New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Worst . . . argument . . . ever . . .

Unemployment might seem high and GDP growth low, but I suspect this is more like a peak in the business cycle. It's just that the peaks ain't what they used to be (when we were coming out of an era of general poverty as opposed to entering one of undistributed abundance).
It is quite likely that we're near the peak of the business cycle, just given how long this growth has lasted. It's already the third-longest in history, exceeded only by the Clinton and Kennedy/Johnson cycles.
 
No it doesn't'. Deflation = lower prices.

It often appears when artificialy stimulated economic bubbles pop and the market corrects itself.

Lower prices mean lower wages, since wages are the price of labor - power. And lower prices means businesses going under because they can't get sufficient return through sales to cover their sunken costs.

The only "artificial stimulation" needed to blow up a bubble that'll inevitably pop is competition. Inflationary policies can exacerbate deflation, but anti-growth policies cannot prevent it.
 
Lower prices mean lower wages, since wages are the price of labor - power. And lower prices means businesses going under because they can't get sufficient return through sales to cover their sunken costs.

The only "artificial stimulation" needed to blow up a bubble that'll inevitably pop is competition. Inflationary policies can exacerbate deflation, but anti-growth policies cannot prevent it.

So, competition is an "artificial stimulate", but not central banks buying $85B a month in toxic stocks/bonds to prop up Wall Street which is 50% owned by the 1%?
 
Yes, that's sometimes the case. However, electronics generally have another factor driving sales -- enormous improvements in quality from one generation to the next. For example, when every other year you have a smart phone that's twice as fast and has a ton of new features, excitement can lure consumers off the sidelines even if they know they could wait another few months and get a better price. When you're talking about cars, houses, and the like, you don't get that same kind of mindset in the case of falling prices, because there aren't revolutionary improvements from generation to generation.



It did not. 1873 through 1879 is known as the "Long Depression." It is the longest recessionary period in US history -- 65 months, which even puts the big recession of the Great Depression (43 months) into the shade. Those were miserable years, from an economic perspective. Even the longer period from 1870 to 1900 was nothing to write home about. Check out real GDP per capita figures:

http://socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/2012/09/us-real-per-capita-gdp-from-18702001.html

As you can see, in 1870, the figure was $2445. By 1900 it was $4091. That works out to annualized growth of just 1.73%. To put that in perspective, you'll see that in the 30 years preceding Bush tanking the economy in 2001 (a thirty-year period that included the inflation of the 70s and early 80s) we averaged 2.11% annualized real GDP per capita growth. Such a terrible shortfall (1.73% versus 2.11%) ends up being extremely significant over a period that long -- making about 12% difference, cumulatively. The deflation of the late 19th century left a great deal of value on the table, from an economic perspective.

Deflation is beloved by the "banksters and money changers," since it has the impact of increasing the real value of the loans owed to them, but they, and the monied class generally, are among the very few who win in a deflationary system. If you were a Rothschild, sitting on a giant pile of appreciating cash and fixed-rate notes, 1870 to 1900 was a great time to be alive. If you were a working slob, being raped by the robber barons in their deathtrap factories, it sucked.

Fact is.. From 1870 to 1900, the US enjoyed an economic boom and a soaring middle class at the same time prices were falling which you said couldn't happen in a previous post.

The reasons why Americans enjoyed an economic boom and falling prices for those 3 decades is as follows:

A: Stable non-manipulated currency. (Gold)

B: Soaring increases in production and efficiency brought upon with the huge influx of capital investments into the USA during that period.
 
Fact is.. From 1870 to 1900, the US enjoyed an economic boom and a soaring middle class at the same time prices were falling which you said couldn't happen in a previous post.

No. The fact is that between 1870 and 1900, the US suffered seven separate recessions (one every four years or so), including the longest recession in American history. Overall, per capita real GDP growth was distinctly underwhelming -- coming in well shy of the thirty years leading up to the Bush administration, for example.

As suggested in my previous post, long periods of falling prices are shitty times to be alive for most people. Sure, it was a fantastic era if your last name was Rothschild, or Rockefeller. For the Banksters and Robber Barons, it was a golden age. But for most Americans, it was a grim time of child labor, death trap factories, and 60+ hour workweeks. It was also the dark days of sharecropping, when falling prices helped to make it impossible for sharecroppers to get out of debt. If you owed your landowner a given sum, that sum would effectively have risen in value by the time you paid it back, before even considering interest, thanks to deflation. Every year you'd get less and less for your crops, and yet every year you'd have to pay the same amount to the man who effectively held you in debt slavery. You couldn't count on inflation helping to devalue what you owed the way that happens in a period with healthy inflation levels.

It was a brutal era in American history, but those rich folks who think back enviously about the depredations of neo-feudal lords like Jay Gould would like Americans to mis-remember that history -- to imagine that those horrible years of deflation were something to be emulated. But you merely need to pick up a history book to remember otherwise.
 
Back
Top