New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Why does the present administration PROTECT

I don't see how I was condescending to you. I've read way too many posts where people have asserted exactly that, and I wanted it made clear.

He is going to be under detention, he accepted that. And no doubt he will be questioned more. A defense lawyer can advise him on anything, but it is his choice if he answers or not. A lawyer can not overrule what he chooses to do.

From what I've read and heard, he's been very open in his responses.
 
I understand the process that would have to be followed. But there needed to be time between the moment he was apprehended and the time where he lawyers up to find out about certain things: [1] who was financing the brothers; [2]what happened in the older brother's trip overseas; [3] how did they learn to make those bombs; [4]info regarding future bombings in the works (if they were part of a group); and probably a few more things I haven't thought of.

If he gets a lawyer now, there is no chance at getting this information. He still gets due process of law, but if he is deemed an enemy combatant, those questions will be able to be asked and just maybe some answers might save others.

It is quite possible that this young man was bullied by his obviously controlling older brother and if he isn't bullied by his new lawyer he will talk to those questioning him. He may not. But it looks like we won't find out.

My initial question was why does this administration seem to protect enemy combatants (especially if they are of Middle Eastern or Muslim origins)? THAT is the question I would like to have answered.

And really, I don't think you are in a position to make a good guess about what I might scream about so let's just leave the personal comments out of it. I tend not to even validate posts that go straight to personal commentary with a response (but you don't do that, so I always try to respond to you. Thanks for that).

Jen

So it is fine with you to disobey the law? any good Attorney would tell you that is why the Miranda law was passed.

If they did not read him his rights,you and the gang would be screaming about that!
 
The administration may have to make that call (that's information I am not certain of). And it would be more a formality to allow him to be questioned without a lawyer than anything else. Once he has a lawyer, that lawyer's duty is to tell him not to speak. But if he gets the enemy combatant designation, he can be questioned (without a lawyer); what he says can't be used against him in the trial;and he can (and would be expected to) contest the designation and possibly get it

It is the right thing to do. But for some reason the administration doesn't seem to want to cooperate and get the information that is so much needed.

If you are not certain,then why try to state it as fact?
 
I understood that he was questioned and then Mirandized thus stopping any questioning until he got a lawyer.
And it appears to be the administration that makes the designation or not.........

Things are still falling into place. I don't think anything is written in stone and I hope this administration does the right thing if it is their place to make that designation.

I withdraw any perceived judgment against the administration, but I stand by what I've said.........that he needs to be given the designation (without obstruction) and questioned before he gets a lawyer.

Can you agree with that at all?

You may,"understand," but like the rest of us you have no facts to back what you ,understand!" In other words you are just guessing,based on what you heard last!
 
Muslim extremists such that they leap to give this guy his Miranda rights before even checking him out enough to see if he might be termed an "enemy combatant" so we can get information from him before he lawyers up?????? WTH?????

Under the law that Lindsey Graham wrote, the Obama administration could deem Jokar an "enemy combatant" and get the information and still try him in a civilian court. He is not eligible to be tried by a military tribunal since he is a USA citizen. But he can be given enemy combatant status if he meets certain criteria and at this point it looks like he might meet that criteria.

What has been done will get him lawyered up and shut him up thus giving us NO information that we may need to remain safe.

This LINK will explain what I am trying to say.
THIS LINK will explain what you're trying to say?? What LINK is that, Jen? Why not just post the LINK instead of trying to hide behind THIS LINK?? Why not say you got your information from Fox News? Sneaky but not surprising. I clicked on your link and closed the page without reading it. Since you obviously don't know what you're talking about, shouldn't you go to some UNBIASED site instead of clicking on Fox and spreading their gossip and prejudice?

There isn't an incident where Obama makes a statement or makes a decision (if this was actually his decision to begin with...appears to me it's the LAW) that you don't start your negative top posting about whatever he did. Every single time. Of course you backtrack at times after others point out your hate for him.

