New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Woolley Arguments.

You should listen to Keens solution to this crisis, it is not that far off from what you are saying here in regards to issuing special money to pay off debts. I do believe in the Fed as an institution, it has generally served us well when the economic philosophy of the Chairman was to follow a Keynesian model. We are still debating the after affects of the true cause of our total economic mess. That is the predominance of The Chicago School in the worlds economic institutions. From the IMF to Goldman to the Fed, the last 30 years have been a giant clusterfuck of monetarism mixed with Randism with supply side and every other discredited notion imaginable. We need to hit the reset button to the world prior to 1980. Sure we had inflation in the 70s and yes, no one thinks Keynes was some form of Moses handing down immutable truths for all time but the main thrust of his advice was caution, prudence, real growth, discouraging asset speculation and a return to sound banking. I am a huge fan of the MMT folks. They understand aggregate demand, debt, regulations and the fake prosperity that comes with credit bubbles. The key is to control the Fed in a different manner. I am not sure how to do it but perhaps by diminishing the power of the Chairman in some fashion. Make the term 10 years perhaps or force the Fed to act more like a committee instead of a dictatorship. Sorry Days, I tend to agree more with Degs here on his criticisms of your advice.

Go listen to Keen,you will enjoy this man.
 
I fail to see how unlimited credit expansion has hurt the industrial sector. The industrial sector is driven by short term profits in the USA. By allowing virtually unlimited credit to anyone who wants it, short term profits have exploded while long term strategy and thinking has been deemed irrelevant. The entire system of money, stocks, bonds and wealth has been turned on it's head by Wall Street because that is how they make money for themselves and their shareholders. Making money is the only goal, there is no other value system left. This is what needs to change.
 
The idea that globalization will work for individual nations is absurd. I have never been a proponent of unfettered free trade or global finance myself. Comparative advantage has only shifted profits to the top and moved wages to the bottom leaving us with a false sense of wealth here based upon exploitation of cheap labor abroad. This is nothing more than the United Fruit Company across all sectors.
 
He admits their policy preferences lead to bigger government (which they apparently support) and everything they believe must be viewed through this prism. Yes, ever bigger government leads to continued economic growth. This is fine until until it outstrips the government's ability to tax and then they start borrowing and when the debt gets out of hand, then they suggest the government should just start printing money. What could possibly go wrong with this strategy? Consider me unimpressed by their arguments.
 
When is it that the ability to tax exceeds the ability to grow? I have never seen any definitive analysis from the real world that defines this mystical relationship. Given that in an economy with a sovereign currency the government can always just print more money as Days explains, how does your theory work? Lukey, your points are based solely upon your opinions and are not based in any data or example. This is fundamentally why the Austrians are ignored en masse but for a few small tidbits of interesting advice they give which is not solely their purview but are part of most rational observers recommendations. What is lost in everything you promote is that money and government exists solely for one reason alone, to serve the interests of the people as a whole. The day both of them fail to serve the interests of the majority of the people is the day both go down in a ball of fire thrown off a cliff.
 
As both Degs and I maintain constantly, Professor Keen and his merry band of accolytes are the only rational people in the world proposing solutions and analysis for what ails us today economically. I wish that economics was not a partisan psuedo-science but it is unfortunately. On the one side we have the Keynesians who follow the advice of that great man and accept both monetary and fiscal policy as tools for economic success. On the other side we have your monetarists, supply siders, Austrians and Randians who abhor fiscal policy and refuse to even consider it as a means of managing an economy.

They have good reasons for rejecting Keynesians monetary and fiscal policy as tools for economic success.

The first problem of Keynesian monetary and fiscal policy is having politicians/banksters in charge of it. These are the same people who cannot make a profit running a monopoly bookie operation, let alone a complex economy.

Another problem Keynesian's face, is the simple fact people wont do as their told. Especially coming from sociapthic control freak eggheads, holding grand meetings while eating caviar, speak in 6 syllable words, boasting of 10,000 page/5 year plans, and yet, couldn't tie their own shoe laces until the age 30.
 
