New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

What a weak dollar really does...

Perhaps....

however I do find the video in the second post to be nothing less than brilliant....it is a simple concept...." Fiddling with the scales "......as he put it.


JO
Ok you and Beck find it brilliant. Its bogus economics but that shouldn't change the views of a true believer I guess.
 
Lukey said:
Yet a quick scan of the first page in your link clearly shows the word being repeatedly used in that very context.
Which tells us nothing about the 2nd page or any of the other 170 million hits you are claiming supports your thesis that this is a legitimate usage. It may be used a lot by folks who are ignorant of its actual meaning. That people misuse Whom and Who and "irregardless" itself gets 2 million hits on google, doesn't mean they are correct usages.

But again this has no core bearing on the economic argument you present. It simply goes to show that level of critical reasoning you are bringing to the process.

And, um, no, the rest of Marx's teachings are NOT "irrelevant."
In a discussion of economics, a political polemic has little relevance. But that in fact is the problem you are yourself facing - you don't seem to recognize that

Are you contesting the data reported by USA Today?
read what I wrote. And address it please.

"Equity Investment is not the same as how many entrepreneurial startups there are." No, but I didn't say it was. Neither is it how much VC money that is raised.
Actually VC money is BY DEFINItION Equity Investment - in startups.

And yes you did say the two are equal Because you used a measure of "entrepreneurial activity" (which measures mostly PRE-VC activity) as a "refutation" to the Price Waterhouse Coopers data on 22% year-on-year increase in VC funding. And remember what the discussion was

That Penalizing SAVINGS drives money into EQUITY INVESTMENT. to which your response was "there is no evidence of this happening". Which I refuted with the PWC data. You then switched form that issue to Entrepreneurial activity - which is a different issue and not related either to savings or Equity Investment for startups.

But you don't seem to understand the difference.


Besides, I didn't change the subject - you did! I just said bad government economic policy is killing new business investment
Which the VC increase refutes. Because VC funding is clearly NEW BUSINESS INVESTMENT

- and I'd say being at a point where you have a 25 year low in entrepreneurial activity (and are bumping along at decade lows in VC investment) is pretty much going to support my point.
No it does not. Since you have made ZERO connection other than temporal coincidence between the penalizing of savings and the low Entrepreneurial rate. Frankly there is a much simpler reason for the low entrepreneurial rate than your convoluted connection to something that even in good times is CONTRARY to entrepreneurial activity (ie savings). And that factor is the implosion of Home Equity. Most entrepreneurial activity is funded by
1) Home Equity Lines of Credit
2) Credit Card lines of Credit (go read up on how Netscape was funded)

NEITHER of which has anything to do with BANK SAVINGS or MONEYMARKET SAVINGS - which is what you were complaining was being penalized (and it is - for good reason as the VC numbers show) and both of which have to do with the economic collapse we have seen. Look I'm a prime example - I had a business plan all set to go for a startup. I was going to take out a 2nd mortgage to fund the development. Now that puts me over the 80% LTV ratio and hence I cannot fund the startup. And having already struggled with one business that was undercapitalized - I'm not going down that road a second time.

That's 2 developers that didn't get hired and one startup that didn't go... not because I make more money with my 401k and IRA in the stock market rather than the bank - but because the economic slump specifically affected the core equity I had built up outside of the securities markets.


You need to learn how the economic system works. You are making shiit up that just isn't true. "savings" are NOT USED TO FUND STARTUPS... . Savings fund very conservative investments. That's why their returns tend to be crap.

FACTS MATTER
RELEVANT ONES - not ones that happen to be a nice coincidence.


So what, exactly, is yours? That Obamanomics is a font of entrepreneurial activity? If so you are going to have to do better than your PWC one year data point to prove that. So have at it...[/QUOTE]
 
Which tells us nothing about the 2nd page or any of the other 170 million hits you are claiming supports your thesis that this is a legitimate usage. It may be used a lot by folks who are ignorant of its actual meaning. That people misuse Whom and Who and "irregardless" itself gets 2 million hits on google, doesn't mean they are correct usages.

But again this has no core bearing on the economic argument you present. It simply goes to show that level of critical reasoning you are bringing to the process.


In a discussion of economics, a political polemic has little relevance. But that in fact is the problem you are yourself facing - you don't seem to recognize that


read what I wrote. And address it please.


