New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

What are we doing ?

There are six families in Britain mourning their dead boys, one was 19, three 20, one 21 and one 33. In Afganistan there are families having to come to terms this morning with whole little families within their larger familes horrifyingly murdered in their beds last night, nine of them children and there is one traumatised American soldier who had been sent mad by the madness, his life is over too. What are we doing ?
 
I can't answer that. But the power of the military industrial complex seems to have possessed even this president.

We can only hope that he shakes it off and does the right thing.
 
Bad things happen when war happens, but the big reason it never stops is those who start wars and figure out how to fight them, never seem to partake in the not so fun parts of dying from them.
 
Oh God, it is worse. It sounds as though laughing drunken US soldiers went on a killing spree, pouring chemicals over the bodies afterwards and having a human bonfire ....................... Get out ? I don't think that is an option Bo, if it was it would have been long over.
 
Again. Except for the grace of God there go I.

On a personal note I am thankful the decision over how to deal with this tragedy doesn't trickle down to me. When something of this nature occurs half way around the world it is apparent to me that those in charge who are obligated to respond actually had nothing to do with the actual event. If I had to sum it up in a few words I would say the soldier who committed the atrocity went mad but mad or sane nothing we can do now can rectify the end result.

I suspect the slayer will be tried for the crimes and punishment will be forthcoming and somewheres around sixteen people will still be dead and ten times that many hearts will remain broken but wars will continue to plague society until the end of times because the underlying purpose of war is to destroy the enemy and it appears to me that the day of organized resistence by standing armies has given way to radical warriors who do not resemble soldiers. Who, then, makes the distinction between friend or foe if not the foot soldier who is charged with doing his duty in a world gone mad? And those most affected by the madness of it all are first those who we've sent to do the dirty work we'd rather not do ourselves. To repeat "war is hell" is probably the biggest understatement of record.

Bad, isn't Queenie. Worse yet, ten years from now only a few scattered participants will even recall this happened and the rest of the world will move on. That is the reality of things however harsh it sounds.

Gramps



I can't answer that. But the power of the military industrial complex seems to have possessed even this president.

We can only hope that he shakes it off and does the right thing.
 
Again. Except for the grace of God there go I.

On a personal note I am thankful the decision over how to deal with this tragedy doesn't trickle down to me. When something of this nature occurs half way around the world it is apparent to me that those in charge who are obligated to respond actually had nothing to do with the actual event. If I had to sum it up in a few words I would say the soldier who committed the atrocity went mad but mad or sane nothing we can do now can rectify the end result.

I suspect the slayer will be tried for the crimes and punishment will be forthcoming and somewheres around sixteen people will still be dead and ten times that many hearts will remain broken but wars will continue to plague society until the end of times because the underlying purpose of war is to destroy the enemy and it appears to me that the day of organized resistence by standing armies has given way to radical warriors who do not resemble soldiers. Who, then, makes the distinction between friend or foe if not the foot soldier who is charged with doing his duty in a world gone mad? And those most affected by the madness of it all are first those who we've sent to do the dirty work we'd rather not do ourselves. To repeat "war is hell" is probably the biggest understatement of record.

Bad, isn't Queenie. Worse yet, ten years from now only a few scattered participants will even recall this happened and the rest of the world will move on. That is the reality of things however harsh it sounds.

Gramps

Harsh words don't bother me Gramps. I know what you say is so, men and beasts are wonderful recouperators, thank the 'Goddess' for it. But though the actual is forgotten it stays in the psyche of people, It is our different experiences as peoples that sit in our psyches that are the 'vive la difference' of the past but now it seems it is the 'difference' that 'we' hate so much.

I do not believe that we shall always War with each other. It is not in most people to want to, most want to live in peace. It is greed alone which make for modern Wars, just greed. Sold to us through fear and pity and such like. Greed Gramps, thats all :) On the 'Planet of plenty', that is the true madness of it all.
 
There are six families in Britain mourning their dead boys, one was 19, three 20, one 21 and one 33. In Afganistan there are families having to come to terms this morning with whole little families within their larger familes horrifyingly murdered in their beds last night, nine of them children and there is one traumatised American soldier who had been sent mad by the madness, his life is over too. What are we doing ?

