New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A parable.

Let them try it again in January.

I don't think they have the balls for it. They know they took an ass whipping, whether they're willing to admit it in public, or not.

Three months hence is a lot closer to election day on 2014. Unless the RW manages to conceive a more productive strategy next time around than they did this time around they're in trouble. I think Boehner summed it up nicely with the term "fight" rather than standoff since that actually describes the tussle to a "T". At least that's an honest appraisal of what happened rather than pretending it was for the good of anyone to holdout in hopes of dismantling the ACA. There is no doubt we are in need of some budgetary changes but unless they attack the overall problem rather than a single issue it's useless to even try.

gramps
 
Arkady I think you missed the brilliance in this. Revisiting it after the holidays was set by Obama who orchestrated and it should not go without notice that he got everything he asked for and everything he asked for was strategically well thought out. The republican party whose new minority members took the hostages harming all family members have already been captured by the people, the party is divided, what better thing than too allow a cooling off period after a lesson was learned that crime doesn't pay? The real genius in this is who will turn state's evidence in court dates set for January and February as a result of evidence and lessons learned.

The police banked on the House putting itself together and trying to avoid going to jail in the public eye with the perps. I fully expected it to be January because that was the headlines when the Police Chief offered the deal to capture them.

The Republican House, now in chaos, will either regain control of their wayward members or the House Republican members will lose their House in foreclosure. This is a high stakes war that will be played out after the holidays, just long enough for them to seal their own fate with the public.

The question within the party is who will be standing in January. Brilliant imo. What you missed is this is what "win again" looks like when the only adult has isolated and charged the criminal and the court of public opinion reflects distain for the criminals crime.
 
Last edited:
One strategy that I think republicans could benefit from is to force the democrats to implement Obamacare as passed, and then use the labor participation rate to tie the resulting tragedy in with the legislation. The only way that people will accept sacrifice is if they see what not sacrificing will do. Democrats will have to own it, and republicans may gain the upper hand before the 2014 elections.

A reasonable position.

My personal problem is that I just don't believe in the PROPLE involved as much as you do.

For example, you state, " use the labor participation rate to tie the resulting tragedy in with the legislation." MY problem with doing that is that I don't believe there are enough people out there concerned with the labor participation rate. In my opinion Democrats target those who have no desire to participate in labor anyway so they will not CARE. Any tragedy will involve those in, or trying to be in, the labor force so there will be a huge percentage of Americans not interested in the least.

As for your assertation, "The only way that people will accept sacrifice is if they see what not sacrificing will do.", I agree. MY problem with that is I think there are too many people out there who are not now, nor will they be in the future, making or beingasked/forced to make ANY sacrifices.

There simply are too many Americans who will not now, nor have they ever been, asked or forced to sacrifice ANYTHING. Couple all of them with the number of Americans who, be they right or wrong, are under the impression that all of this will require sacrifices from OTHERS, not themselves and the result will be a greater number of Americans wanting this for everyone because they believe it will ONLY require that OTHER PEOPLE make a sacrifice, NOT them.

And therefore they are very useful, EXTREMELY efficient tools. Tools that the Democrats can then use to force their will on the whole of the country.
 
Let them try it again in January.

I don't think they have the balls for it. They know they took an ass whipping, whether they're willing to admit it in public, or not.

We've heard that before. Do you remember the last time the Democrats, the media, and the posters here portrayed a "big win" for Democrats in one of these standoffs? People must have very short memories, because it was less than a year ago:

http://articles.latimes.com/2012/dec/31/nation/la-na-fiscal-cliff-analysis-20130101

That was consistently portrayed as a "win" for Obama. But, to recount what actually happened: Obama was in a position where he had unilateral power to let all the Bush tax cuts expire, and then could have negotiated from a position of strength in order to cut taxes for those earning under $250,000. Instead, Obama let the Republicans make nearly all the Bush tax cuts permanent -- the only change would be for those in the top sliver of the income structure (less than 1% of all earners). Basically, the Republicans got over 99% of Bush's tax cuts made permanent.

That's hardly a lone example. Time and again there have been engineered crises that the media, most posters here, the Democrats, and even most Republicans portray as Obama wins, big and small. Yet, time and again the Republicans walk away from the confrontation with three things:
(1) a gain of some sort (whether a small one, as in the current case ora gigantic one, as with the fiscal cliff deal),

(2) a near-term opportunity to run the same grift again, and

(3) the knowledge that not only did the Dems get no new items from the liberal wish list as part of the deal, but that the "terms of the debate" have been more firmly set in the Republicans' favor (e.g., emphasizing deficit reduction rather than reducing the unemployment rate).