Actually VC money is BY DEFINItION Equity Investment - in startups.

And yes you did say the two are equal Because you used a measure of "entrepreneurial activity" (which measures mostly PRE-VC activity) as a "refutation" to the Price Waterhouse Coopers data on 22% year-on-year increase in VC funding. And remember what the discussion was

That Penalizing SAVINGS drives money into EQUITY INVESTMENT. to which your response was "there is no evidence of this happening". Which I refuted with the PWC data. You then switched form that issue to Entrepreneurial activity - which is a different issue and not related either to savings or Equity Investment for startups.

But you don't seem to understand the difference.



Which the VC increase refutes. Because VC funding is clearly NEW BUSINESS INVESTMENT


No it does not. Since you have made ZERO connection other than temporal coincidence between the penalizing of savings and the low Entrepreneurial rate. Frankly there is a much simpler reason for the low entrepreneurial rate than your convoluted connection to something that even in good times is CONTRARY to entrepreneurial activity (ie savings). And that factor is the implosion of Home Equity. Most entrepreneurial activity is funded by
1) Home Equity Lines of Credit
2) Credit Card lines of Credit (go read up on how Netscape was funded)

NEITHER of which has anything to do with BANK SAVINGS or MONEYMARKET SAVINGS - which is what you were complaining was being penalized (and it is - for good reason as the VC numbers show) and both of which have to do with the economic collapse we have seen. Look I'm a prime example - I had a business plan all set to go for a startup. I was going to take out a 2nd mortgage to fund the development. Now that puts me over the 80% LTV ratio and hence I cannot fund the startup. And having already struggled with one business that was undercapitalized - I'm not going down that road a second time.

That's 2 developers that didn't get hired and one startup that didn't go... not because I make more money with my 401k and IRA in the stock market rather than the bank - but because the economic slump specifically affected the core equity I had built up outside of the securities markets.


You need to learn how the economic system works. You are making shiit up that just isn't true. "savings" are NOT USED TO FUND STARTUPS... . Savings fund very conservative investments. That's why their returns tend to be crap.

FACTS MATTER
RELEVANT ONES - not ones that happen to be a nice coincidence.


So what, exactly, is yours? That Obamanomics is a font of entrepreneurial activity? If so you are going to have to do better than your PWC one year data point to prove that. So have at it...
[/QUOTE]

First of all, "irregardless" isn't even a word. "Decimate" is. And one of its definitions is "to destroy a great number or proportion of." Another is "to cause great destruction or harm to." So, like, are the dictionaries "ignorant of its actual meaning" too? Or is it you? As I have said repeatedly, I used it in an acceptable fashion and context. I have presented overwhelming evidence to that effect. That you persist in claiming it is wrong in the face of this evidence is your problem, not mine. I categorically reject your false and erroneous assertion that I used the word incorrectly. And this certainly speaks to the level of "critical reasoning" YOU bring to the process here.

Now, on to the economics at hand. In a "discussion of economics" a complete examination of the political efforts that are necessary (or suggested) to effect the economic policy is not only appropriate, it is, in fact, essential. So any and all of Marx's theories and teachings are fair game in any discussion about how Marxist someone is (or isn't) in their economics. As usual, you want to limit that discussion to minimize the likelihood that your policy preferences will be recognized for what they are (so you can maintain the charade that they are "moderate" or "mainstream").

And I do read and address what you write - you just like to ignore it when it gets uncomfortable. All the data is relevant (including your single data point on VC investment). But you have certainly failed to make the case that current equity investment is robust (even if we limit it to VC money, which, of course, is absurd - "equity investment" is any money that is invested in a firm by its owners or shareholders - a definition that would include but not be limited to VC funding).

While $28 billion (22% increase) in VC investment seems like a nice thing to see, buried in the fine print of your report is that where appropriate, government money is included (which is why "clean tech" is one of the two highest funded areas). IOW, this includes Obama's investments in Solyndra and all the other failed "green" companies, which, as we have seen, does little for actual job and/or wealth creation. Back that out and we'll see this number drop back to a less impressive level, I am sure.

And that is why a statistic like I offered, that shows entrepreneurial activity at 25 year lows is more indicative of the actual economic state of the business start up sector of the economy than your number that is puffed up by the Federal Government's wasted tax dollars being pumped into failed or failing "green" businesses.

