New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Why do we keep bases overseas?

We are a military family, but only my one brother ever worked in the Pentagon. I asked him the question why do we keep all these bases overseas when we could save a lot of money by just closing them. I thought he would say something like closing bases would hurt the local economies in the nations where we keep the bases, but I was wrong. There was really a very good reason for keeping the bases open that I had not thought of. They are military depots where we store equipment and supplies if they are needed in a hurry. Sending troops can be done quickly, but getting supplies and equipment takes time as we found out in the first Gulf War when we had to send most of our equipment by ship. Now with the problems we have with North Korea and Russia, having those bases in and around Europe and Japan make a lot more sense. We do keep sufficient troops at the bases to keep the equipment checked and ready for use if needed. This shows where are stationed overseas. http://time.com/4075458/afghanistan-drawdown-obama-troops/
 
So people can have excellent duty stations at some point.:rolleyes:

We do need various storage points and staging points. If there was a major conflict in the ME that we had to be part of, it would take a lot of time to build a staging point so it's better for us to have at least those we have in Germany, Italy, Turkey and other places (at least one of the Stans).
 
We are a military family, but only my one brother ever worked in the Pentagon. I asked him the question why do we keep all these bases overseas when we could save a lot of money by just closing them. I thought he would say something like closing bases would hurt the local economies in the nations where we keep the bases, but I was wrong. There was really a very good reason for keeping the bases open that I had not thought of. They are military depots where we store equipment and supplies if they are needed in a hurry. Sending troops can be done quickly, but getting supplies and equipment takes time as we found out in the first Gulf War when we had to send most of our equipment by ship. Now with the problems we have with North Korea and Russia, having those bases in and around Europe and Japan make a lot more sense. We do keep sufficient troops at the bases to keep the equipment checked and ready for use if needed. This shows where are stationed overseas. http://time.com/4075458/afghanistan-drawdown-obama-troops/
There are other reasons that I'm sure he knows. It doesn't take too much imagination to guess some.
 
....There was really a very good reason for keeping the bases open that I had not thought of. They are military depots where we store equipment and supplies if they are needed in a hurry. Sending troops can be done quickly, but getting supplies and equipment takes time as we found out in the first Gulf War when we had to send most of our equipment by ship. Now with the problems we have with North Korea and Russia, having those bases in and around Europe and Japan make a lot more sense. We do keep sufficient troops at the bases to keep the equipment checked and ready for use if needed. This shows where are stationed overseas. http://time.com/4075458/afghanistan-drawdown-obama-troops/
Correct. So why does the US have to do this and not our Euro and Asian allies? After WWII and for 40+ years of the Cold War, it made sense, but now? Not so much. Our allies need to start carrying their own weight.
 
Correct. So why does the US have to do this and not our Euro and Asian allies? After WWII and for 40+ years of the Cold War, it made sense, but now? Not so much. Our allies need to start carrying their own weight.
Most of the countries do have their own military and carry as much weight as they can afford. Remember that many of these countries are much smaller. They also don't try to be the world's policeman as we have become. Maybe you think we should reduce our military spending and at the same time have the greatest military with the best weapons as Trump said in his speech today. Don't see how that is going to work.
 
Most of the countries do have their own military and carry as much weight as they can afford. Remember that many of these countries are much smaller. They also don't try to be the world's policeman as we have become. Maybe you think we should reduce our military spending and at the same time have the greatest military with the best weapons as Trump said in his speech today. Don't see how that is going to work.

We can have bases all over the world which are relatively dormant, and still not be the world's policeman. Syria - Asssad gassing his own people - not our problem. Somalia - Bosnia - not our problem.
 
We are a military family, but only my one brother ever worked in the Pentagon. I asked him the question why do we keep all these bases overseas when we could save a lot of money by just closing them. I thought he would say something like closing bases would hurt the local economies in the nations where we keep the bases, but I was wrong. There was really a very good reason for keeping the bases open that I had not thought of. They are military depots where we store equipment and supplies if they are needed in a hurry. Sending troops can be done quickly, but getting supplies and equipment takes time as we found out in the first Gulf War when we had to send most of our equipment by ship. Now with the problems we have with North Korea and Russia, having those bases in and around Europe and Japan make a lot more sense. We do keep sufficient troops at the bases to keep the equipment checked and ready for use if needed. This shows where are stationed overseas. http://time.com/4075458/afghanistan-drawdown-obama-troops/

I don't know, my best Liberty ports didn't have Naval bases.;)
 
Most of the countries do have their own military and carry as much weight as they can afford. Remember that many of these countries are much smaller. They also don't try to be the world's policeman as we have become. Maybe you think we should reduce our military spending and at the same time have the greatest military with the best weapons as Trump said in his speech today. Don't see how that is going to work.
You're incredibly naive if you don't realize our overseas bases are providing us more than we are giving the host nations. We are not there for host nation protection. It's a valuable investment for us. And not just for staging.
 
