cheerleaders" for getting into Iraq in the first place were Bush chickenhawks.

Obama's Afghanistan surge sucked.. but he does get credit for getting us out of Iraq.

As the Occupiers of a Land you had conquered you were responsible for the safty of that Land.

And Libya? Somalia? Yemen? ect
 
The facts don't jive with what you have alleged. What happened in Germany between 1933 and 1939 is documented history, and you'll not find one reputable historical scholar who would deny this. Perhaps you would prefer this source for "Kristallnacht", or will you dismiss this one as propaganda as well:


http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/the-night-of-broken-glass


http://library.thinkquest.org/12663/summary/19331939.html

Also ..take note. Every time the folly of WWII is bought up ............instead of actually talking about the rights and wrongs of the War .......up comes the holocaust and any explorations of it causes, which may help us understand enough to stop future Wars, are stopped in there tracks ........very useful is the propaganda of the victors, it gives the 'great unwashed' the feel good factor for they vanquished the Monster ......well no they didn't and don't they fight FOR the monster and the monster tells them the opposite and so they all do it again and again and again and again. a Fabricated Hitler and the fabricated Holocaust are held up all the time as the monster we must fight in every bloody War.
 
Also ..take note. Every time the folly of WWII is bought up ............instead of actually talking about the rights and wrongs of the War .......up comes the holocaust and any explorations of it causes, which may help us understand enough to stop future Wars, are stopped in there tracks ........very useful is the propaganda of the victors, it gives the 'great unwashed' the feel good factor for they vanquished the Monster ......well no they didn't and don't they fight FOR the monster and the monster tells them the opposite and so they all do it again and again and again and again. a Fabricated Hitler and the fabricated Holocaust are held up all the time as the monster we must fight in every bloody War.


You made statements that were not true, so naturally I felt compelled to refute them and back my points with hard evidence.

Any war fought to keep Hitler from carrying out his aims was a war worth fighting. You and I are both far better off for it having been fought.
 
Does it matter? Is it not more important to stop murdering than pointing the finger of blame?

Why don't you join together to say 'Stop killing in my name' since all of you seem to want that.

Dem and Repub Govs alike are murderers of indigenous peoples for their Land.
Of course it matters!!! These Righties either have blatant amnesia blatant denial. It is not possible to find truth or have honest discourse when people are walking around with either of these afflictions.

The TRUTH is the Righties did support the horrid invasion and occupation of IRAQ while people like me and many others strongly OPPOSED it. For that we were called "traitors and terrorist sympathizes"! But the Righties now want to say that did not happen! That is dishonest and inaccurate and it revises history and the truth.
 
I thought my original post condemned all unnecessary war. But it seemed only fair to point out that the biggest "cheerleaders" for getting into Iraq in the first place were Bush chickenhawks.

Obama's Afghanistan surge sucked.. but he does get credit for getting us out of Iraq.


Not hardly.

Obama wanted to STAY in Iraq. But was forced to stick to Bush's timetable.

http://www.washingtontimes.com/blog/robbins-report/2011/oct/22/obamas-iraq-failure/

http://www.salon.com/2011/10/21/about_that_iraq_withdrawal/

He gets 'credit' for being as big a warmongering scumbag as Bush.
 
What the hell is it good for.

Some cheer it, as if it's no more than a Sunday afternoon John Wayne movie, or a football game. They are completely detached from the reality of war, and for good reason. Most cheerleaders have never been in a war, so they have no idea what it entails.

There was a poem, I read many years ago, by a 21 year old Lance Cpl Lester Atherden, who died 4 March, 1966 in Quang Ngai. Here is his poem. There are errors in the body of the poem, but just ignore them. I made fun of Marines, but I respected them. My fellow classmates who enlisted as well as my cousins, and I weep for all those who died.

FROM MARINE LESTER ROBERT ATHERDEN:

WHO IS HE? YOU SIT AT HOME AND WATCH YOUR TV SIPPING A REFRESHING COLD ICED TEA, THE NEWS COMES ON AND THEN YOU HERE, THE ALL-STAR GAME IS DRAWING NEAR, THEN YOU SEE A FAR OFF LAND, WHERE MEN ARE DYING IN THE SAND, A FROWN APPEARS ACROSS YOUR FACE, YOU'RE TIRED OF HEARING ABOUT THIS PLACE.

WHO CARES ABOUT VIETNAM ACROSS THE SEA, IT'S FAR AWAY AND DOESN'T CONCERN ME, YOU'D RATHER HEAR THE BEATLES PLAY, THAN LEARN ABOUT THE WORLD TODAY, BUT STOP AND THINK A MOMENT OR TWO, AND ASK YOURSELF,DOES THIS CONCERN YOU? IT'S GREAT TO BE ALIVE AND FREE, BUT WHAT ABOUT THE GUY ACROSS THE SEA, HE'S GIVING UP HIS LIFE FOR ME, SO I CAN LIVE UNDER LIBERTY. HE'S FAR AWAY FIGHTING A WAR, INSTEAD OF FIGHTING AT MY FRONT DOOR.