Every business investment is an "equity investment" including the money put into a start up by an entrepreneur, and at least my number isn't distorted by bad government policy masking the true level of (private) economic activity being studied. As usual, you are touting big government Keynesian "investments" over actual, real dollars provided by and invested in the private economy (which is quite likely depressed by the very ill advised government policies I originally suggested - including those that produced the housing bubble that you suggest is helping to suppress current entrepreneurial activity). And it's not just the low interest rates (which you are correct in saying is normally helpful toward business investment) but also the declining value of the dollar that I referred to as "punishing savers." The government, through its bad fiscal and monetary policy is "crowding out" the private sector (including business investments). People just don't feel confident enough in the future economic growth to invest in entrepreneurial activities, so they park their money in low return cds or they speculate in stocks, rather than funding a start up or expansion of a small business.

So, as usual, the relevant facts matter, and I am the one presenting them - while you are just spewing more spin based on wasteful big government spending and bad economic policy.
 
Well for one Lukey I want to compliment you for taking somewhat of a step back and actually writing something less than purely polemical echo chamber nonsense. If more of your posts were like this one, we might even have an interesting discussion. YOUR CALL.

First of all, "irregardless" isn't even a word. [/quote]
2 million posters think so. According to the logic you use for Decimate, that means it is... and is properly used...."

Decimate has an etymology that a person who wants to use that word would normally know. Clearly you did not. Instead you were using it as phrase of "received wisdom" that you really did not fully understand - like your claims on the impact of savings.

Now, on to the economics at hand. In a "discussion of economics" a complete examination of the political efforts that are necessary (or suggested) to effect the economic policy is not only appropriate, it is, in fact, essential. So any and all of Marx's theories and teachings are fair game in any discussion about how Marxist someone is (or isn't) in their economics.
Not really - because much of what Marx argues "politically" isn't a whole lot different than what can be found in Acts 4 and 5 of the christian bible or in sections of the Koran etc.

The POLITICAL issue of Marxism then is actually just an ad hominem cudgel that is a modern form of McCarthyism. It was bullshiit demagougery then and it is Bullshiit Demagougery now.


All the data is relevant (including your single data point on VC investment). But you have certainly failed to make the case that current equity investment is robust (even if we limit it to VC money, which, of course, is absurd - "equity investment" is any money that is invested in a firm by its owners or shareholders - a definition that would include but not be limited to VC funding).
Ah but NEW business activities is funded by VC money. We already know from the major equity market indexes that overall equity investment is solid and has been for close to 30 months.

VC investment is a measure of equity funds avaialbable to NEW businesses that are growing. Why? Because VC money looks for businesses with business plans that have 1000% ROI over 5 years. They run a 95% failure rate but it still gives them great ROI.

While $28 billion (22% increase) in VC investment seems like a nice thing to see, buried in the fine print of your report is that where appropriate, government money is included (which is why "clean tech" is one of the two highest funded areas). IOW, this includes Obama's investments in Solyndra and all the other failed "green" companies, which, as we have seen, does little for actual job and/or wealth creation. Back that out and we'll see this number drop back to a less impressive level, I am sure.
Actually the governemnt VC investment rate has a better payoff than the private VC rate. Private VC rate runs a 95% failure rate.


And that is why a statistic like I offered, that shows entrepreneurial activity at 25 year lows is more indicative of the actual economic state of the business start up sector of the economy than your number that is puffed up by the Federal Government's wasted tax dollars being pumped into failed or failing "green" businesses.

But the discussion was not about the state of the Startup Sector... and this is where again you are engaged in the Red HErring fallacy. The discussion was about whether or not a disincentive for SAVINGS was the right monetary strategy to encourage growth in a recovery. And you have not shown how incentivizing savings in any way INCREASES entrepreneurial activity. In fact it DOES THE OPPOSITE. Because if you are "increasing savings" you are NOT taking entrepreneurial risks.

So in point of fact the very policy you advocate - one that supports savings rather than penalizing it WOULD REDUCE Entrepreneurial activity.