When Obama and the Dems keep letting the Republicans walk away with those three things, from their various "ass whippings," is it really any surprise the Republicans always have "the balls" to engineer the next crisis? They have almost nothing to lose (these crises play badly in the wider country, but there's no sign they hurt the Republican members of Congress who are engineering them; and they never backfire, in terms of policy, by leading to some substantial new liberal policy becoming law); and they have much to gain (even if most of their gains are quite small, as in this case, some are large, so why not take a shot, especially if the Dems will help you set up another spin at the roulette wheel just a few months down the road?).
 
Once upon a time, a team of professional extortionists issued a ransom notice -- either pay them a million dollars by midnight, October 16, or they'd shoot a hostage. Officials, who'd found themselves repeatedly faced with demands like this and had repeatedly made payments, decided to make a stand this time -- they would give nothing, because they knew giving up anything would simply encourage future hostage-taking. As time ticked down, officials changed their mind and negotiated a small payment for a stay of execution. For $100, the extortionists agreed not to shoot the hostage until early February. Inexplicably, some members of the hostage-taking team were livid at this deal, while the officials patted themselves on the back for having extended the hostage crisis by nearly four months.

the bottom line - after weeks and weeks of insisting he would never sign a debt bill with "preconditons" or changes, obama in fact did just that at the 11th hour. he now solely owns the 2 week shutdown.
 
You're not seeing the forest for the trees.

Republican political capital has been severely diminished by their outrageous behavior. They can put all the lipstick they want onto this pig. It's still a pig.

It will still be a pig when 2014 rolls around.

Hide and watch.

I hope you're right. This may, in fact, hurt the Republicans' hopes of winning broader political power, since centrists will see them as poisonous, and liberals will be more motivated to turn out. But I'd be surprised if it personally hurt the Republicans in the arch-conservative House districts who engineered this crisis, and so why wouldn't they just do the same thing again and again? From their perspective, there's little downside and much upside.
 
One strategy that I think republicans could benefit from is to force the democrats to implement Obamacare as passed, and then use the labor participation rate to tie the resulting tragedy in with the legislation. The only way that people will accept sacrifice is if they see what not sacrificing will do. Democrats will have to own it, and republicans may gain the upper hand before the 2014 elections.

The labor participation rate had been declining for years before Obamacare was implemented and is fully expected to continue declining regardless of Obamacare, and has been declining in other leading countries which, obviously, didn't implement Obamacare. The reason is demographic. The Boomers are aging. Most people aren't very smart, but even with an audience of idiots, I'd think it would be pretty easy to argue that point, if anyone tried to link a falling participation rate with Obamacare, especially in the face of falling unemployment.
 
The labor participation rate had been declining for years before Obamacare was implemented and is fully expected to continue declining regardless of Obamacare, and has been declining in other leading countries which, obviously, didn't implement Obamacare. The reason is demographic. The Boomers are aging. Most people aren't very smart, but even with an audience of idiots, I'd think it would be pretty easy to argue that point, if anyone tried to link a falling participation rate with Obamacare, especially in the face of falling unemployment.
Your post is entirely false, but I do understand your need to justify your positions.
latest_numbers_LNS11300000_2003_2013_all_period_M08_data.gif
 
A reasonable position.

My personal problem is that I just don't believe in the PROPLE involved as much as you do.

For example, you state, " use the labor participation rate to tie the resulting tragedy in with the legislation." MY problem with doing that is that I don't believe there are enough people out there concerned with the labor participation rate. In my opinion Democrats target those who have no desire to participate in labor anyway so they will not CARE. Any tragedy will involve those in, or trying to be in, the labor force so there will be a huge percentage of Americans not interested in the least.

As for your assertation, "The only way that people will accept sacrifice is if they see what not sacrificing will do.", I agree. MY problem with that is I think there are too many people out there who are not now, nor will they be in the future, making or beingasked/forced to make ANY sacrifices.

There simply are too many Americans who will not now, nor have they ever been, asked or forced to sacrifice ANYTHING. Couple all of them with the number of Americans who, be they right or wrong, are under the impression that all of this will require sacrifices from OTHERS, not themselves and the result will be a greater number of Americans wanting this for everyone because they believe it will ONLY require that OTHER PEOPLE make a sacrifice, NOT them.

And therefore they are very useful, EXTREMELY efficient tools. Tools that the Democrats can then use to force their will on the whole of the country.
Unfortunately, you may be right. Democrats have been working tirelessly to create a dependent underclass for decades. And it may be that they are now benefiting from the fruits of their efforts. If there is a push back, it can't be sudden. Democrats have been implementing little programs here and there that start out benign but become monsters after just a few years. Is there anyway that republicans can institute such austerity programs?
 
the bottom line - after weeks and weeks of insisting he would never sign a debt bill with "preconditons" or changes, obama in fact did just that at the 11th hour. he now solely owns the 2 week shutdown.

