New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Wow!

Not even close. Fatima is a story. There is no actual verifiable or negatable prediction that was made, nor is there comprehensive, independent evidence of that prediction coming true. Fatima is the quintessential case of Post Hoc Reasoning Fallacy. the Mary in Akita can be explained with basic stage magician tricks. So there is no need for "god" to exist for either of these to have occurred. QED there is not even "preponderance of evidence" to suggest these are "miracles".


In the words of a famous scientist, David Berlinski ---- “It is painful to see this advanced as an argument.”

No rebuttal on this or any other points you made in your post, you win for now. Still I consider it primarily “invincible ignorance.”
 
In the words of a famous scientist, David Berlinski ---- “It is painful to see this advanced as an argument.”

No rebuttal on this or any other points you made in your post, you win for now. Still I consider it primarily “invincible ignorance.”
What you "consider it" is hardly meaningful since all you have demonstrated is ad hominem and other invalid forms of logic. IE exactly what Kant indicated... irrationality as the basis for belief.

You may find it painful to see valid logic and verifiable facts advanced as an arguement, but that's the difference between something being Rational and something being irrational.

And yes I'm not surprised you find it painful to be exposed as irrational and unable to mount a cogent rebuttal.
 
What you "consider it" is hardly meaningful since all you have demonstrated is ad hominem and other invalid forms of logic. IE exactly what Kant indicated... irrationality as the basis for belief.

You may find it painful to see valid logic and verifiable facts advanced as an arguement, but that's the difference between something being Rational and something being irrational.

And yes I'm not surprised you find it painful to be exposed as irrational and unable to mount a cogent rebuttal.


I understand what you are trying to say. I have no doubt you are being honest with me, either, and that is a plus.
 
I understand what you are trying to say. I have no doubt you are being honest with me, either, and that is a plus.

I am also using

Facts - as in independently verifiable and repeatable observations
REASONING - as in Valid logic.. as in devoid of Logical Fallacy.

And that's the key difference. You are doing what Kant suggested you need to do in the face of that- BELIEVING DESPITE reason. IE Believing based on irrationality.

Just own that and we can move on.
 
JV,I am a Christian and believe the words that Jesus spoke,"To help the least of us," so what the Democrats try to do when in office suits me just fine.
I am really tired of those who speak the words, yet back a party that is the complete opposite of what the Bible teaches us!
There were a lot of people at that Convention who do not want Religion and politics mixed. I am one of them!
Ted Strickland is the one who brought that up. Now,I voted for Ted and am sorry Kasich won by 2% in the state,but think he should have left that one alone. He is a Minister so I can understand how he felt. That does not change my feeling.
Thomas Jefferson and Roger Williams,the founder of the Baptist Church thought the same way I do. That is why they worked together to make sure Freedom of Religion was put in to the Constitution. I still feel the same although a group of Baptists think differently today. I am not one of them.

Where was it that Jesus said it's okay to murder babies?
 
I am also using

Facts - as in independently verifiable and repeatable observations
REASONING - as in Valid logic.. as in devoid of Logical Fallacy.

And that's the key difference. You are doing what Kant suggested you need to do in the face of that- BELIEVING DESPITE reason. IE Believing based on irrationality.

Just own that and we can move on.


I'll own it if I need to tell a joke.

Jack may be right... maybe your denials of the evidence in front of you is due to dishonesty. Denial is a form of dishonesty, I guess. But I don't agree --- and don't take this too personally. I see the world's egotistical intelligentsia suffer from invincible ignorance. Hard to explain it, but highly apparent. Admittedly, we all suffer to some degree in some areas from it. But for some, they suffer in areas of greatest importance. "Magician's tricks"..... sure thing.
 
I'll own it if I need to tell a joke.

Jack may be right... maybe your denials of the evidence in front of you is due to dishonesty. Denial is a form of dishonesty, I guess.

I'm not denying any "evidence"...I'm simply subjecting it to RATIONAL and critical analysis. For example. if you blew out the ACL in your knee and you had two "doctors" tell you the following things:

  1. We can do ACL replacement surgery. The typical recovery time based on average patients your age and activity level is 6 weeks if you don't get an infection and follow your Physical Therapy regime and 90% of the time you will then have no loss of function
    .
  2. We can do ACL replacement surgery. It will hurt. you will get back some functionality.

And you then go get surgery and you have a 5 week recovery period, no infection and you get back 100% functionality.

Well BOTH MDs "predicted" the outcome. But only the first one predicted it in a way that was meaningfully measureable. The second one basically gave you a prediction that would have ALSO occurred IF YOU HAD DONE NOTHING.

But if the Second MD told you "I prayed about how your surgery was going to turn out and I received the feeling that you will do well in recovery"... You would feel the "prayer" had PREDICTED your recovery for ANY level of recovery from 75%-100%+

The less precise the prediction - the more likely it is to FEEL true. An the prediction from the Lady of Fatima was -well basically very very very general. And as such its a meaningless prediction from a VALID REASONING standpoint (go talk to a Jesuit about this - since you won't take it from me)

A meaningful prediction OTOH is one that is precisely verifiable. For example, Stephen Hawkings did work on "quantum teleportation" out of black holes. And he made TWO very precise predictions from that

  1. That no black hole below a certain mass would ever be discovered because smaller ones would have "boiled away"
  2. That every black hole would have a "halo" of X-ray radiation in a precise frequency spectrum.

And not only did BOTH predictions turn out accurate (although the 1st one is still POSSIBLE to be invalidated) but the FIRST prediction ALSO confirmed and coincided with other measurements of the age of the Universe.

THAT is a specific prediction.


SO if the predictions in the Lady of Fatima were that

  • At such and such a time
  • This particular effect will take place
  • And there will be no other way to explain that effect naturally
  • and THE people will ALL experience it identically

THEN and ONLY THEN would you have an actual prediction of a future event.

But instead what you have is

  • Three children making NO SPECIFIC PREDICTIONS
  • A generalize "prediction of a miracle" for a particular date but no specific description nor time
  • A normal weather phenomenon fully explainable by NORMAL atmospheric occurances
  • NOT WITNESSED identically by the people watching
  • And a large crowd that WANTED to beleive SOMETHING would happen

That's evidence of??? well the belief of a crowd that wants to believe.

Hardly miraculous.

I see the world's egotistical intelligentsia suffer from invincible ignorance.
And of course it is in your PERSONAL INTEREST to "see" this.

Because

  • It makes you be able to feel superior
  • Makes you be able to feel that you have an insight into some sort of "knowledge" that those who in general ARE smarter than you, "don't have" (ie it appeals to YOUR ego - the very thing you accuse others of doing)
  • lets you avoid directly castigating others
  • And allows you to ignore reasoned logic.
 
I'll own it if I need to tell a joke.
Jack may be right... maybe your denials of the evidence in front of you is due to dishonesty. Denial is a form of dishonesty, I guess. But I don't agree --- and don't take this too personally. I see the world's egotistical intelligentsia suffer from invincible ignorance. Hard to explain it, but highly apparent. Admittedly, we all suffer to some degree in some areas from it. But for some, they suffer in areas of greatest importance. "Magician's tricks"..... sure thing.

If I were writing Degs' resume, honesty is not a term I would use.
 
What did Romney promise? Tax cuts for the wealthy. Repeal Obamacare (but now he says he'll keep most of it). Do better in Afghanistan (but then Ryan says they agree with Obama on Afghanistan)...Balance the budget? If you are math impaired then I can understand why you'd think his plan would do that...
 
Back
Top