And it's not just the low interest rates (which you are correct in saying is normally helpful toward business investment) but also the declining value of the dollar that I referred to as "punishing savers."
Again, punishing savers is GOOD FOR ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITY. So is a weak dollar. Why? Because it reduces the competitiveness of imports. Thus- for example - $1 buys less of an Indian Call Center's time. Which makes a USA Call Center MORE PRICE COMPETITIVE. And when you add in the intangibles of better cultural affinity that you get with domestic call centers - you have created an entrepreneurial incentive.

And this applies across a host of businesses from service sector through manufacturing.

The government, through its bad fiscal and monetary policy is "crowding out" the private sector (including business investments).
There is Zero data to support your "crowding out" thesis. Again you are just spouting "received wisdom" that you cannot back up with facts

People just don't feel confident enough in the future economic growth to invest in entrepreneurial activities, so they park their money in low return cds [/quote]
Um that is "savings". Your claim is that
1) Savings rates are down (so "parking money" is down)
2) the policies in place PUNISH such decisions... so what rational investor would do this?

or they speculate in stocks, rather than funding a start up or expansion of a small business.
Stocks are Equities. Equities are the expansion of businesses, small and large.... you just contradicted yourself for the second time in one sentence... well done.

So, as usual, the relevant facts matter, and I am the one presenting them

Right... Savings are being punished so people will be saving more which is a bad thing???!!!????

LISTEN TO YOUR OWN IDEAS!!!
 
Well for one Lukey I want to compliment you for taking somewhat of a step back and actually writing something less than purely polemical echo chamber nonsense. If more of your posts were like this one, we might even have an interesting discussion. YOUR CALL.

First of all, "irregardless" isn't even a word.
2 million posters think so. According to the logic you use for Decimate, that means it is... and is properly used...."

Decimate has an etymology that a person who wants to use that word would normally know. Clearly you did not. Instead you were using it as phrase of "received wisdom" that you really did not fully understand - like your claims on the impact of savings.


Not really - because much of what Marx argues "politically" isn't a whole lot different than what can be found in Acts 4 and 5 of the christian bible or in sections of the Koran etc.

The POLITICAL issue of Marxism then is actually just an ad hominem cudgel that is a modern form of McCarthyism. It was bullshiit demagougery then and it is Bullshiit Demagougery now.



Ah but NEW business activities is funded by VC money. We already know from the major equity market indexes that overall equity investment is solid and has been for close to 30 months.

VC investment is a measure of equity funds avaialbable to NEW businesses that are growing. Why? Because VC money looks for businesses with business plans that have 1000% ROI over 5 years. They run a 95% failure rate but it still gives them great ROI.


Actually the governemnt VC investment rate has a better payoff than the private VC rate. Private VC rate runs a 95% failure rate.




But the discussion was not about the state of the Startup Sector... and this is where again you are engaged in the Red HErring fallacy. The discussion was about whether or not a disincentive for SAVINGS was the right monetary strategy to encourage growth in a recovery. And you have not shown how incentivizing savings in any way INCREASES entrepreneurial activity. In fact it DOES THE OPPOSITE. Because if you are "increasing savings" you are NOT taking entrepreneurial risks.

So in point of fact the very policy you advocate - one that supports savings rather than penalizing it WOULD REDUCE Entrepreneurial activity.


Again, punishing savers is GOOD FOR ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITY. So is a weak dollar. Why? Because it reduces the competitiveness of imports. Thus- for example - $1 buys less of an Indian Call Center's time. Which makes a USA Call Center MORE PRICE COMPETITIVE. And when you add in the intangibles of better cultural affinity that you get with domestic call centers - you have created an entrepreneurial incentive.

And this applies across a host of businesses from service sector through manufacturing.


There is Zero data to support your "crowding out" thesis. Again you are just spouting "received wisdom" that you cannot back up with facts

People just don't feel confident enough in the future economic growth to invest in entrepreneurial activities, so they park their money in low return cds [/quote]
Um that is "savings". Your claim is that
1) Savings rates are down (so "parking money" is down)
2) the policies in place PUNISH such decisions... so what rational investor would do this?


Stocks are Equities. Equities are the expansion of businesses, small and large.... you just contradicted yourself for the second time in one sentence... well done.



Right... Savings are being punished so people will be saving more which is a bad thing???!!!????

LISTEN TO YOUR OWN IDEAS!!!