I don't understand why, when following the law, any President should be bashed. Maybe he should go against the law and have him tortured? Would that make you feel better? I doubt it...then he'd be wrong about that. Your hate for Obama is very obvious but why make up crap? He's not protecting anyone.
 
Because the suspect is an American citizen and has rights under the Constitution. Every time we as a Nation bend the rules in the pursuit of justice or safety it's been a disaster - the internment of Japanese Americans in WWII comes to mind.

Besides, if you had been following the story you would know that the public safety exception was applied to the suspect, which allowed him to be interogated prior to being Mirandized due to possibility of imminent danger to the general the public - apparently there was some concern that the suspects had planted bombs in other locations.
 
Muslim extremists such that they leap to give this guy his Miranda rights before even checking him out enough to see if he might be termed an "enemy combatant" so we can get information from him before he lawyers up?????? WTH?????

Under the law that Lindsey Graham wrote, the Obama administration could deem Jokar an "enemy combatant" and get the information and still try him in a civilian court. He is not eligible to be tried by a military tribunal since he is a USA citizen. But he can be given enemy combatant status if he meets certain criteria and at this point it looks like he might meet that criteria.

What has been done will get him lawyered up and shut him up thus giving us NO information that we may need to remain safe.

This LINK will explain what I am trying to say.


Because, unlike the previous administration, they are attempting to operate under the constraints of the US Constitution. Besides, torture isn't useful for gaining accurate information. It's only useful for exciting the lizard-brain mentalities of the Republican electoral base.
 
Muslim extremists such that they leap to give this guy his Miranda rights before even checking him out enough to see if he might be termed an "enemy combatant" so we can get information from him before he lawyers up?????? WTH?????

Under the law that Lindsey Graham wrote, the Obama administration could deem Jokar an "enemy combatant" and get the information and still try him in a civilian court. He is not eligible to be tried by a military tribunal since he is a USA citizen. But he can be given enemy combatant status if he meets certain criteria and at this point it looks like he might meet that criteria.

What has been done will get him lawyered up and shut him up thus giving us NO information that we may need to remain safe.

This LINK will explain what I am trying to say.

Why is the administration protecting the Constitution in this case? Well, probably because they love our country more than you do.... or, possibly, they're just less cowardly than you.
 
the answer is so simple even a cavewoman could understand it.

which is why no one is shocked you don't, much like they aren't surprised about you making another TRAGICALLY stupid post in an effort to dishonestly malign the pres.
 
as i understand it, the FBI flubbed their investigation into Tamerlen and Jugheads overseas trips when Russia was trying to alert us, and the Justice department decided they didn't want to wait additional weeks (or months) for a mulligan on whether or not these guys had foreign training. If the FBI could have state "definitively" these guys ever took Terrorism 101 classes overseas, the "enemy combatant" label would have been immediate and appropriate.
 
Muslim extremists such that they leap to give this guy his Miranda rights before even checking him out enough to see if he might be termed an "enemy combatant" so we can get information from him before he lawyers up?????? WTH?????

Under the law that Lindsey Graham wrote, the Obama administration could deem Jokar an "enemy combatant" and get the information and still try him in a civilian court. He is not eligible to be tried by a military tribunal since he is a USA citizen. But he can be given enemy combatant status if he meets certain criteria and at this point it looks like he might meet that criteria.

What has been done will get him lawyered up and shut him up thus giving us NO information that we may need to remain safe.

This LINK will explain what I am trying to say.

Will YOU please define an ENEMY COMBATANT as compared to someone like Timothy McVeigh, please?
 
I understood that he was questioned and then Mirandized thus stopping any questioning until he got a lawyer.
And it appears to be the administration that makes the designation or not.........

Things are still falling into place. I don't think anything is written in stone and I hope this administration does the right thing if it is their place to make that designation.

I withdraw any perceived judgment against the administration, but I stand by what I've said.........that he needs to be given the designation (without obstruction) and questioned before he gets a lawyer.