You're incredibly naive if you don't realize our overseas bases are providing us more than we are giving the host nations. We are not there for host nation protection. It's a valuable investment for us. And not just for staging.

Some are occupational bases. When I was home ported in Yokosuka, Japanese ships were denied access to the base. They had to anchor in Tokyo Bay.
 
Some are occupational bases. When I was home ported in Yokosuka, Japanese ships were denied access to the base. They had to anchor in Tokyo Bay.

Here's a question, Wahbooz.

Why don't they just spell "Yokosuka" ......."Yakuska"? or maybe "Yokuska"?
Japanese language uses figures, so when they were doing English spelling, why did they make it screwy like that?
 
Here's a question, Wahbooz.

Why don't they just spell "Yokosuka" ......."Yakuska"? or maybe "Yokuska"?
Japanese language uses figures, so when they were doing English spelling, why did they make it screwy like that?

I guess because Yakuska is not how it's really pronounced. American servicemen chose to pronounce it that way. It isn't very audible to Western ears but it is pronounced Yokosuka.
 
Here's a question, Wahbooz.

Why don't they just spell "Yokosuka" ......."Yakuska"? or maybe "Yokuska"?
Japanese language uses figures, so when they were doing English spelling, why did they make it screwy like that?

When I was home ported there I got to know quite a few Japanese, and I was corrected once. The 'ko' in Yokosuka is nearly silent, it's more like a gutteral sound.
 
When I was home ported there I got to know quite a few Japanese, and I was corrected once. The 'ko' in Yokosuka is nearly silent, it's more like a gutteral sound.
I've heard it that way so I know what you mean here. But it's hard for us to say and sailors have always said Yakuska.
 
I've heard it that way so I know what you mean here. But it's hard for us to say and sailors have always said Yakuska.

I know, everybody I have ever run into said it that way. I never met a sailor on the base that didn't pronounce it that way. I got to know one bar owner, in an out of the way place, and used to take MPC to the EM club and exchange it for him. Sailors who did come in didn't want to walk the distance back to the EM club, so he'd exchange their MPC for 300Y instead of 360Y. He taught me quite a bit, even closed the bar one Christmas, and me and all the staff went to Tokyo and ate at one of the best restaurants I've ever eaten in.
 
I know, everybody I have ever run into said it that way. I never met a sailor on the base that didn't pronounce it that way. I got to know one bar owner, in an out of the way place, and used to take MPC to the EM club and exchange it for him. Sailors who did come in didn't want to walk the distance back to the EM club, so he'd exchange their MPC for 300Y instead of 360Y. He taught me quite a bit, even closed the bar one Christmas, and me and all the staff went to Tokyo and ate at one of the best restaurants I've ever eaten in.

Travel and experiences like that are what makes life rich. I lived in Hawaii briefly, but never traveled to Asia. I wish I could have done that.

I did have some experiences with the rural people of Sardinia..... spent New Years 83 - 84 at a party in the basement of the owner of the grocery store in the town where we lived. A multi-course meal that was wonderful was served up.

And Christmas Eve 1983 at a barn dance out at a Godfather's ranch where the live music was an accordion player and the music was all Italian music that I had never heard before and the wine was "feet wine" (opium based and so strong I couldn't get past the first sip).

I am certain you have had similar experiences in your travels.
 
Travel and experiences like that are what makes life rich. I lived in Hawaii briefly, but never traveled to Asia. I wish I could have done that.

I did have some experiences with the rural people of Sardinia..... spent New Years 83 - 84 at a party in the basement of the owner of the grocery store in the town where we lived. A multi-course meal that was wonderful was served up.

And Christmas Eve 1983 at a barn dance out at a Godfather's ranch where the live music was an accordion player and the music was all Italian music that I had never heard before and the wine was "feet wine" (opium based and so strong I couldn't get past the first sip).

I am certain you have had similar experiences in your travels.

