New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

would this be using class warfare

What Newt and the republicons don't address is the "why" there are so many people needing food stamps, the majority of them with jobs working 40 hours a week. It couldn't possibly be because of the failed policies of "trickle down" economics that they espouse could it? HMMMM?
 
Well it looks more like bashing big government than class warfare if you ask me (and polls show a strong majority fear big government, btw). As for what the "rich" are "getting" in the tax code, as I have repeatedly shown, what they are really getting is double taxation (and btw they BY FAR pay the bulk of income taxes). And that "favorable" tax treatment on investment income to alleviate the level of double taxation came into being during the early sixties (when Democrats running the country were capitalists and the double taxation argument made sense to them) and it more recently survived the Clinton Administration, when the Democrats were STILL capitalists, and was, in fact lowered by Clinton. So now, after 50 years the Democrats have suddenly decided to reject the double taxation argument for tax favored treatment of dividends and capital gains in the pursuit of wealth re-distribution. And yet we can't call you guys Marxists? LOL!

The rich pay the bulk of income taxes because they have the bulk of the money Lukey. The top ten percent have about 80% of the money, so naturally they should pay 80% of the tax burden. Of course with all the loopholes, hiding money in the Caymans, Switzerland, and other offshore hideyholes, and just plain cheating on their taxes, they pay much less.
 
And even though the data shows lower taxes on investments means more investment and more jobs and more revenue to the government, you insist that raising these taxes is a "must do" in the interest of "fairness." Well, we were warned this was coming. At least now we know who to blame for the crappy economy and the lack of jobs (and just who the Marxists are around here)...

BS Lukey, if that were true the US would have 110% employment. So me where the Bush tax cuts created an abundance of jobs...oh please show me.
 
That's fine. Raising their taxes is one thing.

Villianizing them for paying what the tax code said they had to pay is another story, though. And that's the message that's coming across lately.

Notice how Buffett gets a pass while Romney doesn't? They both play with in the same tax code.
 
Notice how Buffett gets a pass while Romney doesn't? They both play with in the same tax code.

One is saying his taxes need to be raised, while the other plans on lowering his own taxes, does not take a rocket scientist to see which one the middle class should support.
 
BS Lukey, if that were true the US would have 110% employment. So me where the Bush tax cuts created an abundance of jobs...oh please show me.

Cutting tax rates without cutting spending just increases deferred taxes. The only REAL tax cut is a budget cut...
 
When a corporation pays 35% on its profits and then pays dividends out of what remains and the shareholder pays the 15% tax on that.

How is that double taxation? The corporation pays on its profits (after taking hefty deductions for all sorts of loopholes and boondoggles, well some do anyway, some don't pay anything at all) and the individual pays taxes on the income they receive from owning stock, that is unless they hold that stock in the Cayman Islands or Switzerland, then they pay nothing . Two different taxes on two different entities.
 
How is that double taxation? The corporation pays on its profits (after taking hefty deductions for all sorts of loopholes and boondoggles, well some do anyway, some don't pay anything at all) and the individual pays taxes on the income they receive from owning stock, that is unless they hold that stock in the Cayman Islands or Switzerland, then they pay nothing . Two different taxes on two different entities.

I'll try and make it as simple as possible. Say I own a car wash as a sole proprietorship. It makes $100,000 profit and I pay income taxes on that $100,000. Even if I have another job, say I'm a lawyer so we can say I pay 35% so I net $65,000 on those profits. Okay? You with me so far? That's not double taxation.

Now, imagine a national chain of car washes with $1 billion in profit and a public shareholder structure with 10,000 shareholders. That's $100,000 in profits per shareholder (if they all own equal shares for simplicity's sake). It pays a 35% corporate tax on that and then say it pays out all the rest ($650 million) in dividends so now I get only $65,000 and pay 15% taxes on that for a net of $55,250. THAT is double taxation.

Capisce?
 
