New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

What next?

Are you saying that if President Obama were to authorize, or attempt to authorize arming a civilian group, it would be unconstitutional?

He didn't say that and neither did I. You can't (or won't) read the link and comprehend what he actually said.

Resorting to straw men = surrender. Not a very dignified one, but a surrender nonetheless.

Oh, wait a minute....that would mean you actually surrendered in your TP. Pure genius.
 
No because Article 1 Section 8 allows for the Foederal Government to "call forth the militia".... but the purpose of the 2nd Amendment was to reassure states - particularly southern states - that they could have the armament to revolt against an overly oppressive Foederal Government. Particularly one that had become disconnected from the individual states.

And Alito in McDonald threw out that as a basis for 2nd Amendment challenges.

Ok, but a little off topic.
How do we know that the 2nd is talking about federal oppression when it comes to States?

Why could they not also be talking about adjoining states or territories?

There a lot of areas around the states that werent "States"
 
I think you responded with the appropriate level of distress over the TP's harsh warning.

What's selling faster right now? Guns or duct tape?
 
Ok, but a little off topic.
How do we know that the 2nd is talking about federal oppression when it comes to States?

Why could they not also be talking about adjoining states or territories?

There a lot of areas around the states that werent "States"

For instance,
The territory of louisiana purchased by us in 1803.
Could the framers also have been talking about say a French type invasion?
 
We know the 2nd is talking about Foederal oppression of the states by reading the minutes of the Constitutional Convention and its discussion on the subject as well as the arguments put forth by the appologists for the Bill of Rights in the ratification debates (remember not all of the proposed ammendments got ratified - one did not). Since the territories were under direct federal jurisdiction (as Guam and Puerto Rico are for example) - there is no issue there. States meant what it meant - the states that were the founding ratifiers of The Constitution.

this was actually a big issue in the debates that lead to Lincoln's election and inaugural. Basically there was the question as to whether or not Slavery was intended to apply Constitutionally to all states or just to the Southern states that had it at ratification (an "incorporated power" under the "incorporated powers doctrine") And that was settled by the Civil War (which btw refutes the notion that somehow a minority of the populace armed with light arms could confront the US Federal military - but that's a digression into another thread you and I are discussing).
 
I fully understand it... but apparently the Supreme Court does not and has not for almost 100 years since Miller when it allowed the banning of "dangerous" weapons. Remember that in Heller Scalia even mused that "to Bear Arms" only applied to those "arms" a single individual could personally "bear" (ie physically carry). and Alito in McDonald went further asserting that the fear of an oppressive Foederal Military HAD NOT APPLIED to the 2nd amendment since the late 1800s...

It's hard to picture that "physically carry" rule being applied consistently. There are all sorts of things you can physically carry that are outlawed. You can physically carry heavy machine guns. You can physically carry land mines. You can carry all sorts of surface-to-air missiles and anti-tank weapons. You can physically carry chemical and biological warheads. You can even carry a nuclear weapon:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davy_Crockett_(nuclear_device)

Would even a braying nincompoop like Scalia argue that because the individual can "bear" a 20-ton nuclear device (something like eight times as destructive as the OK City truck bomb, and radioactive), that we all have a Constitutional right to do so? I don't think so. I think Scalia is pulling nonsense arguments out of his butt for purposes of serving the goals of the NRA and the conservative movement, but he'd never follow those arguments to their logical conclusion.
 
Back
Top