No, according to MY "logic" I used decimate correctly because on-line dictionaries list my usage as being correct, AND it is commonly used the way I used it, as evidenced by the myriad examples listed by a simple Google search. Now those are facts and you claim to be a fan of facts, but in this instance you insist on ignoring the facts and maintaining your ignorance. So why should anyone be induced to accept your regular rejection of everything else I have ever posted as "counter-factual" when you display here a clear bias against obvious facts that don't comport with your (rather narrow) viewpoint?

Which is exactly why I find so little motivation to (seriously) address your posts that are long on jargon and made up "facts" (i.e. resultant from biased studies that only accept and, in fact, feature left wing theoretical DNA) and rather short on logic and (what we call in the reality based community) actual evidence. Maybe if you can (finally) admit your obvious over-reach on the "correct" usage of the word "decimate" then we could possibly find some other "facts" to agree on. Until then, I would posit that most (if not all) of your criticism of my posts is rooted in a similar myopia.
 
Hint, the yuan is not the PRC's currency...

Actually, yes, it is. The Renminbi is denominated in Yuan, which is the term commonly used when referring to Chinese currency matters:

http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/03/20/us-china-currency-oecd-idUSBRE82J0EZ20120320

Perhaps this will help:

The distinction between the Renminbi and the Yuan is similar to the distinction between the British Sterling and Pound. Renminbi refers to the whole Chinese money system whereas Yuan is the base unit of Renminbi. Yuan is used to denominate bills, and is the unit in which prices are measured.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_currency

Again, we find Degsme finding fault where fault does not exist, in a (rather) lame attempt to denigrate my posting (yawn).
 
No data supports this. No major economist supports this. The REAL problem was deregulation of Wall Street in both major legislative avenues (Gramm-Leach-Bliley, CMFA) and administrative (evisceration of the SEC's investigatory and enforcement arms, waivers for reserve requirements).

Had there been no cross-pollination via CDSes, Lehman would have failed and not endangered the rest of the banking structure.
Had there been no cross-pollination via CDSes, AIG would have had zero impact on Chrysler and GM
Had there been no cross-pollination via CDSes, Wall Street's illness would not have affected banks World Wide

There is an economic law for this sort of cross-pollination contamination - its called Gresham's Law. Essentially Gresham's law says - like most fundamental laws do - something quite common sensical: When you cannot distinguish between something of value and something of fake or bad value - EVERYONE errs on the side of assuming it is bad.

Thus the cross-pollination of CDSes as a way of backing all sorts of composite and derivative securities meant that no one could easily tell what the actual value of any portfolio was.

Had GLB not passed, Investment banks would not have been allowed into the Mortgage securitization market
Had Investment banks not been in the Mortgage Securitization market, there would have been no explosion of NINJA and similar loans (this was not driven by Fed Easing, this was GLB)

Had the Commodities Modernization Futures Act (CMFA) not passed, CDSes would have been regulated like the options they are. Which means that you would not have been able to sell more options than there was actual equity in the markets without those CDSes receiving higher risk ratings due to their "nakedness" (ie lack of connection to underlying commodities). The the CMFA allowed for the cross polination described above.



And to refute Lukey's claim about the Fed Easing being the source of the problem. No that simply isn't true. Had GLB not passed but the Fed had eased - there would still be NO NINJA LOANS in the volumes we saw... why? Because Invetment banks would still have been unable to securitize these high risk mortgages, and would not have been able to give sales incentives to local banks and aggregators to package them.

OTOH had the Fed NOT eased but GLB passed, we still WOULD HAVE SEEN the implosion. And of largely the same magnitude. Because the driving force behind the tranching (sliced up securitization) of the "non-conforming" (which means Unpurchasable by FNMA/FMAC) aka "subprime" loans was not the silly supply side argument of Fed Easing. Had there been no demand for these products, the Fed could have eased till judgment day with no effect. But there was a HUGE DEMAND for these products. The demand was driven by APAC new wealth.

As DefeatObama demonstrated in another thread - the wealthy - particularly the newly wealthy - tend to invest their core assets in "Safe" "Fixed rate of return" investments that then give then a steady and safe level of predictable income that "cannot be touched". The newly minted APAC wealth sought this. And the NY Equity markets being the least corrupt, most stable and most solid were where they went. And this was an influx of a HUGE amount of purchasing dollars that the investment banks sought to satisfy.

