New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Worst . . . argument . . . ever . . .

Which person on here claimed that attempting to delay Obamacare was nothing short of murder? I want a specific name. Because, if you're referring to me, I expressly said I didn't think that was true. But I've gotten the feeling that reading comprehension isn't really your strong suit, so I guess it's possible you really did fail to follow what was written.

Really, the guy who asks over and over again for help deciphering what people are writing is talking about reading comprehension? Lol! You've got the lowest comprehension of just about anyone here.
 
Yesterday one of the dimmer PJ lights (regarding economics) began thumping his chest in multiple threads to assert that the government shutdown “would cause a worldwide recession”. Really. He actually said that, as a rationale to keep spending money we don’t have, with constantly escalating debt limits.

First of all “very little” of what the government buys comes from overseas. Maybe some oil. Possibly copy machines, PCs and some vehicles. But a few weeks delay of THOSE purchasing programs is not about to send the world’s economy into a death spiral.

Rather, what I assume this economic-illiterate had in mind was “consumer spending”. The 20% of government workers who are non-essential would put off buying new PCs, foreign cars, french wines, and Italian sweaters. They might even delay international vacations.

I concede this point. If people aren’t getting a paycheck, they can rethink those electronics upgrades, new cars, and vacations. But I refuse to use this as a rationale for spending money we don’t have. We have a global responsibility to Nissan, Sony, and British Air to keep adding to the national debt? That’s effing ridiculous.

This reasoning comes from the same crowd who believes it’s none of America’s business if dictators gas their civilians en masse, or al Qaeda blows up shopping malls and schools as a rehearsal for the next attack on US soil. We have no obligation to human rights and freedom, just to sustain the cash flow and lifestyles of trading partners?

You might think I’m agitated. I’m not. I’m not even amused, even though this is hilariously flawed logic.

I appalled at the pathetic level of reasoning some people attempt to foist on others.


Anyone who thinks a US Government shutdown would cause a worldwide recession is an idiot and really not worth your time.
 
(e.g., a $1 drop in income worries you enough to cause you to drop spending by $1.01, which is a $1.01 decrease in other people's income, encouraging them to drop spending by $1.02, and so on, until you get massive economic declines).

People afraid to spend and buying less, prices would go DOWN. Falling prices is an incentive to buy more and makes goods more affordable to a larger group of people.

Of course in today's command/control crony market, falling prices (deflation) is taboo and must be avoided at all costs.

If the US Federal Govt was thrown in the ash heap of history, prices of food, medicine, housing and just about everything would crash by more than half.

Fact: Everybody except banksters and money changers win with falling prices.
 
People afraid to spend and buying less, prices would go DOWN. Falling prices is an incentive to buy more and makes goods more affordable to a larger group of people.

It's not that simple. A one-time decrease in prices might make you more likely to buy, but what about an ongoing drop? Are you likely to buy something for $100 today, if you think it'll cost $99 if you wait until tomorrow, and $80 if you wait a month, for example? That's why deflation can make it very tough to get out of a recession -- there's no penalty for thrift, and a diminished penalty for not investing, since the money you're sitting on is gaining more and more buying power the longer you sit on it. That can become a self-reinforcing thing, which is what happens during a depression.

Of course in today's command/control crony market, falling prices (deflation) is taboo and must be avoided at all costs.

Can you name a time or place in history with sustained deflation that you'd want to live in? There's a reason deflation has a very negative reputation among economists and historians. Go ahead and give it a shot -- find a period when prices fell over the course of, say, five years, and we can take a look at whether it was a period when everyone other than the "banksters and money changers" were winning.
 
Last edited:
Are you likely to buy something for $100 today, if you think it'll cost $99 if you wait until tomorrow, and $80 if you wait a month, for example?

History proves that consumers will often pay higher prices today, knowing costs will be lower tomorrow. TVs an computers are a perfect example.

Can you name a time or place in history with sustained deflation that you'd want to live in?

From 1870 to 1900 the USA experienced the longest period of deflation at same time the economy boomed. All the while, workers income remained the same. This allowed an almost 50% more in purchasing power for the working stiff by 1900.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Deflation
 
History proves that consumers will often pay higher prices today, knowing costs will be lower tomorrow. TVs an computers are a perfect example.

Yes, that's sometimes the case. However, electronics generally have another factor driving sales -- enormous improvements in quality from one generation to the next. For example, when every other year you have a smart phone that's twice as fast and has a ton of new features, excitement can lure consumers off the sidelines even if they know they could wait another few months and get a better price. When you're talking about cars, houses, and the like, you don't get that same kind of mindset in the case of falling prices, because there aren't revolutionary improvements from generation to generation.

From 1870 to 1900 the USA experienced the longest period of deflation at same time the economy boomed.

It did not. 1873 through 1879 is known as the "Long Depression." It is the longest recessionary period in US history -- 65 months, which even puts the big recession of the Great Depression (43 months) into the shade. Those were miserable years, from an economic perspective. Even the longer period from 1870 to 1900 was nothing to write home about. Check out real GDP per capita figures:

http://socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/2012/09/us-real-per-capita-gdp-from-18702001.html

As you can see, in 1870, the figure was $2445. By 1900 it was $4091. That works out to annualized growth of just 1.73%. To put that in perspective, you'll see that in the 30 years preceding Bush tanking the economy in 2001 (a thirty-year period that included the inflation of the 70s and early 80s) we averaged 2.11% annualized real GDP per capita growth. Such a terrible shortfall (1.73% versus 2.11%) ends up being extremely significant over a period that long -- making about 12% difference, cumulatively. The deflation of the late 19th century left a great deal of value on the table, from an economic perspective.

