New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Was Aikin Really Wrong?

You're wrong. Rape is rape.
Really? Rape is rape? What is it when it's a 16 year old boy and a 15 year old girl, and they've gotten drunk on their first-ever bottle of wine and had sex? In some places, that's rape. In others, it's not. What if it's a 23-year-old female teacher and a 17 year old male student? That's rape in most jurisdictions in the U.S.

Of course, those are "consensual" acts where there is doubt about the ability to give consent because of age, or intoxication or a combination thereof.

But what of what I think of as "morning after rape" -- the "victim" wakes up and yells rape? I know of one person who served jail time in such an incident.

The point is, there are multiple things the law defines as rape -- Obama is simply wrong if he said "rape is rape."

People who know my perspective within this forum know I'm in favor of abortion, I still want to make it clear that the upcoming example is not my own personal point of view.

If "rape is rape," then wouldn't it also be fair to say, "life is life," and that the progeny created via a rape has as much right to live as those created via consensual sexual activity?

The world is obviously a more complex place.
 
Interesting. I wonder if the Mecklinburg article is what I'm remembering. But Degs, even you realize that the immorality of the scientist has nothing to do with the validity or invalidity of the scientist's studies. It appears to make no mention of Ph, which is for some reason what's still bouncing around in my memory.

But the data coming from Nazi concentration camp experiments has no control corroboration. And the environmental circumstances were such that you cannot extrapolate to current modern life. Remmber many of these women were trying to kill themselves during their tortures. And starvation - which they were undergoing - also affects reproduction. So it simply is scientifically invalid to make that extrapolation.

Combining an invalid scientific extrapolation from data gathered immorally under the most horrific circumstances, and pretending this is "scientific" is well.... worse than "cynical".... and no it is not "being skeptical"
 
The term I tend to apply to myself is "global warming skeptic."

You're not. You are a Denier. You lack the mathematical and scientific tools with which to make legitimate assessments, and yet you make such assessments. Its a bit like someone having taking Middle School Sex Ed - claiming to be sufficiently skilled to provide genetic counseling to folks at risk for inherited genetic diseases.

Or perhaps its like someone who went to a 4th Tier University, only took undergrad Econ courses, did not even manage a B+ Average - and now positions himself as an expert on the national economy...
 
Back
Top