THIS GUY WHO LIVES IN FILTH AND SLIME. HOW CAN HE DO IT ALL THE TIME? HE'S ABOUT MY AGE SO WHY SHOULD HE CARE, ABOUT A WAR SOMEONE ELSE SHOULD SHARE. YOU CALL HIM VILE NAMES AND MAKE FUN OF HIS CAUSE, YET HE IS ALWAYS FIRST TO WIN YOUR WAR. YOU LUCKY GUY, YOU LAUGH AND SNEER, BECAUSE YOU'VE NEVER REALLY KNOWN FEAR. THIS YOUNG MAN FACES DEATH EACH DAY, BUT HE'S ALWAYS GOT SOMETHING FUNNY TO SAY. NO MAIL AGAIN, AGAIN A TWINGE OF SORROW, OH WHAT THE HELL THEIR ALWAYS TOMORROW. THE MORALE IS LOW THE TENSION IS HIGH, SOME EVEN BREAK DOWN AND CRY.

HE WANTS TO GO HOME AND SEE A LOVED ONE. HE WORKS ALL DAY AND STANDS GUARD ALL NIGHT. HE'S TIRED AND SICK BUT CONTINUES TO FIGHT, THE COLLEGE CROWD THINKS HE'S A FOOL, BUT THAT'S WHAT MAKES HIM HARD AND CRUEL. YOU DON'T APPRECIATE WHAT HE WILL DO, LIKE GIVING UP HIS LIFE FOR YOU. HE SACRIFICES MUCH YET HR ASK NOTHING IN RETURN, JUST SO THAT YOU CAN STAY SCHOOL AND LEARN. HE BELIEVES IN FREEDOM AND AMERICAN LIFE, NO PARTIES AND DANCES FOR THIS YOUNG MAN, UNTIL HE COMES HOME AGAIN.

THE DAYS ARE HOT AND THE NIGHTS ARE TOO, WHAT WONDERS A COLD CAN OF BEER CAN DO! HE DREAMS OF COLD BEER AND A THICK JUICY STEAK, WHEN SOMEONE SHOUTS, WE'VE GOT A HILL TO TAKE. SOME WILL BE HEROES BECAUSE THEY ARE BRAVE, AND OTHERS WILL GET A WREATH ON THEIR GRAVE. YOU'LL RECOGNIZE HIM AS HE WALKS BY, THERE'S A SADDENED LOOK IN HIS EYE, HE WALKS SO PROUD YET LOOKS SO MEAN, HE'S CALLED THE WORLD'S GREATEST FIGHTING MACHINE. NO WONDER HE'S PROUD, HE'S A UNITED STATES MARINE!


Not all war is bad. Some wars must be fought. But these are wars of defense...not aggression.
 
You made statements that were not true, so naturally I felt compelled to refute them and back my points with hard evidence.

Any war fought to keep Hitler from carrying out his aims was a war worth fighting. You and I are both far better off for it having been fought.

I didn't bring up the Holocaust and what I said in reply was true.

I am better off because to WWII? No way Jose ............. That mad bastard Churchill lost the Empire ................ what ever any of us think of Empire because of and only because of the desimation of Europe in that War, the World has been in a miserable savage Chaos ever since. Good God!

We lost everything for a couple of old mens wet dreams.
 
Of course it matters!!! These Righties either have blatant amnesia blatant denial. It is not possible to find truth or have honest discourse when people are walking around with either of these afflictions.

The TRUTH is the Righties did support the horrid invasion and occupation of IRAQ while people like me and many others strongly OPPOSED it. For that we were called "traitors and terrorist sympathizes"! But the Righties now want to say that did not happen! That is dishonest and inaccurate and it revises history and the truth.

So did Lefties if memory serves me right ................. We didn't here, neither right nor left, no matter what the Papers said.
 
I didn't bring up the Holocaust and what I said in reply was true.

I am better off because to WWII? No way Jose ............. That mad bastard Churchill lost the Empire ................ what ever any of us think of Empire because of and only because of the desimation of Europe in that War, the World has been in a miserable savage Chaos ever since. Good God!

We lost everything for a couple of old mens wet dreams.


Your "Empire" that you miss was acquired by war. You just refuted your own argument.

And your statements concerning the Holocaust were not only false, they were easily proven false.
 
Your "Empire" that you miss was acquired by war. You just refuted your own argument.

And your statements concerning the Holocaust were not only false, they were easily proven false.


Nope I am not .............. I do not pine for the Empire nor do I argue for Empire, I do not, but ................

I am saying that because so many of our men were dead and our coffers empty, Europe in tatters, the Empire, that was ( no matter what I feel about it being, it was ) could not be maintained and so it fell into a terrible bloody and chaotic state ................ It was in the 'contract' with all peoples under British rule that our presence was temporary and the intent was always that once able to rule themselves the Land/Nation would revert back to the peoples .......mmmm yes of course questionable ect ............ but that is what was written and was the highest intent.