Deflation is beloved by the "banksters and money changers," since it has the impact of increasing the real value of the loans owed to them, but they, and the monied class generally, are among the very few who win in a deflationary system. If you were a Rothschild, sitting on a giant pile of appreciating cash and fixed-rate notes, 1870 to 1900 was a great time to be alive. If you were a working slob, being raped by the robber barons in their deathtrap factories, it sucked.
 
you get the doofus of the month award for resurrecting a thread that ended over 3 years ago, even if it is my thread.

and you didn't even have a coherent point to make.

get a life.

Teleprompters were a constant in the winger argument about Obama being incompetent...it is especially relevant today with Trump struggling with a complete sentence on his own.

What is funny is that you guys don't want to be reminded of the things you said in the past....Colorforms doesn't like to be reminded of what she said last week.
 
You need to step back and look at the big picture. Everyone's spending is someone else's income. So, US consumers buy fewer Japanese PCs. Then Japanese consumers buy fewer iPhones or movie tickets to Hollywood offerings, or medical devices made here in the US, etc. It's possible to get into a self-reinforcing cycle, where human psychology amplifies the effect (e.g., a $1 drop in income worries you enough to cause you to drop spending by $1.01, which is a $1.01 decrease in other people's income, encouraging them to drop spending by $1.02, and so on, until you get massive economic declines).

That is, in essence, what a recession is: when too many people try to decrease spending at the same time, causing a decrease in income, causing people to want to decrease spending even more, and so on, in an accelerating fashion.

I'm not saying the government shutdown is a big enough factor to start that kind of negative self-reinforcing cycle on a global basis. But it's certainly not outside the realm of possibilities. The US government is the biggest single economic player on the entire planet, so if it suddenly draws down its spending significantly, that's as likely as any single factor to trigger a vicious global cycle. That's especially true at a time like this, with high global unemployment and mediocre GDP growth, meaning there's no sign that the private sector is well positioned to take up the slack. Standard economic doctrine says that the government should be INCREASING spending in a time like this, to get the ball rolling. It's Keynesianism 101. So, if we instead decrease spending significantly, we shouldn't act shocked if the results are horrible for us.

Unemployment might seem high and GDP growth low, but I suspect this is more like a peak in the business cycle. It's just that the peaks ain't what they used to be (when we were coming out of an era of general poverty as opposed to entering one of undistributed abundance).
 
You expect forwarding a false premise to aid you in your point? There is no indicator that even begins to prove your "austerity" claim. Obama, in 5 years, has outpaced all other presidents in growing the debt. That doesn't happen under austere conditions. If you're not willing to have a rational conversation, that's fine. But don't pass this BS off as intelligent discussion.

Looks like he cut spending significantly without significantly raising taxes, all right.
 
"we've been trying austerity fo years"??????

this is just so insane. we've had astonishing deficits and increases in debt for the past decade. you are completely crazy

The deficit was cut by over $1 trillion under Obama. It's true that the tax-increase side of austerity didn't go far.
 
I posted my numbers. If you're unable to cope with them, then just move along. But if you want to address them, step one is acknowledging that there's been a very significant decrease in total government employment since this crisis began, and markedly sub-par federal government spending growth (possibly also overall government spending decline, but I couldn't find a source for total government spending, the way there's one for total government employment). Deficits, of course, are up. However, that's not due to unusual government spending growth. Quite the opposite. It's due to poor revenue growth, partly due to uncommonly low taxes, and partly due to the economy being depressed (which, in turn, is partly due to government austerity).

And, of course, the deficit is way down compared to its 2009 peak.
 
thanks for making my case - the same government that promotes obamacare is leading the charge to pacify the public with opiates.

I didn't realize Obama was president in 2003. I also didn't know that administering non-psychoactive cannabis extracts to prevent brain degeneration was the same as pacifying people with opiates. o_O
 
People afraid to spend and buying less, prices would go DOWN. Falling prices is an incentive to buy more and makes goods more affordable to a larger group of people.

Of course in today's command/control crony market, falling prices (deflation) is taboo and must be avoided at all costs.

If the US Federal Govt was thrown in the ash heap of history, prices of food, medicine, housing and just about everything would crash by more than half.

Fact: Everybody except banksters and money changers win with falling prices.

Deflation = falling wages, plant closures
 
ark - what other nations have a debt = 100% plus of their GDP? Are they nations anyone admires or which have a high/improving standard of living?

what is the ratio of america's debt to gdp? when will it surpass 100% at this rate?

All nations with debt-to-GDP ratios above 100%:

Japan 250%
Greece 179%
Lebanon 146%
Italy 133%
Portugal 130%
Jamaica 128%
Cape Verde 123%
Bhutan 119%
Singapore 112%
Cyprus 108%
Belgium 106%
U.S. 104%

A mixed bag, I'd say
 
Back
Top