New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Why a flat tax doesn't work

Unfortunately that march is to insolvency. The system is NOT fiscally sound. You can veil the cost of government through the sale of bonds for only so long.

When you go to an Exxon station and spend a $1 on gas. How much goes to Exxon's bottom line, its shareholders? Now how much goes to the various governments?

Do you really think that our society will prosoper with government spending at all levels in excess of 40% of GDP?


Since you consider yourself (and everyone else) hopelessly doomed, why do you bother to cling so tightly to a political ideology? Might as well just enjoy your "last days" instead.
 
You almost hit on it. Let's get right to the point...

QUESTION: What does a flat tax, tax? Income? Income from what? Income from investments?

Every time I hear "flat tax" I wonder if the whole ploy is just another way of eliminating investment income taxes and inheritance taxes. That's what they are always trying to pull.
 
You almost hit on it. Let's get right to the point...

QUESTION: What does a flat tax, tax? Income? Income from what? Income from investments?

Every time I hear "flat tax" I wonder if the whole ploy is just another way of eliminating investment income taxes and inheritance taxes. That's what they are always trying to pull.

Yup, it's about locking in not just a rate, but the "simplicity" of that rate. The smaller issue- by far, would be that if we decided the rate was insufficient, it would be politically difficult to raise it. The bigger issue - by far, would be that when we figured out how the filthy rich were dodging it, it would be almost politically impossible to adjust it so's to recapture them.
 
I paid $0.00.

No wages, no salary, and a small pension. However, I have Social Security income, own commercial property, which I bought with income that had been taxed, and investment income, also derived from income that had been taxed.
 
I am a fan of the Fair Tax though, primarlly for two reasons.

1) It basically does away with the IRS, tax codes, tax cheats, the politics of taxation, and it's efficient...both for tax collection and for businesses.

2) It also generates additional revenue from "black market" activity (for want of another term). By that I mean those engaged in illegal trade, (drugs for example) still spend money.
 
This flat tax calculator says something different.
LINK
The flat tax proposal does give certain deductions. I tried it with an income of $30,000 and 3 children and there was $0 tax due. I tried it on several incomes with varying situations and the tax called for took into account the lower income folks and they were not hit.
Link to the home site.

Propaganda outlets will tell you what they want you to hear. Do the math yourself. It's very easy. Yes, the more deductions, the more complicated (and the less accurate it is to call it a flat tax). But start at the top. If the very richest currently pay a higher effective rate than the proposed flat tax (and they do, or they wouldn't support it), then others have to pay more under the flat tax to reach revenue neutrality. It isn't rocket science.
 
You're the propagandist, they're economists.

Read your top-post again for the propaganda. You're supporting THIS tax system over any viable alternative? That's borderline insanity.
 
I was happy with the result I got from my income too. It was about 11% on mine too.
I am not completely sold on the flat tax idea but I think it should be looked at as a possibility.

The flat tax is an absurd scheme designed for those who are so bad with numbers (or so lazy) that you can tell them any ridiculous thing and count on them not doing the math.

Look, I'll make it super simple, to spare you any unnecessary thinking. See here:

http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/12-29-2005FedTaxRates.pdf

In Table 1, you'll see the top 5% and top 1% paid more in individual federal taxes than the 17% your propaganda site calls for. Cut their taxes and you need to hike effective tax rates, on average, for the other 95%, to reach revenue neutrality. You can't collect a lower rate from the rich and expect the shortfall to magically vanish.

It's worse than that, since their effective rate would be lower than 17%, under the "flat tax," thanks to deductions, and since the rich actually pay more today than in 2003 (the date of that table), thanks to the last tax hike. So, moving them to the "flat tax" scheme would represent an even bigger revenue shortfall, and thus would require an even bigger tax hike for the average member of the 95% to reach revenue neutrality.
 
You're the propagandist, they're economists.

Read your top-post again for the propaganda. You're supporting THIS tax system over any viable alternative? That's borderline insanity.

Do the math. You'll see they're lying to you. The math is easy. Don't be lazy.
 
But the rich are sheltering it. How does that simple fact elude you?

Money moving overseas, underreporting income, and multiple incentives and outlets for tax sheltering could vanish, and the government could realize a lot of lost income this way.

You are advocating and defending a fatally flawed system with huge gaps in available revenue captured.

How to defend a system almost half of people not paying into, while the rest work hard at to cheat at it, and we have trillion dollar a year shortfalls?
That's simply madness.
 
Well Swimmer...if you could give an example of the nonsense, I'd at least I'd know that you knew what I was talking about.

As it is.......
 
But the rich are sheltering it. How does that simple fact elude you?

Money moving overseas, underreporting income, and multiple incentives and outlets for tax sheltering could vanish, and the government could realize a lot of lost income this way.

You are advocating and defending a fatally flawed system with huge gaps in available revenue captured.

How to defend a system almost half of people not paying into, while the rest work hard at to cheat at it, and we have trillion dollar a year shortfalls?
That's simply madness.


There are certainly some tax loopholes that are in need of repair. That said, a leaky shingle doesn't indicate that tearing off the roof and replacing it with thatch is the ideal solution.
 
You think what this tax system needs is a quick-fix patch? You have as much confidence in the IRS as you do in the geological knowledge of Biblical authors. Tough to back up that srgument.
 
Various flat tax proposals have been around for years, but only one that I'm aware of was ever developed by an actual economist. The economist also served in Congress, and introduced a bill that would have put his flat tax in place -- the congressman was Dick Armey, and he said in 1998, that we could have replaced the then-extant tax system with a 17 percent flat tax, and that tax wouldn't have kicked in until after the first $20K (if memory serves). Of course, his flat tax was also connected to rigorous spending controls so that the amount of revenue raised would not be less than the amount of government paid for.

It failed. Getting the current out-of-control deficit back to where it belongs will be tough, no matter what is used to generate revenues. What it certain is that we will not solve our financial problems if new revenues are simply used to pay for new programs.
 
Various flat tax proposals have been around for years, but only one that I'm aware of was ever developed by an actual economist. The economist also served in Congress, and introduced a bill that would have put his flat tax in place -- the congressman was Dick Armey, and he said in 1998, that we could have replaced the then-extant tax system with a 17 percent flat tax, and that tax wouldn't have kicked in until after the first $20K (if memory serves). Of course, his flat tax was also connected to rigorous spending controls so that the amount of revenue raised would not be less than the amount of government paid for.

It failed. Getting the current out-of-control deficit back to where it belongs will be tough, no matter what is used to generate revenues. What it certain is that we will not solve our financial problems if new revenues are simply used to pay for new programs.

A 17% flat tax would be a huge tax cut for the very rich. As such, to be revenue neutral, it would need to be a tax hike for the average non-very-rich person. It's basic math. Generally these flat tax proposals are designed for innumerate people who can't be bothered to do the math. When you do the math, you realize that either it's going to VASTLY increase the taxes of the non-rich, or it's going to VASTLY increase the deficit, or it will require VASTLY unrealistic spending cuts.
 
Back
Top