New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Was Aikin Really Wrong?

That depends I guess.

Is this rock-solid conservative belief that women should not have an abortion even after a rape?

or

Is this belief that a woman's body can reject a pregnancy in the case of an actual rape?

You see there's a MAJOR difference there??


Both. Mecklenbuerg's "The Indications for INduced Abortion: a Physicians Perspective" by Mecklenburg is a common text http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2012/08/21/akin-rape-theory-rooted-in-nazi-death-camp-experiments/ for BOTH sets of believers.
 
NC had a argument with reality and they parted company forever

Regards
Pace
 
LeRoy: Are you capable of recognizing the results of an information campaign conducted by climate change denialists? Or is that something you have not 'seen'?

Yes, I believe such a campaign exists. It isn't not as prevalent as the one that the climate science proponents have. Just for example -- messaging includes labeling your opponents in some negative way. What is the label applied by proponents of athropogenic global warming to people who question their claims? (Hint, it is attached to a highly negative connotation).

Conversely, what is the label applied by the skeptics to the global warming proponents? You're right, no such label exists.
 
Trap your not skeptical You are cynical about any science that doesn't comport with your belief. You are cynical about Climate science. and the 'science' of reproduction you are talking about comes from the Nazi death camps and a misinterpretation of that data http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2012/08/21/akin-rape-theory-rooted-in-nazi-death-camp-experiments/

Interesting. I wonder if the Mecklinburg article is what I'm remembering. But Degs, even you realize that the immorality of the scientist has nothing to do with the validity or invalidity of the scientist's studies. It appears to make no mention of Ph, which is for some reason what's still bouncing around in my memory.
 
You know trap's posting history as well as any of us, LeRoy. When it comes to "provide for the common defense", any expansion of the federal government is permissible; however, when it comes to "promote the general welfare", no expansion of government power is warranted.

Oh, please. I don't believe in expanding the government one iota in the name of common defense. "Defense" however includes the ability to respond to a threat. If the enemy converts to armored steamships, you can no longer defend yourself with wooden sailing ships -- the meaning of "defense" doesn't change but the infrastructure to provide it has to change. That is by no means an expansion of government.

And I'm going to give you a pass. You used the words "promote the general welfare" and my standard response is that "promote" isn't the same thing as "provide." The pass I'm going to give you is that Article 1, Section 8, allows Congress to pay taxes to "provide for the general welfare..." But it makes no provision for providing a specific welfare for say, drought-ridden farmers, the elderly, the indigent, people with out insurance, etc. "General" means many things -- it can't mean "specific" without the language descending into incomprehensibility.
 
So he really didn't say that a woman's body knows a rape from "legitimate" sex and will not allow pregnancy in the case of a rape?

Akin and the base want to eliminate abortion all together. Why not just say that? What pisses me off about the republican party is the dishonesty. Just say that you don't want to extend unemployment because it let's people who used to be engineers turn down jobs at McDonalds. Just go with Romney's statement about letting people get thrown out of their homes so that the "investor" class can buy cheap foreclosures and rent them back to the former owners....Be honest, republicans like the idea of a faith based health insurance plan for people who are living on two minimum wage jobs....pray you don't get sick. "Trickle Down" lives. All rich people are job creators. All rich people are productive.

Quit dancing around the truth of what the party stands for. Aristocracy.
 
Well -- now you're just being incomprehensible. First, he didn't combine any " illigetimate" thing with anything else. Secondly, there is at least some science supporting the views (it is far from an indisputable "happens every time" thing).

He was trying to push a theory to support the elimination of abortion under all circumstances. If rape victims didn't get pregnant then no access to abortion is needed. He and Ryan came up with a bill that allowed abortion in the case of a pregnancy resulting from "violent" rape....Why was that? If the rape was not violent then no abortion, right?

There is no science supporting that view.
 
He was attempting to make the case that there are women who would lie about being raped so as to qualify for an abortion....
 
Yes, I believe such a campaign exists. It isn't not as prevalent as the one that the climate science proponents have. Just for example -- messaging includes labeling your opponents in some negative way. What is the label applied by proponents of athropogenic global warming to people who question their claims? (Hint, it is attached to a highly negative connotation).

Conversely, what is the label applied by the skeptics to the global warming proponents? You're right, no such label exists.

You are NOT SERIOUS!!!!
They demonized everyone as Gore Drones, Global Warming Moonbats, GW Liars, GW Hypocrits if we flew on a lpan or drove a car, Gore Helpers (Helping Gore get rich), the list goes on and on and on how we have and are demonized by those who insist there is no climate change from man's arrogant disregard for the planet.
 
