New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

We All Know....

I'll agree they're more likely....i don't know about 10 times. I think just about anyone though that has the smarts and works hard for it, if they started out poor, will actually be MORE stingy with their money later in life.

RIGHT... and being "stingy" means you INVEST CAREFULLY. whereas if you are born to wealth, you really can't tell the difference between earnign $10 on a $100 investment or earning $1... because you are used to so much income, the difference does not affect you.

Not everyone handles different circumstances the same
True - - but when you make POLICY DECISIONS you need to look at the BROAD DATA. and the BROAD DATA tells us that the Economic law known as the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility of Income (a fancy way of saying that $100 extra means more to your son than it does to me) tells us that THE UPPER 20% OF AMERICANS - are as a rule, LOUSY INVESTORS.

And that actual "job creation" comes primarily from MIDDLE CLASS investors.

For example. CALPERS - which is one working class retirement fund in only one industry in only one state - HAS MORE INVESTED IN JOB CREATION than the 10 wealthiest Americans COMBINED.
 
First off, DoD Expenditures have- according to CONSERVATIVE ECONOMISTS like Barro http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States have a Fiscal Multipler of 0.5. That compares to say civilian government infrastructure spending of 1.5 and as much as 4.0 for social safetynt programs.

That's an interesting analysis. It could well be that simply by decreasing the amount of value essentially being destroyed by military spending, we'd get economic growth that caused a balanced budget to be surprisingly easy to create. That would be consistent with the picture we saw in the Clinton era -- when holding military spending in check did, in fact, coincide with a surprisingly large increase in GDP, and an unexpected jump in revenues.

But, those kinds of "multipliers" are so speculative that I can't imagine too many conservatives will find that argument convincing. It's kind of the lefty equivalent of conservatives arguing that cutting taxes creates so much extra economic activity as to have those taxes pay for themselves.... well, obviously, not really the equivalent of that, but you get the point.

To be sufficiently "conservative" (in the classic sense of the word), the budget projections shouldn't rely on any of those kinds of economy-growing effects. If the beneficial effects do, indeed, materialize, great-- that'll put us in surplus. But the planning should aim to get us to balance without it.
 
Progressive taxes are the hallmark of communism, and we all know how that works out.

LeRoy: Adam Smith was a strong supporter of a progressive tax system. Adam Smith is generally considered the patron saint of capitalism. So this is a very ignorant and historically illiterate comment on your part.

A true flat tax system would utterly annihilate the middle class in this country. That seems to be what you guys are trying to do. Why you evidently favor a feudal economy and/or banana republic is something that you never bother to explain. Why don't you take a crack at it? Or are you chicken?
 
A true flat tax system would utterly annihilate the middle class in this country. That seems to be what you guys are trying to do. Why you evidently favor a feudal economy and/or banana republic is something that you never bother to explain. Why don't you take a crack at it? Or are you chicken?

I've tried to get Republicans to crunch the numbers on this, before, but I never get any takers. The math isn't actually hard, and the source data is available online. I think I'll first-tier post the challenge, with links, and see if it gets any takers.
 
I've tried to get Republicans to crunch the numbers on this, before, but I never get any takers. The math isn't actually hard, and the source data is available online. I think I'll first-tier post the challenge, with links, and see if it gets any takers.

LeRoy: Yes, by all means, do so!!
 
But, those kinds of "multipliers" are so speculative that I can't imagine too many conservatives will find that argument convincing. It's kind of the lefty equivalent of conservatives arguing that cutting taxes creates so much extra economic activity as to have those taxes pay for themselves.... well, obviously, not really the equivalent of that, but you get the point.

I agree. One thing that I like to do in these situations is to play around with a range of multipliers and watch what happens in different scenarios - most pessimistic case to best case. (I am very skeptical of the budget projections that Paul Ryan comes up with.)
 
I would enjoy that.

I've tried to get Republicans to crunch the numbers on this, before, but I never get any takers. The math isn't actually hard, and the source data is available online. I think I'll first-tier post the challenge, with links, and see if it gets any takers.
 
