New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

What should we do about Rape ?

http://www.independent.co.uk/opinio...ays-but-the-reality-is-different-8079403.html

I read this article just now and yet again I am stuck with the same old delema .What good does prison do ?

Anyone who is truly dangerous should not be free to rape or murder, abuse, again, With the pantomime villians I have no problem except that they are simply treated as criminals and given a sentence and let out again,but that is another subject.

As our concepts of what is 'acceptable' change ( OK we can quibble over whether or not it was ever acceptable ) as in, 'Masogistc values are disappearing in our social phyche but as with all changes they take time to sink down and into the lower depths, so to speak. Meanwhile I honestly don't see how locking up many, ill morally educated, people solves any problems at all.

I'm not asking for an answer as to what should happen to those found guilty of this form of rape but question that if we are shifting in our ethical thinking which has come about at the same time as our sexual freedoms should we not be finding a more consructive way of righting these 'faults' ?
 
Castration works fairly well.

I know chopping bits off people is legal punishment in some parts of the World .....I didn't realise it was in America ......Ah well it doesn't suprise me ...............

I'll keep the question for those inhabiting more Civerlised Lands shall ?
 
http://www.independent.co.uk/opinio...ays-but-the-reality-is-different-8079403.html

I read this article just now and yet again I am stuck with the same old delema .What good does prison do ?

Anyone who is truly dangerous should not be free to rape or murder, abuse, again, With the pantomime villians I have no problem except that they are simply treated as criminals and given a sentence and let out again,but that is another subject.

As our concepts of what is 'acceptable' change ( OK we can quibble over whether or not it was ever acceptable ) as in, 'Masogistc values are disappearing in our social phyche but as with all changes they take time to sink down and into the lower depths, so to speak. Meanwhile I honestly don't see how locking up many, ill morally educated, people solves any problems at all.

I'm not asking for an answer as to what should happen to those found guilty of this form of rape but question that if we are shifting in our ethical thinking which has come about at the same time as our sexual freedoms should we not be finding a more consructive way of righting these 'faults' ?

Good question, QT, and great article. It seems to me that the type of rape the author describes, what Akin would not consider 'legitimate' rape, stems from a fundamantal misogynistic attitude that still pervades our society. It begins with the idea that being female is less preferable to being male. It is inculcated in our society by (to give one example) coaches who call the boys on baseball teams "girls" to exhort them to greater effort - because to a boy, what could be worse than being called a girl? Unfortunately all too many of these boys grow up with the attitude that they have the right to take from girls what they want, because they (the boys) are intrinsically 'better.' Couple that with the 'boys will be boys' wink wink nudge nudge attitude towards male sexuality and the still-present 'good girls don't have sex' attitude that is pervasive even after the sexual revolution, and you have a recipe for males believing that a young woman who just wants to sleep off a bad drunk (or drugged drunk?) is intentionally making herself available to any man who wants to stick his dick in her.

I don't think it's going to change QT.
 
it is in the process of changing and will continue to do so. it wasnt too long ago that society believed it was necessary to beat wives to "keep them in line"
 
it is in the process of changing and will continue to do so. it wasnt too long ago that society believed it was necessary to beat wives to "keep them in line"

I think a lot of men still believe that; they just know it's not condoned anymore so it gets driven underground. Women's shelters still exist for a very good reason. But if major political candidates still find a distinction between legitimate and non-legitimate rape, attitudes toward women have not changed as much as we'd llke to think. And one of the women on these boards posted recently that she agrees and that "a lot" of women lie about being raped. Incredible, especially coming from a woman.
 
lol! i thought i was the most cynical, pessimistic guy i'd ever met but you are rapidly stealing my title. and i didnt say it was changing as rapidly as we'd like, i said it was changing and will continue to do so.
 
lol! i thought i was the most cynical, pessimistic guy i'd ever met but you are rapidly stealing my title. and i didnt say it was changing as rapidly as we'd like, i said it was changing and will continue to do so.

