New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

When were you wrong?

I also thought that Hillary Clinton would be the Democratic nominee in 2008.

I was wrong about the outcome of the SCOTUS decision regarding Obamacare.

I was for the invasion of Iraq and I remain in favor of it. While it is true that the WMD were not found there, the world is better off without Saddam Hussein running a country.


Obamacare...yeah I was wrong about that..but EVERYONE was...who ever thought that they would call it a TAX?

Of course, after the moronic decision of Citizen's United...we all knew anything was possible.
 
I'm a Broncos fan, and for me the coach's name is mud. He made repeated ultra conservative calls that gave the game away. And it's not like he was just "playing the numbers" (taking the statistically correct move, even if it's uninspiring). He was essentially playing them the wrong way. If going for it gave you 60% chance of winning and punting gave you 40%, he'd go for the punt. It was agonizing.



If I remember correctly (always a risky proposition these days), the Broncos got the ball back with about thirty seconds left and all of their times outs. I thought they'd at least try to get into field goal range. Curious they fell on the ball instead.

Last year the Broncos went to overtime and won - with Tim Tebow! You would think with Peyton Manning they would have at least taken a shot at the end. Sometimes playing it safe can cost you.
 
Who knew you were old enough to remember Carter, let alone vote for him?.....:>)

I wasn't old enough to vote yet, but if I was, I don't think I'd have regretted it. Carter's presidency was decent. Job creation rates were exceptionally good, deficits didn't rise, and he installed the Fed chairman and policies that ultimately broke the back of the inflation problem he'd inherited. The hostages were released, we avoided any major wars, and it was a brief period of energy conservation. It wasn't a great era, to be sure, but overall I'd rate it better than what came before or after him. And I say that as someone who is culturally predisposed to dislike the guy (since he's a conservative, devout, Baptist farmer, hunter, and military officer from the rural Deep South, he's not exactly in my cultural mode).
 
If I remember correctly (always a risky proposition these days), the Broncos got the ball back with about thirty seconds left and all of their times outs. I thought they'd at least try to get into field goal range. Curious they fell on the ball instead.

Last year the Broncos went to overtime and won - with Tim Tebow! You would think with Peyton Manning they would have at least taken a shot at the end. Sometimes playing it safe can cost you.

Yep, that's about right. They had, arguably, the best quarterback in football, the mile high advantage in the two-minute drill, thin air for kicking, the home crowd on their side, and they can't be bothered to try to get in field goal range?! It was a mistake that arguably cost them not just that game, but a championship, since you can make a decent case that they could have won out.
 
I was torn in 2008,because I knew what the Cons would do to Hillary, but they have been worse to Obama! How could you blame Obama for not being more open?

The Press and Cons attack him like rabid dogs every time he is open! Good Heavens,Arkady,think about this criticism!
 
I was reading a story about Iraq-War proponents in the press and their comments today, looking back at that catastrophic invasion. It made me think that it would be a healthy exercise for people to call out their own political mistakes and, if they're able, to identify the cause of those mistakes.

I stand by most of my recent political decisions. I was a gay marriage supporter and an Iraq War opponent before most Americans caught up on those issues. I don't regret voting for Obama either time, even though he's been a train wreck on civil liberties (I still think he was the lesser of the two evils in each election). I stand by my Krugmanite economic views. I'm trying to think of any really big political mistakes lately (on the scale of supporting the Iraq War), and am not coming up with any.

Most of what's occurring to me is minor. For example, I twice underestimated Obama as a candidate. In 2008, I thought Hillary Clinton would beat him, because I doubted anyone as inexperienced as him could be such a wiley campaigner, and in 2012, although I expected him to win the overall election, I didn't expect him to win the second and third debates so handily (though I've got bragging rights for being one of the few on the left who wasn't at all surprised by his extremely weak showing in the first debate). The last significant political mistake that comes to mind for me was supporting Edwards in 2008 -- I see now that I was dazzled by his charisma and his class-consciousness, and that if he'd won the nomination it might have been disastrous for the Democratic Party and the nation.

Another fairly significant error was opposing the bailout of GM. I was overly concerned with the moral hazard, and thought it should be allowed to fail, but since then I've developed a more sophisticated understanding of the importance of regional economic systems, and I see how a failure by GM might have set off a regional death spiral for heavy industry, in a region that's already suffering horribly. I was also wrong to be so skeptical of Romneycare in Massachusetts. I was worried that it would drive away business and attract the poor and sick, and that turned out not to be a serious problem -- I simply overestimated the mobility of people and businesses.