To me the worst part is the fact that our gov't isn't accepting ANY of the blame. They've even talked about giving the soldier the death penalty which at this point would probably be the kindest thing they could do. Nothing anybody could do would ever take the horror of it all out of his mind.

The man clearly needed mental help before he got to the point he got to. Instead, our intrepid 'leaders' had sent him back for more of that which he already couldn't deal with. It really wasn't his fault that he snapped. Far too many of our troops are being denied the help they so desperately need. It's a convenient way to cut our expenses.

But hey, some people are making a great deal of money from all of this war stuff. THAT is what has become important to them and they probably don't give a second thought to the real cost of all of their baubles.
 
To me the worst part is the fact that our gov't isn't accepting ANY of the blame. They've even talked about giving the soldier the death penalty which at this point would probably be the kindest thing they could do. Nothing anybody could do would ever take the horror of it all out of his mind.

The man clearly needed mental help before he got to the point he got to. Instead, our intrepid 'leaders' had sent him back for more of that which he already couldn't deal with. It really wasn't his fault that he snapped. Far too many of our troops are being denied the help they so desperately need. It's a convenient way to cut our expenses.

But hey, some people are making a great deal of money from all of this war stuff. THAT is what has become important to them and they probably don't give a second thought to the real cost of all of their baubles.

Talk of the death penalty would be too apease the Afghanis, they want the trial in Afghanistan. Usually nobody is even prosicuted in these, not unsual it seems,incidents and when they are they do hardely any 'time' if any. This one was just to big to cover up as 'Taliban'.

I dunno Boltlady I have been reading more accounts than just that one villager's. Other villagers are saying there were more than one soldier and that they sounded drunk and were laughing pulling off womens cloths and so on.
There are 40 nightraids on homes a night by US patrols in that province alone, why should he be alone that night when every one else was out searching houses in a groups Boltlady ? Many Afghanis are saying that this has happened many times before. It is the same as Vietnam.

Even if it such brutalities are not enouraged from higher levels, which is perfectly possible. Imposing horrors on the few to instill terror in the masses is not a new trick. Even if that is not so a blind eye or two is being turned.

And yes young men who may not have been so to begin with are being turned into psycopaths. But nope I don't believe that ...sorry. I just do not believe the 'one mad person' story any more, heard it too many times before. Three houses ? Nah they were a patrol.
 
That is not to say that I am not deeply touched by the plight of soldiers in and after Wars but as Wulk said the other day. These are Professional soldiers who volenteered. They are not conscripted soldiers.

In this story it is what they are doing to those that under International law it is their duty to be protecting, the vunerable ones, which is of more immediate importance, I think. Few others on here seem to think so, though.
 
That is not to say that I am not deeply touched by the plight of soldiers in and after Wars but as Wulk said the other day. These are Professional soldiers who volenteered. They are not conscripted soldiers.

In this story it is what they are doing to those that under International law it is their duty to be protecting, the vunerable ones, which is of more immediate importance, I think. Few others on here seem to think so, though.

These guys may be volunteers but I can't believe they had any idea of what all they were volunteering for. Many of them are there because they couldn't get a job anyplace else. Of course there are those who really believe they are 'defending' our country but then they have to convince themselves that what they are doing is for the good of all. They definitely should not be going back for tour after tour after tour. It's as though they are drained of everything they have and then tossed aside.

The really bad thing is how far too many of them really get into it.

So many say that well it is a part of war, but that's much easier said when it's happening far away. Their opinions might change when it's their wives, mothers, sisters and children who are being brutalized.
.
 
Probably the simplest explanation for why we're still there, is that for every Afghani killed at the hands of the west and/or the official Afghan guvmint, ten are killed by the Taliban. One way or another, everything loops back to this reality.

BTW, I shouldn't HAVE to qualify that none of this is intended as apologia for anything, but I've learned that I probably need to in any case.
 
Probably the simplest explanation for why we're still there, is that for every Afghani killed at the hands of the west and/or the official Afghan guvmint, ten are killed by the Taliban. One way or another, everything loops back to this reality.

BTW, I shouldn't HAVE to qualify that none of this is intended as apologia for anything, but I've learned that I probably need to in any case.