You are NOT SERIOUS!!!!
They demonized everyone as Gore Drones, Global Warming Moonbats, GW Liars, GW Hypocrits if we flew on a lpan or drove a car, Gore Helpers (Helping Gore get rich), the list goes on and on and on how we have and are demonized by those who insist there is no climate change from man's arrogant disregard for the planet.

And yet not one of those is a universally applied label, a piece of messaging, that makes the person "evil" in the eyes of the reader or listener. "Denier" -- linked in most people's minds with the word "holocaust" -- portrays even a modest skeptic myself as evil. It was when the word "denier" started to become a common appellation that I started to suspect there was a coordinated messaging campaign. After Hurricane Katrina, I was certain of it.
 
Yes, I believe such a campaign exists. It isn't not as prevalent as the one that the climate science proponents have. Just for example -- messaging includes labeling your opponents in some negative way. What is the label applied by proponents of athropogenic global warming to people who question their claims? (Hint, it is attached to a highly negative connotation).

Conversely, what is the label applied by the skeptics to the global warming proponents? You're right, no such label exists.

LeRoy: Nonsense, Trap. The proponents are often called "global warming alarmists". Or, more extreme folks like Rush Limbaugh call them "Enviro-Nazis". I believe you know this, but simply forgot.
 
LeRoy: Nonsense, Trap. The proponents are often called "global warming alarmists". Or, more extreme folks like Rush Limbaugh call them "Enviro-Nazis". I believe you know this, but simply forgot.


I think the only term you've used that carries anything close to the "deniers" appelation is "enviro-nazis" -- and it is not in common use, whereas I've seen "global warming deniers" used on actual newspaper editorial pages and within hard-news reports.
 
I think the only term you've used that carries anything close to the "deniers" appelation is "enviro-nazis" -- and it is not in common use, whereas I've seen "global warming deniers" used on actual newspaper editorial pages and within hard-news reports.

LeRoy: I have FREQUENTLY seen the phrase "global warming alarmists" used, in MANY newspaper editorials. It is sometimes combined with the phrases "Chicken Littles" and "gloom-and-doomers". The phrase "environmental extremists" is QUITE common.
 
Well, it is one thing to believe someone is overly alarmed, or an extremist, and another to associate them implicitly with the Nazi Holocaust in Europe.

But I think the thread has strayed to far from its original topic.
 
Well, it is one thing to believe someone is overly alarmed, or an extremist, and another to associate them implicitly with the Nazi Holocaust in Europe.

But I think the thread has strayed to far from its original topic.

LeRoy: Although you probably differ, I don't believe there was any conscious attempt to associate global warming denialists with Nazi Holocaust denialists. Do you have a word that you think would be better to describe the people who vehemently disagree with the consensus in climate science? Global warming 'opponents' does not work in this context.
 
LeRoy: Although you probably differ, I don't believe there was any conscious attempt to associate global warming denialists with Nazi Holocaust denialists. Do you have a word that you think would be better to describe the people who vehemently disagree with the consensus in climate science? Global warming 'opponents' does not work in this context.

The term I tend to apply to myself is "global warming skeptic." I think there is some evidence of global warming, even some evidence that there is anthropogenic global warming, but I'm not convinced that it is the proximate cause of any short-term weather system (such as our current drought), nor that it merits pushing the panic button and essentially wrecking our economy to attempt to reverse it.

But you're right, I disagree that the term "denier" is being used non-maliciously. I think the term is being intentionally used to link those who aren't convinced about global warming (and hence don't back the various political solutions to the perceived problem), to those who deny the Holocaust.
 
"Skeptic" probably does have a very different connotation than "denier". I would, for example, tend to presume that a "global warming denier" was denying that there is ANY evidence that the world is warming. As you note, a "global warming skeptic" might agree that the world is warming, but deny there is any evidence of anthropogenic causes to the warming; or they might even acknowledge that humans might be causing it to some extent, but argue that the human impact is much smaller than natural causes. So, yes, I can certainly see that you would probably prefer to be called a "global warming skeptic" than a "global warming denier". And I have no a priori objection to the term.

On the other hand, though, if you were to call someone a "Holocaust skeptic", does that not sound very much almost as bad as to call them a "Holocaust denier"?
 
I suppose that would depend on what the skeptics statements were.

LeRoy: Well, some Holocaust 'skeptics' that I have heard deny that six million people (or thereabouts) were killed in Nazi concentration camps, and say (for example): "Hey, it was sixty thousand, TOPS!"
 
Back
Top