You are (clearly) more optimistic than I. I see it moving closer to the Taliban than away with the new in-your-face astonishingly sexist viewpoints from the right. I thought the abortion question was effectively ended w/ Roe v Wade. Not. I thought women were now being at least listened to WRT rape. Not. I thought women were being more closely considered to be equal to men - then I picked up my grandson from baseball practice and listened to his coaches, and also listen to my daughter who is working on an Air Force base and still experiences the same (although more subtle) sexism that women my age experienced 25 years ago, so Not.
 
i sympathize with your dissappointments bobby and can only say i think youre being a tad impatient. big changes in society take many many generations to take place.
 
Good question, QT, and great article. It seems to me that the type of rape the author describes, what Akin would not consider 'legitimate' rape, stems from a fundamantal misogynistic attitude that still pervades our society. It begins with the idea that being female is less preferable to being male. It is inculcated in our society by (to give one example) coaches who call the boys on baseball teams "girls" to exhort them to greater effort - because to a boy, what could be worse than being called a girl? Unfortunately all too many of these boys grow up with the attitude that they have the right to take from girls what they want, because they (the boys) are intrinsically 'better.' Couple that with the 'boys will be boys' wink wink nudge nudge attitude towards male sexuality and the still-present 'good girls don't have sex' attitude that is pervasive even after the sexual revolution, and you have a recipe for males believing that a young woman who just wants to sleep off a bad drunk (or drugged drunk?) is intentionally making herself available to any man who wants to stick his dick in her.

I don't think it's going to change QT.

Neither of my Grandmothers had the vote when they were young ........... My problem is that this as other problems come out of our society as a sickness of society, if you like, the meds just don't seam to be quite the right ones to cure its' ails, being in many cases to brutal only leading to more brutality and or other negatives.
 
Not really, OG. Rape is not a sex crime...it's a crime of power, dominance and (tho not always) violence.

The tendency to demand “eye for an eye” style justice is experiencing resurgence as various groups, in countries scattered all over the globe, clamor for a harsher deterrent to crimes of rape and child molestation. Certain states within the U.S. have actually successfully instituted new laws demanding or offering chemical or surgical castration to criminals convicted of rape or child molestation.

While there are certainly many fans of this development, it would be a mistake to assume that either method of castration effectively removes the sadistic fantasies and tendencies that actually lead someone to commit rape. Like courage, sadism exists in the mind and the character – not in the testicles. And as a thorough reading of any sadist’s biography will inform one, it doesn’t require a sperm-squirting penis to violate another person’s sexual parts.

LINK
 
http://www.independent.co.uk/opinio...ays-but-the-reality-is-different-8079403.html

I read this article just now and yet again I am stuck with the same old delema .What good does prison do ?

Anyone who is truly dangerous should not be free to rape or murder, abuse, again, With the pantomime villians I have no problem except that they are simply treated as criminals and given a sentence and let out again,but that is another subject.

As our concepts of what is 'acceptable' change ( OK we can quibble over whether or not it was ever acceptable ) as in, 'Masogistc values are disappearing in our social phyche but as with all changes they take time to sink down and into the lower depths, so to speak. Meanwhile I honestly don't see how locking up many, ill morally educated, people solves any problems at all.

I'm not asking for an answer as to what should happen to those found guilty of this form of rape but question that if we are shifting in our ethical thinking which has come about at the same time as our sexual freedoms should we not be finding a more consructive way of righting these 'faults' ?

Yep, Laurie Penny was raped. Quite a lot of folks these days would agree that if a man penetrates a woman who is drunk, asleep, a casual acquaintance at best, and who has never given him any explicit indication that she intends or wants to have sex with him, it's rape.

Of course not very long ago at all the rules were very different, no? Spousal rape was an oxymoron. Young women were routinely advised that mashers, cads, and bounders were always on the prowl. Good girls took the lessons to heart and kept to the straight and narrow. Daddy's little girl, clean and pure... She was the sweet young thing that all the boys wanted and no one could touch until a ring was put on that finger. Bad girls strayed from the path and got what they deserved. Wolf food, damaged goods... Suitable for entertainment, perhaps, but not for marrying. That was the official mythos anyway.