It's terrific to really get to know people. I never got to Europe, and didn't miss the Atlantic Ocean, it was a killer in storms.

I'll bet that was quite an experience. I'd love to go to Italy some time, I've known some Italians here.

When we went to Subic Bay, I got to know some guys in a band, and I'd write down lyrics to songs for them. As a thank you they'd take me to some places most servicemen never see.

That restaurant, and I've worked in and ran a number of restaurants, was the first time I ever saw Japanese chef's work those knives. It blew my mind.

I was thrilled to get to go to Hong Kong, and while we were there Sean Connery was filming a scene from You Only Live Twice at that one garden.
 
We are a military family, but only my one brother ever worked in the Pentagon. I asked him the question why do we keep all these bases overseas when we could save a lot of money by just closing them. I thought he would say something like closing bases would hurt the local economies in the nations where we keep the bases, but I was wrong. There was really a very good reason for keeping the bases open that I had not thought of. They are military depots where we store equipment and supplies if they are needed in a hurry. Sending troops can be done quickly, but getting supplies and equipment takes time as we found out in the first Gulf War when we had to send most of our equipment by ship. Now with the problems we have with North Korea and Russia, having those bases in and around Europe and Japan make a lot more sense. We do keep sufficient troops at the bases to keep the equipment checked and ready for use if needed. This shows where are stationed overseas. http://time.com/4075458/afghanistan-drawdown-obama-troops/
I thought that was common knowledge. Doesn't mean we shouldn't close bases if those countries don't exclusively use our Dollar in international trade to keep it the reserve currency of the world. If they can't pay we shouldn't play with them.
 
It's terrific to really get to know people. I never got to Europe, and didn't miss the Atlantic Ocean, it was a killer in storms.

I'll bet that was quite an experience. I'd love to go to Italy some time, I've known some Italians here.

When we went to Subic Bay, I got to know some guys in a band, and I'd write down lyrics to songs for them. As a thank you they'd take me to some places most servicemen never see.

That restaurant, and I've worked in and ran a number of restaurants, was the first time I ever saw Japanese chef's work those knives. It blew my mind.

I was thrilled to get to go to Hong Kong, and while we were there Sean Connery was filming a scene from You Only Live Twice at that one garden.

I always wanted to go to Hong Kong. And you were fortunate to get with those band guys. It's better to immerse with the locals to get a taste of the real life of the place. My husband traveled around the Pacific in the Navy but it was before we were married.

I loved Italy and loved being able to travel in Europe in my car. We also traveled some by train. I'm still friends on facebook with an Italian man (and his wife) who used to post on the fray. He went by the moniker of a_n. He was from Tuscany. He is getting older now but I still speak to his wife often. I don't know if you were on Slate Fray.
 
I always wanted to go to Hong Kong. And you were fortunate to get with those band guys. It's better to immerse with the locals to get a taste of the real life of the place. My husband traveled around the Pacific in the Navy but it was before we were married.

I loved Italy and loved being able to travel in Europe in my car. We also traveled some by train. I'm still friends on facebook with an Italian man (and his wife) who used to post on the fray. He went by the moniker of a_n. He was from Tuscany. He is getting older now but I still speak to his wife often. I don't know if you were on Slate Fray.

I hope you get to go to Hong Kong sometime, it's amazing. I missed going to Singapore because i was transferred to an LST when the ship stopped there. And wouldn't you know it, we went straight back to Vietnam.

I was on War Stories, and then they made us move to KFS. That's great that you still have friends there, enjoy them. I've seen some amazing sights on Rick Steve's travelogs on PBS. Maybe some day I'll get there.
 
I hope you get to go to Hong Kong sometime, it's amazing. I missed going to Singapore because i was transferred to an LST when the ship stopped there. And wouldn't you know it, we went straight back to Vietnam.

I was on War Stories, and then they made us move to KFS. That's great that you still have friends there, enjoy them. I've seen some amazing sights on Rick Steve's travelogs on PBS. Maybe some day I'll get there.

My hubs went to Singapore as well as Hong Kong and of course I'm jealous. He and I were in San Diego at the same time, but didn't meet until we were both in Italy. I doubt I will make it to Asia. My daughter in law is from the Philippines (though she grew up in Seattle). My grandson is not quite 3 but has his passport to travel the world....... I've instilled a love of travel into all my kids so if I don't get to do it, they will. I moved to Hawaii with that same son when he was 3 months old. It's in his blood to travel.;)
 
Back
Top