I've heard some candidates talk about the fact that more and more people are requiring food stamps. That's not damning the poor and it's not an effort to incite resentment for the poor. That's just discussion about the state of our economy. Candidates do talk about that.

In NJ, it was a democrat state rep that brought legislation to require state union employees to contribute more to their 19K per year medical benefits package because his constituents were asking for that. Employees earning 60K per year were paying 1900 dollars a YEAR for their top notch insurance plans. The increase in cost to them was about 1500 a year and it was the union employees, not the non-union private sector voters, who got "riled up". I think it's just a fact that in some situations, citizens can barely afford to keep their own heads above water and they're being made to pay more and more for services through unions. Unions are wonderful. But there are situations out there where the people supporting those employees' benefits are really struggling to provide bare bones stuff for their own families.
That's something that's got to be talked about, too.

On the flip side, I heard candidate Obama back in 2008 call anyone making over 250K "greedy" if they weren't on board with a tax increase. He used that word specifically.
Look at OWS. That's an attempt at class warfare.

I would guess that there are as many super wealthy people on the left as on the right. Somebody's paying $38,000 a plate at Obama fundraisers and I doubt it's the rightwing doing it. Granted, hearing Springsteen live is priceless, but that's alot of money. When you've got 38K to spend on dinner, consider yourself blessed, but maybe you shouldn't voice an opinion on who else has too much money. And when you depend on people to spend that kind of money on one of your fundraisers, same deal....recognize that you depend on that one percent yourself.

It seems from the rhetoric the idea being shoved around is that anyone who's leaning right is well off and has no empathy for people who struggle. But the truth is, most of us, both right and left, are scratching our heads a bit these days trying to figure out how to make 2 and 2 equal 5 at the end of the month.

because the rich screw up this country with the banks and the housing industry, we have had a downturn in the economy. It had nothing to do with what Unions were being paid. But since it happened it's been put front and center by the right as being unfair. No what was unfair is what the greedy bastards did to the country. Now because they have cut taxes, lowered capital gains, added the cost of two wars that weren't paid for by raising taxes and then the downturn happens and all of a sudden it's the fault of Unions.

If you did some real reading you would understand that at the time the contracts were signed it was the govt that set the rates, for pay and health ins, and retirement packages. Your looking in the wrong direction, the direction you should be looking at are those corp that are hiding profits, sending jobs overseas, and people being elected by support of big money who are, have and will continue to make it better for those at the top.

Then they get people like you to start a class warfare about someone who makes a little more than you do to keep the bullseye off of them, as they pull in billions. Why is it those at the top don't seem to be having a hard time? Why have they went from owing 49% of our country in 1990 to owning 73 % 21 years later. the bottom 270 million Americans own 7% of the wealth of this country. The top 400 families own more than 50% of our population.

The problem isn't unions, the problem is the govt has not continued to look out for our country and the general welfare over the last 50 years.

and it's going to get nothing but worse under republican rule. The cost of govt has been passed onto local and state govts while the taxes at the federal level have been slashed which in turn has forced less and less to go to the states and be passed down.
 
I'll try and make it as simple as possible. Say I own a car wash as a sole proprietorship. It makes $100,000 profit and I pay income taxes on that $100,000. Even if I have another job, say I'm a lawyer so we can say I pay 35% so I net $65,000 on those profits. Okay? You with me so far? That's not double taxation.

Now, imagine a national chain of car washes with $1 billion in profit and a public shareholder structure with 10,000 shareholders. That's $100,000 in profits per shareholder (if they all own equal shares for simplicity's sake). It pays a 35% corporate tax on that and then say it pays out all the rest ($650 million) in dividends so now I get only $65,000 and pay 15% taxes on that for a net of $55,250. THAT is double taxation.