Had GLB not passed, they would have been unable to create the tranches they did, and that cash would have gone into TBills. But instead it did not.



all of these are INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIABLE data points. NONE of which Lukey can address except by ad hominem about Marxism and "anti capitalim" and similar clap trap.

Um, not so fast:

A collateralized mortgage obligation (CMO) is a type of debt security first created in 1983 by the investment banks Salomon Brothers and First Boston for U.S. mortgage lender Freddie Mac.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collateralized_mortgage_obligation

So, what we find is that, in fact, the CMO was not the problem, but rather too much loose Fed policy, which gave rise to the "sub-prime" CMO as people reached for yield in the face of artificially low interest rates. So, what were you saying about "independently verifiable data points?"
 
Actually, yes, it is. The Renminbi is denominated in Yuan, which is the term commonly used when referring to Chinese currency matters:

http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/03/20/us-china-currency-oecd-idUSBRE82J0EZ20120320

Perhaps this will help:

The distinction between the Renminbi and the Yuan is similar to the distinction between the British Sterling and Pound. Renminbi refers to the whole Chinese money system whereas Yuan is the base unit of Renminbi. Yuan is used to denominate bills, and is the unit in which prices are measured.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_currency

Again, we find Degsme finding fault where fault does not exist, in a (rather) lame attempt to denigrate my posting (yawn).

Nah - I'm fine learning new things. Exchange rate is based on the Renminbi. Using "common terms" when trying to have a discussion about precise economic factors is a bit like misusing the term "decimate" to mean more than a 10% reduction.

But lets get back to the factual discussion of the actual data.


One of the claims made was that somehow the weak dollar is CAUSING oil price increases rather than other factors being in play. Now if this were true, then US dollar prices for oil would have increased and other currency prices would not have. After all since the dollar is weakening relative to those currencies, their purchasing power WRT oil should have increased. So lets look at that chart
http://www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2012/03/17/opinion/sunday/0318-web-edit1.html?ref=sunday
agraphics8.nytimes.com_images_2012_03_17_opinion_sunday_0318_web_edit1_0318_web_edit1_popup.png

Notice how gasoline prices WORLD WIDE are moving in lock step here? IOW the weakness of the Dollar relative to The Euro, and the Pound Sterling is CURRENTLY LOCK STEP

Notice that this WAS NOT the case in '98-2000 (england diverges as the currency strengths diverged)


So much for the idea that a "weak dollar" is CAUSING the high oil prices.
 
What a weak dollar really does...

A weak dollar means more dollars are required to purchase goods and services.

It means your savings that you worked for all your life to accumulate, and your retirement standard of living will be lowered.

Inflation is the one form of taxation that can be imposed without legislation, and that is what the Obama administration is doing. It transfers more wealth to the government as more money has to be earned, either by working harder and longer hours, or investing in instruments that are a hedge against inflation, and increasing the number people occupying the higher tax brackets, paying more taxes at higher tax rates.

We are increasingly becoming a nation that taxes work and subsidizes non work.

This is why that, if you put the federal government in charge of the Sahara Desert, in 5 years you'd be out of sand.
 
Um, not so fast:

A collateralized mortgage obligation (CMO) is a type of debt security first created in 1983 by the investment banks Salomon Brothers and First Boston for U.S. mortgage lender Freddie Mac.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collateralized_mortgage_obligation

So, what we find is that, in fact, the CMO was not the problem, but rather too much loose Fed policy, which gave rise to the "sub-prime" CMO as people reached for yield in the face of artificially low interest rates. So, what were you saying about "independently verifiable data points?"

Yup. And at the time, they were not allowed to work directly with lenders, but were only allowed to tranch mortgages that were owned, insured and originated by other parties. That meant that they were in competition with the GSEs.. And since the GSEs were more efficient - there wasn't much profit to be made here except when market momentum changed.

Gramm-Leach-Bliley allowed this barrier to come down. Now the Investment banks could directly own, originate and insure these CMOs. Which meant that they could DIRECTLY CREATE the NINJA loans.
 
A) As I have demonstratively shown, I did NOT use decimate "incorrectly." Here is the link to dictionary.com for those of you who need the proof:

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/decimate

"To destroy a great number or proportion of" is a correct usage of the term "decimate." It is no longer limited to just "ten percent" and has not been for quite a long time (for anyone, I suppose, except angry Marxists).