Can you agree with that at all?

They interrogated him for SEVERAL HOURS before reading him his Miranda rights. They were convinced that there was no further danger to the public----which was the legal basis for the Miranda exclusion----so, at that time, it became quite proper to 'Mirandize' him.

Sheesh.
 
as i understand it, the FBI flubbed their investigation into Tamerlen and Jugheads overseas trips when Russia was trying to alert us, and the Justice department decided they didn't want to wait additional weeks (or months) for a mulligan on whether or not these guys had foreign training. If the FBI could have state "definitively" these guys ever took Terrorism 101 classes overseas, the "enemy combatant" label would have been immediate and appropriate.

It has been reported that after questioning Tamerlan, the FBI requested more information from the Russian intelligence services, and none was forthcoming. The younger brother never left the country, so how could he have taken 'Terrorism 101 classes overseas"?!???
 
Constitutional rights don't apply to Native Americans, Blacks, Catholics, Mormons, Chinese, Irish, Jehovah's Witnesses, Jews, Japanese, anarchists, Germans, Italians, communists, queers, Wiccans, Latinos, Satanists, or Muslims. Other than that, it's liberty and justice for all. Except hippies. :hippie:

Well, I know I fit in that list,somewhere,some how! :)
 
THIS LINK will explain what you're trying to say?? What LINK is that, Jen? Why not just post the LINK instead of trying to hide behind THIS LINK?? Why not say you got your information from Fox News? Sneaky but not surprising. I clicked on your link and closed the page without reading it. Since you obviously don't know what you're talking about, shouldn't you go to some UNBIASED site instead of clicking on Fox and spreading their gossip and prejudice?

There isn't an incident where Obama makes a statement or makes a decision (if this was actually his decision to begin with...appears to me it's the LAW) that you don't start your negative top posting about whatever he did. Every single time. Of course you backtrack at times after others point out your hate for him.

I don't understand why, when following the law, any President should be bashed. Maybe he should go against the law and have him tortured? Would that make you feel better? I doubt it...then he'd be wrong about that. Your hate for Obama is very obvious but why make up crap? He's not protecting anyone.


Your spittle-flecked, deranged hatred and unhinged hostility oozes from every post you make. It's truly scary that you own guns...I fear for the people near you.
 
Why does the present administration PROTECT Muslim extremists.....?

that sentence is why we dismiss you as a rightwing nutcase.

George Bush did to Jose Padilla what you wrongly think the Obama admin. should to this guy. they tortured Padilla till they drove him insane.
 
Jen - A few days ago I asked the same question. However, once I learned the scumbag in question is indeed a citizen, my trepidation fell away. No matter what we think of the wisdom of actually making this dink a citizen, he is. Therefore he is awarded all the rights and protections afforded to citizens. This means no GITMO, no torture and due process as required by law.

Look at it this way, Jen, at least this time, Obama is trying to adhere to law...as opposed to using a drone on a 16 year old kid.

I suppose that's evolving, right?
 
Jen - A few days ago I asked the same question. However, once I learned the scumbag in question is indeed a citizen, my trepidation fell away. No matter what we think of the wisdom of actually making this dink a citizen, he is. Therefore he is awarded all the rights and protections afforded to citizens. This means no GITMO, no torture and due process as required by law.

Look at it this way, Jen, at least this time, Obama is trying to adhere to law...as opposed to using a drone on a 16 year old kid.

I suppose that's evolving, right?

Just yesterday, you were saying that taking a hammer to Dzhokar's testicles was 'too good for him'. And it had already been widely reported that he was a U.S. citizen.

I suppose it is asking too much for you to display anything resembling consistency.
 
At the time of that post I had no idea he was a citizen.

None.

I'm the most consistent poster here.

Tell me Leroy, what's your stance on killing 16 year old citizens with drones?

Oh, wait... never mind....you'll go for whatever Obama tells you to go for.
 
Back
Top