New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A break

Status
Not open for further replies.
no , they would not. They would advocate that type of weapons available only to "well regulated militia" to fight off foreign aggression and/or colonial power, not to just any private citizen
Can you prove me wrong?

Yes - because the standing army was known as the "regular" Army, and a well-regulated militia was one that could work hand in hand with such a regular army, meaning it was using the same sort of equipment, the same ammo and the same tactics in the same ways. A well regulated militia, at the time, was expected not to receive arms from the government, but to provide its own via private ownership. This private ownership was not only an expectation, it was a requirement of the Militia Act of 1792.

In the same way that the 1st Amendment's right to print is not bound to the printing technology of the 18th century, neither is the unorganized militia (recognized in the current militia act) bound by the firearms technology of the 18th century.
 
yea, sure, those German citizens with their weapons if available would be able to fight off Hitler's armies. I recall ,that required cooperation of USSR and Western allies, full might of them.
There are strict gun laws in other European countries, did not see any fascistic dictatorship establishing in any of them.
If by any chance our government would become fascistic, how much resistance idiotic 2 amendment aficionados would provide and for how long?

People in the Warsaw ghetto tied up a division of Hitler's army's using small arms alone (they had nothing else). There were only a couple of thousand of them. What if it had been every person in Poland?
 
People in the Warsaw ghetto tied up a division of Hitler's army's using small arms alone (they had nothing else). There were only a couple of thousand of them. What if it had been every person in Poland?

I always wondered why Hitler never invaded Switzerland which had one of the smallest standing armies in Europe and lots of gold.

[video=youtube;B31SUm0nrwc]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B31SUm0nrwc[/video]
 
I'm thinking of taking a break from the forum. I like to have reasoned discussions of issues, where even if I disagree with a person, I learn something.

Lately, the level of discussion here simply hasn't provided that. It's descended into mostly a forum for name calling and finger pointing. You can't have a reasonable discussion about gun control with someone who calls you a "brown shirt." You can't discuss entitlement reform with someone who believes all entitlement programs amount to socialism.

I think that rather than advancing a discussion or attempting through dialog to build a better nation, we've simply become a version of Monty Python's argument clinic (perhaps the first room -- "oh, I'm sorry, you've gotten abuse. Arguments are down the hall).

Maybe its the fact that the dark days of winter have finally arrived, but all this simply makes me tired. I have a friend who defines all such participation in forums as "intellectual wanking" and I'm starting to think he's right.

I haven't surrendered all hope. I'm not certain I will step away from the forum, but I will unless something occurs to invigorate my belief in honest and open discussion, and the innate fairness of the human spirit.

I guess we'll see.
Well, that post is a blast from the past.

I've taken several short breaks from the forum, but usually simply because I found myself being a complete dick and figured I needed a break to be a bit more civil. I don't mind being a dick, but I don't want to be a COMPLETE dick.

Anyway, although the discourse here is often more abusive than argumentative, and although the quality of that abuse is often crap, I still find I learn a lot here. If nothing else, I find out what talking points are making the rounds of the conservative media. I suppose I could get that simply by skimming Breitbart every morning, or tuning into Fox News for a few minutes, but in a way this is superior, because I learn no just what the talking points are, but what the rank-and-file conservatives THINK the talking points are.

Those can be two different things. Sometimes, the talking points making the rounds in the conservative media are factual but are designed to invite people to make false assumptions, and when those talking points are echoed back by unsophisticated conservatives, paraphrased in a way that makes the deceptive implication into an express statement, I learn what the "truthy" false assumption is.

For example, the conservative media might run a headline about Obama breaking his record for rounds of golf in 2014. If I got that right from the conservative media source, I might not even realize the false impression that's meant to create. I'd read it literally, as a statement that Obama will have golfed more in 2014 than he did in prior years. But I won't realize that less intelligent people will read it and think it's reporting that he's setting some sort of annual golfing record for presidents (an intentional misapprehension, pushed by a subject line that speaks generically of him setting a record, without noting its a personal record). When some right-winger here links to the article, to support the falsehood that he's golfed a lot more than other presidents, the propaganda maneuver is revealed to me in a way I wouldn't otherwise have spotted.
 
Sure did -- happens all the time.

Yes, I know it does. Pretty much in every discussion you take part in, you misread what others write. It's a special talent.

Still, the top post whine is pretty classic. Two years old, we can all see that little has changed. There are realities to internet forums and one is that they will degenerate into name calling fests in short order. It even happens on the sports boards.. Even on music videos on YouTube...

There are of course, a number of ways to deal with this reality. Ignore it, choosing instead a less obnoxious path. Make fun of it, deride it. Ban the posters who cannot alter their appraoch in the slightest. Or...engage and become little more than an insult machine. There are instances of each in the ensuing two years from the time you penned this little whine.
 
Yes, I know it does. Pretty much in every discussion you take part in, you misread what others write. It's a special talent.

Still, the top post whine is pretty classic. Two years old, we can all see that little has changed. There are realities to internet forums and one is that they will degenerate into name calling fests in short order. It even happens on the sports boards.. Even on music videos on YouTube...

There are of course, a number of ways to deal with this reality. Ignore it, choosing instead a less obnoxious path. Make fun of it, deride it. Ban the posters who cannot alter their appraoch in the slightest. Or...engage and become little more than an insult machine. There are instances of each in the ensuing two years from the time you penned this little whine.

I try to avoid the name calling and focus on issues. I don't think the name calling is useful.
 
Your insults are well couched that way...

"for people who don't understand"...

It wasn't a personal attack, was it? Especially Bugsy does not seem to understand where the authorities in the Constitution originated. To me, you don't seem to understand the composition of the militia. But we can continue that in the other thread without personal insult.
 
It wasn't a personal attack, was it? Especially Bugsy does not seem to understand where the authorities in the Constitution originated. To me, you don't seem to understand the composition of the militia. But we can continue that in the other thread without personal insult.

Yes, it was a personal attack. It was a snide comment on my understanding of the documents. And you do it again...right there in the above post.
 
Yes, it was a personal attack. It was a snide comment on my understanding of the documents. And you do it again...right there in the above post.

I'll grant you it was snide -- but I didn't say "you're a Nazi" or "you're stupid" or any other attack on your character. If you're wrong or misinformed on a topic, that's correctable -- it doesn't make you a bad person.
 
I'll grant you it was snide -- but I didn't say "you're a Nazi" or "you're stupid" or any other attack on your character. If you're wrong or misinformed on a topic, that's correctable -- it doesn't make you a bad person.

Again...you say you don't...when you do.

It simply makes you mendacious.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top