When is it that the ability to tax exceeds the ability to grow? I have never seen any definitive analysis from the real world that defines this mystical relationship. Given that in an economy with a sovereign currency the government can always just print more money as Days explains, how does your theory work? Lukey, your points are based solely upon your opinions and are not based in any data or example. This is fundamentally why the Austrians are ignored en masse but for a few small tidbits of interesting advice they give which is not solely their purview but are part of most rational observers recommendations. What is lost in everything you promote is that money and government exists solely for one reason alone, to serve the interests of the people as a whole. The day both of them fail to serve the interests of the majority of the people is the day both go down in a ball of fire thrown off a cliff.

It is fundamentally flawed in that it is based on spending money you don't have. First it's borrowing and when that runs out, then it's printing money all in a myopic pursuit of keeping aggregate demand out in front of production and supply. It is a perversion of capitalism is what it is - no one ever should suffer a loss based on a bad decision. Big government will step in and bail you out. It's really for the weak willed in that it fulfills their desire that no one ever suffer as a result of the free market.
 
It is fundamentally flawed in that it is based on spending money you don't have.
Hmm and what defines how much money a sovereign government has? Lets here this.


First it's borrowing and when that runs out,
And what level of debt would that be for the Foederal Government? Considering that right now the COST of US debt is still DECREASING with increased borrowing, what level of debt do you predict results in a cost upturn? http://www.businessinsider.com/national-debt-vs-10-year-yield-2012-6


Then it's printing money
Hmm and what is different about printing MORE money vs the current amount of money or the amount of money we had in 2001? FACTS please

all in a myopic pursuit of keeping aggregate demand out in front of production and supply.
Nice strawman, since that's not the goal you might try with an ACCURATE claim... of course I suspect an accurate claim isn't as easy for you to criticize


FACTS MATTER Lukey
When are we going to see some from you?
 
They have good reasons for rejecting Keynesians monetary and fiscal policy as tools for economic success.

The first problem of Keynesian monetary and fiscal policy is having politicians/banksters in charge of it. These are the same people who cannot make a profit running a monopoly bookie operation, let alone a complex economy.

Hmm and Cutting taxes on the Carried Interest of investment bankers as the Paul Ryan plan suggests puts monetary and fiscal policy in the hands of???? oh yeah... Politicians and Banksters. so far no difference and hence not a problem with Keynesian vs. Supply Side econ.

Another problem Keynesian's face, is the simple fact people wont do as their told.
Um since when does Keynesian econ expect any sort of central control? Its precisely THE OPPOSITE

Before yo umake up criticisms... perhaps you should learn more about what Keynesian econ is actually about

THEN you can work on tying shoe laces.
 
Hmm and what defines how much money a sovereign government has? Lets here this.

The wealth of its citizens leveraged to infinity

Hmm and Considering that right now the COST of US debt is still DECREASING with increased borrowing.

That is artificially manipulated by the Federal Reserve monetizing 10/30yr USTs

What do you think interest rates would be if the Federal Reserve was not buying 70% of U.S debt?

Hmm and what is different about printing MORE money vs the current amount of money or the amount of money we had in 2001? FACTS please

Much the same as as a stock split.
 
Hmm and Cutting taxes on the Carried Interest of investment bankers as the Paul Ryan plan suggests puts monetary and fiscal policy in the hands of???? oh yeah... Politicians and Banksters. so far no difference and hence not a problem with Keynesian vs. Supply Side econ.


Um since when does Keynesian econ expect any sort of central control? Its precisely THE OPPOSITE

Before yo umake up criticisms... perhaps you should learn more about what Keynesian econ is actually about

THEN you can work on tying shoe laces.

Dude, our entire marketplace is currently under Keynesian control, or do you still pretend we have a free market?
 
Dude, our entire marketplace is currently under Keynesian control, or do you still pretend we have a free market?
Define "free marke"? Do you mean one with no regulation? keynesian econ does not call for a regulated market per se. And we had a regulated market LONG BEFORE Keynes wrote his first ABCs in St. Faiths public school..
 