B) Don't be fooled by Degsme's flawed logic. Every single one of the currencies he is using in this example have been declining in value relative to gold as developed nations (dare I say it?) decimate their currencies by printing money to maintain their extensive welfare states.

For example, if the dollar since 2002 had been as good as the:

• Chinese yuan, the price of oil today would be $82 and a gallon of regular gas would cost about $3.10;

• Euro, the price of oil today would be $77 and regular gas would cost about $2.90;

• Japanese yen, the price of oil today would be $71 and regular gas would cost about $2.75;

• Swiss Franc, the price of oil today would be $63 and regular gas would cost about $2.50.

Even these results miss the full decline in the dollar’s value because the value of all of these currencies, too, have fallen over the past decade. If the dollar had been as good as gold, the price of oil today would be about $20 a barrel, and the price of gasoline would be down near $1 a gallon.


http://www.forbes.com/sites/charleskadlec/2012/03/19/the-rising-price-of-the-falling-dollar/
 
Yup. And at the time, they were not allowed to work directly with lenders, but were only allowed to tranch mortgages that were owned, insured and originated by other parties. That meant that they were in competition with the GSEs.. And since the GSEs were more efficient - there wasn't much profit to be made here except when market momentum changed.

Gramm-Leach-Bliley allowed this barrier to come down. Now the Investment banks could directly own, originate and insure these CMOs. Which meant that they could DIRECTLY CREATE the NINJA loans.

For which there would have been NO DEMAND had the Fed not been maintaining too loose a policy.
 
quote_icon.png
Originally Posted by degsmeYup. And at the time, they were not allowed to work directly with lenders, but were only allowed to tranch mortgages that were owned, insured and originated by other parties. That meant that they were in competition with the GSEs.. And since the GSEs were more efficient - there wasn't much profit to be made here except when market momentum changed.

Gramm-Leach-Bliley allowed this barrier to come down. Now the Investment banks could directly own, originate and insure these CMOs. Which meant that they could DIRECTLY CREATE the NINJA loans.
For which there would have been NO DEMAND had the Fed not been maintaining too loose a policy.

Not true. The demand was largely from Overseas via APAC. This had nothing to do with The Fed... NOTHING. The data on this is quite clear.
 
Not true. The demand was largely from Overseas via APAC. This had nothing to do with The Fed... NOTHING. The data on this is quite clear.

Do you mean from trading partners who were looking for a better yield than Treasuries to buy with their (declining in value) dollars?
 
quote_icon.png
Originally Posted by degsmeNot true. The demand was largely from Overseas via APAC. This had nothing to do with The Fed... NOTHING. The data on this is quite clear.
Do you mean from trading partners who were looking for a better yield than Treasuries to buy with their (declining in value) dollars?
Nope
 
A weak dollar means more dollars are required to purchase goods and services.

No not true. It only means more dollars are required to purchase IMPORTED GOODS AND SERVICES

It means your savings that you worked for all your life to accumulate, and your retirement standard of living will be lowered.
Only if your savings is in cash. If your savings is in productive Securitized Equities - particularly ones that have export components, your standard of living will GO UP.

Inflation is the one form of taxation that can be imposed without legislation
But a weak dollar is not necessarily "inflation". It can be inflation and it does inflate IMPORTED goods. But it also increases DOMESTIC productivity and output. Therby reducing domestic inflation.

We are increasingly becoming a nation that taxes work and subsidizes non work.
Nope - you have no evidence for this. In fact the parts of the economy where this is MOST true is CONSERVATIVE STATES. Conservative states would not be able to operate on even a 20th Century basis were it not for subsidies from "Blue" States and Blue regions.

When are you going to start pulling your own weight?
http://www.taxfoundation.org/research/show/26337.html
http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/welfare-state/Content?oid=6686284
http://www.taxfoundation.org/research/show/22685.html
 
No not true. It only means more dollars are required to purchase IMPORTED GOODS AND SERVICES


Only if your savings is in cash. If your savings is in productive Securitized Equities - particularly ones that have export components, your standard of living will GO UP.


But a weak dollar is not necessarily "inflation". It can be inflation and it does inflate IMPORTED goods. But it also increases DOMESTIC productivity and output. Therby reducing domestic inflation.