Prior to that, I'd also stupidly supported Susan Collins and Olympia Snowe in Maine. After they stood up as two of the only Republican senators (along with Specter and Chaffee) to oppose removing Clinton from office, I idealized them in a way that just wasn't justified. I was so eager to find some example of a "good Republican" that I saw their vote as an act of courage, rather than just political calculus by a pair of veteran politicians who knew they had a fairly liberal electorate to face. It took me years to realize what a cynical pair they really were, and now, looking back, I'm mortified I could have fallen for them in the first place.

There are lots of other dumb political things I used to believe, but most of them are from many decades ago, when I was still a kid. No more recent ones are occurring to me.

I don't think on the major issues I was wrong at all. But I have an advantage -my experience dealing with totalitarian lying regime for many years and with plenty of brainwashed people.
I still think I was correct against bombing of Serbia.
I was correct on Gore -Bush results and i knew the SC will go for their fave.
I knew the Iraq war will happen right after the 9/11, i knew Bush and neocons will go after Iraq and will lie their asses off to justify the war right then.
I knew the Iraq vote will be a disadvantage to Clinton against Obama, and I knew that he can not be uniter with the huge chunk of population and one major party going totally bonkers with hatred and idiocy. I knew the results of the stimulus will be not that impressive if GOP was let to insert in the bill their amendments, I still think that Obamacare is not good enough and eventually will be improved to Universal HC, I was positive ,Obama will win the second term and I was sure he will be not peacenick regarding the ME countries ,employing a lot of members of Clinton cabinet. But my best prediction is -I was totally correct many years ago when i saw how GOp is degrading into the resemblance of commies, more and more...
 
Yep, that's about right. They had, arguably, the best quarterback in football, the mile high advantage in the two-minute drill, thin air for kicking, the home crowd on their side, and they can't be bothered to try to get in field goal range?! It was a mistake that arguably cost them not just that game, but a championship, since you can make a decent case that they could have won out.



They may have another shot at it this year, adding Welker should help. They need to keep Dumerville.
 
I also thought that Hillary Clinton would be the Democratic nominee in 2008.

I was wrong about the outcome of the SCOTUS decision regarding Obamacare.

I was for the invasion of Iraq and I remain in favor of it. While it is true that the WMD were not found there, the world is better off without Saddam Hussein running a country.

After Bush v. Gore, I don't wager on SCOTUS decisions any more. God knows what they're thinking.

As for Iraq, one way to think about whether it was worth it is to think about the opportunity cost of the money we spend there. For example, if the long-term cost of the Iraq invasion is $2 trillion, and you can typically save one American life per $2 million spent on life-saving measures, or one third-world life per $20,000 spent on life-saving measures, then deciding to invade Iraq rather than spend the same money on one of those things can be viewed as a cost of 1 million American lives or 100 million third-world lives. Was it really worth that?

Keep in mind, those are extremely conservative estimates, meant to understate my case. You can find estimates of the Iraq War cost as high as $6 trillion:

http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=...bGlcNy0Qe7dgRGRJGummvZA&bvm=bv.43828540,d.dmg

There are ways to save American lives at a cost far below $2 million per life (like $517,000 per life for mobile intensive care units in small towns, after adjusting for inflation):

http://www.ecolo.org/documents/documents_in_english/en.cost_of_lives_saved.htm

And you can save lives in the third world for a whole hell of a lot less than $20,000 per life. Some malaria prevention and sanitation measures can cost mere hundreds of dollars per life saved.

So, we could well be talking as many as 12 million American lives we could have saved if we'd spent that Iraq War money on something productive, and many hundreds of millions of third-world lives saved. Was getting rid of Hussein worth it? I'd say we'd have been better off containing him and waiting for him to go the way of Ceaucescu or Marcos or Soeharto, or countless other dictators, while spending that money in ways that would have saved millions or maybe hundreds of millions of lives.
 
I was up for and ready to be united in 2000. I didn't vote for Bush and he was a huge disappointment. I was glad that the country had voted in a black man as President. And Hillary as the first woman would have been good too as a "first". Obama was a huge disappointment pretty early on when he dabbled in a civil argument and took the wrong side. Things went downhill from that point. I never saw Obama heal any wounds. I did see him create brand new ones....... ones so bad that they may never heal.

I didn't vote in 2000. There was no one I really liked.