That's an interesting analysis. It could well be that simply by decreasing the amount of value essentially being destroyed by military spending, we'd get economic growth that caused a balanced budget to be surprisingly easy to create. That would be consistent with the picture we saw in the Clinton era -- when holding military spending in check did, in fact, coincide with a surprisingly large increase in GDP, and an unexpected jump in revenues.
EXACTLY

But, those kinds of "multipliers" are so speculative that I can't imagine too many conservatives will find that argument convincing.

Wrong. There is nothing speculative about them There is about 70 years of solid data supporting them. Remember that with civillian government "stimulus" in the recovery from The Great Depression the USA grew at 8.1% year on year GDP with the exception being the one year there was a cutback (37/38)

We saw the same thing with the two recessions that came in the 80s. the one that Reagan inherited ran under Carter stimulus/welfare legislation and was shallower and narrower for each percent GDP lost than the one under Reagan. And recovery from the first one was faster.

Meanwhile if you look at the GDP growth during the GWB era, it UNDERPERFORMED HISTORIC AVERAGES BY 22%... Precisely what the multipliers predicted. http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/gdp-growth

Now you are correct, NO IDEOLOGICAL CONSERVATIVE will find this data "convincing" - but that's more a case of "I'll see it when I believe it" more than anything else. Remember these clowns are still insisting that FDR - despite an annualized growth rate of 8.1% was "making the depression longer"....


To be sufficiently "conservative" (in the classic sense of the word), the budget projections shouldn't rely on any of those kinds of economy-growing effects.
Then in essence you want us to model the economy using Von Mises Voodoo economics that are untethered from observable reality. I won't do that.
 
We all know that Romney/Ryan's plan is to destroy the middle class, enrich the wealthy, end medicare and social security, because Obama and the Democrats are telling us that is what they will do, and we know that Obama and the Democrats NEVER lie or exaggerate or misrepresent or tell half truths.

A rare moment of lucidity. Well done, Sarge.

But what exactly is Obama and the Democrats plan? I mean, yesterday Obama was say it was "shared prosperity." What does that mean? Is a more prosperous person going to be forced to share his prosperity with a less prosperous person? Will a person who works hard be forced to share the fruits of his labor with a person who works less hard?

Is that why we are making people who buy their own food pay for people who don't buy their own food. Is that why we are forcing people who save for their own pensions to fund other people's pensions? Is that why we are taking money from people who pay into social security and medicare to pay for people on Disability and Medicaid who don't pay into social security and Medicaid.

I wanna know what Obama and the Democrats plan is. Or is it more of the same. More takers and fewer makers?

I WANNA KNOW!!!!!

The Democratic plan is to start taxing the wealthy again.
 
Load of hooey. "Basic primates" live by might makes right -- vis, mating rituals.
Actually that's not the case at all. They are highly cooperative. You need to read up on the research. your ignorance is showing here. In the particular experiment, 3 chimps were kept in adjacent cages all day and their feeding was delayed. Then one was given 10 bananas, one was given 6 bananas and one was given none. Since the cages were close, they could transfer the bananas. the 10 banana one shared 3 bananas to the no banana one. and the 6 banana chimp shared 1 banana.... that left them with 7,5 and 4. And it was "progressive taxation"...


There is no level of taxation of the rich that is "enough," Degs, that's the point you miss.
And that's just a hollow conservative strawman.

While a given level might be enough to suit you, personally, there is never going to be enough to suit the idea of "fairness."
Sure it will again, Marginal Utility of Income. And we have that data.


And that specifically answers the question. We know from the WSJ published data that the "Laffer Curve" plateau is around 70% marginal tax rate.
Laffer.jpg
We know from Marginal Utility of Income http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/aea/jel/2008/00000046/00000001/art00003 starts falling rapidly after about $70,000 annual income and hits less than 1% by the time you hit $1 mill/yr income.

So MUoI would have us set the top rate at 99%...

But that's foolish since that's not an EFFECTIVELY COLLECTABLE rate and it COSTS MORE than it garners. So we set the top rate at 70%, and roll off deductions after $500k income.

Simple.
 
Back
Top