Nope - you have no evidence for this. In fact the parts of the economy where this is MOST true is CONSERVATIVE STATES. Conservative states would not be able to operate on even a 20th Century basis were it not for subsidies from "Blue" States and Blue regions.

When are you going to start pulling your own weight?
http://www.taxfoundation.org/research/show/26337.html
http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/welfare-state/Content?oid=6686284
http://www.taxfoundation.org/research/show/22685.html

Well unless you have a closed economy, the general price level is going to go up because if I buy imported stuff and my costs for them is going up I am quite likely to raise the price of my consulting services to accommodate them. So my customer who only buys domestic will see inflation regardless. As for your suggestion that investors in equities can prosper from inflation, not likely unless they use (low cost) leverage (i.e. hedge fund type investing) or eschew equities for precious metals:

4684361960_dd127c3e87.jpg

And exactly how does inflation increase productivity? It doesn't of course, because what it does s decrease the value of your compensation which makes your work appear more productive. So, like, does breaking the back of a union and lowering wage rates also make a worker "more productive?"
 
Well unless you have a closed economy, the general price level is going to go up because if I buy imported stuff and my costs for them is going up I am quite likely to raise the price of my consulting services to accommodate them.

Hmm so in the US Economy you don't have domestic sources???? sorry you do. For almost every product. Which means even if you choose to buy BMW trucks as your fleet vehicles, you are competing against other vendors who chose Freightliners or Kenworths - and thus you have to eat the cost difference or do less volume of business (simply supply/demand cost point)

Yes somethings don't have "substitute products" (oil) but in the US economy, most things do. And that does not require a "closed economy" in any way. So in fact most customers won't see much inflation except in some minor sectors. In fact if you look at domestic inflation rates vs. Dollar strength - there is very little correlation http://one-simple-idea.com/USD_Falling.htm much less causation.

You keep using Gold as a measure of inflation but gold buggery - as I have demonstrated in the divergence of gold from other species commodities - obviates that as a useful measure.

And exactly how does inflation DOMESTIC increase productivity?

Notice how you left out the crucial DOMESTIC productivity and how you conflate inflation with a weak dollar (which there is little correlation between). Once again you are arguing a strawman that isn't worth answering.
 
Hmm so in the US Economy you don't have domestic sources???? sorry you do. For almost every product. Which means even if you choose to buy BMW trucks as your fleet vehicles, you are competing against other vendors who chose Freightliners or Kenworths - and thus you have to eat the cost difference or do less volume of business (simply supply/demand cost point)

Most people aren't in the market for Semi Trucks. But they are in the market for clothing, televisions, shoes, etc. And your devalued dollar won't bring down the prices of American made goods, it will simply raise the prices of imports, many of which, such as televisions and most electronics, have no American counterparts. This will hurt low and middle income people the most.

And since oil is priced in dollars, with a devalued dollar you will also pay more for gasoline and diesel. Since all of our Farm equipment runs on diesel or gas, this will raise the cost of food, transportation and virtually everything else.

So much for liberals who support the middle class and the poor. Your policies are disastrous for them. And your president has been a disaster for the vast majority of the country.

Of course it's to be expected; Liberalism-Socialism-Marxism-Progressivism has spread more misery to more people than any other single fact of history.

But it's done with so called good intentions so it's always excused. It's time people woke up to the truth.
 
Most people aren't in the market for Semi Trucks.
And most products have US produced substitute products

But they are in the market for clothing, televisions, shoes, etc. And your devalued dollar won't bring down the prices of American made goods, it will simply raise the prices of imports, many of which, such as televisions and most electronics, have no American counterparts.

For those products without counterparts, the result is mostly a delay in purchasing - which increases disposable income for domestic products.

Meanwhile - the PRC - which is a large source of those products, has their currency pegged to the dollar, thus no change in prices for those imports.

So the average consumer DOES NOT SEE much inflation due to the Weak Dollar.
And since oil is priced in dollars, with a devalued dollar you will also pay more for gasoline and diesel. Since all of our Farm equipment runs on diesel or gas, this will raise the cost of food, transportation and virtually everything else.
Actually since the price of oil is about average relative to historic prices - this isn't going to drive inflation. And the price increase we are seeing is LESS THAN 5% change in the annual middle-class budget.


FACTS MATTER
try some.
 
Back
Top