Nonsense. The shutdown belongs to the Tea Partiers in the House and he less extreme House Republicans who refused to allow the matter to com to a vote. Whatever small piece of blame goes to Obama is only based on the way his over-eagerness to "compromise" with political terrorists has encouraged such behavior.
 
Except for the fact that we've determined that the extortionists lack the intestinal fortitude to actually pull the trigger and will sell out for pennies on the dollar.

Not the preferred outcome, but considering the alternatives, not a bad one either.

Indeed. It's not the talk or the posturing that kills....it's the will to pull the trigger.

Will that the GOP doesn't have.
 
Once upon a time, a team of professional extortionists issued a ransom notice -- either pay them a million dollars by midnight, October 16, or they'd shoot a hostage. Officials, who'd found themselves repeatedly faced with demands like this and had repeatedly made payments, decided to make a stand this time -- they would give nothing, because they knew giving up anything would simply encourage future hostage-taking. As time ticked down, officials changed their mind and negotiated a small payment for a stay of execution. For $100, the extortionists agreed not to shoot the hostage until early February. Inexplicably, some members of the hostage-taking team were livid at this deal, while the officials patted themselves on the back for having extended the hostage crisis by nearly four months.

Parables usually have more substance and an air of timelessness. I don't get that feeling here.
 
We've heard that before. Do you remember the last time the Democrats, the media, and the posters here portrayed a "big win" for Democrats in one of these standoffs? People must have very short memories, because it was less than a year ago:

http://articles.latimes.com/2012/dec/31/nation/la-na-fiscal-cliff-analysis-20130101

That was consistently portrayed as a "win" for Obama. But, to recount what actually happened: Obama was in a position where he had unilateral power to let all the Bush tax cuts expire, and then could have negotiated from a position of strength in order to cut taxes for those earning under $250,000. Instead, Obama let the Republicans make nearly all the Bush tax cuts permanent -- the only change would be for those in the top sliver of the income structure (less than 1% of all earners). Basically, the Republicans got over 99% of Bush's tax cuts made permanent.

That's hardly a lone example. Time and again there have been engineered crises that the media, most posters here, the Democrats, and even most Republicans portray as Obama wins, big and small. Yet, time and again the Republicans walk away from the confrontation with three things:
(1) a gain of some sort (whether a small one, as in the current case ora gigantic one, as with the fiscal cliff deal),

(2) a near-term opportunity to run the same grift again, and

(3) the knowledge that not only did the Dems get no new items from the liberal wish list as part of the deal, but that the "terms of the debate" have been more firmly set in the Republicans' favor (e.g., emphasizing deficit reduction rather than reducing the unemployment rate).

When Obama and the Dems keep letting the Republicans walk away with those three things, from their various "ass whippings," is it really any surprise the Republicans always have "the balls" to engineer the next crisis? They have almost nothing to lose (these crises play badly in the wider country, but there's no sign they hurt the Republican members of Congress who are engineering them; and they never backfire, in terms of policy, by leading to some substantial new liberal policy becoming law); and they have much to gain (even if most of their gains are quite small, as in this case, some are large, so why not take a shot, especially if the Dems will help you set up another spin at the roulette wheel just a few months down the road?).


Republicans are so pissed at the 'cave-in' they forget the last time....Socialcrats are so enamored with the 'win' they forget the last time.


To me...it all seems so...orchestrated.
 
Republicans are so pissed at the 'cave-in' they forget the last time....Socialcrats are so enamored with the 'win' they forget the last time.


To me...it all seems so...orchestrated.
They can now stop fiddling with Obamacare. And it needs a lot of fiddling. Un-fiddled it will die. The president didn't negotiate on Obamacare now why should the house in the future?
 
Unfortunately, you may be right. Democrats have been working tirelessly to create a dependent underclass for decades. And it may be that they are now benefiting from the fruits of their efforts. If there is a push back, it can't be sudden. Democrats have been implementing little programs here and there that start out benign but become monsters after just a few years. Is there anyway that republicans can institute such austerity programs?

No, not 'may be benefiting'...but 'are benefiting'.

The people LOVE their handouts.

From corporate subsidies to food stamps and Social Security.

They will vote for who offers them the most.

"A democracy can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largess from the public treasury." - Disputed.
 
No, not 'may be benefiting'...but 'are benefiting'.

The people LOVE their handouts.

From corporate subsidies to food stamps and Social Security.

They will vote for who offers them the most.

"A democracy can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largess from the public treasury." - Disputed.

They'll also vote for who lets them keep the most of what they've earned (At least I hope they still do).
 
Back
Top