Are you telling me, that even you ...an educated intellegent chap ...believes that any country, including you own, invades and occupies another sovereign State for the sole purpose of imposing Democracy on them ???? For the betterment of those people without taking something of massive worth for 'it's' self ? Isn't that a tad naive fairsheet ?

I don't know where you got the ten to one from, or how you distiguish Taliban from goat herds and any other Afgani, since your Military doesn't seem to be able too.

But even if that were so ...by every account from people who know the place, the Taliban would have been ousted by the Afghans, who were already getting totally pissed off with them by the time we invaded, long ago ...if we had not invaded and occupied them for so long. A quite brutal occupation it has been too and so now the Taliban are a hundred times stronger than they were before. Staying longer just prolongs the agony and possibly, probably by Afghani accountsm kills more babies in their beds ? They absolutly hate you. How does that bring anything good to a peoples.

The Taliban were/are no Saddam or Gaddafi or Assad, they didn't have such systems in place as those Tyrants had/have built up over the years but you are going to be handing over to them the most evil and monsterous Prison which is about the only thing you have built in Afghanistan. A prison far worse than any other in the World giving any sadist Tyrant who gets they hands on it the best play pit imaginable.

Nothing absolutly nothing that we have done in Afghanistan was for the benifit of the people of Afghanistan. And it is'we are foreign soldiers killing the 'natives' whom they do not have the might to fight bak. A whole different story to them fighting their own.

It is and always was a Wild Land.
 
At least, at the very least the old Empires used to leave behind them something of some worth. Railways, plumbing, infrasructure in fact and Justice systems and Cricket/Sports and they used to take their families and go and live in the places they had invaded and truly try to keep order, for all their faults. Be honest with youselves all you do is pillage and plunder and leave behind utter utter chaos death and distruction, you lay waste. It is too my country's shame that we go with you into any of these 'escapades'.
 
Are you telling me, that even you ...an educated intellegent chap ...believes that any country, including you own, invades and occupies another sovereign State for the sole purpose of imposing Democracy on them ???? For the betterment of those people without taking something of massive worth for 'it's' self ? Isn't that a tad naive fairsheet ?

I don't know where you got the ten to one from, or how you distiguish Taliban from goat herds and any other Afgani, since your Military doesn't seem to be able too.

But even if that were so ...by every account from people who know the place, the Taliban would have been ousted by the Afghans, who were already getting totally pissed off with them by the time we invaded, long ago ...if we had not invaded and occupied them for so long. A quite brutal occupation it has been too and so now the Taliban are a hundred times stronger than they were before. Staying longer just prolongs the agony and possibly, probably by Afghani accountsm kills more babies in their beds ? They absolutly hate you. How does that bring anything good to a peoples.

The Taliban were/are no Saddam or Gaddafi or Assad, they didn't have such systems in place as those Tyrants had/have built up over the years but you are going to be handing over to them the most evil and monsterous Prison which is about the only thing you have built in Afghanistan. A prison far worse than any other in the World giving any sadist Tyrant who gets they hands on it the best play pit imaginable.

Nothing absolutly nothing that we have done in Afghanistan was for the benifit of the people of Afghanistan. And it is'we are foreign soldiers killing the 'natives' whom they do not have the might to fight bak. A whole different story to them fighting their own.

It is and always was a Wild Land.

Agreed....Bin laden is gone Afghanis assisted after a little arm twisting.. Lets leave them to their own ideals if they stay in their borders we should stay out of theirs, it's time to leave
 
Agreed....Bin laden is gone Afghanis assisted after a little arm twisting.. Lets leave them to their own ideals if they stay in their borders we should stay out of theirs, it's time to leave

Afghanis have never gone out of their 'borders' but even those borders were drawn by the West. Let Arabia go back to it's natural State without our Military interference, yes I agree :)

And now I'm pissing off 'cos I am getting really cross with you all ................ Later xxxx
 
Calmed down :)

Look at yesterdays disgusting story, which shows the utter corruption of the Afgan Gov and how out of touch they are with their own people.

They went to the village and tryed bribing those people who are mourning their dead to say the right thing (repeat the official 'untrue' story ) and they were suprised that gun fire broke out ? Even I would have taken pot shots at them !!!!!

The Afghanis for all their not being 'coiverlized' are by all accounts increadably honourable and the offer of money, which to us would be disgusting to them is worse than insulting.
 
Back
Top