These days...? Things are in flux, that's for sure. That's unavoidable when the old regime crumbles, don't you think? It does take time after all for a new culture to grow to fill the voids. Part of what we're seeing is little more than that, I reckon. And part of that is the incessant fighting and the oscillations between liberation and criminalization.

Some things don't change, though. Sexual encounters, even those between long-time intimate partners, pretty much always involve some power dynamic, some element of dominance and submission. On some level sex is about having and being had by another. We open ourselves up, we make ourselves vulnerable. It's part and parcel of intimacy. Some degree of risk is inescapable, really. Even the best of intentions won't eliminate all the potential for hurting and being hurt. And often enough the best of intentions may be taxed in the heat of the moment, eh?

So, yeah, the hurting isn't always inflicted by monsters and pantomime villains. Surely we can agree on that.

Well then, do “nice guy” rapists belong in jail? Maybe not always, but surely individuals like Laurie Penny deserve some recourse. I don't know exactly what form that should take. The lines can be fuzzy, but push things far enough and eventually it's pretty clear that a line has been crossed. Penny's case crosses that line if you ask me. For the hazier cases, maybe we do need some kind of reconciliation process that doesn't involve criminal charges.

Cheers.
 
Yep, Laurie Penny was raped. Quite a lot of folks these days would agree that if a man penetrates a woman who is drunk, asleep, a casual acquaintance at best, and who has never given him any explicit indication that she intends or wants to have sex with him, it's rape.

Of course not very long ago at all the rules were very different, no? Spousal rape was an oxymoron. Young women were routinely advised that mashers, cads, and bounders were always on the prowl. Good girls took the lessons to heart and kept to the straight and narrow. Daddy's little girl, clean and pure... She was the sweet young thing that all the boys wanted and no one could touch until a ring was put on that finger. Bad girls strayed from the path and got what they deserved. Wolf food, damaged goods... Suitable for entertainment, perhaps, but not for marrying. That was the official mythos anyway.

These days...? Things are in flux, that's for sure. That's unavoidable when the old regime crumbles, don't you think? It does take time after all for a new culture to grow to fill the voids. Part of what we're seeing is little more than that, I reckon. And part of that is the incessant fighting and the oscillations between liberation and criminalization.

Some things don't change, though. Sexual encounters, even those between long-time intimate partners, pretty much always involve some power dynamic, some element of dominance and submission. On some level sex is about having and being had by another. We open ourselves up, we make ourselves vulnerable. It's part and parcel of intimacy. Some degree of risk is inescapable, really. Even the best of intentions won't eliminate all the potential for hurting and being hurt. And often enough the best of intentions may be taxed in the heat of the moment, eh?

So, yeah, the hurting isn't always inflicted by monsters and pantomime villains. Surely we can agree on that.

Well then, do “nice guy” rapists belong in jail? Maybe not always, but surely individuals like Laurie Penny deserve some recourse. I don't know exactly what form that should take. The lines can be fuzzy, but push things far enough and eventually it's pretty clear that a line has been crossed. Penny's case crosses that line if you ask me. For the hazier cases, maybe we do need some kind of reconciliation process that doesn't involve criminal charges.

Cheers.

You know, Havelock, I was right there with you. In fact, in my reply, I was conflicted as to how we figure out some middle ground between punishment of rapists like that one described in the TP article, and real rapists. By real I mean those who are not confused by signals or conflicted by when "no" really is a coy signal for "persuade me," but rather rape for the sense of power and taking advantage that they crave. But WTF are we saying, you and me Havelock? Do we believe that a woman could not know the difference beteen consentual sex and rape? Do we really think that "nice guy" rape is somehow less than rape? I'm asking because I don't know, but I want to believe that rape is rape and that "nice guy" rape is not some nice guy who misunderstood the signals he was getting, but rather a guy who saw an opportunity he thought he could get away with.
 
Back
Top