I never thought Obama would be a uniter. I was convinced the conservatives would hate absolutely any Democrat, no matter what, and that they'd do so with their customary blind fury. I even argued that on chat boards, against those Obama supporters, in the 2008 primary, who were convinced he could start to heal the nation's wounds. I feel like I was completely right about that. The last few years went EXACTLY as I pictured them, in terms of mindless, hate-fueled opposition to absolutely anything Obama supports.

However, I'm with you on the transparency thing. Even back when I was supporting Hillary Clinton against Obama in the primary, part of me wanted to support Obama because he spoke so often about transparency, and I thought we'd become dangerously opaque, and really needed that sunlight. I took him seriously on that topic, and I was wrong to do so. You could make a decent argument his has been the LEAST transparent administration.

As for 2000, who did you support?
 
I have a couple.

1: I thought that America wouldn't re-elect Bush after invading Iraq. Never underestimate the stupidity of the American electorate.

2: I never thought a neophyte like Nerobama would ever get elected. Never underestimate the stupidity of the American electorate.

I can't remember what I predicted in the 2004 election. I'm not sure if I was as disilllusioned with the American people as I am now, so I'm not sure how surprised I was by Bush's election. In 2008, I had a strong feeling that whoever the Democratic nominee was would get elected, just because we'd had seven mediocre-to-poor years followed by a year of shear economic terror, and I couldn't picture the public signing up for four more years of Republican rule after that.
 
I don't think on the major issues I was wrong at all. But I have an advantage -my experience dealing with totalitarian lying regime for many years and with plenty of brainwashed people.
I still think I was correct against bombing of Serbia.
I was correct on Gore -Bush results and i knew the SC will go for their fave.
I knew the Iraq war will happen right after the 9/11, i knew Bush and neocons will go after Iraq and will lie their asses off to justify the war right then.
I knew the Iraq vote will be a disadvantage to Clinton against Obama, and I knew that he can not be uniter with the huge chunk of population and one major party going totally bonkers with hatred and idiocy. I knew the results of the stimulus will be not that impressive if GOP was let to insert in the bill their amendments, I still think that Obamacare is not good enough and eventually will be improved to Universal HC, I was positive ,Obama will win the second term and I was sure he will be not peacenick regarding the ME countries ,employing a lot of members of Clinton cabinet. But my best prediction is -I was totally correct many years ago when i saw how GOp is degrading into the resemblance of commies, more and more...

You're way ahead of me. I find myself surprised on a fairly regular basis.
 
I was wrong in supporting The Patriot Act 1.0 and Department of Homeland Security. I didn't bother to dig into the details. We didn't need it and we don't need it now.
 
Another fairly significant error was opposing the bailout of GM.


Agreed the genius of buying 49 billion worth of GM stock and thinking it was a bad idea...is an error:

The financing provided by the Treasury for GM's restructuring – its "investment" in GM, as it has been termed on occasion – totaled some $49.5 billion. Of that, GM has now "repaid" – directly or indirectly – a bit less than $30 billion:

That leaves the Treasury short about $20 billion – and with something like 277 million shares left to sell. The math on that doesn't work out well for taxpayers: The Feds need to get something like $72 a share in order to break even on their "investment".

GM is trading at a bit over $28 as I write this on Thursday. Clearly, the Feds aren't likely to recoup their money any time soon – at least, not by selling their remaining GM stock

http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2013/03/14/will-gm-ever-repay-taxpayers.aspx

needless to say the error in thinking GM is a good investment....is none as long as you are a mouthpiece for thedemocrat party...but if you are of the political party which can do basic math...then you realize that not recouping the loss anytime soon and the interest payments accrued on the additional debt makes the buyout of GM a failed proposition....thus becoming American bailing out Democrat voter jobs again. Now that you have been shownn the error...please feel free to spin . How about you say that the loss at GM is actually debt reduction or something that inane?
 
I was wrong in supporting The Patriot Act 1.0 and Department of Homeland Security. I didn't bother to dig into the details. We didn't need it and we don't need it now.

and for the same reason you will be wrong if you support the gun control laws being put forth by Democrats....

p.s. Any version including Obama's version of the patriot act is wrong
 
Better late than never....oh wait.

No it's not.

Everyone should have marched on Washington the minute they proposed that crap.
 
The government, using tax dollars, baling out a PRIVATE business is ALWAYS a bad idea.

It removes the fear of failure.

Too big to fail means too big to exist.
 
Back
Top