Capisce?

thats bs, because you wouldn't be paying 35%, because the average is 17% taxes on the top 270 corp's out there. What responsibility does that company have to the running of the country. They used the schools to educate their workers. They use the roads to get their products delivered, they use the roads to get their customers to their place of business. They use the govt to provide them with protection. They have a military that also defends them as much as it does me and you. We have a sewer system and a electrical grid, do they not owe for that right.

what you want to do is just like republicans have been doing for years and pass the cost of govt onto the backs of workers. and by doing what you want to do in keeping the whole amount of taxes paid by the company and then turn it over to you at 15% tax rate is once again transferring the taxes due to the working class as you drop your rate of income tax to 15%, pay no SS on the money or Medicade.
and you think that is a fair way to do it, hey?
 
thats bs, because you wouldn't be paying 35%, because the average is 17% taxes on the top 270 corp's out there. What responsibility does that company have to the running of the country. They used the schools to educate their workers. They use the roads to get their products delivered, they use the roads to get their customers to their place of business. They use the govt to provide them with protection. They have a military that also defends them as much as it does me and you. We have a sewer system and a electrical grid, do they not owe for that right.

what you want to do is just like republicans have been doing for years and pass the cost of govt onto the backs of workers. and by doing what you want to do in keeping the whole amount of taxes paid by the company and then turn it over to you at 15% tax rate is once again transferring the taxes due to the working class as you drop your rate of income tax to 15%, pay no SS on the money or Medicade.
and you think that is a fair way to do it, hey?

You are conflating the big megacorps with the millions of small and medium size businesses that create all the jobs. My example of a car wash is precisely the kind of business that drives our economy (any more) and they (likely) pay the corporate tax at the 35% level (because they cannot afford the lobbyists, the tax lawyers and consultants that these big businesses use to avoid paying taxes). And I find it exceedingly ironic that you would express outrage that businesses (and the wealthy folks who own them) use the education system, the roads, the grid, etc. without (adequately) contributing to the funding of same (when in fact they pay something on the order of 70% of income taxes), and then turn right around and champion the "progressive" tax regime that exempts 47% of workers from paying any of the taxes that contribute to that very same funding mechanism (do THEY not owe for that right?). And what I "want" is an equitable tax structure that efficiently collects revenue while interfering with economic growth to the least extent possible.
 
Wait, let me pull the string, all I have to say is "the middle class is taking a hosing at the hands of the 1%."
 
What Newt and the republicons don't address is the "why" there are so many people needing food stamps, the majority of them with jobs working 40 hours a week. It couldn't possibly be because of the failed policies of "trickle down" economics that they espouse could it? HMMMM?

Obama isn't practicing "trickle down" economics. He's practicing oligarchic socialism. And yes, it is indeed a "failed policy."
 
Your argument is phony. No business making $100K in profits would pay $35,000. 35% is the top marginal rate. Corporate tax rates range from 15% to 35% so no company would pay 35% on it's entire profit. Your example is phony because it never happens. A small business making $100K in profits will pay far less than $35,000 in corporate taxes. And those earning interest on shares will pay the 15% in capital gains.

What you call double taxation is corporate taxes paid by Company A and capital gains taxes paid by investors in Company A.

The double taxation argument is phony.
 
Your argument is phony. No business making $100K in profits would pay $35,000. 35% is the top marginal rate. Corporate tax rates range from 15% to 35% so no company would pay 35% on it's entire profit. Your example is phony because it never happens. A small business making $100K in profits will pay far less than $35,000 in corporate taxes. And those earning interest on shares will pay the 15% in capital gains.

What you call double taxation is corporate taxes paid by Company A and capital gains taxes paid by investors in Company A.

The double taxation argument is phony.

In my example I said the owner of this business was an attorney so it could be assumed that a) he would be no more involved in running this business than the public shareholder in the larger chain [c corp] and b) that the business income was all taxed at the top marginal rate. The average tax rate for US corporations is 27%. With so many big multi-nationals paying nothing, I think it is reasonable to assume this type of small(er) corporate chain would likely pay near the upper end of the range. Even if it only paid the average (27%) the double taxation still pots the effective tax rate of the (rich) shareholders in the neighborhood of 41 or 42%.
 
Back
Top