What does the wealth of the citizenry entail? Is it the potential, the assets, the resources they control? Leveraging to infinity might mean that lending is the fuel of an economy or it might mean something else, please explain. Where did you find your stat on how much debt the Fed is buying? As for the expansion of the money supply, it has to be tied to something or it is inflationary. We are not in an inflationary cycle. Please explain.
 
Define "free marke"? Do you mean one with no regulation? keynesian econ does not call for a regulated market per se. And we had a regulated market LONG BEFORE Keynes wrote his first ABCs in St. Faiths public school..

LOL! As soon as we passed the first regulation it was the same as having an all encompassing industrial policy and five year central planning?
 
Another poster with a completely distorted view of Keynesian theory. In this simple view, anything that exceeds tax revenues is Keynesian, anything. I am so glad I learned econ before the 80s, we used to actually learn theory rather than preach it.
 
Define "free marke"? Do you mean one with no regulation? keynesian econ does not call for a regulated market per se. And we had a regulated market LONG BEFORE Keynes wrote his first ABCs in St. Faiths public school..

A FREE MARKET IS REGULATED by the marketplace.

You control freaks really should be proud of your "well regulated market" Anyone with connections to the criminal/mafia regulators, get the big fat govt contracts/ waivers.

Why, since the 10,000 page Frank/Dodd financial reform, we now have 70% interest rates on credit cards, more MF Global types running off with investor money, AND IT ONLY GETS BETTER! Because now, the regulators are implimenting new capital controls that will DENY YOU ACCESS to your money market funds if the amount is to large. (amt to be determined by SEC st any given moment)
 
Another poster with a completely distorted view of Keynesian theory. In this simple view, anything that exceeds tax revenues is Keynesian, anything. I am so glad I learned econ before the 80s, we used to actually learn theory rather than preach it.

A funny thing about theory's. They always look good on paper, but immediately fall apart when confronted with the real world.

BTW: Keynesian has evolved into nothing more than corporate communism.
 
And your proof is? In case you missed it, the entire world was managed by his ideas from the mid-30s until the late 70s. Not too bad a record.
 
I find views like this to be almost adolescent in their naivete. Without law, you have lawlessness. Without rules, you have nothing to stop the cheaters. You should take up golf, it will teach you honor and the respect for dignity which you lack.
 
Again, the reason for having the Fed in the loop is that in a modern economy you want control of both M1 THROUGH M3. With only the Treasury engaged in printing money you lose control of M2 and M3. And thats disasterous.

You want control in whose hands? Wrestling control from the central bank and returning it to the Treasury is the whole point!




Nothing prevents the GSEs from doing so EXCEPT THEIR CHARTERS. And those can be changed. The Fed is not the barrier to this.
The GSEs are still in receivership, which means nothing prevents the Treasury from doing so. But to say that the GSEs could put out zero interest loans without Treasury funding and still turn a profit? That's ridiculous.



Based on what DATA? This is a specious claim. its as though there is no such thing as opportunity cost. Sorry there is.
Garblegook, degs. I need data to prove that loan payments cost business money? Do I need data to prove that grass needs water to grow? I write a point directed at eliminating opportunity costs for start-ups and you twist it into saying that no such costs exist. It doesn't say that, obviously those costs exist and I'm trying to eliminate them.




simply not true.
The point was simple; capital investment strategies are more successful when they are not saddled with loan payments. It is simple and it is true.




Also not true. A business that borrows 10% of its net Profit is still leveraged. But its payments hardly eat ALL of its profits.

Sorry you are making things up again.
No, degs, that's not what happens. Businesses are bought out completely with loans, they are leveraged 100%, and then the buyer will use the business to take out more loans. The game is way harder. If a business has loans of only 10% of their capital, they likely don;t need to be in debt at all.


when you go line by line and argue with everything, your post makes no cohesive argument. IOW, you aren't saying anything with posts like that, it is just stupid argument ... argument for argument's sake.
 
Back
Top