BobbyT
Governor
Don't do it.
True. But it gets done. So then what?
Don't do it.
It can be more complicated than that. There are girls that say "No" and want to see how their partner can work around that. Or bull right through it. Then one day, she says "No" and really means it. panic can happen. Suddenly the guy is acting in a pattern that the two have developed and isn't aware it is now rape. That's not date rape, that's relationship rape. Maybe it only lasts for 30 seconds before the guy realizes that his partner is scared and wants it to stop. Is that 30 seconds of unintentional rape?
Yep, Laurie Penny was raped. Quite a lot of folks these days would agree that if a man penetrates a woman who is drunk, asleep, a casual acquaintance at best, and who has never given him any explicit indication that she intends or wants to have sex with him, it's rape.
Of course not very long ago at all the rules were very different, no? Spousal rape was an oxymoron. Young women were routinely advised that mashers, cads, and bounders were always on the prowl. Good girls took the lessons to heart and kept to the straight and narrow. Daddy's little girl, clean and pure... She was the sweet young thing that all the boys wanted and no one could touch until a ring was put on that finger. Bad girls strayed from the path and got what they deserved. Wolf food, damaged goods... Suitable for entertainment, perhaps, but not for marrying. That was the official mythos anyway.
These days...? Things are in flux, that's for sure. That's unavoidable when the old regime crumbles, don't you think? It does take time after all for a new culture to grow to fill the voids. Part of what we're seeing is little more than that, I reckon. And part of that is the incessant fighting and the oscillations between liberation and criminalization.
Some things don't change, though. Sexual encounters, even those between long-time intimate partners, pretty much always involve some power dynamic, some element of dominance and submission. On some level sex is about having and being had by another. We open ourselves up, we make ourselves vulnerable. It's part and parcel of intimacy. Some degree of risk is inescapable, really. Even the best of intentions won't eliminate all the potential for hurting and being hurt. And often enough the best of intentions may be taxed in the heat of the moment, eh?
So, yeah, the hurting isn't always inflicted by monsters and pantomime villains. Surely we can agree on that.
Well then, do “nice guy” rapists belong in jail? Maybe not always, but surely individuals like Laurie Penny deserve some recourse. I don't know exactly what form that should take. The lines can be fuzzy, but push things far enough and eventually it's pretty clear that a line has been crossed. Penny's case crosses that line if you ask me. For the hazier cases, maybe we do need some kind of reconciliation process that doesn't involve criminal charges.
Cheers.
You know, Havelock, I was right there with you. In fact, in my reply, I was conflicted as to how we figure out some middle ground between punishment of rapists like that one described in the TP article, and real rapists. By real I mean those who are not confused by signals or conflicted by when "no" really is a coy signal for "persuade me," but rather rape for the sense of power and taking advantage that they crave. But WTF are we saying, you and me Havelock? Do we believe that a woman could not know the difference beteen consentual sex and rape? Do we really think that "nice guy" rape is somehow less than rape? I'm asking because I don't know, but I want to believe that rape is rape and that "nice guy" rape is not some nice guy who misunderstood the signals he was getting, but rather a guy who saw an opportunity he thought he could get away with.
If the guy is in a relationship and can't tell the difference between sex play and NO, he needs to start paying attention. It's not as though the woman is going to suddenly say no just because.
You know, Havelock, I was right there with you. In fact, in my reply, I was conflicted as to how we figure out some middle ground between punishment of rapists like that one described in the TP article, and real rapists. By real I mean those who are not confused by signals or conflicted by when "no" really is a coy signal for "persuade me," but rather rape for the sense of power and taking advantage that they crave. But WTF are we saying, you and me Havelock? Do we believe that a woman could not know the difference beteen consentual sex and rape? Do we really think that "nice guy" rape is somehow less than rape? I'm asking because I don't know, but I want to believe that rape is rape and that "nice guy" rape is not some nice guy who misunderstood the signals he was getting, but rather a guy who saw an opportunity he thought he could get away with.
Yes it was rape and no there are no longer any defined lines as to how a 'good girl' behaves nor a gentleman for that matter .....but in the case of what is rape? it does seam that some men have not kept up with the changes in our codes of behaviour and do 'take advantage' of our 'new' ( as in the last 40 odd years ) found freedoms. To be honest in this I have seen little change in certian 'types' of males and indeed some females, because yes there are 'power' plays in all relationships, some subtle some bullish and sometimes especially in the unexperienced and or young 'games' can go very wrong. Trust can be misplaced, with in these times of sexual freedom women, as in the case in the article, have been lulled into a sometimes false sense of security and let down their guard. Many men are still that old preditor and that is life.
Sure, we all know there will always be those who are willing to take advantage of others in order to get what they want. Some power plays are subtle – they may or may not involve bad intent or callous indifference to another's well being. And some self-styled “alphas” will push things as far as they think they can. In any case the weaker, less fortunate, less cautious, and less wise will get hurt to one degree or another. That is life. Whatever the situation, I guess the root question is how best can we deter and minimize the harm.
I hear you saying that prison isn't the best tool for deterring and minimizing that harm in cases where the person involved is more of a “prick” and less of a serial predator. Can't argue with that, Lord knows... We used to believe that prison could serve to rehabilitate as well as to segregate and punish. We seem to have largely given up on that idea at the moment, but I'm sure the pendulum will swing back eventually. In the meantime, the possible value of some other kind of system is what I was alluding to at the end of my last post. I'm thinking of something along the lines of binding civil mediation rather than a criminal proceeding. A venue where grievances could be aired and within which counseling and support could be offered. Some states here in the U.S. currently offer programs akin to this, typically for minor misdemeanors.
Just thinking out loud...
Whatever we do or don't do, I agree that things have changed for the better – and that it's not enough. It's not enough to get rid of antiquated, maladaptive ideas, traditions, and social structures. It's a constant fight to try to ensure that the errors of the past evolve into something better, not merely something different.
Be well, my dear.