WWII, because it broke the keepers of it, destabilized the Worlds Order, of that time, and opened the flood gates for Gangsters and their Chaos.

Russia won the War. There was a deal that Germany would be occupied for 40 years. Dead on that 40 year date, the Berlin wall came down ( I note the US is still there !) The USSR did not fail ................. we chose the side of the Soviets against Hitler, for that was what the War was about, and so now we see and live with the consequences.
 
So did Lefties if memory serves me right ................. We didn't here, neither right nor left, no matter what the Papers said.
Absolutely NOT. So called "Lefties" absolutely OPPOSED the Bush/Cheney Invasion. In fact 144 BRAVE DEMOCRATS in senate and congress voted NO and hundreds of thousands of "Lefties" citizens protested in the streets and spoke out against it and yes I was one of them who spoke out against it!
 
Absolutely NOT. So called "Lefties" absolutely OPPOSED the Bush/Cheney Invasion. In fact 144 BRAVE DEMOCRATS in senate and congress voted NO and hundreds of thousands of "Lefties" citizens protested in the streets and spoke out against it and yes I was one of them who spoke out against it!

Me too here.

But and so, what Righty is now asking of Lefty is why are you backing Obama if you so hate War?

And instead of staying on track of No War, Lefty goes into defence mode and makes excuses for Obombas' bombs.
 
Nope I am not .............. I do not pine for the Empire nor do I argue for Empire, I do not, but ................

I am saying that because so many of our men were dead and our coffers empty, Europe in tatters, the Empire, that was ( no matter what I feel about it being, it was ) could not be maintained and so it fell into a terrible bloody and chaotic state ................ It was in the 'contract' with all peoples under British rule that our presence was temporary and the intent was always that once able to rule themselves the Land/Nation would revert back to the peoples .......mmmm yes of course questionable ect ............ but that is what was written and was the highest intent.

WWII, because it broke the keepers of it, destabilized the Worlds Order, of that time, and opened the flood gates for Gangsters and their Chaos.

Russia won the War. There was a deal that Germany would be occupied for 40 years. Dead on that 40 year date, the Berlin wall came down ( I note the US is still there !) The USSR did not fail ................. we chose the side of the Soviets against Hitler, for that was what the War was about, and so now we see and live with the consequences.



Then why say this:

That mad bastard Churchill lost the Empire ................


You condemn Churchill for "losing the Empire", and then say you're not arguing for the Empire.

If the Empire was "bad", then good for Churchill, right?

You can't have it both ways, tisn't cricket.
 
Me too here.

But and so, what Righty is now asking of Lefty is why are you backing Obama if you so hate War?

Nothing Obama is doing is close to the Iraq invasion and Occupation!!! However, me and many of my fellow lefties absolutely oppose DRONES and many have done civil disobedience and have been speaking out against it for several years.. so yes Lefty does oppose what Obama does. Buit again what Obama is doing is not even close to the $2TRILLION in spending and a few million soldiers cycled through Iraq and the killing of hundreds of thousands!!!
 
Then why say this:

That mad bastard Churchill lost the Empire ................


You condemn Churchill for "losing the Empire", and then say you're not arguing for the Empire.

If the Empire was "bad", then good for Churchill, right?

You can't have it both ways, tisn't cricket.

You said I was better off ................ I know America was better off after the War, Britain wasn't. Nor was anyone else but the Russian Zionists who were given Israel ............ So the US and Russian Rulers and Russian Israelis broke all of the old Empires in WWII and took over and look where we are.

I don't judge History by my own morality, I just like to know the truth of it/us .................
 
Nothing Obama is doing is close to the Iraq invasion and Occupation!!! However, me and many of my fellow lefties absolutely oppose DRONES and many have done civil disobedience and have been speaking out against it for several years.. so yes Lefty does oppose what Obama does. Buit again what Obama is doing is not even close to the $2TRILLION in spending and a few million soldiers cycled through Iraq and the killing of hundreds of thousands!!!

Libya was just as bad as Iraq ................. it was just unseen, out of sight and all that .......

And now that Righty and Lefty meet on one level ...anti war ..why aren't you making the most of it against the never ending War? Instead of fighting each other.
 
Last edited:
You said I was better off ................ I know America was better off after the War, Britain wasn't. Nor was anyone else but the Russian Zionists who were given Israel ............ So the US and Russian Rulers and Russian Israelis broke all of the old Empires in WWII and took over and look where we are.

I don't judging History by my own morality, I just like to know the truth of it/us .................


You are free to believe you'd be better off living under the swastika if you like. I doubt few will join you in that.
 
You are free to believe you'd be better off living under the swastika if you like. I doubt few will join you in that.

I wouldn't be ................. Hitler had no wish to invade any of Northern Europe. The War would have been between him and Stalin ............... if we had kept out of it completely and or fought on Germanys' side we would be living in a far better World now.
 
Indeed, one has only to look at the cheerleading chickenhawk neocons surrounding Bushie who never served a day in their pathetic lives to grasp the folly.

But to answer your question... absolutely NOTHIN'.


"Say it again!!!"
 
Back
Top